Sincere opinions of a Monster Quest episode ...

the evilist serene

New Blood
Joined
Apr 28, 2007
Messages
20
This topic will be discussing exactly what the topic title states. To keep it on topic, let's try to limit only those who were not there to post for the first week or so. This would allow for the most objectivity; however, if those who were there absolutely are compelled to post, because censorship is morally repugnant, obviously there are no consequences if you do post, such as deletion of your message, banning, and whatnot.

As of the moment, adamsclimber, bipto, DDA, HairyMan, laseryeti, mellisa, nefarious1, Whistling Woman, and tugboatwa might want to sit back and review what folks' thoughts are before diving in. You know ... reflect a bit. Listening is a virtue, afterall.

If anyone has any questions about this topic before I open, please PM me directly.

Also note that this topic is not for discussion of the Skookum Cast, nor should folks bash Rick Noll.
 
I was indifferent to the show. I played online Scrabble the entire time (current rating of 1343 ;->). I guess you could say I was bored, but this more likely is due to my having a medium to high understanding of the Bigfoot phenomenon than to the opinion that it was a "bad" show--it was just stuff I already knew, or knew but think is dull, or knew but wish I didn't, you know, ... know.

The show caught my attention a few times:

The dude in the doorway of some 1950s labish/officeish place marching in place to show the Patty gait, all the while my horror sense tingling that he was going to trip over the big black cord that was running from one room to the other. :yikes:

The explanation about the importance of wearing gloves while setting out apples made me wonder if the Mexican migrants who picked those apples had also worn gloves ... and had the big brown paper bag been sterilized. Comparing that with an earlier scene where apples were being cut up and placed on a tree stump--no gloves. :confused:

The two scenes with Ms. Strain adamently stating that the nest was absolutely not an elk lay, to which I could only cock my head ... in wonder. :hypnotize

And that damn luck ... rock tossing, big ol' maybe footprints, branch breaks. Made me all akimbo. :eye-poppi
 
Just a parody that a handful of bigfooter folks here will get (and they did, and it was worth the cheer-up). Hope that's cool. ;-7
 
Just a parody ...

Those women on their Bigfoot quest-- yearning for the big fellow to notice them and their apples (that jaw-- I don't know-- looks like a meat-eater to me)-- that was a parody already.

We had Bigfoot up in the Blue Mountains in Eastern Washington; he was incredibly coy there, too, only showing himself in vivid speculation. If this is truly a primate, where's his clan or family? How does he keep the kids in line so well so that they are never seen either?

The validity of the evidence is one thing, the realism of the proposed animal another thing altogether. But here's the thing: there might be an ape that has evolved a highly-effective masking technique and used up all of its IQ genes doing that instead of becoming advanced like us and killing one another by the cityfull.
 
How would any hoaxer know to drive by at just the moment the camera was set up to point in that direction?

And how would a hoaxer even get a vehicle out into the vast virgin wilderness like that?

I find the vehicle footage very credible.

Though I would have never thought of using hanging CD's to attract one.

Brilliant!
 
I can't understand why anyone doesn't believe that was a sasquatch bedding area.

There were elk and deer all over the place. Naturally, any bedding area was not made by them.
 
What are you talking about?
Serene is referring to a couple of episodes of the cryptozoology themed show Monster Quest. The show is directed/produced by Doug Hajicek who was also responsible for bigfooter's much beloved Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science film. The show featured some bigfooters that have posted here before such as Melissa Hovey and Kathy Strain and was to feature our own tube AKA Matt Crowley. Tube did not sign a release for what was filmed of him after he felt members of the production were not being forthright. He is a well known figure in bigfootery who through rigourous testing established that what were often being claimed as dermatoglyphics in certain alledged bigfoot prints were most certainly casting artifacts. The Meldrum Bigfoot DNA thread is on the subject.

In the process of the show being made Crowley was asked by well know bigfooter Rick Noll to wear an ape suit. Crowley was told by Noll that at a later time he would do an interview with Crowley asking questions about the experience of wearing the suit. When the time came for the interview Noll asked Crowley completely unrelated, leading questions that were most certainly intended to elicit responses that would anger bigfoot enthusiasts and tarnish his image. Noll also asked Crowley to state for the camera "The Patterson creature looks like a man in a suit, till you see a man in a suit." Noll told Crowley that he was asked by Hajicek to instruct all interview subjects to say this. (???)

After the interview Crowley asked Noll why the questions he was told he was to be asked were not to which Noll replied that another interview with those questions would be conducted at a later time. After a few days of reflection on the matter Crowley decided he was uncomfortable with the situation and contacted Noll to tell him and that he did not wish to continue to which Noll agreed.

I have not yet seen the show but I am hoping I will be able to soon. Serene, if there are any errors in my post please correct me.
 
Kitakaze's account of my involvement with the production of the Monsterquest episode is by and large correct, which is pretty good considering that it's a third hand account.

Though I was greatly irritated by the interview at the time, I have never spoken publicly about it until now, though obviously I could have done so at any time. For some reason Noll decided to publicize my involvement, and so my account deserves to be heard, too. As you might imagine, I've spoken about this privately with various people.

Noll asked me to wear an ape suit as part of his Monsterquest TV show. I agreed for several reasons. One was that he's done favors for me in the past, such as photographing casts for me and allowing me to make a copy of CA-19 from a female mold that he owns. I felt I should repay those favors. Another reason was that I was simply curious about what it's like to wear an ape suit, and what it looks like on camera. The finished product was to constitute "B-roll" material for his TV episode, and this is in fact what it turned out to be.

Wearing his ape suit was in no way an "attempt to duplicate Patty" either in look or gait. This is a bizarre distortion and implication by another individual.

Noll's ape suit fit well, and was comfortable, and I was advised it was "home made" by another individual in the Bigfoot world. The designer did a good job. The head, however, appeared to me to be a factory-made mask, though Noll claimed it was also home-made. The great flaw in the head piece was that there WERE NO EYE HOLES. One had to both look forward and breath THROUGH TWO TINY HOLES IN THE NOSTRILS OF THE MASK. It was a grossly irrational design from the standpoint of the costume wearer.

I had to slog through very tall grass, mostly waist high, with some blades up to my head. My vision, gait, and breathing were so compromised by the poor design of the mask and the tall grass that it was all I could do to simply walk along. Despite this, you see 2 or 3 seconds of this footage at the very end of the program. I'm surprised it looked as good as it did.

Later on, Noll contacts me wanting to interview me on camera "about what it was like wearing the suit". About this time, DesertYeti declined to be interviewed for Noll's program, which made me think twice about participating at all. Nevertheless, I decided that little could go wrong by simply talking about "what it was like to wear the suit". My intuition began to kick in though, as I pondered what value there would be in voicing on national TV the fact that "wearing the suit sucked"... I began to suspect that something more was going on.

During the ape suit filming and afterward, Noll asserted that "Spandex was not available in 1967". This struck me as false, and when I returned home later that day I found that Wikipedia lists the year of invention as 1959. Noll also claimed that during Patterson's filming of Patty that "the temperature was 90 degrees". This I also doubted.

Michael Dennett and I showed up for on-camera interviews on the same day and at the same place. Dennett was interviewed first, and his interview lasted fairly long. Time was beginning to run out. When I was interviewed Noll asked me a variety of questions, mostly open ended and non-controversial. Things like "do you totally rule out the possibility of Sasquatch". Eventually he asked me TO REPEAT AS MY OWN STATEMENT the idea that "Patty looks like a man in a suit until you see a man in a suit". At this I flat out balked, as this is not what I believe at all. The next day, I believe, I complained to Noll by telephone. Noll claimed that the line was one of MATT MONEYMAKER's, and that they were "playing a joke on Matt Moneymaker". This I didn't find funny at all, as I was certainly never let in on Noll's little joke. The final question also irritated me, as it was a variation on the old "Are you calling Bob Gimlin a liar" challenge.

The bottom line here, is that NONE OF THE QUESTIONS HAD ANYTHING AT ALL TO DO WITH MY EXPERIENCE OF WEARING HIS APE SUIT. But I did in fact sign his release form at the end of his interview.

Later that afternoon things began to sink in, and I realized I'd been had. I called Noll back and told him that I would not be attending any further on-camera interviews as he wanted. When I confronted him with my main discontent, that no questions involved what it was like wearing his suit, he claimed that "we ran out of time".

I find this excuse irrational, because if you know you have a time limit, a rational response is to prioritize, and get the MOST IMPORTANT tasks done first. Why didn't he ask the "ape suit" questions first? Though I felt none of his questions really "put me on the spot" or would make me look foolish on TV, it seemed to me that the premise of simply asking "what was it like to wear an ape suit" was a total fraud.

The attempt to put Matt Moneymaker's words into my mouth was really beyond the pale.

To his credit, Noll promised me that he would not air the interview, and this promise was kept. Frankly I was simply going to forget about the whole episode until I see that Noll himself has brought it up.

I feel I've repaid any favors that have been done for me by providing B-roll content FOR FREE, and as you might imagine, have no wish to involve myself with Noll in the future.
 
The great flaw in the head piece was that there WERE NO EYE HOLES. One had to both look forward and breath THROUGH TWO TINY HOLES IN THE NOSTRILS OF THE MASK. It was a grossly irrational design from the standpoint of the costume wearer.

That vaguely sounds like the ventilation/eye holes used in the Godzilla costumes. However, the holes for those are located in the chest/neck area and consist of several small holes that form a small square of "dots." If you look hard enough in some of the Godzilla movies, you should be able to see 'em.

I had to slog through very tall grass, mostly waist high, with some blades up to my head. My vision, gait, and breathing were so compromised by the poor design of the mask and the tall grass that it was all I could do to simply walk along.

Let me guess...they didn't give you any chance to practic moving around in the suit so they could make it seem like suits are always cumbersome and are unlikely to be used in a hoax. Because we all know that no hoaxer would ever try something like practice being in a suit...

During the ape suit filming and afterward, Noll asserted that "Spandex was not available in 1967". This struck me as false, and when I returned home later that day I found that Wikipedia lists the year of invention as 1959. Noll also claimed that during Patterson's filming of Patty that "the temperature was 90 degrees". This I also doubted.

No spandex in 1967? That's funny, I could've sworn that the ape-men costumes used in the movie "2001: A Space Odyssey" used that material. Said movie started filming in 1965.

Even if it was truly 90 degrees when the filming took place, it wouldn't rule out a hoax. Haruo Nakajima, the man who played Godzilla from 1954-1972, performed in a costume that weighed over 200 pounds and that got heated to around 120 degrees due to factors like studio lighting during the filiming of the first Godzilla movie. He, and others who have worn Godzilla suits, did not have the luxury of any internal cooling systems; they just had to tough it out until the take ended. A hoaxer would have the advantages of getting such breaks and perhaps a cold beverage from a cooler. Another method would've been to store the costume and mask in a cooler, with bags of ice stuffed inside them, until filming began. And let's not forget that a waterbag filled with ice-cold water would also make the heat much more bearable.

I do know that cooling vests can be purchased for people who have to wear mascot costumes, but I don't know if they were available back then. Personally, I suspect that Roger Patterson would've opted for the other options before he'd consider this (assuming that he would know of the existence of such a device).

Besides, they should've used a chicken in a Bigfoot costume in order to pay tribute to Ivan Sanderson's knowledge of special effects.

Michael Dennett and I showed up for on-camera interviews on the same day and at the same place. Dennett was interviewed first, and his interview lasted fairly long. Time was beginning to run out. When I was interviewed Noll asked me a variety of questions, mostly open ended and non-controversial. Things like "do you totally rule out the possibility of Sasquatch". Eventually he asked me TO REPEAT AS MY OWN STATEMENT the idea that "Patty looks like a man in a suit until you see a man in a suit". At this I flat out balked, as this is not what I believe at all. The next day, I believe, I complained to Noll by telephone. Noll claimed that the line was one of MATT MONEYMAKER's, and that they were "playing a joke on Matt Moneymaker". This I didn't find funny at all, as I was certainly never let in on Noll's little joke. The final question also irritated me, as it was a variation on the old "Are you calling Bob Gimlin a liar" challenge.

You made the right call by being suspicious/asking him not to air those comments. He was clearly trying to get you to say that in order to make it look like a skeptic admitted that the footage wasn't a fake.

Similarly, I wonder if Mr. Prohaska got roped into saying what he said in that pro-Bigfoot documentary by some Noll-type character.

I find this excuse irrational, because if you know you have a time limit, a rational response is to prioritize, and get the MOST IMPORTANT tasks done first. Why didn't he ask the "ape suit" questions first?

Well, it's not like Bigfoot proponents are known for their prioritizing skills... :)
 
Just in case it's going in this direction. 'Ventilation' when used in conjunction with hairy costume design is a word taken from the wig making process of hand knotting individual hairs - not 'air conditioning'.

There is a picture and article on this very forum showing a 'ventilated' gorilla suit from 1940 if I remember correctly.
 
I posted a short review of the Monsterquest episode in another thread here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3199560&postcount=9103

I thought I would add to it with another anecdote:

On a couple of occasions, I've picked up roadkill raccoons and deposited them outside where I could study their decomposition. One time I cut off the rear legs in order to make a cast impression. I decided that a cement cast would run the risk of breaking at the finest features of the foot, the claws, so I used a two part urethane instead.

I pressed the feet into potters clay, applied a bit of generic Pam as a release agent, and poured in the urethane. The casts came out great, even capturing the fine detail of the claws. The casts were cute little buggers, but too big for earrings...

The relevance of this story to this thread is that I discussed this little project with a Bigfooter associate of mine, who immediately cautioned me that an impression of a static (dead) body part is not the same as an impression made by a living animal. Indeed, just take a barefoot walk on a sandy beach sometime and examine how much variation there can be between the shape of a track and the shape of a human foot.

The upshot of all this is that the gentleman I spoke to was OWEN CADDY...

I see that one of Anton's signatures on BFF was "Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain."--Wizard of Oz
 
Roger was strangely dressed for a 90 degree day...

The reason I doubted Noll's strange claim was that Caddy had presented his Patterson film analysis at two of these Bigfoot conferences, and in doing so had mentioned how heat waves might have been a factor. I remember him claiming that it was in the 70's that day. I know various people on BFF have posted weather records regarding how hot it was on October 20, if in fact the film was taken on October 20.

Some time back I was in Austin TX, staying at a hotel on Congress Ave. Just up the street was a costume shop so I decided to check it out. Many of the costume masks had plastic scrim for eyes, the kind of plastic scrim that today's screen doors are made of. Much better than a gaping eye-hole.
 
Just in case it's going in this direction. 'Ventilation' when used in conjunction with hairy costume design is a word taken from the wig making process of hand knotting individual hairs - not 'air conditioning'.

There is a picture and article on this very forum showing a 'ventilated' gorilla suit from 1940 if I remember correctly.

Oddly enough, I seem to recall that article mentioning how bellows-like devices in the armpits of the suit helped cool off the actor inside. Such a device isn't mentioned in this article, but it does mention the short of heat an actor had to put up with.

tube said:
Many of the costume masks had plastic scrim for eyes, the kind of plastic scrim that today's screen doors are made of. Much better than a gaping eye-hole.

People who make homemade masks (and some low budget movies) use black pantyhose to get the same effect.
 
Sorry AMM - I should have been clearer what was on my mind. Recently I saw an article by an FX artist stating (among other things) that it is unlikely they would have made a ventilated costume back in '67 for the PG film (I forget the exact words). The alarm bells went off as I could see misinformed proponents (or skeptics for that matter) adding another level of mystery to the film as 'Wow - they sure couldn't have built an air-conditioned suit in '67'. This is quite understandable as 'hot' costumes and 'ventilation' sound like they are all part & parcel.

What I am certain was being referred to was ventilation in the form of the wig making term - commonly used in descriptions of hairy costumes by their makers.

I can't post links yet, but Googling 'ventilating needles, wigs' works.
 
Last edited:
Every time I read "ventilated wigs" I think of all the old aluminum Salvation Army-bought collanders I've got (in the kitchen cabinet where you don't dare open the door because out falls 24 items if you do). They'd make a great start for a helmet-toupe.
 
I watched the latest MonsterQuest episode on Big Black Cats with interest. I honestly don't know much about the subject, but one segment in particular caught my attention. This was where a woman from Texas, I believe, noticed the carcass of a large black animal next to a fence by the side of a road she was driving on. Others noticed it too, and perceived it as a Big Cat. Before anyone could take photographs or tissue samples, the carcass was gone. But bones remained, and someone kept some of them.

The bones were analyzed for DNA. They came back as DOMESTIC DOG. At this point in the show I literally started laughing out loud. But then a deeper issue came to me; why would the producers of MonsterQuest choose to include such a ridiculous episode?

The issue actually arose earlier for me, with the WhiteWolf produced Legend Meets Science of a few years ago. If you remember, they took a great deal of time, effort, and money to re-create the "Memorial Day" footage by having a sprinter run the same path as the film subject. The sprinter beat the film subject by a mile. So why show this negative result?

It's now my opinion that Bigfootery in particular and Cryptozoology in general is still stalled where it was 40 years ago; the first step is to LEGITAMIZE THE MYSTERY.

John Green was quite explicit about this 40 years ago. The great rationalization of why Bigfoot was not being found was that MAINSTREAM SCIENTISTS WERE NOT TAKING THIS STUFF SERIOUSLY. You see Jeff Meldrum making the same claim today in his claim that "the evidence warrants a serious look at the subject".

So it's now my opinion that WhiteWolf has figured out this basic angle of mystery promotion:

IT'S NOT THE RESULT THAT COUNTS BUT THE METHOD EMPLOYED.

The great way to legitimize a mystery is by promoting the concept that:

1. Credentialed scientists are examining the evidence. Today the Bigfoot star is Jeff Meldrum, 35 years ago it was Grover Krantz. Whitewolf clearly tries to enlist degreed individuals to appear on camera when it can.

2. High tech and expensive equipment is required to investigate these mysteries. 40 years ago all you needed was a bag of plaster of Paris and a 35mm camera loaded with black and white film. Now you need theodolites, GPS, pheromone chips, black light illumination, computers, and rubber gloves for casting your mysterious impressions in the dirt.

3. Novel analytic techniques. The mysteries are so profound that novel techniques must be employed to "research" them. This is the kind of thing that appeals to the "amateur spirit", and allows non-credentialed individuals to appear on TV.

So what if the sprinter aces the film subject, or if the "big cat" turns out to be a dog; it's just more of "the big one that got away" or, "we'll get 'em next time" because we are now using such high-tech "research" techniques that it's just a matter of time...

None of this actually adds up to solid science, because if it did we would read about it in the pages of Nature or Science, rather than watching it at 10:00 on the History Channel.
 
Last edited:
I was indifferent to the show. I played online Scrabble the entire time (current rating of 1343 ;->). I guess you could say I was bored, but this more likely is due to my having a medium to high understanding of the Bigfoot phenomenon than to the opinion that it was a "bad" show--it was just stuff I already knew, or knew but think is dull, or knew but wish I didn't, you know, ... know.

The show caught my attention a few times:

The dude in the doorway of some 1950s labish/officeish place marching in place to show the Patty gait, all the while my horror sense tingling that he was going to trip over the big black cord that was running from one room to the other. :yikes:

The explanation about the importance of wearing gloves while setting out apples made me wonder if the Mexican migrants who picked those apples had also worn gloves ... and had the big brown paper bag been sterilized. Comparing that with an earlier scene where apples were being cut up and placed on a tree stump--no gloves. :confused:

The two scenes with Ms. Strain adamently stating that the nest was absolutely not an elk lay, to which I could only cock my head ... in wonder. :hypnotize

And that damn luck ... rock tossing, big ol' maybe footprints, branch breaks. Made me all akimbo. :eye-poppi


Ms. Strain?
 
Some good observations Tube..

I have raised the question of the science behind " Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science " , more than once ..

They should add the tag line : " And is soundly trounced..."

Such tactics have been used on everything from UFO's to poltergeists ..

" Scientist take a close look at ( insert phenomenon here ) .... "

For some, ' scientists taking a look at something ' , somehow gives it credibility and they don't bother to read the last chapter where we are told they came up with nothing...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom