It makes it as necessary as it does for anyone else. When I hear phrases like "own the media" I am given the impression that the originators of such claims have very little clue what "the media" really is. These moguls you refer to own "the media" just about as much as Bill Gates owns Microsoft-- which is to say not at all in the literal sense of the term. These moguls "own" companies and corporations that maintain administrative control over numerous media outlets, though in most cases there is very little direct administrative control over the different smaller affiliates that fall under their banner. Some people, like Murdoch, have worked to direct levels of management down as far as it could go in order to provide results that are to the enjoyment of Murdoch, but even with his remarkable (and documented, tracked, and highly criticized) success, there are still NewsCorp affiliates who run stories that are antithetical to Murdoch's own publicly known political views. There are still articles, radio spots, and other pieces that fall outside of the ideology of Murdoch-land. Since many of the affiliates don't have the ability or resources to rely solely on inside writing and journalism, the work of other sources (including freelance and otherwise affiliated) is common use.
What these people "own" is a revenue source, not some magical keys to the public mind. There is definitely sensationalism, pandering, bias, and intellectual dishonesty that goes on in all types of media, including news media. There is no evidence that it's all being directed by anyone but a series of flaky, overzealous, and disconnected people who run affiliate stations or are program managers, editors, and in some cases even the journalists themselves.
Well, I can only point you back a page or two to where this part of the thread commenced. In my personal experience, the media behave on occasions exactly as though they are under centralised control.
GreNME said:But there isn't an extreme lack of information. It's the extreme different in the interpretation of information based on the assumptions of the viewer of the information. See my response to the "steering committee" thing as an example. I only know this after having seen steering committees and what they do, and after having the experience of dealing with bureaucratic organizational structures where lots of people have overblown titles compared to their actual duties. This is an organization phenomenon that is common in bureaucratic ladders where everyone wishes to be a manager of something. It isn't even an obscure phenomenon. Conspiracy theorists, however, often never consider simplistic answers like this to explain what is otherwise referred to them as ominous and suspicious signs of foul play.
That is one example, perhaps. I don't know that it can really be said to demonstrate any kind of principle here. In addition, the Bilderberg "steering committee" would presumably also be busy with just who was invited to the annual gathering. And presumably what subjects might be discussed. To me this suggests a little greater than menial significance. It could effectively be a core decision-forming group, though online sources appear to place it as the second of three rings.
GreNME said:Only in the minds of conspiracy theorists. Many of the things a conspiracy theory may demand investigation of have either already been examined or are already known without the ominous subtext. Without the ominous subtext of supposed malicious intent, many conspiracy theories crumble under their own assertations.
Well, let's see. I guess time will tell.
GreNME said:'Symbols' are just representations for language, and are studied along with character-based linguistics.
What !! On what basis can you assert the primacy of language over symbol? Are you sufficiently familiar with the experience of thought that you can track it back to its source?
How do you know that the unconscious isn't symbolic in actual nature?
GreNME said:Symbols are dependent on interpretation, and any number of symbols can be placed together in a similar context when they are described in a single language. This is the failing of attempting to understand the conveyance of symbols without understanding the context of how concepts are conveyed within their respective languages. I'm not claiming that someone studying these things needs to understand all languages, but understanding how different languages portray concepts is crucial to understanding what the symbols actually are. Otherwise (like with pre-Rosetta-Stone Egyptology) many of the symbols and symbolism are subject to conjecture and wild speculation.
Language can be used to relate symbology and can be a medium for relating different symbol systems but I see nothing to assert that language is itself primary in the experience of ideation, or indeed in any way primary over symbols.
GreNME said:That passage is describing differences in accent and variation within a single language passed down over time. This is what I meant earlier about attributing too much significance to the wrong things. The passage you quote is talking about differences like the difference in things like the American and British pronounciation of words like aluminum, schedule, and herbs (with special mention of Eddie Izzard for using it as a joke).
Well, it was pretty much the only passage in the piece that actually did describe just what Blevin's piece was about.
GreNME said:I pointed out to you examples of why other fields have come to the conclusion of separate development of key aspects of their respective cultures and civilizations. The implication is that the general consensus has concluded separate development of many of these civilizations, which would remove the possible methods through which any unified "monomyth" could be transferred from one civilization to another. The existence of a monomyth and the consensus of every academic field regarding ancient civilizations are mutually exclusive to one another.
You quote a lot of high intensity rhetoric, GreNME, and apparently seem convinced of your truth. But I remain unconvinced. When I read Mark Rosenfelder, I can follow his arguments easily. He speaks simple language and it makes sense to me. But when I read you, you overlay this constant convinced position that you are articulating some implicit truth when, let's face it, everyone in this field knows you're dealing with shades of grey. You can't make these absolute assertions and back them up, however attractive it might be to do so.
GreNME said:You're moving the goalpost now, Nick. Do you want to cover how this discredits the idea of monomyth, or are we now back to speaking specifically of the Jesus myth in Zeitgeist? The whole rest of your post was referring to the former, not the latter.
GreNME, we've been discussing Jesus as a figure in the monomyth all along. As far as I was aware. That was the Zeitgeist position.
GreNME said:You understand incorrectly. Parallel evolution refers to separate but similar environmental conditions resulting in similar (but not always the same) results.
The source? What statement does it make about the source, GreNME? I submit that parallel evolution makes a statement about the process but none about the source. The phenomena of parallel, or convergent, evolution provides a mechanism for understanding how things can become similar over time, but it makes no statement about their source. It in no way excludes the possibility that things had a direct relationship at source level, merely demonstrates that this does not necessarily have to be present.
Nick