Is this new ammo for the alternative medicine crowd?

TacoSnake

New Blood
Joined
Nov 16, 2007
Messages
13
Please replace the DOT with . - I can't post links yet. :o

wwwDOTconsumeristDOTcom/consumer/health/honey-better-than-dextromethorphan-at-treating-coughs-329475.php

It basically says that honey is a better cough treatment than dextromethorphan. Honey is known to be anti-bacterial in nature and used in a wide variety of folk medicines and treatments. I don't think there is anything woo about it, but unfortunately it will probably be used to bolster claims against modern medicine.
 
Link to the article.

http://consumerist.com/consumer/hea...extromethorphan-at-treating-coughs-329475.php

Here is the link to the study.

http://archpedi.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/161/12/1140

As pleased as I am to have my favourite cold remedy confirmed (hot rum toddys), the results aren't particularly exciting. There's hardly any difference in the actual scores - the trends are significant, but almost all of the pairwise comparisons aren't. And the title of the article is misleading considering that there were no significant differences between honey and DM.

Oh, well.

How would this be used to bolster claims against modern medicine, though?

Linda
 
Last edited:
One of the woo "natural medicines" is honey. You will often find suggestions to use it on wounds as an antiseptic, It does work, but only as well (or poorly) as refined sugar which has the advantage of being nuch less likely to cause an allergic reaction.
 
As pleased as I am to have my favourite cold remedy confirmed (hot rum toddys), the results aren't particularly exciting. There's hardly any difference in the actual scores - the trends are significant, but almost all of the pairwise comparisons aren't. And the title of the article is misleading considering that there were no significant differences between honey and DM.

Oh, well.

How would this be used to bolster claims against modern medicine, though?

Linda

Just about any time I go online and see a study that shows the effectiveness of an "old world" remedy I tend to see forums fill up with posts praising natural and alternative treatments over any form of modern medicine. They look to these studies as proof that modern medicine is a scam and that we could cure all ills if "the establishment" only took their particular pet quackery seriously.

I am not sure it is fair to say that the article title is totally misleading considering what the study indicated. I am wondering however, how the study concluded honey is significantly better than DM, yet comparatively have no difference.

From the linked study:
Results Significant differences in symptom improvement were detected between treatment groups, with honey consistently scoring the best and no treatment scoring the worst. In paired comparisons, honey was significantly superior to no treatment for cough frequency and the combined score, but DM was not better than no treatment for any outcome. Comparison of honey with DM revealed no significant differences.

Conclusions In a comparison of honey, DM, and no treatment, parents rated honey most favorably for symptomatic relief of their child's nocturnal cough and sleep difficulty due to upper respiratory tract infection. Honey may be a preferable treatment for the cough and sleep difficulty associated with childhood upper respiratory tract infection.
 
Last edited:
One of the woo "natural medicines" is honey. You will often find suggestions to use it on wounds as an antiseptic, It does work, but only as well (or poorly) as refined sugar which has the advantage of being nuch less likely to cause an allergic reaction.

DO you think all medicinal claims about honey are woo, or that honey is given too much credit for its properties and bleeds into woo beliefs? I am on the fence, but I have always thought it might be a safer alternative to some of the over-the-counter treatments available. About the same price as many cough syrups too.

From the Article:
For cough and cold symptoms, honey is cited by the World Health Organization as a potential treatment.12 In the World Health Organization report on the treatment of URIs in young children, honey is considered as a demulcent that is cheap, popular, and safe. Although there is no scientific evidence to support the use of honey for symptoms associated with a URI, it is suggested in the World Health Organization report that demulcents may soothe the throat and can be recommended to provide some relief from cough in children.
 
Just about any time I go online and see a study that shows the effectiveness of an "old world" remedy I tend to see forums fill up with posts praising natural and alternative treatments over any form of modern medicine. They look to these studies as proof that modern medicine is a scam and that we could cure all ills if "the establishment" only took their particular pet quackery seriously.

Right....

The techniques that modern medicine uses in order to separate the wheat from the chaff is laudable when their product is the wheat, but not when its the chaff.

I am not sure it is fair to say that the article title is totally misleading considering what the study indicated. I am wondering however, how the study concluded honey is significantly better than DM, yet comparatively have no difference.

I suspect it is because there is a statistically significant difference between honey and no treatment for cough frequency, but there isn't a statistically significant difference for DM and no treatment. However, while the differences in symptom scores may have been statistically significant, the absolute difference is minor - not even the difference between "a little" and "somewhat".

Linda
 
DO you think all medicinal claims about honey are woo, or that honey is given too much credit for its properties and bleeds into woo beliefs? I am on the fence, but I have always thought it might be a safer alternative to some of the over-the-counter treatments available. About the same price as many cough syrups too.

From the Article:
For cough and cold symptoms, honey is cited by the World Health Organization as a potential treatment.12 In the World Health Organization report on the treatment of URIs in young children, honey is considered as a demulcent that is cheap, popular, and safe. Although there is no scientific evidence to support the use of honey for symptoms associated with a URI, it is suggested in the World Health Organization report that demulcents may soothe the throat and can be recommended to provide some relief from cough in children.

To be truthful (it's after midnight and I'm allowed to say that once a day :D) I don't know All About Honey. I am pretty certain (TM) about sugar vs honey as an antiseptic though.

But here is one for everybody:

http://www.mayerthorpefreelancer.com/News/359064.html

Health Canada warning parents that concerns have been raised regarding the safety of non-prescription cough and cold products in children, particularly for those under two years of age.

Maybe a solution of sugar would be the best of all.
 
Linda - with you on the hot toddy, although I prefer Scotch whisky in mine.

Juice of half a lemon, spoonful of honey, 1 measure of whisky, top up with boiling water and drink it hot.

How on earth would you do a DBPC trial on that?

Anyway - makes me feel better and I reckon that's the most you can hope for with ordinary coughs and colds.
 
Linda - with you on the hot toddy, although I prefer Scotch whisky in mine.

Juice of half a lemon, spoonful of honey, 1 measure of whisky, top up with boiling water and drink it hot.

How on earth would you do a DBPC trial on that?

Anyway - makes me feel better and I reckon that's the most you can hope for with ordinary coughs and colds.

Sometimes I leave out some of the ingredients.

And the sore throat!
 
Of course, it provides ammo for the alt med folks.

They will consider, anything, no matter how weak, will be considered support.

Everything else will be ignored.
 
Of course, it provides ammo for the alt med folks.

They will consider, anything, no matter how weak, will be considered support.

Everything else will be ignored.
That depends on how economical they wish to be with the truth. There is no statistically significant difference between honey and DM in terms of efficacy.
If the sCAM crowd wish to hype this up as a victory, then perhaps they should also be aware that this "natural" therapy appears to be more toxic than the pharmaceutical preparation. So much for natural=safe, I guess.
The combination of mild reactions that include hyperactivity, nervousness, and insomnia occurred in 5 patients treated with honey, 2 patients in the DM group, and no patients in the no-treatment arm (P = .04). In the honey group, the parent of 1 patient reported drowsiness and the parents of 2 patients reported stomachache, nausea, or vomiting, but these adverse events were not significant when examined separately from a statistical perspective (drowsiness, P = .65; stomachache, nausea, vomiting, P = .21).
PS I'm just being devil's advocate really. But what's sauce for the goose...
 
Last edited:
Of course, it provides ammo for the alt med folks.

They will consider, anything, no matter how weak, will be considered support.

Everything else will be ignored.

What the alt med people claim is that the traditional ways of identifying effective treatments - careful observation without controls or blinding, subjective perception as a measure of objective change, extrapolating on the basis of analogy rather than theory, etc. - are a useful way of identifying these treatments. However, that these methods can occasionally identify a truly effective treatment is not the issue. The issue is that these methods are unable to identify which treatments are ineffective (a much larger number), and they miss many more effects than they discover. That is, these methods produce a plethora of false-positives and false-negatives for only a few true-positives and true-negatives. And it is only the subsequent application of modern research techniques that sorts out which is which.

This study is actually ammo for the evidence-based crowd. While we were able to identify honey as a true-positive, the methods used by the alt med crowd were unable to distinguish between honey and other treatments that we know to be ineffective, such as vitamin C. We can discover that honey helps and vitamin C does not. The alt med people still cannot make that claim.

Linda
 
Last edited:
This study is actually ammo for the evidence-based crowd. While we were able to identify honey as a true-positive, the methods used by the alt med crowd were unable to distinguish between honey and other treatments that we know to be ineffective, such as vitamin C. We can discover that honey helps and vitamin C does not. The alt med people still cannot make that claim.

Linda

You are correct, that this is victory for good science.

However, I think they will take this instance of one of "their" remedies being proven right and blow it all of proportion.

Small victory for science, big PR win for alt med.
 
Linda - with you on the hot toddy, although I prefer Scotch whisky in mine.

Juice of half a lemon, spoonful of honey, 1 measure of whisky, top up with boiling water and drink it hot.

How on earth would you do a DBPC trial on that?

Anyway - makes me feel better and I reckon that's the most you can hope for with ordinary coughs and colds.


My grandfather's approach was a glass of hot milk, a spoonful of honey and a more than generous measure of Jameson's: he drank this preventatively for sixty years and never complained of a sore throat. Mind you, he was incoherent most of the time.
 
Hang on a minute. From the conclusion:
parents rated honey most favorably for symptomatic relief of their child's nocturnal cough and sleep difficulty
and yet:
In the honey group, the parent of 1 patient reported drowsiness
That just doesn't sound all that effective at helping with sleep difficulty.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom