ZEITGEIST, The Movie

It makes it as necessary as it does for anyone else. When I hear phrases like "own the media" I am given the impression that the originators of such claims have very little clue what "the media" really is. These moguls you refer to own "the media" just about as much as Bill Gates owns Microsoft-- which is to say not at all in the literal sense of the term. These moguls "own" companies and corporations that maintain administrative control over numerous media outlets, though in most cases there is very little direct administrative control over the different smaller affiliates that fall under their banner. Some people, like Murdoch, have worked to direct levels of management down as far as it could go in order to provide results that are to the enjoyment of Murdoch, but even with his remarkable (and documented, tracked, and highly criticized) success, there are still NewsCorp affiliates who run stories that are antithetical to Murdoch's own publicly known political views. There are still articles, radio spots, and other pieces that fall outside of the ideology of Murdoch-land. Since many of the affiliates don't have the ability or resources to rely solely on inside writing and journalism, the work of other sources (including freelance and otherwise affiliated) is common use.

What these people "own" is a revenue source, not some magical keys to the public mind. There is definitely sensationalism, pandering, bias, and intellectual dishonesty that goes on in all types of media, including news media. There is no evidence that it's all being directed by anyone but a series of flaky, overzealous, and disconnected people who run affiliate stations or are program managers, editors, and in some cases even the journalists themselves.

Well, I can only point you back a page or two to where this part of the thread commenced. In my personal experience, the media behave on occasions exactly as though they are under centralised control.

GreNME said:
But there isn't an extreme lack of information. It's the extreme different in the interpretation of information based on the assumptions of the viewer of the information. See my response to the "steering committee" thing as an example. I only know this after having seen steering committees and what they do, and after having the experience of dealing with bureaucratic organizational structures where lots of people have overblown titles compared to their actual duties. This is an organization phenomenon that is common in bureaucratic ladders where everyone wishes to be a manager of something. It isn't even an obscure phenomenon. Conspiracy theorists, however, often never consider simplistic answers like this to explain what is otherwise referred to them as ominous and suspicious signs of foul play.

That is one example, perhaps. I don't know that it can really be said to demonstrate any kind of principle here. In addition, the Bilderberg "steering committee" would presumably also be busy with just who was invited to the annual gathering. And presumably what subjects might be discussed. To me this suggests a little greater than menial significance. It could effectively be a core decision-forming group, though online sources appear to place it as the second of three rings.



GreNME said:
Only in the minds of conspiracy theorists. Many of the things a conspiracy theory may demand investigation of have either already been examined or are already known without the ominous subtext. Without the ominous subtext of supposed malicious intent, many conspiracy theories crumble under their own assertations.

Well, let's see. I guess time will tell.


GreNME said:
'Symbols' are just representations for language, and are studied along with character-based linguistics.

What !! On what basis can you assert the primacy of language over symbol? Are you sufficiently familiar with the experience of thought that you can track it back to its source?

How do you know that the unconscious isn't symbolic in actual nature?

GreNME said:
Symbols are dependent on interpretation, and any number of symbols can be placed together in a similar context when they are described in a single language. This is the failing of attempting to understand the conveyance of symbols without understanding the context of how concepts are conveyed within their respective languages. I'm not claiming that someone studying these things needs to understand all languages, but understanding how different languages portray concepts is crucial to understanding what the symbols actually are. Otherwise (like with pre-Rosetta-Stone Egyptology) many of the symbols and symbolism are subject to conjecture and wild speculation.

Language can be used to relate symbology and can be a medium for relating different symbol systems but I see nothing to assert that language is itself primary in the experience of ideation, or indeed in any way primary over symbols.


GreNME said:
That passage is describing differences in accent and variation within a single language passed down over time. This is what I meant earlier about attributing too much significance to the wrong things. The passage you quote is talking about differences like the difference in things like the American and British pronounciation of words like aluminum, schedule, and herbs (with special mention of Eddie Izzard for using it as a joke).

Well, it was pretty much the only passage in the piece that actually did describe just what Blevin's piece was about.


GreNME said:
I pointed out to you examples of why other fields have come to the conclusion of separate development of key aspects of their respective cultures and civilizations. The implication is that the general consensus has concluded separate development of many of these civilizations, which would remove the possible methods through which any unified "monomyth" could be transferred from one civilization to another. The existence of a monomyth and the consensus of every academic field regarding ancient civilizations are mutually exclusive to one another.

You quote a lot of high intensity rhetoric, GreNME, and apparently seem convinced of your truth. But I remain unconvinced. When I read Mark Rosenfelder, I can follow his arguments easily. He speaks simple language and it makes sense to me. But when I read you, you overlay this constant convinced position that you are articulating some implicit truth when, let's face it, everyone in this field knows you're dealing with shades of grey. You can't make these absolute assertions and back them up, however attractive it might be to do so.


GreNME said:
You're moving the goalpost now, Nick. Do you want to cover how this discredits the idea of monomyth, or are we now back to speaking specifically of the Jesus myth in Zeitgeist? The whole rest of your post was referring to the former, not the latter.

GreNME, we've been discussing Jesus as a figure in the monomyth all along. As far as I was aware. That was the Zeitgeist position.


GreNME said:
You understand incorrectly. Parallel evolution refers to separate but similar environmental conditions resulting in similar (but not always the same) results.

The source? What statement does it make about the source, GreNME? I submit that parallel evolution makes a statement about the process but none about the source. The phenomena of parallel, or convergent, evolution provides a mechanism for understanding how things can become similar over time, but it makes no statement about their source. It in no way excludes the possibility that things had a direct relationship at source level, merely demonstrates that this does not necessarily have to be present.

Nick
 
update on screw zeitgeist...

so i have begun, and must i say...YAAWWWNNN....i think i might just cut out the whole religion part of the movie and get to the juicy 9/11 stuff.

Religion is often fraudulent, the Hebrews were nomadic when they were making the Biblical tales, and took stories from other cultures, nothing exciting, nothing exciting.

Plus, I noticed alot of you guys just said why bother with this part anyways. Your thoughts?
 
Well, I can only point you back a page or two to where this part of the thread commenced. In my personal experience, the media behave on occasions exactly as though they are under centralised control.

Or subject to the mob. Never underestimate the power of the mob. The common motto of news, especially television news, is "if it bleeds, it leads." Murdoch's NewsCorp certainly blazed the trail for this type of editorial direction in news reporting, but asserting that he (Murdoch) or any of his peers are actually maintaining a "centralized control" because of this ignores the mob and the effect it has on things. What the FOX stations were able to do is take the market share from the huge networks by promoting sensationalism and using "shock" or questionable journalism. Heck, FOX itself has a show-- Inside Edition-- that has in the past "investigated" conspiracy theories itself. Bill O'Reilly, often considered one of the biggest "shills" there is (and a right bastard), broadcast JFK conspiracy theories at one point in his career on the show (long before he ever adopted his recent television persona). Isn't SkyOne, which despite its complaints about unnecessary censorship often runs documentaries that sometimes cover conspiracy claims or question government actions, still owned by Rupert Murdoch?

For being part of a "centralized control" Murdoch has done a poor job at keeping a tight reign on the "information" that he and his ilk supposedly suppress.


That is one example, perhaps. I don't know that it can really be said to demonstrate any kind of principle here. In addition, the Bilderberg "steering committee" would presumably also be busy with just who was invited to the annual gathering. And presumably what subjects might be discussed. To me this suggests a little greater than menial significance. It could effectively be a core decision-forming group, though online sources appear to place it as the second of three rings.

I don't know how you go from listing administrative tasks (which are essentially menial tasks in bureaucracy) into assuming they have a duty "greater than menial significance." No source, whether online or through people I've asked specifically, can give me a straight answer on how something that all available information describes as a group of overblown maître d's hold any more significance than what is openly known about them. Heck, the CEO of the companies I work for is worth at least a few million dollars and he pays someone to do that sort of work for him, too. Not for nothing, but the people he has hired top do such work have all been well-paid personal assistants.


GreNME said:
Only in the minds of conspiracy theorists. Many of the things a conspiracy theory may demand investigation of have either already been examined or are already known without the ominous subtext. Without the ominous subtext of supposed malicious intent, many conspiracy theories crumble under their own assertations.
Well, let's see. I guess time will tell.

I doubt it. There are still conspiracy theories that Abraham Lincoln's assassination was a secret conspiracy plot. Old conspiracy theories simply work their way into the annals of Grand Unified Conspiracy Theorytm.


GreNME said:
'Symbols' are just representations for language, and are studied along with character-based linguistics.
What !! On what basis can you assert the primacy of language over symbol? Are you sufficiently familiar with the experience of thought that you can track it back to its source?

How do you know that the unconscious isn't symbolic in actual nature?

You're using "symbol" in the form of abstract ideas. I used "symbol" in the form of actual recorded symbols that have been left for archaeological discovery-- symbols in picture form, written form, and artistic creation. Unfortunately, there exists no way to read the minds of people long since deceased in order to glean from them their ideas. Instead, we work from their creations, all of which have been left in different levels of language. Written language, pictorial language, scientific language, engineering language, behavioral language... all of which (and more) are studied in order to gain a better understanding of how and why people in ancient times did what they did. Nothing we know from any civilization-- and this includes their myths-- came to a historical understanding without their languages in context. Otherwise it is pure conjecture.


Language can be used to relate symbology and can be a medium for relating different symbol systems but I see nothing to assert that language is itself primary in the experience of ideation, or indeed in any way primary over symbols.

Well, since "symbology" as an actual academic study is in itself younger than I am, and because symbology is rarely conclusive-- more prone to the eye of the beholder who is assuming an objective stance (didn't you state objection to objectivity?)-- I don't place enough faith in its study to make any conclusive judgments from it.

Language is the only way in which one person can convey to another person an idea. Even animals use language.


You quote a lot of high intensity rhetoric, GreNME, and apparently seem convinced of your truth. But I remain unconvinced. When I read Mark Rosenfelder, I can follow his arguments easily. He speaks simple language and it makes sense to me. But when I read you, you overlay this constant convinced position that you are articulating some implicit truth when, let's face it, everyone in this field knows you're dealing with shades of grey. You can't make these absolute assertions and back them up, however attractive it might be to do so.
Mark Rosenfelder has the distinct advantage of not actually taking part in a conversation with you. In fact, in his reply to you he basically referred you to another of his writings instead of explaining to you outright. So, unless you are going to tell me you are asking him to explain and give details for his conclusions in the same manner you have been with me, then I'm going to have to wonder why you are comparing what I've been saying with what he has, since we've both been saying the exact same thing-- similarities do not imply relationships, and claims implying relationships are not based in facts as we know them.

Let me use the simplest language I can: "monomyth" is a ridiculous assertion because it relies on similarities, which have shown throughout pretty much every academic field of research to not be indicative of a relationship. Just because there are similarities means nothing. Establish a relationship first, and then allow the similarities to support the established relationship. If you cannot first establish a relationship, then doing so using similarities is intellectually dishonest. Clear enough?


GreNME, we've been discussing Jesus as a figure in the monomyth all along. As far as I was aware. That was the Zeitgeist position.
Now you're making things up. Nowhere in the film do they make the assertions of the monomyth as you've described. You are projecting your own conclusions onto what the film was (incorrectly) saying. You are compounding wild speculation atop wild speculation, at this point.


GreNME said:
You understand incorrectly. Parallel evolution refers to separate but similar environmental conditions resulting in similar (but not always the same) results.
The source? What statement does it make about the source, GreNME? I submit that parallel evolution makes a statement about the process but none about the source. The phenomena of parallel, or convergent, evolution provides a mechanism for understanding how things can become similar over time, but it makes no statement about their source. It in no way excludes the possibility that things had a direct relationship at source level, merely demonstrates that this does not necessarily have to be present.

Nick

There is no known singular source. Let me repeat: there is no known singular source. You may as well be attempting to prove the divine. There is no known evidence of any singular source, and as I have repeated over and over, similarities do not prove any such existence. The onus is not on me to provide for you proof of a non-existance of some kind of source for your monomyth, the onus is on you to provide proof positive of an existance. There is no such proof.

Zeitgeist attempts to claim evidence of a proof, and gets it completely wrong. We've been over this. You then moved to the position that maybe what they meant instead of what was said in the film was more significant. I have maintained that none of that still actually provides a proof positive. There exists no known evidence of such a proof, only a handful of similarities that appear to have been produced through similar means in different places.
 
update on screw zeitgeist...

so i have begun, and must i say...YAAWWWNNN....i think i might just cut out the whole religion part of the movie and get to the juicy 9/11 stuff.

Religion is often fraudulent, the Hebrews were nomadic when they were making the Biblical tales, and took stories from other cultures, nothing exciting, nothing exciting.

Plus, I noticed alot of you guys just said why bother with this part anyways. Your thoughts?

My thought it you're making a huge mistake. If you want to just tackle 9/11 or anti-Fed videos you can find plenty of those out there. The whole premise behind this film is that these three parts are tied together.
 
Let me use the simplest language I can: "monomyth" is a ridiculous assertion because it relies on similarities, which have shown throughout pretty much every academic field of research to not be indicative of a relationship. Just because there are similarities means nothing. Establish a relationship first, and then allow the similarities to support the established relationship. If you cannot first establish a relationship, then doing so using similarities is intellectually dishonest. Clear enough?

absolutely clear, however I am curious if you would take the time to point out why there is no connection at all...specifically. you have stated over and over that mainstream academia has debunked the notion of connection but the only real info I have found is murky at best. some prominent scholars have indeed disputed the notion, and others haven't...so the question is, how can you be so sure? i understand you have an extensive library of knowledge on this subject, but unfortunately we can't all go out and read everything you have suggested. would you kindly summarize as briefly as possible the evidence against the idea.
 
absolutely clear, however I am curious if you would take the time to point out why there is no connection at all...specifically. you have stated over and over that mainstream academia has debunked the notion of connection but the only real info I have found is murky at best. some prominent scholars have indeed disputed the notion, and others haven't...so the question is, how can you be so sure? i understand you have an extensive library of knowledge on this subject, but unfortunately we can't all go out and read everything you have suggested. would you kindly summarize as briefly as possible the evidence against the idea.

I don't think you understand. It isn't that there is a ton of evidence stating outright that the connection explicitly doesn't exist. Science does not attempt to prove negatives. However, everything I have stated, linked, suggested, and repeated is that there is no evidence that some connection does exist. There is no proof. Anyone who claims otherwise (like the film) is a charlatan. If such proofs existed, it would be at the very top of the archaeological and historical discussion academically. It would, quite literally, revolutionize history as we know it.

This is exactly the reason why no claims that there does exist such a thing have ever been consistent, reviewed, or confirmed. Plenty of people claim to have such proofs, some even write books on the subject (a few were referenced on the film's site), but none of them have ever been proven to any degree of certainty (beyond the author's insistence) in order to have any veracity or verifiable evidence to study.

The main problem with it is that it suffers the same requirement that religious faith does: you have to believe it in your heart, and then you'll 'know' it to be 'true'. This is why I have continually kept away from arguing from a position of "truth" and instead focus on "fact" and "what is known for sure."
 
Or subject to the mob. Never underestimate the power of the mob. The common motto of news, especially television news, is "if it bleeds, it leads." Murdoch's NewsCorp certainly blazed the trail for this type of editorial direction in news reporting, but asserting that he (Murdoch) or any of his peers are actually maintaining a "centralized control" because of this ignores the mob and the effect it has on things.

Hi GreNME,

What I said, if I recall correctly, was that there are significant cases where the pattern of activity in mass media reporting clearly resembles that of a body under centralised control. This includes -

- jumping en masse, overnight, on one particular event and asserting conclusions as to what caused it without even waiting for proper judicial procedures to be followed

- refusing en masse to cover significant events

- taking a unified stance on one political issue, where previously there appeared to be a broad range of stances taken by different media orgs

I said that this pointed to centralised control, not that it actually demonstrated it. I said, if I recall, that is gives reason for concern.



GreNME said:
For being part of a "centralized control" Murdoch has done a poor job at keeping a tight reign on the "information" that he and his ilk supposedly suppress.

Information comes out, yes.

GreNME said:
I don't know how you go from listing administrative tasks (which are essentially menial tasks in bureaucracy) into assuming they have a duty "greater than menial significance." No source, whether online or through people I've asked specifically, can give me a straight answer on how something that all available information describes as a group of overblown maître d's hold any more significance than what is openly known about them. Heck, the CEO of the companies I work for is worth at least a few million dollars and he pays someone to do that sort of work for him, too. Not for nothing, but the people he has hired top do such work have all been well-paid personal assistants.

In the case of the Bilderbergs, it is very hard to get any information. If you care to google I'm sure you will find that they don't exactly advertise their existence, and have been subjected to very little scrutiny from the mass media.


GreNME said:
I doubt it. There are still conspiracy theories that Abraham Lincoln's assassination was a secret conspiracy plot. Old conspiracy theories simply work their way into the annals of Grand Unified Conspiracy Theorytm.

The future is unwritten. Let us see what transpires.


GreNME said:
You're using "symbol" in the form of abstract ideas. I used "symbol" in the form of actual recorded symbols that have been left for archaeological discovery-- symbols in picture form, written form, and artistic creation. Unfortunately, there exists no way to read the minds of people long since deceased in order to glean from them their ideas.

Given that you and I are from the same species as people living a couple of thousand years ago, I think it's reasonable to assume that examining the inner workings of our own minds, and attempting to divine if language precedes symbology in the process of ideation, is a valid methodology.

GreNME said:
Instead, we work from their creations, all of which have been left in different levels of language. Written language, pictorial language, scientific language, engineering language, behavioral language... all of which (and more) are studied in order to gain a better understanding of how and why people in ancient times did what they did. Nothing we know from any civilization-- and this includes their myths-- came to a historical understanding without their languages in context. Otherwise it is pure conjecture.

If one refuses to undertake any level of internal enquiry then this is true. One is stuck with the Rosetta Stone, or whatever. BTW, it is actually the decision to search for the answer also within oneself that marks a crucial stage of the journey towards adulthood of the Hero.



GreNME said:
Mark Rosenfelder has the distinct advantage of not actually taking part in a conversation with you. In fact, in his reply to you he basically referred you to another of his writings instead of explaining to you outright. So, unless you are going to tell me you are asking him to explain and give details for his conclusions in the same manner you have been with me, then I'm going to have to wonder why you are comparing what I've been saying with what he has, since we've both been saying the exact same thing-- similarities do not imply relationships, and claims implying relationships are not based in facts as we know them.

But I feel that I do understand Mark's argument. I'm not convinced that you do.

GreNME said:
Let me use the simplest language I can: "monomyth" is a ridiculous assertion because it relies on similarities, which have shown throughout pretty much every academic field of research to not be indicative of a relationship. Just because there are similarities means nothing. Establish a relationship first, and then allow the similarities to support the established relationship. If you cannot first establish a relationship, then doing so using similarities is intellectually dishonest. Clear enough?

The monomyth relates the journey into adulthood of the Hero. I submit that it is of intrinsic significance because, on some level or other, pretty much everyone is busy with it. Mark pointed out that ancient man would have had relatively few things to construct myths about. This is a good point but it does not actually undermine the existence or reasons for the prevalence of monomyth.

GreNME said:
Now you're making things up. Nowhere in the film do they make the assertions of the monomyth as you've described. You are projecting your own conclusions onto what the film was (incorrectly) saying. You are compounding wild speculation atop wild speculation, at this point.

As I recall, Part 1 of Zeitgeist commences by listing attributes for a range of mythologies or religious deities, making the assertion (true or otherwise) that they are closely related. This does seem to me to be pretty much monomyth.


GreNME said:
There is no known singular source. Let me repeat: there is no known singular source. You may as well be attempting to prove the divine.

I am not attempting to "prove the divine." And, if I was, I certainly wouldn't attempt to do so by trying to validate the existence of a universal source. If a universal source exists (exists not being an ideal term here), then everything would be arising from it, including any attempts to prove or disprove its existence. It would be an exercise in futility.

Nick
 
What I said, if I recall correctly, was that there are significant cases where the pattern of activity in mass media reporting clearly resembles that of a body under centralised control. This includes -

You don't have to "recall correctly," because it's right there. I even quoted it. There's no need for either of us to dance around the obvious, wouldn't you agree?


- jumping en masse, overnight, on one particular event and asserting conclusions as to what caused it without even waiting for proper judicial procedures to be followed

Who decides which procedures to follow? What you are describing is sensationalism, which has always been present since before current media outlets and seems to be the soup du jour of news media reporting nowadays. Since there is no single unified set of procedures, what are you suggesting everyone follow?



- refusing en masse to cover significant events

You're going to have to give an example here, because I'm calling BS on this one. "Significant" is a modifier that has almost completely subjective meaning in the context of news.


- taking a unified stance on one political issue, where previously there appeared to be a broad range of stances taken by different media orgs

Once again, I'm going to need examples, because I'm once again calling BS. There are certain networks out there (FOX, for example) whose entire shtick is to be an opposing ideological view to the assumed "liberal" bias of everyone else.


I said that this pointed to centralised control, not that it actually demonstrated it. I said, if I recall, that is gives reason for concern.

To imply "pointed to" in this case should be predicated by an ability to demonstrate to some degree reasonable evidence of it being used. Come on, you can do better than quibble over semantics when making such a sweeping generalization. Are we going to quibble over the meaning of the word "is" next?


Information comes out, yes.

You're mis-stating what I said. "Information" doesn't just come out, it is often produced, edited, and aired by the very sources who would, if claims of centralized control are made, specifically not want aired. It's as impractical as the proverbial comic book evil mastermind giving clues to the comic book hero of the evil master plan that is about to be executed or is in the process of being executed. It is a simplistic and unrealistic view of things that happen in the world and why they happen.


In the case of the Bilderbergs, it is very hard to get any information. If you care to google I'm sure you will find that they don't exactly advertise their existence, and have been subjected to very little scrutiny from the mass media.

That's a preposterous assumption. Many of the attendees are public figures who undergo scrutiny all the time. That in and of itself gives a pretty strong reason to the emphasis on privacy in these informal meetings. However, having come across things like this alleged 'minutes' to the 1999 e meeting, the impression I get from looking over some of the items in the agenda is one not unlike this very forum and many others like it around the web. Their formatting is not unlike the more publicized TED conferences, whose speakers tend to be individuals who are less likely to have their words misquoted or taken out of context for political reasons, as opposed to the individuals who attend the Bilderberg meetings (though I wouldn't be surprised to see some overlap).


The future is unwritten. Let us see what transpires.

I think that, in this case, you and I have completely different expectations and criteria of what might happen. I am saying that conspiracy theories rarely ever totally die out. I can't think of many that have ever been considered fully 'debunked' by everyone. I have no reason to think this will change. I'd be interested to see if you had any reason to believe that such a pattern might change, though I'm not sure you have that position.


Given that you and I are from the same species as people living a couple of thousand years ago, I think it's reasonable to assume that examining the inner workings of our own minds, and attempting to divine if language precedes symbology in the process of ideation, is a valid methodology.

Methodology for what? For establishing historical fact? For examining cultural phenomenon? What you describe is not only vague, but it is being proposed by you in a manner that is incredibly far-reaching and seems like some proposed panacaea for answering all of the questions ever. Whether that is what you or saying or not, it is exactly the kind of example I am trying to make here: you and I are using the same written language to communicate ideas to each other, and yet we're still not agreeing on a methodology because you keep dropping into this vague spirituality language that has little practical application as an academic methodology.

I'm not trying to argue the concept of "know thyself" with you, Nick. I am attempting to explain for you, using as many examples as possible, why I not only think the entire first section of Zeitgeist got everything incorrect (in various ways), but why the proposition of some assumed monomyth is not based in any kind of real or verifiable evidence.


If one refuses to undertake any level of internal enquiry then this is true. One is stuck with the Rosetta Stone, or whatever. BTW, it is actually the decision to search for the answer also within oneself that marks a crucial stage of the journey towards adulthood of the Hero.

You need to quit the grandiose rhetoric with me, because I'm not buying it and it takes away from your otherwise credible statements. Like I said, this isn't a discussion on the inward journey into ourselves, but an examination of outward historical and cultural claims made by others. I can appreciate that you are very interested in concepts of the inner workings of cultural and mythological symbols on the internal self, but quite frankly this isn't a discussion on how you "feel" about it.


GreNME said:
Mark Rosenfelder has the distinct advantage of not actually taking part in a conversation with you. In fact, in his reply to you he basically referred you to another of his writings instead of explaining to you outright. So, unless you are going to tell me you are asking him to explain and give details for his conclusions in the same manner you have been with me, then I'm going to have to wonder why you are comparing what I've been saying with what he has, since we've both been saying the exact same thing-- similarities do not imply relationships, and claims implying relationships are not based in facts as we know them.
But I feel that I do understand Mark's argument. I'm not convinced that you do.

Prove it. Prove it right now by contacting him yourself and asking him to read the last four pages of this thread. While I am quite sure you may be interpreting what was written by him in mostly a non-conversational format in your own way, you claiming you have an understanding of what he has written and that I do not is about as arrogant and dismissive a reply without actually providing a lick of evidence as you could have possibly made. I back up my claims, I would really appreciate you doing the same when you make statements like this.


The monomyth relates the journey into adulthood of the Hero. I submit that it is of intrinsic significance because, on some level or other, pretty much everyone is busy with it. Mark pointed out that ancient man would have had relatively few things to construct myths about. This is a good point but it does not actually undermine the existence or reasons for the prevalence of monomyth.

To paraphrase what you just said: "The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence."

The problem with that argument is that it equally applies to claims of evidence of existence: the absence of evidence does not support claims of existence.

There is an absence of evidence. Until you can provide evidence of existence-- real evidence, not some hypothetical maybe or what-if or could-be-- of your proposed monomyth theory, I and many others must maintain that there is an absence of evidence that does not support claims of exististence.

As I recall, Part 1 of Zeitgeist commences by listing attributes for a range of mythologies or religious deities, making the assertion (true or otherwise) that they are closely related. This does seem to me to be pretty much monomyth.

Like I said before, "as I recall" is being intellectually lazy in this case. The video is available to download and view again. The film does not do as you describe, and I challenge you to go back and watch it yourself so that I don't have to quote the film for you word-for-word. It makes an affirmative claim to have evidenced and documented proof of the origins of the most popular Christian and Jewish mythological figures. It draws straight lines between these figures and specific figures of other cultures. This film is to your described monomyth as Creationism is to Intelligent Design.


I am not attempting to "prove the divine." And, if I was, I certainly wouldn't attempt to do so by trying to validate the existence of a universal source. If a universal source exists (exists not being an ideal term here), then everything would be arising from it, including any attempts to prove or disprove its existence. It would be an exercise in futility.

Okay, I am going to challenge you and state that you are being intentionally obtuse to my obvious use of metaphor here. I did not accuses you of trying to prove any divinity at all. I said outright that the tactics you are using and the rhetorical habits you are expressing are the same as those used to attempt to prove the divine. I am accusing you of using the same flawed methodology, not of doing the exact same thing. Considering your very heavy focus on the subject of symbols and symbology, the use of a simple metaphor like this should not be foreign to you, and is indicative of stalling.

I'm waiting for you to give proof of existence, by the way. I've stated clearly that the onus is on you to give examples of evidence to support the claim of monomyth. I've already gone over and over the reasons why similarity does not imply a relationship, and as such need a basis from which to quantify it as evidence. Provide such evidential information and we can work from there. My only other suggestion would be to report such information to your local academia, since it would be a huge breakthrough in the fields of history and archaeology.
 
Who decides which procedures to follow? What you are describing is sensationalism, which has always been present since before current media outlets and seems to be the soup du jour of news media reporting nowadays. Since there is no single unified set of procedures, what are you suggesting everyone follow?

Hi GreNME,

I'm saying it looks suspicious when a nation's entire media leap overnight on one situation. The Leah Betts case was suspicious as hell. It indicates to me the liklihood of either a degree of centralised co-ordination, or a prior agreement to just jump all over the first suitable Ecstasy-related incident.


GreNME said:
You're going to have to give an example here, because I'm calling BS on this one. "Significant" is a modifier that has almost completely subjective meaning in the context of news.

Cassini.


GreNME said:
Once again, I'm going to need examples, because I'm once again calling BS. There are certain networks out there (FOX, for example) whose entire shtick is to be an opposing ideological view to the assumed "liberal" bias of everyone else.

When British troops went back into Iraq, in the wake of the WMD / 911 drama, I scoured the mainstream media for a dissenting voice. None to be found. 6-12 months after the event the muttering started, when it was patently obvious that a decent-sized proportion of the British public were quite concerned as to what we were doing there, and had been all along.

Now, you can find alternative explanations for all of these things. I can. But I still maintain that there is sufficient impression of high-level corruption to justify public concern.


GreNME said:
You're mis-stating what I said. "Information" doesn't just come out, it is often produced, edited, and aired by the very sources who would, if claims of centralized control are made, specifically not want aired. It's as impractical as the proverbial comic book evil mastermind giving clues to the comic book hero of the evil master plan that is about to be executed or is in the process of being executed. It is a simplistic and unrealistic view of things that happen in the world and why they happen.

My experience is that the world is, in actuality, nowhere near as complex a place as many would believe. Working as a therapist, I see people daily go through a multitude of dramas rather than simply be vulnerable and learn to accept love. The mind will spin off all over the place, creating complexity to avoid self-confrontation, to avoid feeling. To me personally, it's absolutely normal to see the creation of complexity to mask the simpicity of an unaccepted reality.


GreNME said:
That's a preposterous assumption. Many of the attendees are public figures who undergo scrutiny all the time. That in and of itself gives a pretty strong reason to the emphasis on privacy in these informal meetings. However, having come across things like this alleged 'minutes' to the 1999 e meeting, the impression I get from looking over some of the items in the agenda is one not unlike this very forum and many others like it around the web. Their formatting is not unlike the more publicized TED conferences, whose speakers tend to be individuals who are less likely to have their words misquoted or taken out of context for political reasons, as opposed to the individuals who attend the Bilderberg meetings (though I wouldn't be surprised to see some overlap).

Well, I know very little about the Bilderbergs. I just think they look like something out of James Bond. I mean, this bunch + 911 - you really couldn't make this stuff up if you tried. I repeat...either someone is setting these guys up, or George Bush is just the unluckiest man alive.


GreNME said:
I think that, in this case, you and I have completely different expectations and criteria of what might happen. I am saying that conspiracy theories rarely ever totally die out. I can't think of many that have ever been considered fully 'debunked' by everyone. I have no reason to think this will change. I'd be interested to see if you had any reason to believe that such a pattern might change, though I'm not sure you have that position.

It's reasonable to assume that there could be a mathematical underpinning to the prevalence and popularity of conspiracy theories, especially if they are merely a cyclical phenomena. Perhaps, I guess.


GreNME said:
Methodology for what? For establishing historical fact? For examining cultural phenomenon? What you describe is not only vague, but it is being proposed by you in a manner that is incredibly far-reaching and seems like some proposed panacaea for answering all of the questions ever. Whether that is what you or saying or not, it is exactly the kind of example I am trying to make here: you and I are using the same written language to communicate ideas to each other, and yet we're still not agreeing on a methodology because you keep dropping into this vague spirituality language that has little practical application as an academic methodology.

But I'm not an academic person. Academia bores me, mostly. I never found anything there very satisfying. When you ask "methodology for what?" - I would answer simply..."for finding out the truth." Is this what you seek, GreNME? Are you interested in the truth or are you interested in proving something to somebody else? If you had a choice of one or the other, which would you pick?


GreNME said:
I'm not trying to argue the concept of "know thyself" with you, Nick. I am attempting to explain for you, using as many examples as possible, why I not only think the entire first section of Zeitgeist got everything incorrect (in various ways), but why the proposition of some assumed monomyth is not based in any kind of real or verifiable evidence.

Well, I think it would be fair to say that the dice, so to speak, were loaded with regard to mythology. There probably would be relatively few things that ancient man would have been concerned with and that would become the stuff of legend. One might also say that the elements in mythos which remained relevant or intriguing to the next generation would be the ones most likely to be preserved. From this, one could say that there could be parallel evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives. One could say that there could be convergent evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives.

One might even say that the apparently increasing fascination with alternative theories of religion in general, or even CTs, is due to convergent evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives.

So, for me, these are a few factors here. You are saying there's no monomyth. I'm sorry if it makes me sound like an idiot but I really have yet to see you bring up one thing that actually backs this up. As I see it you are just trying to bring it all back to language and then apply a set of rules valid for language to the notion that mythology has been sustained by language over time.

You have to appreciate something here. I'm not from an academic background. (Possibly you guessed this already). I'm a Qabalist. We study symbols. We study Tarot keys for, like, years! Really. The same 22 year in year out. Symbology attracts us to put our awareness at its feet and we do so, finally gladly. It's relatively meaningless to me to assert primacy to language, except as an auditory experience.

GreNME said:
Like I said before, "as I recall" is being intellectually lazy in this case. The video is available to download and view again. The film does not do as you describe, and I challenge you to go back and watch it yourself so that I don't have to quote the film for you word-for-word. It makes an affirmative claim to have evidenced and documented proof of the origins of the most popular Christian and Jewish mythological figures. It draws straight lines between these figures and specific figures of other cultures. This film is to your described monomyth as Creationism is to Intelligent Design.

For sure it's true that the bit about "journey of the hero into adulthood" I'm overlaying myself to try and provide a deeper layer of convergent meaning. I also posted on deeper spiritual meanings at http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2998561#post2998561. Personally, I think it's justified.

I'm not sure if it makes the claim to have documented proof of the origins of mythological figures, but, assuming your right, then I would agree that that is a pretty extreme claim. I agree that the film examines attributes, and attempts to draw very precise parallels. I would not be surprised if history had not left quite such precise records.

The film also, if I recall, asks people to check out things for themselves, and to look deeper than the surface layer.

GreNME said:
Okay, I am going to challenge you and state that you are being intentionally obtuse to my obvious use of metaphor here. I did not accuses you of trying to prove any divinity at all.

Yes, fair enough. I did actually notice that on re-reading when the post was online. I didn't think it significant about to be worth reposting on, given that I did mention the inevitable issues that surround trying to demonstrate the existence of a unified source.

GreNME said:
I'm waiting for you to give proof of existence, by the way. I've stated clearly that the onus is on you to give examples of evidence to support the claim of monomyth. I've already gone over and over the reasons why similarity does not imply a relationship, and as such need a basis from which to quantify it as evidence. Provide such evidential information and we can work from there. My only other suggestion would be to report such information to your local academia, since it would be a huge breakthrough in the fields of history and archaeology.

I can give you Jesus - Horus/Osiris in Qabalah, in fact I think I probably have, but I doubt you're going to like it much!

I can't give you historical or archaeological evidence. Perhaps it doesn't exist, perhaps it does. I wouldn't know because I know nothing, or relatively little, about history or archaeology.

Finally, I figure, all this academic stuff is, well, academic. Convergent evolutionary unconscious drives, man. An overwhelming and seemingly irrational attraction to certain dramas that symbolically resemble repressed ego conflicts. Better known as conspiracy theories. It's the new zeitgeist, the spirit of the age. Still, I do wish I had sufficient patience be able to argue with you in more academic fashion. It would be nice.

Nick
 
I don't think you understand. It isn't that there is a ton of evidence stating outright that the connection explicitly doesn't exist. Science does not attempt to prove negatives. However, everything I have stated, linked, suggested, and repeated is that there is no evidence that some connection does exist. There is no proof. Anyone who claims otherwise (like the film) is a charlatan. If such proofs existed, it would be at the very top of the archaeological and historical discussion academically. It would, quite literally, revolutionize history as we know it.

Maybe I don't, but I suppose thats your perception of things. My problem with this I think may be logical. History isn't science, so invoking it as a form of logic to determine the validity of the comparison of monomyth like figures proves little. Your absolutely correct that correlation does not equal causation...in science. When talking about meme's and their influence on social history I don't think it is possible to pin down empirically what caused what. History is written by the victors, and it suprises me that we haven't really touched on the well established fact that new rulers bring about new idea's and do away with the ones they don't like. You seem to be appoaching this like recorded history is infallible because "its documented" and verified by persons who are just as fallible as you or I. Yes they have experitise...but it's still an interpretation, and as yet I haven't found a single interpretation by any scholar that states emphatically that there is little or no truth to the idea of cultural cross pollination.

This is exactly the reason why no claims that there does exist such a thing have ever been consistent, reviewed, or confirmed. Plenty of people claim to have such proofs, some even write books on the subject (a few were referenced on the film's site), but none of them have ever been proven to any degree of certainty (beyond the author's insistence) in order to have any veracity or verifiable evidence to study.

But how exactly in a historical sense does that automatically disprove the theory?

The main problem with it is that it suffers the same requirement that religious faith does: you have to believe it in your heart, and then you'll 'know' it to be 'true'. This is why I have continually kept away from arguing from a position of "truth" and instead focus on "fact" and "what is known for sure."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_proof

It is asserted that a proposition is true, only because it has not been proven false. The negative proof fallacy often occurs in the debate of the existence of supernatural phenomena

Since we are not talking about god here...

In some cases a reversed burden of proof may be appropriate. This occurs when there are two competing explanations, and neither can be confirmed by observation. For example: when an empirical relationship has been observed, but the underlying mechanism is unknown, it may be reasonable to infer from the lack of conflicting evidence that the observed relationship is most likely causal

I have asked for direct proof from you that the idea isn't valid, and you tell me I don't understand, and that because there is no proof that such a thing could have existed it most likely didn't, even though some might consider the correlations to be proof because idea's unlike stone are impermanent and subject to change. We know that cultures interact, we can never know exactly how much influence went where, but we know they did...we know all these things are subject to the whims of the ruling class, and that most likely history has been manipulated at different junctures to suit the rulers of the day. As yet you haven't provided any reason to think there isn't something to the correlation other than the lack of evidence that most likely wouldn't exist in the first place. I fail to see how that invalidates a premise such as this considering the last passage quoted in this post.
 
I'm saying it looks suspicious when a nation's entire media leap overnight on one situation. The Leah Betts case was suspicious as hell. It indicates to me the liklihood of either a degree of centralised co-ordination, or a prior agreement to just jump all over the first suitable Ecstasy-related incident.

Never attribute to malice what can more easily be attributed to stupidity. I think sensationalism is close enough to stupidity in most cases.


GreNME said:
Nick227 said:
- refusing en masse to cover significant events
You're going to have to give an example here, because I'm calling BS on this one. "Significant" is a modifier that has almost completely subjective meaning in the context of news.
Cassini.

Can you explain what significance you are referring to that would have predicated the entire world's media? Frankly, while I find it interesting, I wouldn't qualify it as "significant" in a literal sense outside of its respective field. However, I don't know what "media" you have been exposed to, but I recal several mentions of the spacecraft over the years, and I don't know if you knew this but every launch is televised in the US (though since Columbia it hasn't been live on network television). Sorry, but I'm going to have to call you wrong on this one.

If you're interested in Cassini, though, it has its own website.


When British troops went back into Iraq, in the wake of the WMD / 911 drama, I scoured the mainstream media for a dissenting voice. None to be found. 6-12 months after the event the muttering started, when it was patently obvious that a decent-sized proportion of the British public were quite concerned as to what we were doing there, and had been all along.

You
Must've
Not
Looked
Hard
Enough

Distorted reality much? Maybe just because you didn't see them doesn't mean they weren't there?


Now, you can find alternative explanations for all of these things. I can. But I still maintain that there is sufficient impression of high-level corruption to justify public concern.

Corruption and a worldwide conspiracy are two very different things. For example, Rupert Murdoch and his NewsCorp have an ever-present thorn in their side now of watchdogs just waiting until they have enough information to report the company for corruption and bad practices. That does not lead logically to a mass worldwide conspiracy, it leads logically to Murdoch and the people he hires to run his companies are jerks.


My experience is that the world is, in actuality, nowhere near as complex a place as many would believe. Working as a therapist, I see people daily go through a multitude of dramas rather than simply be vulnerable and learn to accept love. The mind will spin off all over the place, creating complexity to avoid self-confrontation, to avoid feeling. To me personally, it's absolutely normal to see the creation of complexity to mask the simpicity of an unaccepted reality.

While I wouldn't call it normal, I would agree that it's common. Many people regularly see patterns in the bark of a tree or with clouds in the sky. The difference is that usually people are able to accept that it is their minds making these patterns and not the patterns having been there all along in hiding (use of artistic license and romanticism excepted).


Well, I know very little about the Bilderbergs. I just think they look like something out of James Bond. I mean, this bunch + 911 - you really couldn't make this stuff up if you tried. I repeat...either someone is setting these guys up, or George Bush is just the unluckiest man alive.

Believe me, I can think of a few other choice modifiers to add to his name that are far worse than "unlucky." :)

However, read that alleged document transcripting the 1999 Bilderberg meeting. I found it fascinating in that it reads very much like a political internet discussion forum summarized into small transcripts.


But I'm not an academic person. Academia bores me, mostly. I never found anything there very satisfying. When you ask "methodology for what?" - I would answer simply..."for finding out the truth." Is this what you seek, GreNME? Are you interested in the truth or are you interested in proving something to somebody else? If you had a choice of one or the other, which would you pick?

I choose facts and understanding over "truth" any day. I have stated numerous times already that I distrust claims of "truth." Fact and knowledge are not truth-- I could be telling you the truth and never once mention a single fact or increase your knowledge.


Well, I think it would be fair to say that the dice, so to speak, were loaded with regard to mythology. There probably would be relatively few things that ancient man would have been concerned with and that would become the stuff of legend. One might also say that the elements in mythos which remained relevant or intriguing to the next generation would be the ones most likely to be preserved. From this, one could say that there could be parallel evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives. One could say that there could be convergent evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives.

You read any Jung lately? ;)

I agree that one could say those things, and depending on the application of those things could have varying degrees of accuracy.


One might even say that the apparently increasing fascination with alternative theories of religion in general, or even CTs, is due to convergent evolutionary factors relating to unconscious drives.

Or seeing patterns in clouds.


So, for me, these are a few factors here. You are saying there's no monomyth. I'm sorry if it makes me sound like an idiot but I really have yet to see you bring up one thing that actually backs this up. As I see it you are just trying to bring it all back to language and then apply a set of rules valid for language to the notion that mythology has been sustained by language over time.

I reply once again with the fact that the onus is on the one who makes the assertion, not the one who points out that no evidence has been supplied to make the assertion and has even explained how the original assertion is flawed.


You have to appreciate something here. I'm not from an academic background. (Possibly you guessed this already). I'm a Qabalist. We study symbols. We study Tarot keys for, like, years! Really. The same 22 year in year out. Symbology attracts us to put our awareness at its feet and we do so, finally gladly. It's relatively meaningless to me to assert primacy to language, except as an auditory experience.

For sure it's true that the bit about "journey of the hero into adulthood" I'm overlaying myself to try and provide a deeper layer of convergent meaning. I also posted on deeper spiritual meanings at http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2998561#post2998561. Personally, I think it's justified.

I'm sorry, but I'm not going to argue with you about the relevance of your religion here. I do not share your religious (or, if you prefer, mystical) faith. Faith is not evidence. I am discussing evidence. Perhaps the religious subforum is more suited to your line of discussion in this regard. I am unqualified to tell you whether your faith is "right" or not.


I'm not sure if it makes the claim to have documented proof of the origins of mythological figures, but, assuming your right, then I would agree that that is a pretty extreme claim. I agree that the film examines attributes, and attempts to draw very precise parallels. I would not be surprised if history had not left quite such precise records.

It's left varying degrees of precision depending on the culture in question. But the precise assertions in the film are where I have my quibbles, because the larger all-encompassing "truth" of the matter is something that falls out of the realm of academic study, and the academic resources that do exist have found that many claims that were assumed in the past-- many of which were used as bases for the claims made in the film-- are not existant in many cases, and not consistent enough to have a conclusion in others.

The film also, if I recall, asks people to check out things for themselves, and to look deeper than the surface layer.

It only does this implicitly, and only suggests the sources it used to make the film, many of which are based on outdated or fractured / fragmented study.


I can give you Jesus - Horus/Osiris in Qabalah, in fact I think I probably have, but I doubt you're going to like it much!
But we've already been over this. There is nothing but similarities implying a relationship. In the realm of claiming a spiritual symbolism in the similarities, I am sure there is validity in your example. However, it does not actually show a real, evidential connection outside of the similarity.


I can't give you historical or archaeological evidence. Perhaps it doesn't exist, perhaps it does. I wouldn't know because I know nothing, or relatively little, about history or archaeology.

Finally, I figure, all this academic stuff is, well, academic. Convergent evolutionary unconscious drives, man. An overwhelming and seemingly irrational attraction to certain dramas that symbolically resemble repressed ego conflicts. Better known as conspiracy theories. It's the new zeitgeist, the spirit of the age. Still, I do wish I had sufficient patience be able to argue with you in more academic fashion. It would be nice.

I think you've done quite well in your efforts thus far, so don't short-change yourself. I think that at this point, similar to before, the place on the path where we diverge begins at the point where spirituality and symbolism meet. But that brings us to a point-- call it philosophical, spiritual, or whatever-- where we don't really have to have a firm agreement in order to accept the previous parts of our discussion.
 
Maybe I don't, but I suppose thats your perception of things. My problem with this I think may be logical.

Excuse me, but you're going to need to explain the logic behind this:


History isn't science,

You are wrong on so many levels with a statement like this I don't even know where to begin. I'm just going to suggest you go tell a history professor or a historian that history isn't science. While you're at it, tell a sociologist, architect, linguist, mathematician, geologist, and political theorist that their respective fields aren't science, either. You see, history-- real history, not some social studies assignment in primary school-- requires not only consideration but examination of all of these fields and more. Archaeology expeditions tend to include resident experts from many of these fields in their research, and are accounted for and examined in historical study. Tell a historian who can explain to you how and why Egyptians used a base 2 mathematical system or a historian who can show you the Mayan base 20 mathematical system that their field isn't science.


so invoking it as a form of logic to determine the validity of the comparison of monomyth like figures proves little. Your absolutely correct that correlation does not equal causation...in science.

Which applies with history and archaeology, which is what I've been saying.


When talking about meme's and their influence on social history I don't think it is possible to pin down empirically what caused what. History is written by the victors, and it suprises me that we haven't really touched on the well established fact that new rulers bring about new idea's and do away with the ones they don't like.

That is a horribly simplistic explanation for a concept that is far more complex than you are attempting to portray.


You seem to be appoaching this like recorded history is infallible because "its documented" and verified by persons who are just as fallible as you or I. Yes they have experitise...but it's still an interpretation, and as yet I haven't found a single interpretation by any scholar that states emphatically that there is little or no truth to the idea of cultural cross pollination.

You're still taking way too simplistic an approach. For instance, until the discovery of the Nag Hammadi, there was very little known of the different sects of Christians and their differences in mythology, but their existence was known despite attempts to remove traces of their existence. As a result, many theories were formed with possibilities abouth some details of their lives. After the discovery of the Nag Hammadi, many of these theories were either discarded or altered to accurately reflect the new discovery. This same process happened when the Rosetta Stone was discovered. This same process happens all the time. There is no "history" that is set in stone, becausewhen new information is found the perspective reacts accordingly. My entire assertion throughout these past few pages is that the claims made in the film are based on old and dated information, often compiled into commentaries by people who refuse to accept the newer discoveries.


But how exactly in a historical sense does that automatically disprove the theory?

Not in the way you think.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_proof
It is asserted that a proposition is true, only because it has not been proven false. The negative proof fallacy often occurs in the debate of the existence of supernatural phenomena

I find it ironic that you quote this and then commit that very fallacy


I have asked for direct proof from you that the idea isn't valid, and you tell me I don't understand, and that because there is no proof that such a thing could have existed it most likely didn't, even though some might consider the correlations to be proof because idea's unlike stone are impermanent and subject to change. We know that cultures interact, we can never know exactly how much influence went where, but we know they did...we know all these things are subject to the whims of the ruling class, and that most likely history has been manipulated at different junctures to suit the rulers of the day. As yet you haven't provided any reason to think there isn't something to the correlation other than the lack of evidence that most likely wouldn't exist in the first place. I fail to see how that invalidates a premise such as this considering the last passage quoted in this post.

The movie made an assertation, and the fallacy you are committing is stating that because I am not providing proof that the movie's assertation is false. I am instead providing a number of proofs that are showing why there is no proof to support the movie's assertation. I have also corrected a number of its incorrect claims due to things ranging from improper linguistic context to improper dating on a timeline. In the end, however, the biggest fallacy of the film's assertions regarding religion is that correlation does not imply causation and that similarities to not imply a relationship.

And now you are replying by not only supplying the logical fallacy you then proceed to commit, but you top it off with saying history isn't a science and as such does not require a logical connection to be proven for the movie's misleading claims to be taken seriously.
 
Never attribute to malice what can more easily be attributed to stupidity. I think sensationalism is close enough to stupidity in most cases.

Hi GreNME,

I don't see how stupidity causes a whole spectrum of mass media to move as one. It's not about the details of the case, (though we could go there too). It's about the pattern of activity.

GreNME said:
Can you explain what significance you are referring to that would have predicated the entire world's media?

Cassini was powered by 32 kg of radioactive plutonium, which is, if I recall, the world's most toxic substance. It was fired into space and then, later, brought back into the earth's orbit for a fly-by to send it towards Saturn. Whilst varying sources widely differ as to the actual level of risk, there's certainly historical reason for concern. Can you think of a potentially more dangerous man-made event in recent world history? Given that plutonium has previously been dumped into the upper atmosphere by spaceships and studies, which for sure could still be debated, have attributed significance in global cancer rates, I would have thought that many of the world's citizens would have liked to know what NASA were up to. I think many people would have liked to debate whether getting some nice pictures of Saturn was worth this risk. Had I been sitting in Rupert Murdoch's chair for that week I would have had the entire planet reading my newspapers. No problemo. But, virtually no one was aware of it.




GreNME said:

There were reports of the peace rally. There was no, as I recall, actual dissent in the media. Good piece in the Independent though, must have missed that one.



GreNME said:
Corruption and a worldwide conspiracy are two very different things. For example, Rupert Murdoch and his NewsCorp have an ever-present thorn in their side now of watchdogs just waiting until they have enough information to report the company for corruption and bad practices. That does not lead logically to a mass worldwide conspiracy, it leads logically to Murdoch and the people he hires to run his companies are jerks.

At some point in this dialogue it may occur to you that actually what I am talking about is patterns of activity, and whether there is cause for concern. Hope springs eternal!

GreNME said:
I choose facts and understanding over "truth" any day. I have stated numerous times already that I distrust claims of "truth." Fact and knowledge are not truth-- I could be telling you the truth and never once mention a single fact or increase your knowledge.

Perhaps truth can't meaningfully be debated.


GreNME said:
I reply once again with the fact that the onus is on the one who makes the assertion, not the one who points out that no evidence has been supplied to make the assertion and has even explained how the original assertion is flawed.

I must admit that I have missed your actual case against Zeitgeist Part 1, that the attributions supplied are significantly not validated. Not saying you haven't made it, just that I don't seem to have read it yet.



GreNME said:
I'm sorry, but I'm not going to argue with you about the relevance of your religion here. I do not share your religious (or, if you prefer, mystical) faith. Faith is not evidence. I am discussing evidence. Perhaps the religious subforum is more suited to your line of discussion in this regard. I am unqualified to tell you whether your faith is "right" or not.

I can assure you that there are core aspects to your very notion of selfhood for which there is no meaningful evidence whatsoever. You have it entirely on faith, or rather on prefering not to check for evidence or lack of it.

This aside, Zeitgeist asserts that the travels of the Sun provides the unifying symbology that provides a source for the varied mythos it quotes. I am saying that, whilst this may be considered valid, the case becomes stronger (imo) when one examines the mythology from other perspectives, such as the Journey into Adulthood of the Hero, or extensions of this into spiritual philosophy. Whilst one might very well challenge the veracity of these philosophies to achieve what they may purport to, this does not really make any difference to the fact that many people have and still study and believe these things, or indeed, to the notion that the Jesus myth is merely an extension of them.


GreNME said:
But we've already been over this. There is nothing but similarities implying a relationship. In the realm of claiming a spiritual symbolism in the similarities, I am sure there is validity in your example. However, it does not actually show a real, evidential connection outside of the similarity.

But is the whole case not based around similarity? There are strong similarities in the attributions assigned to the varying mythoi. There are strong similarities with central themes in human life and development. Why don't we get down to actually debating the evidence you have to oppose the claims in Zeitgeist p1? What do you think?

Nick

ps - regarding Jung, quoting from memory - the psychological rule says that when an individual remains remains undivided and does not become conscious of his inner contradiction , the world must perforce act out the conflict and be torn into opposite halves NWO=CT. They need each other!
 
Cassini was powered by 32 kg of radioactive plutonium, which is, if I recall, the world's most toxic substance. It was fired into space and then, later, brought back into the earth's orbit for a fly-by to send it towards Saturn. Whilst varying sources widely differ as to the actual level of risk, there's certainly historical reason for concern. Can you think of a potentially more dangerous man-made event in recent world history? Given that plutonium has previously been dumped into the upper atmosphere by spaceships and studies, which for sure could still be debated, have attributed significance in global cancer rates, I would have thought that many of the world's citizens would have liked to know what NASA were up to. I think many people would have liked to debate whether getting some nice pictures of Saturn was worth this risk. Had I been sitting in Rupert Murdoch's chair for that week I would have had the entire planet reading my newspapers. No problemo. But, virtually no one was aware of it.

Did you ever stop to think that perhaps it was because it wasn't nearly as big a deal as you might think? From what I remember, the initial fear of the radioactive material was eased by the explanations from NASA that there was no worldwide danger of dispersal, and that worst case scenario most of the radioactivity wouldn't make it near populated areas.

This was on US stations that I saw this, so YMMV.


There were reports of the peace rally. There was no, as I recall, actual dissent in the media. Good piece in the Independent though, must have missed that one.

Come on. That was two minutes of searching. Two minutes. I'm sure more could be found, this was more an example that your perception and reality in this case were not quite the same. These were, after all, not schroedinger-like articles. :)


Perhaps truth can't meaningfully be debated.

Considering "truth" differs from person to person, I don't see how debating in in any other fashion than "is so-and-so telling the truth from their perspective?" to be unrewarding at best. To keep somewhat on-topic, I can listen to a conspiracy theory that someone tells me and conclude that the person telling me is being completely truthful with what they believe and feel, but such a thing doesn't make the theory any more "true" to me, and does not necessitate being factual on all counts. I think that eyewitnesses in criminal trials tend to be telling the whole truth as they believe it when testifying in courtrooms, but on the other hand several murder and rape convictions in my state have been overturned of the past few years due to conclusive DNA evidence showing that the individuals convicted were innocent.


But is the whole case not based around similarity? There are strong similarities in the attributions assigned to the varying mythoi. There are strong similarities with central themes in human life and development. Why don't we get down to actually debating the evidence you have to oppose the claims in Zeitgeist p1? What do you think?

I think you're slightly misunderstanding. The evidences and proofs I have been providing from the get-go are not tailored to prove claims made in Zetgeist pt1 specifically wrong, they display how the claims of evidence in the film are in fact false or non-existant. The movie isn't wrong because there is some single paper or proof out there that specifically proves them wrong. The movie is wrong because it makes specific claims about specific myths from specific cultures, and the claims it makes are either backward, misconstrued, mistranslated, not in a proper sequential order, or outright false claims. I even went through and listed a whole slew of them in a PDF document. There is no "A + B = C" evidence or proof that is going to make the case one way or the other, and that's one of the film's overall largest fallacies (and one of many CTs)-- presenting things in an "A + B = C" manner as if everything that ever happens always adds up that way.

What I think specifically about the Zeitgeist film is that it attempts to draw specific lines of delineation for relationships in different mythologies in an intellectually dishonest and lazy manner. Some of the issues it discusses, like claims that Egyptians influenced the Jews, are almost completely baseless and contradictory to what things we do know historically-- the areas where these two cultures developed were separate from each other, and if nothing else the Hyksos dynastic period would have been the most likely period for any crossover, which would have been in the opposite direction. Other things the film discusses, like the astrology aspects of many cultures, draws conclusions solely on the basis of similarities and does not show any evidence of actual relationships where these similarities could be determined to have been shared-- this is notably so in its vague descriptions between Greek, Babylonian, and Egyptian versions of astronomy, where the film relies heavily on Greek names and interpretations that were documented thousands of years after-the-fact by the likes of Ptolemy, whereas Egyptian and Babylonian counterparts used different names and different myths to symbolize the figures. Overall, what archaeological and historical evidence leads modern study to understand is that the basic elements of life-- rain, the Sun, the Moon, and seasonal shifts-- played a large role in the development of cultural mythologies. The film attempts to take this a step further and accuses certain religions (in the film's case, Christianity and Judaism), of plagiarizing from Egyptian sources first, Greek sources second, and other sources after that. Not only is such an accusation wrong on many levels, but on some of those levels it has mixed-up timelines for when the cultures communicated with each other and for changes in specific cultural mythologies-- for instance, the Egyptians experienced extreme changes in mythological stories attached to their astrology between dynasties (specifically related to the new rulers, not outside influences), and the film never takes this into account.

Overall, the whole first part of Zeitgeist is historically inaccurate and intellectually misleading, for what seems to culminate at the end of pt1 to be a conclusion inferring malicious motivations for the existence of the religious mythologies in question-- Christianity in particular, Judaism in supplement. This film has every indication of having formed the conclusion ahead of time and cherry-picking sources of dubious accuracy in order to support its predetermined conclusion.
 
Did you ever stop to think that perhaps it was because it wasn't nearly as big a deal as you might think? From what I remember, the initial fear of the radioactive material was eased by the explanations from NASA that there was no worldwide danger of dispersal, and that worst case scenario most of the radioactivity wouldn't make it near populated areas.

Oh, well that's perfectly alright then! I mean I would consider NASA to be sooooo a neutral observer. (BTW, if you check online, you will find a multitude of opposing opinions on the subject. Given our lack of knowledge of cancer, I'm personally surprised Nasa scientists felt so confident of their opinions. I wonder how many would care to ingest those miniscule levels of plutonium 238 just to prove the point).

I see, however, that it did make news in the States at the time. USA Today quoted NASA scientists for one, so fair enough, there was some coverage. I saw virtually none in the UK. I was searching around the time of the fly-by, which, for the record, threatened to dump up to 10Kg into the earth's upper atmosphere had it gone wrong. Given that our knowledge of the causes and effective treatment is minimal, this seems to me an absolutely insanely reckless manoevre. I'm also confident that, had they known about it, virtually no one on earth would have considered researching Saturn worth this risk.

GreNME said:
Come on. That was two minutes of searching. Two minutes. I'm sure more could be found, this was more an example that your perception and reality in this case were not quite the same. These were, after all, not schroedinger-like articles. :)

GreNME,

Whilst I hate to stop a CT-opposer in full flow, busy putting out a position that is unquestionably valid, yet not what was actually being discussed, I do in this instance feel a strange compulsion to point out once again, that this is not the point we were discussing. I did not say that the media had a ban on reporting the British troops return to Iraq, or any demonstations. I said that there were no discenting voices from them at the time. The front page stance of all the UK dailies, as I recall, was uniformly pro the conflict, despite the fact that everyone knew a lot of the British public were not. Why, it almost seemed the media were once again toeing an unseen line.



GreNME said:
I think you're slightly misunderstanding. The evidences and proofs I have been providing from the get-go are not tailored to prove claims made in Zetgeist pt1 specifically wrong, they display how the claims of evidence in the film are in fact false or non-existant. The movie isn't wrong because there is some single paper or proof out there that specifically proves them wrong. The movie is wrong because it makes specific claims about specific myths from specific cultures, and the claims it makes are either backward, misconstrued, mistranslated, not in a proper sequential order, or outright false claims. I even went through and listed a whole slew of them in a PDF document. There is no "A + B = C" evidence or proof that is going to make the case one way or the other, and that's one of the film's overall largest fallacies (and one of many CTs)-- presenting things in an "A + B = C" manner as if everything that ever happens always adds up that way.

The opposer field has been known to do the same. Where there's an unconscious need to either believe or disbelieve, you can pretty much guarantee that meaningful researching won't occur. Did you link your pdf, btw? Would be great to have a read.


GreNME said:
What I think specifically about the Zeitgeist film is that it attempts to draw specific lines of delineation for relationships in different mythologies in an intellectually dishonest and lazy manner. Some of the issues it discusses, like claims that Egyptians influenced the Jews, are almost completely baseless and contradictory to what things we do know historically-- the areas where these two cultures developed were separate from each other, and if nothing else the Hyksos dynastic period would have been the most likely period for any crossover, which would have been in the opposite direction.

I don't recall the quote and so it may or may not be of any significance to mention that both "Egyptians" and "Israelites" have separate, symbolic meanings in Qabalah, as when Moses leads them out of Egypt. Journey of the Hero metaphor again.

GreNME said:
Other things the film discusses, like the astrology aspects of many cultures, draws conclusions solely on the basis of similarities and does not show any evidence of actual relationships where these similarities could be determined to have been shared-- this is notably so in its vague descriptions between Greek, Babylonian, and Egyptian versions of astronomy, where the film relies heavily on Greek names and interpretations that were documented thousands of years after-the-fact by the likes of Ptolemy, whereas Egyptian and Babylonian counterparts used different names and different myths to symbolize the figures.

Well, astrology's not really my thing but I must admit that it did look a bit suspect.

GreNME said:
Overall, what archaeological and historical evidence leads modern study to understand is that the basic elements of life-- rain, the Sun, the Moon, and seasonal shifts-- played a large role in the development of cultural mythologies. The film attempts to take this a step further and accuses certain religions (in the film's case, Christianity and Judaism), of plagiarizing from Egyptian sources first, Greek sources second, and other sources after that. Not only is such an accusation wrong on many levels, but on some of those levels it has mixed-up timelines for when the cultures communicated with each other and for changes in specific cultural mythologies-- for instance, the Egyptians experienced extreme changes in mythological stories attached to their astrology between dynasties (specifically related to the new rulers, not outside influences), and the film never takes this into account.

If they accused the Christians of plagiarism, I think that's a bit harsh. Personally, I'm sure the Gospels were written in good faith. If anything, Christ is an amalgamation and extension of the powers and voyages of the older Heroes from which he descended.

Be great to read your paper.

Nick
 
Oh, well that's perfectly alright then! I mean I would consider NASA to be sooooo a neutral observer. (BTW, if you check online, you will find a multitude of opposing opinions on the subject. Given our lack of knowledge of cancer, I'm personally surprised Nasa scientists felt so confident of their opinions. I wonder how many would care to ingest those miniscule levels of plutonium 238 just to prove the point).

I see, however, that it did make news in the States at the time. USA Today quoted NASA scientists for one, so fair enough, there was some coverage. I saw virtually none in the UK. I was searching around the time of the fly-by, which, for the record, threatened to dump up to 10Kg into the earth's upper atmosphere had it gone wrong. Given that our knowledge of the causes and effective treatment is minimal, this seems to me an absolutely insanely reckless manoevre. I'm also confident that, had they known about it, virtually no one on earth would have considered researching Saturn worth this risk.

I don't think I expressed my point clearly enough. It wasn't that NASA claimed a worst-case scenario would be harmless, it was that NASA worked out the trajectories to ensure that, in the case of a worst scenario, that the plutonium would re-enter far away from populated areas. NASA does this all the time, with every single mission they fly. It is for this very reason that NASA administrative heads, government fund committees, the media, and the US public are so heavily affected when something goes FUBAR in a mission (like Columbia). The success rate for redundancies that NASA puts into their missions is higher than any government or military failsafe I can think of, and more successful than contingenies that any other space program around the world has had (so far).

I understand you not having faith in the word of engineers just because they say so. That's a valid concern. However, enough had been explained and the history of NASA's due diligence in avoiding disasters on missions has been stellar, and if anyone ever thought that wasn't enough, you could obtain a lot of the actual technical specifications that explain their goals, failsafes, and contingencies in the case of failures at every stage. They don't hand out the information as if they were leaflets at a convention, but they don't keep their math that has been worked out a secret.


Whilst I hate to stop a CT-opposer in full flow, busy putting out a position that is unquestionably valid, yet not what was actually being discussed, I do in this instance feel a strange compulsion to point out once again, that this is not the point we were discussing. I did not say that the media had a ban on reporting the British troops return to Iraq, or any demonstations. I said that there were no discenting voices from them at the time. The front page stance of all the UK dailies, as I recall, was uniformly pro the conflict, despite the fact that everyone knew a lot of the British public were not. Why, it almost seemed the media were once again toeing an unseen line.

You know, setting me up as an "opposer" is disingenuous. You said there was no coverage of dissent. Within a couple of minutes I found several articles. If I wanted to show you that perhaps just because you didn't percieve any such thing it does not mean said thing didn't exist. Clearly it did, though perhaps not in a level acceptable or indicative of your perceived public support or outrage. When talking about the level of actual questioning of the claims being made by both of our governments, I agree there should have been more examination and less jingoistic marching to the tune of faux patriotism. I see no reason to blow that disappointment with the run-up to the war out of proportion, because I think the indictment that complacency in the form of jingoism is what kept them silent is damning enough.


The opposer field has been known to do the same. Where there's an unconscious need to either believe or disbelieve, you can pretty much guarantee that meaningful researching won't occur. Did you link your pdf, btw? Would be great to have a read.

I linked a PDF copy of notes I took during my viewing of the film. They are notes, not collected into any full essay form, and not covering all of the separate inconsistencies (only the most glaring ones). It was linked a few pages back by me.


I don't recall the quote and so it may or may not be of any significance to mention that both "Egyptians" and "Israelites" have separate, symbolic meanings in Qabalah, as when Moses leads them out of Egypt. Journey of the Hero metaphor again.

But they weren't talking about metaphor. They were talking about literal historical precedent taken from one by the other.


Well, astrology's not really my thing but I must admit that it did look a bit suspect.

If they accused the Christians of plagiarism, I think that's a bit harsh. Personally, I'm sure the Gospels were written in good faith. If anything, Christ is an amalgamation and extension of the powers and voyages of the older Heroes from which he descended.

Who was it that said there is only a certain number of stories (was it seven or ten?) that can be written, and that all stories are variations of those base themes? If supposing that the permutations for hero mythology pieces is limited, then the conclusion is that there are obviously going to be similarities. That doesn't seem to contradict anything. However, when taken to the extent that the film does in claiming a direct progression, the credibility runs ever thinner as the "evidence" in the claims proves dubious or outright false.


Be great to read your paper.

Nick

Feel free to check back a couple pages for the initial PDF containing the notes, but to date I have no actual paper written on it. I probably will eventually, and if I do I can keep you in mind for a copy of it.
 
I don't think I expressed my point clearly enough. It wasn't that NASA claimed a worst-case scenario would be harmless, it was that NASA worked out the trajectories to ensure that, in the case of a worst scenario, that the plutonium would re-enter far away from populated areas.

Was that for the launch, or the fly-by? Could they predict, in the event of an accident in the latter, just where burn-up and re-entry would have occurred?

GreNME said:
NASA does this all the time, with every single mission they fly. It is for this very reason that NASA administrative heads, government fund committees, the media, and the US public are so heavily affected when something goes FUBAR in a mission (like Columbia). The success rate for redundancies that NASA puts into their missions is higher than any government or military failsafe I can think of, and more successful than contingenies that any other space program around the world has had (so far).

Well, I can't imagine there are so many of them but I can certainly imagine that it's inevitably a risky business.


GreNME said:
I understand you not having faith in the word of engineers just because they say so. That's a valid concern. However, enough had been explained and the history of NASA's due diligence in avoiding disasters on missions has been stellar, and if anyone ever thought that wasn't enough, you could obtain a lot of the actual technical specifications that explain their goals, failsafes, and contingencies in the case of failures at every stage. They don't hand out the information as if they were leaflets at a convention, but they don't keep their math that has been worked out a secret.

I wasn't so concerned about the engineers, more NASA's line on plutonium 238 itself. I submit, it's very difficult given the relative lack of understanding we, even now, have about cancer to make accurate statements as to the long-term risk of exposure. Maybe it's not significant, maybe it is. For me it's anyway there's enough to warrant a lot more concern that the media gave the topic.


GreNME said:
You know, setting me up as an "opposer" is disingenuous. You said there was no coverage of dissent.

Actually, what I said was..."- taking a unified stance on one political issue, where previously there appeared to be a broad range of stances taken by different media orgs". Maybe I didn't express it so well. I didn't say there was no coverage of public dissent, rather that there was no dissent expressed by the mainstream media themselves. As I recall. Left wing, right wing, when the troops marched in they all toed the invisible line, prompting the question - if a line was set, who set it?

GreNME said:
I linked a PDF copy of notes I took during my viewing of the film. They are notes, not collected into any full essay form, and not covering all of the separate inconsistencies (only the most glaring ones). It was linked a few pages back by me.

I'll check for it. Thanks.

GreNME said:
Who was it that said there is only a certain number of stories (was it seven or ten?) that can be written, and that all stories are variations of those base themes? If supposing that the permutations for hero mythology pieces is limited, then the conclusion is that there are obviously going to be similarities. That doesn't seem to contradict anything. However, when taken to the extent that the film does in claiming a direct progression, the credibility runs ever thinner as the "evidence" in the claims proves dubious or outright false.

I saw an interesting precis of Harpur's "Pagan Christ" online at www.religioustolerance.org/chr_jcpa5.htm What do you think? On the surface it looks pretty convincing.

Nick
 
Excuse me, but you're going to need to explain the logic behind this:

Gladly.

You are wrong on so many levels with a statement like this I don't even know where to begin. I'm just going to suggest you go tell a history professor or a historian that history isn't science. While you're at it, tell a sociologist, architect, linguist, mathematician, geologist, and political theorist that their respective fields aren't science, either. You see, history-- real
history, not some social studies assignment in primary school-- requires not only consideration but examination of all of these fields and more. Archaeology expeditions tend to include resident experts from many of these fields in their research, and are accounted for and examined in historical study. Tell a historian who can explain to you how and why Egyptians used a base 2 mathematical system or a historian who can show you the Mayan base 20 mathematical system that their field isn't science.

I'll do you one better, my lady friend who is a "human geographer" at the university of iowa was presented with this argument(that social sciences aren't like hard sciences) and as I cringed in preparation for my reaming she informed me that she agreed to an extent. Her answer was, to paraphrase:

"They operate with similar methods, however social sciences are much less objective then say chemistry, or mathematics, or physics. The social world we live in is far too complex to break down in such a linear way because humans are infinitely more unpredictable than say...atoms..."

I bring this up, because you are attempting to imply that they are as rigid as hard sciences in order to lend your argument more credibility.


That is a horribly simplistic explanation for a concept that is far more complex than you are attempting to portray.

Just because something can be summarized clearly and succinctly doesn't mean that it isn't complex. You must have some idea as to the complexity involved in trying to unravel cross cultural meme's?

My entire assertion throughout these past few pages is that the claims made in the film are based on old and dated information, often compiled into commentaries by people who refuse to accept the newer discoveries.

And the newer discoveries are??? You have had much time to unravel this for us, and yet here, and even in your own 11 page dissection of the films first part I see little reference to this mysterious evidence. There isn't even a bibliography or cited references, something that the film at least supplied. I keep assuming that you could spend a minute to summarize these findings for our consideration, and am disappointed time and again when nothing surfaces...so I go and look through jstor, and the universities own online peer reviewed paper database and still find nothing that states with the certainty you have anything that would bolster YOUR claims.


I find it ironic that you quote this and then commit that very fallacy

I find it ironic that you can take that statement like I am assuming that I have the answer. That was posted demonstrate what you think is going on here...
For example: when an empirical relationship has been observed, but the underlying mechanism is unknown, it may be reasonable to infer from the lack of conflicting evidence that the observed relationship is most likely causal

And that was posted to let you know what is really in fact going on here imo...hence the emboldened text.

The movie made an assertation, and the fallacy you are committing is stating that because I am not providing proof that the movie's assertation is false. I am instead providing a number of proofs that are showing why there is no proof to support the movie's assertation. I have also corrected a number of its incorrect claims due to things ranging from improper linguistic context to improper dating on a timeline. In the end, however, the biggest fallacy of the film's assertions regarding religion is that correlation does not imply causation and that similarities to not imply a relationship.

What real proofs have you supplied though? You are attempting to not only debunk the films assertions but whole areas of study that support the thesis. I think we are all well aware and have stated several times in agreement that the films first section is lacking a certain historical rigor. No one is disputing that, what is being defended is the thesis...hence the reference to the monomyth hypothesis, and meme's and mysticism...the correspondences of which you have not addressed or considered to the best of my knowledge.

Why don't we get down to actually debating the evidence you have to oppose the claims in Zeitgeist p1? What do you think?

Awesome....best suggestion yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom