Torture memo...OMG

I didn't throw rocks at him, or anyone here specifically. I apologize to him and everyone else here for the confusion. I do think that the "complexity" claimed by some people is cover for a fundamental flaw in their empathy. Some people really are just looking for an excuse to hurt other people, and the reasons are less important than the satisfaction of some need they feel to see other people suffer.

DR:

Thanks for the stand up, but I didn't take offense to what he said...

Joe:

If you look a the different examples I used earlier, I was trying to show that depending on the circumstances, the view one has towards what is acceptable can change.

Look at these two examples:

(A) A father has captured a member of a team of terrorists that holds his son captive. This man knows the location of his son, and the "codeword" that if spoken to the head of the team, will allow the release of his son. His son will be killed in 3 hours if the codeword is not given.

As the father, what lengths would you go to get the code word, if getting it was your only option to save your son? Is waterboarding permissible? other methods? are any methods unacceptable in this case, from your perspective as the father?

(B) a CIA agent is captured by Arab Officials. He is being held for obtaining and passing on, state secrets of that Arab Country. The officials know there is another mole within, and want to find out who. What lengths should the be allowed to go to, to get this info?

Two very different scenarios, with different stakes emotionally and tactically. My point, using these two cases, is that the decision to use certain methods of "heavy-handedness" or torture, is not as simple as always or never, and the decision can be heavily influenced by how close the decision maker is to the participants and circumstances.

For that reason, I suggest the complexities make it paramount that such decisions, in terms of what is acceptable, should be made by emotionally detached persons, and done in a situation that does not require the immediate application of such rules and governances, as such circumstance might apply undue, and influencing pressures on the arbitors of such.

TAM:)
 
After he did what he did. So much for checks and balances.

Remember "It isn't illegal if the President does it" - or however it went? I really think Nixon believed that, and he sure was one who knew how the US works.
This administration learned from Nixon's mistakes and I believe that is part of the problem why we are not seeing the public outraged and screaming "Impeach them". This administration is controlling information in a much tighter way. The truth comes out but they are very good at stopping it from snowballing.

However, that only goes so far. Everything is falling apart for these guys now. There isn't enough lipstick to put on all the pigs that they've made. But since the Democrats expect to win the Presidency in 2008 and probably expand their lead in the Senate and Congress, I think a number of them are afraid (they shouldn't be but they are) that if they undertake a harsher attack against Bush it could backfire.
 
.....would you accept the "near drowning" ,face slapping, and other methods we discuss here? ...
A good place to remind everyone about the framing going on here.

Waterboarding or near drowning?

Face slapping? I doubt that is how we'd be describing it if we witnessed it.

Stress positions? What, like hanging you up in a way that if you don't hold your weight up with your toes you can't breathe and leaving you there for days?

Just remember when you hear these watered down words to describe torture that the administration probably spent hours in committees coming up with terminology to distract you from the facts: they are talking about TORTURE, not slapping someone in the face.

Just like they claimed they picked up "enemy combatants during battles" when in reality they arrested a lot of these people after someone turned them in for a reward. Don't like your neighbor, just tell the US soldiers he was one of the Taliban and you not only get rid of him, you get a few thousand dollars too.

I wonder how much information you can get torturing face slapping an innocent person who someone turned in for a reward an enemy combatant arrested during a battle?
 
Last edited:
DR:

Thanks for the stand up, but I didn't take offense to what he said...

Joe:

If you look a the different examples I used earlier, I was trying to show that depending on the circumstances, the view one has towards what is acceptable can change.

Look at these two examples:

(A) A father has captured a member of a team of terrorists that holds his son captive. This man knows the location of his son, and the "codeword" that if spoken to the head of the team, will allow the release of his son. His son will be killed in 3 hours if the codeword is not given.

As the father, what lengths would you go to get the code word, if getting it was your only option to save your son? Is waterboarding permissible? other methods? are any methods unacceptable in this case, from your perspective as the father?

(B) a CIA agent is captured by Arab Officials. He is being held for obtaining and passing on, state secrets of that Arab Country. The officials know there is another mole within, and want to find out who. What lengths should the be allowed to go to, to get this info?

Two very different scenarios, with different stakes emotionally and tactically. My point, using these two cases, is that the decision to use certain methods of "heavy-handedness" or torture, is not as simple as always or never, and the decision can be heavily influenced by how close the decision maker is to the participants and circumstances.

For that reason, I suggest the complexities make it paramount that such decisions, in terms of what is acceptable, should be made by emotionally detached persons, and done in a situation that does not require the immediate application of such rules and governances, as such circumstance might apply undue, and influencing pressures on the arbitors of such.

TAM:)
I think you've been watching too much TV. Rather than making up movie versions of the circumstances the torture is being used under, it makes more sense to look at the circumstances the actual torture is being used under and the actual results being obtained. The military experts believe the results from torture are mostly useless information. I posted the citations...I have to find the thread.
 
Two very different scenarios, with different stakes emotionally and tactically. My point, using these two cases, is that the decision to use certain methods of "heavy-handedness" or torture, is not as simple as always or never, and the decision can be heavily influenced by how close the decision maker is to the participants and circumstances.

For that reason, I suggest the complexities make it paramount that such decisions, in terms of what is acceptable, should be made by emotionally detached persons, and done in a situation that does not require the immediate application of such rules and governances, as such circumstance might apply undue, and influencing pressures on the arbitors of such.

TAM:)
I disagree with you, using your same reasoning. These decisions have already been made, by emotionally detached persons, and the decision is that we don't torture, ever. We have laws against it, laws that the Bush administration and its supporters think should be ignored, using the sort of emotional "complexities" that you say shouldn't override the decision-making process. Further, we know from the experts that torture does NOT yield positive, reliable results, so the motive to commit torture comes from an illogical, disturbed place, not from a logical and results-based standpoint.
 
PBS: DEBATING TORTURE

The Torture Myth
Yet -- as he remembers saying to the "desperate and honorable officers" who wanted him to move faster -- "if I take a Bunsen burner to the guy's genitals, he's going to tell you just about anything," which would be pointless. Rothrock, who is no squishy liberal, says that he doesn't know "any professional intelligence officers of my generation who would think this is a good idea."

Amnesty International: Military, Intelligence and Law Enforcement Officers Opposing Torture
 
Actually, Joe, you agree with me 100%.

My point (god I guess I was bad at showing it) was that the Geneva conventions are what should be followed for those very reasons (see my first mention if them in this thread).

TAM:)
 
Actually, Joe, you agree with me 100%.

My point (god I guess I was bad at showing it) was that the Geneva conventions are what should be followed for those very reasons (see my first mention if them in this thread).

TAM:)

No, see... you agree with me! I'm glad you came around to my point of view. :D
 
I think you've been watching too much TV. Rather than making up movie versions of the circumstances the torture is being used under, it makes more sense to look at the circumstances the actual torture is being used under and the actual results being obtained. The military experts believe the results from torture are mostly useless information. I posted the citations...I have to find the thread.

You are right that my examples of torture are not realistic ones, in terms of what we would likely have going on in the every day world. They were more for illustration than exposition of "honest to gosh" possibilities.

The point was to use two theoretical, albeit highly unlikely, examples as a means to show that attachment to the situation (or lack of distance from it), as well as the particular circumstances of a particular case can make the decision on what to use in terms of interrogation techniques/methods too clouded, too bias, to leave in the hands of those near the situation. As well, as mentioned in my earlier posts, the political climate, and the emotional state of the nation, can unduely influence this.

That is why, I BELIEVE, we should always follow the Geneva Conventions.

TAM:)
 
The problem there is that once you start adopting tactics which are little better than those of your enemy, you lose any claims of moral superiority.

The first problem with that often stated "law of the universe of the morally superior", is that the only implied difference between the two parties is how they conduct themselves in war, not in peace.

The second problem is that these morally superior beings, like you of course, are more concerned with playing by certain civilian rules than actually fighting, which is a pretty good predictor of how to eventually lose, while feeling good about it.

You seem to have little actual faith in your (or your culture's) moral superiority since all you are concerned with is how people might perceive your moral superiority, particularly how your enemies perceive it. Did it ever occur to you that they already made that decision long before the fighting started?
 
The first problem with that often stated "law of the universe of the morally superior", is that the only implied difference between the two parties is how they conduct themselves in war, not in peace.

The second problem is that these morally superior beings, like you of course, are more concerned with playing by certain civilian rules than actually fighting, which is a pretty good predictor of how to eventually lose, while feeling good about it.

You seem to have little actual faith in your (or your culture's) moral superiority since all you are concerned with is how people might perceive your moral superiority, particularly how your enemies perceive it. Did it ever occur to you that they already made that decision long before the fighting started?

One of your errors is in assuming that doing the right thing is based on looking good for other people. That might be what you base your behavior on, but some of us realize that ethical behavior is independent of the perception of others.

Your second mistake is in equating"torture", which is inhumane, illegal, and ineffective, with "fighting".
 
One of your errors is in assuming that doing the right thing is based on looking good for other people. That might be what you base your behavior on, but some of us realize that ethical behavior is independent of the perception of others.

Your second mistake is in equating"torture", which is inhumane, illegal, and ineffective, with "fighting".

Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.
 
Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.

Your post's "points" can best be described as "dumb and dumber".
 
The second problem is that these morally superior beings, like you of course, are more concerned with playing by certain civilian rules than actually fighting, which is a pretty good predictor of how to eventually lose, while feeling good about it.
My personal feelings on what constitutes morally correct actions is entirely irrelevant to the point I was making. Let me try phrasing it in a different way via hypothetical example.

Nation 1 and nation 2 are in conflict. Nation 1 says nation 2 must be fought because it perpetrates actions A, B, and C. Such actions are reprehensible, vile, evil, against freedom, insert moral argument and terminology of your choice.

But what if it turns out nation 1 is also perpetrating action C?

Nation 1 has framed the fight in moral terms by labelling the actions of the other side as being morally wrong. But how can it claim such moral high ground if it itself is also engaging in one of the vile actions? How can the same action be morally acceptable if done by own's own side and morally unacceptable if done by the other side? That would seem to me to be sheer hypocrisy.

Does that make more clear the larger philosophical point I was getting at?
 
I'm still struggling with the notion that someone would define "moral behavior" as "things you do so that you look good to others"... who thinks that way?
 
I don't.

Personally i do "good things", I behave "morally just" because it feels good...it feels right.

Is this genetic...environmental...both...who knows, but for me it is gut instinct...it is how I feel things should be done.

Blame my ancestor's genes, blame my ancestor's raising me that way, which ever you prefer. I was taught what was right, what was wrong. I went through rebellious teenage life, like everyone...I strayed, but now that I am a mature adult, I see my parents were right. Is it that alone that makes me behave the way I do, or is there a genetic component seeded from hundreds of thousands of years of certain behaviours leading to better survival odds, who knows?

But I can tell you I DO NOT behave the way I do, because of how I want people to perceive me as a fellow citizen...at least not conciously...lol

TAM:)
 
This administration learned from Nixon's mistakes and I believe that is part of the problem why we are not seeing the public outraged and screaming "Impeach them". This administration is controlling information in a much tighter way. The truth comes out but they are very good at stopping it from snowballing.

Considering there's been an almost constant daily stream of "leaks" I don't think they are too good at controlling info.
 
I'm still struggling with the notion that someone would define "moral behavior" as "things you do so that you look good to others"... who thinks that way?

I don't.

Personally i do "good things", I behave "morally just" because it feels good...it feels right.

I agree. Taking moral high ground is more of an internal self-justification and motivator than an external show. More like "I don't care what you think because I'm right" than "Do these virtues make me look fat?" kinda thing.
 
Considering there's been an almost constant daily stream of "leaks" I don't think they are too good at controlling info.
I rather think that actually shows how effective they have become. Whatever leaks, it doesnt seem to create any major stir. Its like braking wind in a discrete way, rather than holding in and then releasing in one dramatic brump. Everybody can smell it, but no one can prove who did it.
 
Last edited:
The second problem is that these morally superior beings, like you of course, are more concerned with playing by certain civilian rules than actually fighting, which is a pretty good predictor of how to eventually lose, while feeling good about it.

I thought this thread was about how to treat alleged "bad" guys who are in custody, not about combat in the field. In fact, I'm sure it is. Why are you veering off topic? Torture is not fighting, it's sadistic gratification and nothing more.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom