Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
But much later we see that left hand looks like a huge open fielder's mitt. How can it go from a mangled or clenched smallness to a full peacock spread? Yet we never see fingers. Where are the enormous fingers of this giant hominoid? We never see any fingers.
 
I actually thought the left hand in 352 might just be clenched or something. It actually never occurred to me that anyone who believed in bigfoot would describe the hand as mangled when there are so many other reasons for it to appear the way it does.

Well, the right thumb has been thoroughly mangled..

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3121506&postcount=8635

Yuk, yuk yuk ... :D


Maybe Mangler has something up his sleeve for the left ...


I can't wait for Sweaty's next insightful analysis ..

I think he sometimes gets confused about which audience he's playing to ..
 
Now you guys are just being silly. Here's the thumb.

BTW, in the next 12 or so frames you can not only see the fingers bend, but you can watch the hand grow.


m :bike:

 
Late October 1967. John Green to Roger Patterson after seeing the footage he had filmed:

JG: Who is the guy with the long black hair?
RP: That's Bob Gimlin. He's my Indian Tracker.
JG: Ah, good. You need somebody like that to help you find Bigfoot. I'm glad you found and filmed one.
RP: Yes, we try to use different approaches to search for Bigfoot.
JG: Who is the guy in the white shirt and black vest leading the packhorse.
RP: That's Bob Heironimus. He's one of our Bigfoot search group.
JG: Ah, good. Best to get as many folks out looking on the trail as you can. Even an assistant like Heironimus could spot a Bigfoot while he is search riding and let out a hoot to inform the others that he is on to something promising. I bet you value guys like Bob when you go on the lookout for Bigfoot.
RP: Yes, Bob Heironimus was an asset that helped us reach the goal of filming a Bigfoot. We finally got that son of a buck!
 
Why are we treated to toes, eye sockets, a neat Neanderthalesque nose, defined lips and a butt crack... and yet we never see fingers? Is this some kind of crime against inquiry? Harumph!
 
In all my Googling, all I could find was "elk" for the area with no mention of variety.

Then my powers of Google must be greater. :D (hint: try putting 'roosevelt elk st. helens' in your Google search)

The information I found on the St. Helens herd being a mix is quite a bit more recent than the Skookum expedition, I believe.
And some of the info I found concerning Roosevelt Elk in the Mt. St. Helens area predates the Skookum expedition.

This one was written in 1991, nearly a decade before the Skookum cast was found.

That afternoon, with Weyerhaeuser's chief helicopter pilot, Ron Wagner, I fly in a Bell LongRanger across the rolling shoulders of lower Mt. St. Helens. Within the new forest as we fly over, I see exciting lifescores of Roosevelt elk scuffing along in a new and welcome habitat.
Another was written in 1996, which again, predated the Skookum cast find:

...but I am moved by the reappearance of plants and trees and animals and fish at Mt. St. Helens - the symbiotic reaching out of fungus filaments to plants roots deep beneath the volcanic ash, the herd of Roosevelt's elk returning to feed on grass sprouting from the earth of an apparently unwelcoming ashy, silica-infused but now media-hyped "miraculous mudslide."
Bottom line, adequate experimentation was not conducted to effectively rule out Roosevelt Elk.

I guess you'd just have to talk with the elk experts Rick and Jeff Meldrum talked to. In the meantime, does this really look like the impression of an elk knee of any size?
Rick has already responded to me and admitted that smaller Rocky Mountain elk was used and not Roosevelt elk. I have no idea whether it looks like the impression of an elk knee, I've never seen one. If I had been asked to conduct an experiment to eliminate elk as the possible culprit however, I'd ensure I use all species and sizes of elk that populate the area, not just the smaller ones.

RayG
 
And some of the info I found concerning Roosevelt Elk in the Mt. St. Helens area predates the Skookum expedition.

And the DNA testing that shows they're a mix. If they're mixed with Rocky Mountain elk, why wouldn't they be smaller than the elk in the coast ranges? Or are they?
 
I don't know if he was even quoted correctly. I have permission to repost the information I have, but I don't know that I saved the post and the archives on the list were closed last time I checked.

Why not ask Jeff?

Mainly because I wanted to see if it had been documented already, which would be the best way to avoid any potential after-the-fact rationalizations or excuses on Dr. Meldrum's part.

Just how do you botch measuring on a tree?

I'm not talking about a tree, I'm talking about the "Bigfoot." This post of mine from another thread talks more about it. But since you mentioned the trees, I might have an explanation for the difference of the measured trees and of Larry Lund's notes on the height of the subject of the video.

I've never worked with Hi-8 video tapes before (I'm more familiar with mini-DV tapes), but I suspect that "Bigfoot" appeared the way it did in relation to the trees due to an issue with the depth of field (and depth perception). Video has a tendency to "flatten" the subject and the background together unless proper steps are taken to minimize or avoid it. This can create the illusion that something is closer to something else than it really is. However, as noted earlier in the thread, film can have a similar effect. Here's one such example. Here's another, more technical look at the issue.

He interviewed the witnesses and found no reason to disbelieve them.

I touch on that here. You can find some more context for that post here.

Meldrum doesn't agree with Byrne and Green thinks Byrne is a fraud (he's botched a few things too).

That's interesting, but I'm talking about the work done by Larry Lund.
 
A recap of a sterling example of footer arrogance/ignorance:
Here's the thumb.......incredibly...:boggled:...amazingly....unbelievably...


And....even more incredibly....it also appears to MOVE!!!! :jaw-dropp

Sweaty, how did you verify that what you're saying is the thumb was not part of the background?

As a thumb, in what manner do you believe it to be moving?

AFAIK, nobody is positing that Patty has no thumbs. If it were clearly demonstrated that a thumb was visible and even that it moved, how does this make a living sasquatch hand more like than a gorilla glove or some other type of suit piece?

Hmmm.....what could that be, on the end of Patty's arm???.....


Maybe it's a cheeseburger...:p....or maybe it's a bottle of Windex...:boggled:.


Hence my use of the term "sewer of a forum". ;)

OMG, don't you see it, Sweaty!? You were so focused on wishing for a thumb you missed it:

There are two, possibly three apparent protrusions coming from Patty's arm. Could this be evidence of the PIGI body armour that TBE was referring to!?

Anyway, hence the term 'creduloid'. Make 'em proud.

Sweaty,

Do you think these illustrate a coincidence? Don’t forget that the X,Y and Z angles of the camera have changed slightly.


m :bike:

Mangler,

You have explained why Patty appeared (to me) to have an extra thumb coming out of her fore-arm in one of the frames. Nice!
Sewer of a forum, hey Sweaty? Suck it up. What I would have given to see the look on your face when looking at mangler's graphic. I know, I know. It's hard to type with a couple feet in your mouth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom