Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

The data I have reported is the latest and most accurate. I've built a spreadsheet to compare all the data series and am trying to see if there is any way that Fsol could possibly be correct. So far, no luck. It's a bit technical.

The issue has to do with

a) correcting the tide gauge readings with the satellite radar altimeter
b) correcting the tide gauges with GPS stations that are closeby

And these "corrections" are done to the historical data that we've already got. But the recent "increasing rate of sea level increase" from the 1.8 mm number that everyone has always heard about, to the 2.8 / 3.1 mm reported for 1993 onward, is at issue.

That comes only from (a), and it appears to be in error. More later.

OK. You have read the paper we were discussing I presume?

Your issue 'a' is not what they did. What they did was calibrate the satellites using tide gauges using GPS corrections to the tide gauges where available. I pointed this out to you already. They did not use the satellite data to make corrections to the historic data. That is why on the IPCC table that you posted, suffix a makes it clear that only the data from 1993 - 2003 is from the satellites. Not the 1960 - 1993 data. That's also why the results quoted in the paper do not extend backwards beyond 1993.

ETA: this one might be fun

Marcos, M. et al. Decadal sea level trends in the Bay of Biscay from tide gauges, GPS and TOPEX. J. Mar. Syst.
(2007), doi:10.1016/j.jmarsys.2007.02.006

Abstract
Sea level time series derived from TOPEX altimeter and from tide gauge measurements in the Bay of Biscay (Eastern North
Atlantic Ocean) are used to investigate the regional sea level rise. Altimetry sea level anomalies are computed from TOPEX
measurements and resampled into fixed along track bins in order to obtain consistent records and to approach as close as possible to the coast. Tidal corrections are critical in the estimation of sea level trends; therefore an additional analysis has been carried out in order to identify and correct for residual tidal signals. The obtained mean sea level rise in the region is +3.09±0.21 mm/year over the period 1993–2002. Tide gauges have been corrected for vertical land motions by means of collocated GPS measurements.
GPS-corrected tide gauges and nearby altimetry trends are found to be statistically consistent. The relationship with the
atmospheric forcing is also investigated revealing that 15% of this sea level rise is attributed to the atmospheric pressure effects.
© 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Sea level; Tide gauge; Altimetry; TOPEX; GPS
 
Last edited:
OK. You have read the paper we were discussing I presume?

Your issue 'a' is not what they did. What they did was calibrate the satellites using tide gauges using GPS corrections to the tide gauges where available. I pointed this out to you already. They did not use the satellite data to make corrections to the historic data. That is why on the IPCC table that you posted, suffix a makes it clear that only the data from 1993 - 2003 is from the satellites. Not the 1960 - 1993 data. That's also why the results quoted in the paper do not extend backwards beyond 1993.



ETA: this one might be fun

Marcos, M. et al. Decadal sea level trends in the Bay of Biscay from tide gauges, GPS and TOPEX. J. Mar. Syst.
(2007), doi:10.1016/j.jmarsys.2007.02.006

Marcos? Actually, no. Marcos is a study on a single site. If you have read the articles then you are aware that the 1.8 mm, and also the 2.8/3.1 mm numbers, are both the average of a large group of studies. Some of these show sea level rise of 1.1 or 1.4mm. Others show higher numbers.

Read the procedure of Lieliette, to the extent to which it is explained. GPS corrected tide gauges were used on a minor (percentage unspecified) number of test sites. The remainder had a presumption of 1.8 mm/yr applied. These two methods were averaged. A fraction of corrected gauges, and a fraction of historical uncorrected gauges, used to correct unknown errors in the satellite radar altimetry.

Ridiculous, except as an interim procedure while GPS is being applied to a larger group of tide gauges. Once that was done, such work is immediately obselete. Get it?



In summary, the historical number of Douglas 1997 of 1.8 mm was a pretty good guess. Lieuliette's work is by his own admission now obsoleted -
The bias error (from Douglas 1997, this is the 1.8 mm/year number) dominates the final altimetric drift rate estimate. An obvious way to eliminate this error would be to use only tide gauges where GPS or DORIS measurements were available. Unfortunately, at present few gauges meet this estimate and narrowing the set of gauges used results in random errors that are much increased...in the future, though GPS should be used at all locations....
​
The 100% use of GPS corrected tide gauges by Woppelmann is correct as suggested by Lieuliette.

It is what Leuliette was suggesting would be possible in the future. Once the presumption of 1.8 mm/year is proved false, then a study which merged this number with modern (radar altimeter) data must be discarded.
 
Marcos? Actually, no. Marcos is a study on a single site. If you have read the articles then you are aware that the 1.8 mm, and also the 2.8/3.1 mm numbers, are both the average of a large group of studies. Some of these show sea level rise of 1.1 or 1.4mm. Others show higher numbers.


Marcos? Actually yes. Here is why.

You have missed the point.

The Marcos et al paper, one of the authors just happens to be Woppelmann by the way, compares TOPEX data with GPS corrected tide gauges for the Bay of Biscay. They use the same GPS correction of tide gauges described in the Woppelmann et al paper. (No big surprise there of course Woppelmann being an author on both papers.) The result of the study is that...

GPS-corrected tide gauges and nearby altimetry trends are found to be statistically consistent.
Furthermore, they think the TOPEX data is the most reliable of the two figures. This can be seen by the relative error bars of the two figures they produce.

For the GPS corrected tide guages +2.01+-0.85 mm/yr

For the TOPEX data +3.09+-0.21 mm/yr

Read the procedure of Lieliette, to the extent to which it is explained. GPS corrected tide gauges were used on a minor (percentage unspecified) number of test sites. The remainder had a presumption of 1.8 mm/yr applied. These two methods were averaged. A fraction of corrected gauges, and a fraction of historical uncorrected gauges, used to correct unknown errors in the satellite radar altimetry.

Ridiculous, except as an interim procedure while GPS is being applied to a larger group of tide gauges. Once that was done, such work is immediately obselete. Get it?
Unfortunately, yes, I do get it. I explained it to you a couple of posts back. Well not the "immediately obsolete" part, because that is nonsense. I spent the time to type out the relevent quotes even. You on the other hand have shown your misunderstanding of the papers and the data ever since you first bought up the Woppelmann paper. Having now been shown several times why your reasoning behind your claims of "The IPCC - Wrong" were, well, wrong, you are clutching at non-existant straws.


In summary, the historical number of Douglas 1997 of 1.8 mm was a pretty good guess. Lieuliette's work is by his own admission now obsoleted -

The bias error (from Douglas 1997, this is the 1.8 mm/year number) dominates the final altimetric drift rate estimate. An obvious way to eliminate this error would be to use only tide gauges where GPS or DORIS measurements were available. Unfortunately, at present few gauges meet this estimate and narrowing the set of gauges used results in random errors that are much increased...in the future, though GPS should be used at all locations....

The 100% use of GPS corrected tide gauges by Woppelmann is correct as suggested by Lieuliette.
I just explained that to you a couple of posts back. You don't need to repeat it back to me.

The tide gauge calibrations are used as a diagnostic tool for the altimetry, they know what the limitations of the process are and they also know how to improve it.

Do you think that the error bars they quote are just plucked from thin air? They know about the bias from using the 1.8 mm/yr. It is taken account of in the error bars. I even typed out the relevent quote about that too.

Hence the estimated bias error due to the altimeter drift is 0.0+-0.4 mm/yr. The calibration error could become much better, because the error model is almost entirely dependent on errors in the land motion estimates used for each of the tide gauges Mitcham (2000). Including improved land motion estimates from GPS and DORIS should reduce the uncertainty in the altimetric rates.
So they have a figure of 2.8+-0.4 mm/yr (with data from the last few years included they have +3.1+-0.4 mm/yr), now it seems to me that even at the extremes of the range given that this is higher than Wopplemanns 1.31+-0.3 mm/yr. It's even higher than 1.8+-0.5 mm/yr. This would suggest to me that the rate of sea level rise is increasing and the IPCC are correct. That is what the data says, including the error bounds, afterall.


As an aside, this was vaguely diverting to begin with, but if you are just going to parrot back things that I had to explain to you in the first place, as if you think I wasn't aware of them, then I can't really see myself being overly interested in carrying on. I am fairly happy from looking at these few papers and others, and comparing them with the relevent parts of Chapter 5 of the IPCC report that you haven't shown them to be wrong.
 
Last edited:
Yes, we are definitely talking right past each other and will probably have to agree to disagree. I've looking into a considerably larger number of articles, and note that this could slip into a "my article says this" "your article says that" type of thing, which is a waste of time.

I've got absolutely no problem with an accurate measurement of sea level rise on the high seas being different than that at tide gauges with or without GPS correction. That makes some intuitive sense. They are completely different issues.

Topex measures the broad expanse of the oceans, not the shores.

However, to blatently confound two such different measures on the same chart as the IPCC did and claim there is an increasing rate of sea level rise is disingenous.

You've noted that conceivably the two columns could mask a hockey stick in the averages, but my examination of the literature appears to rebut that (as I noted, there are wide discrepancies in the literature and to be fair, I'm not going to just quote articles that support "my stand". All of these historical articles are being quickly superceded in this field by the altimeter and GPS corrected work.).

We agree that these current measurements are extremely precise, and in a few years or at the most two decades these matters will be known most definitively.

The below chart shows the Topex data with the seasonal fluctuations removed. As you can see, there is no accelerated rate of sea level increase. (Woppelman notes that several decades of precise monitoring would be necessary to show such an increase in sea level rise rate, because of natural decadal variations). So by examination, the idea that Topex data might hold an accelerating trend has no legs. For details see www.climateaudit.org, An Analysis of the Topex Sea Level Record.



By the way, I don't get your latest reference on my available Ejournal list.

Finally I'd like to note that in the work being done on sea level rise, none of the politicalization is evident that can be seen with the global temperature studies.
 
Whether it's 1.3 or 3.1 mm/y, where does the global flooding scenario I've heard on the radio come from? This type of water-creep would end when all the land ice was gone. When would that be?
 
Don't forget that water expands as it warms. It's not just the ice melt.

Yeah, but not that much. Really, at that melt rate, I'd be more concerned about the dilution of salinity than flooding. (That is if what I've heard about the oceanic conveyor moderating the climate is true.)

Also, if warming will increase the severity of storms, there's already enough water around to do a heck of a lot of damage even without the ice melting.

I'm not questioning AGW here. I'm just trying to make sense of some of the more extreme prognostications I've heard.
 
Yeah, but not that much. Really, at that melt rate, I'd be more concerned about the dilution of salinity than flooding. (That is if what I've heard about the oceanic conveyor moderating the climate is true.)

Also, if warming will increase the severity of storms, there's already enough water around to do a heck of a lot of damage even without the ice melting.

I'm not questioning AGW here. I'm just trying to make sense of some of the more extreme prognostications I've heard.

I think "Global" sums it up for me. You might get none of the extremes, and still have an global crises, purely because it's global. At present, disasters usually hit randomly, so that even though one country get's hit bad, everyone else is able to carry on. A global change is going to destabilise everyone at the same time, in numerous ways. The most obvious and important for us all would be agricultural. Rainfall patterns will change, the ecosystems they exist in will change, temperature ranges will change, weather events that disrupt work will change.

Simultaneously around the world, all ports, that we depend on for trade, will be under stress.
 
Yeah, but not that much.
Actually, estimates make it half or more of the predicted rise. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise#Intergovernmental_Panel_on_Climate_Change_results

Really, at that melt rate, I'd be more concerned about the dilution of salinity than flooding. (That is if what I've heard about the oceanic conveyor moderating the climate is true.)
Mmmm. I don't think that's as much of a concern; the volume of the oceans is pretty enormous compared to the volumes of all the ice put together. I mean, the thickest ice sheets are at most a couple miles thick, but the ocean is several miles deep and covers 70% of the Earth's surface. You can kind of guesstimate that it's not going to be much in terms of the size of the oceans; the issue is the rise, not the total volume. Now, depending on what precisely drives the conveyor, and it's a combination of heat and salinity is my understanding, that could be affected, but I'd expect a change, not a complete elimination or anything, from the salinity. The big problem is the heat, and the way that the heat distribution changes. If the Arctic gets too warm, it could cause there not to be enough heat differential to drive it, if I've understood the arguments correctly.

We should probably go hunt up some figures to get a clearer idea, but I think that's the main thrust of it.

Also, if warming will increase the severity of storms, there's already enough water around to do a heck of a lot of damage even without the ice melting.
The "engine" that drives a hurricane or typhoon is latent heat. Heat evaporates water from the ocean, and the warm, water vapor laden air rises. It gets high enough and condenses, and the latent heat is released. That heat then drives more evaporation, and the cycle continues. If there is more heat available, then the cycle will run harder, and that means that the winds will be stronger, the rain heavier, and so forth. The big thing you see in pictures of hurricanes is the cyclone form induced by coriolis forces, but the real cyclonic nature is a circular flow, upward near the eyewall, and downward at the outside. That's where the energy really comes from, and the positive feedback loop that drives the storm.

I'm not questioning AGW here. I'm just trying to make sense of some of the more extreme prognostications I've heard.
Well, those aren't really the extreme prognostications. I'm not on board with the most extreme ones. I think it's pretty clear that if a hurricane is a heat engine, and there's more heat around, then the hurricane is going to be stronger. I also think that it's pretty obvious that if a bunch of ice melts, the sea is going to get higher, and it's also pretty obvious that if the sea gets warmer it's going to expand, and since there's a lot of it, it will be a large effect.

If you think those are extreme, consider carefully the fact that current theories of paleontology have a couple of the more recent mass extinctions linked to abrupt climate changes of one type or another. Now, that's extreme.
 
Don't forget that water expands as it warms. It's not just the ice melt.


Schneib, what initially irritated me about this matter was the thermal expansion. If you look at the right hand column top, you will see that thermal expansion "suddenly jumped" from 0.4mm per year to 1.6mm per year.

That's not in accordance with any reputable sources that I've seen. Please note this chart is from the IPCC Summary for Policymakers, which is a political document more than a scientific. The contents of Chapter 5 are more scientific of course.

1.6mm????
 
Whether it's 1.3 or 3.1 mm/y, where does the global flooding scenario I've heard on the radio come from? This type of water-creep would end when all the land ice was gone. When would that be?

Hansen promotes an erroneous theory of glacial and Greenland ice being "lubricated from below" by increased water runoff, then these huge masses of ice being slid faster downhill into the ocean until they are all gone.

Obviously he never understood plastic creep and it's relation to temperature.

So to answer your question

1. There are unscientific theories being promoted by the likes of Hansen, Lovelock and Gore on cryosphere dynamics
2. Using "tipping points", unproven hypthetical positive feedbacks, these incorrect theories are asserted to cause 20 foot sea level rise before 2050 (now I think Hansen is babbling about 80 foot sea level rise before 2050).

That's not pretty, but I think it's accurate.

PS: All of Greenland being added to the oceans would be a 7 meter or 20 some foot sea level rise.
 
Slime, I think you may be something of an expert at these aspects of plastic creep so this is laughable old news, but for any who are not acquainted with it here is a good summary. This is materials science 101, and this stuff has been known a long, long time.

This paper explains everything one needs to know about glacier melt and creep and why Hansen's theories of them all sliding down into the ocean are flat wrong, which in turn means that there will not be any 20 or 80 foot sea level rise on a time scale shorter than thousands of years.

Period.


Hansen promotes an erroneous theory of glacial and Greenland ice being "lubricated from below" by increased water runoff, then these huge masses of ice being slid faster downhill into the ocean until they are all gone.

Obviously he never understood plastic creep and it's relation to temperature.

So to answer your question

1. There are unscientific theories being promoted by the likes of Hansen, Lovelock and Gore on cryosphere dynamics
2. Using "tipping points", unproven hypthetical positive feedbacks, these incorrect theories are asserted to cause 20 foot sea level rise before 2050 (now I think Hansen is babbling about 80 foot sea level rise before 2050).

That's not pretty, but I think it's accurate.

PS: All of Greenland being added to the oceans would be a 7 meter or 20 some foot sea level rise.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_142244731ed7796761.png
Schneib, what initially irritated me about this matter was the thermal expansion. If you look at the right hand column top, you will see that thermal expansion "suddenly jumped" from 0.4mm per year to 1.6mm per year.

That's not in accordance with any reputable sources that I've seen. Please note this chart is from the IPCC Summary for Policymakers, which is a political document more than a scientific. The contents of Chapter 5 are more scientific of course.

1.6mm????

Please note that that chart is also in Chapter 5. It's table 5.3. It is actually referenced from there in the SPM. If you look at table 5.2 you get a summary of results for steric sea level change, fully referenced from, I would guess, reputable sources. If you read section 5.3 which deals with thermal expansion, then you will see more references and an explanation of what they think is going on. If you don't agree with them then you can always go back to the sources they quote and dig around to see if they are misrepresenting anything. They even have a chart with error bars (Figure 5.13, someone was asking for one of them I think?) that shows the change in sea level rise since 1870 and which to my eye at least could be seen to show an increase in rate of sea level rise. If you read the discussion of the data you would also see why they think that the rate of sea level rise has increased.

What I don't understand is why you would make such comments here, when you know that anyone can go and look at Chapter 5 and prove that you are being less than I don't really know the right word. It's not honest, but oh, ok...I don't understand why you would make such comments when anyone can go and look and see that you are being disingenuous in the way that you worded your comment. Unless of course you just haven't actually looked at Chapter 5 at all. You could actually find the answers to your questions in there you know.
 
Please note that that chart is also in Chapter 5. It's table 5.3. It is actually referenced from there in the SPM. If you look at table 5.2 you get a summary of results for steric sea level change, fully referenced from, I would guess, reputable sources. If you read section 5.3 which deals with thermal expansion, then you will see more references and an explanation of what they think is going on. If you don't agree with them then you can always go back to the sources they quote and dig around to see if they are misrepresenting anything. They even have a chart with error bars (Figure 5.13, someone was asking for one of them I think?) that shows the change in sea level rise since 1870 and which to my eye at least could be seen to show an increase in rate of sea level rise. If you read the discussion of the data you would also see why they think that the rate of sea level rise has increased.

What I don't understand is why you would make such comments here, when you know that anyone can go and look at Chapter 5 and prove that you are being less than I don't really know the right word. It's not honest, but oh, ok...I don't understand why you would make such comments when anyone can go and look and see that you are being disingenuous in the way that you worded your comment. Unless of course you just haven't actually looked at Chapter 5 at all. You could actually find the answers to your questions in there you know.

I originally said the table was also in Chapter 5, and noted various details from . Again, we are repeating each other in a curious way and reaching different conclusions. It's exactly like I already said, they started using satellite radar altimetry, and all the numbers changed right then.

1993.

Doesn't mean they were made "more correct or precise".

You think that but I've seen no evidence of it.

Uncertainty remains.
 
I originally said the table was also in Chapter 5, and noted various details from . Again, we are repeating each other in a curious way and reaching different conclusions. It's exactly like I already said, they started using satellite radar altimetry, and all the numbers changed right then.

1993.

And see here again, you show us that you either haven't read the work you are referring to, or you simply don't understand it.

Chapter 5 executive summary said:
The rise in global mean sea level is accompanied by
considerable decadal variability. For the period 1993 to
2003, the rate of sea level rise is estimated from observations
with satellite altimetry as 3.1 ± 0.7 mm yr–1, significantly
higher than the average rate. The tide gauge record indicates
that similar large rates have occurred in previous 10-year
periods since 1950. It is unknown whether the higher rate
in 1993 to 2003 is due to decadal variability or an increase
in the longer-term trend.

Try reading "5.5.2.4 Interannual and Decadal Variability and Long-Term Changes in Sea Level" it details and references the decadal variability, it even has a nice graph to look at. It then goes on to say why they think that the combination of the available data (the geological observations, the longest instrumental records and the current rate of sea level rise for the 20th century) indicates an increase in the rate of sea level rise. It provides references for the papers from which they draw their conclusions, so if you still feel that they are misrepresenting the data you can go to their sources and see for yourself.

Doesn't mean they were made "more correct or precise".

You think that but I've seen no evidence of it.

Uncertainty remains.

Well gee, this is science afterall.
 
That's what happened when they started to merge data series from different sources. ClimateAudit did an excellent job about the way the data was simply concatenated without any correction. The temperature graph apparently risen explosively (in a Hockey Stick shape) but it was only showing bad data adjustment. That's why I laugh when somebody says that Manns reconstructions has been validated by satellite data, and they can't explain where you can get satellite data for the past 4,500 years.
 
That's what happened when they started to merge data series from different sources. ClimateAudit did an excellent job about the way the data was simply concatenated without any correction. The temperature graph apparently risen explosively (in a Hockey Stick shape) but it was only showing bad data adjustment. That's why I laugh when somebody says that Manns reconstructions has been validated by satellite data, and they can't explain where you can get satellite data for the past 4,500 years.

If you are talking about this then you are wrong.

http://www.climateaudit.org/?p=859

So maybe if you read it, and then compared it to, I don't know, at the very least if you compared it to the measuring devices I was talking about, or perhaps the timescale I was talking about you would see your mistake. What Mann has to do with it is anyones guess of course but I suppose we all have our obsessions.
 
Last edited:

That's just bizarre. I was going off my knowledge of the density of water vs temperature as reflected here. Water is densest at 4 C but it never really gets too far away from 1 g/cc, so where is this expansion coming from?

The "engine" that drives a hurricane or typhoon is latent heat. ... That's where the energy really comes from, and the positive feedback loop that drives the storm.

Agreed. My comment was more directed at storm surge which is that part of a hurricane/typhoon that kicks our ape butts.
 
Hansen promotes an erroneous theory of glacial and Greenland ice being "lubricated from below" by increased water runoff, then these huge masses of ice being slid faster downhill into the ocean until they are all gone.

That plainly can't be true. If you believe any ice core data, the planet has been as warm before and the ice on Greenland is still there. That ice sheet is older than the last "spike". You're right about creep. Even if the planet got lots warmer, the creep would slowly accelerate but there would be no "sliding".

So to answer your question

1. There are unscientific theories being promoted by the likes of Hansen, Lovelock and Gore on cryosphere dynamics
2. Using "tipping points", unproven hypthetical positive feedbacks, these incorrect theories are asserted to cause 20 foot sea level rise before 2050 (now I think Hansen is babbling about 80 foot sea level rise before 2050).

Pro-AGW people should really be very dissatisfied at the negative feedback they're getting from some of their self-appointed spokespeople. I don't know Hansen very well but I've been seriously shocked by Gore in the past. That guy's a clown. I'm just glad he didn't choose to champion chemistry.

As far as the guesswork, they might be right. Who knows? I doubt it. Most posters here can back up what they say with facts but the two-sigma guys* either way have no way of knowing.

* those who want to pretend that the lower the probability, the more certain the outcome. Kinda reminds me of passage in a Pratchett novel where the Night Watch didn't like their chances of success until they reduced their odds to a million to one.

PS: All of Greenland being added to the oceans would be a 7 meter or 20 some foot sea level rise.

Yikes! I didn't know that. :boxedin:
 
Slime, I think you may be something of an expert at these aspects of plastic creep so this is laughable old news, but for any who are not acquainted with it here is a good summary.

Flattery will get you everywhere but I'm not a physicist or an engineer. I do know that big ice doesn't move like that, though. Ice is too good an insulator.

Thanks for the benefit of the doubt, though! :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom