Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.

From the second url:

And thanks to the work of John Melynchuk and Richard Pitt and others, we now have a law in California that allows anyone to practice homeopathy.

Following the links I see that when Mr Gully says anyone he means anyone. No that's real progress!! :boggled:
 
From the second url:

Originally Posted by Mojo View Post
Perhaps because it appears that after being arrested for practising medicine without a license in Oakland on 5th May 1976, he had to give an undertaking not to diagnose or treat disease. See here and here.

Following the links I see that when Mr Gully says anyone he means anyone. No that's real progress!! :boggled:

That's pretty damned scary if you ask me.

My mother went to some "retreat" thingamajig where people can learn the "art" of some Chinese woo healing practice & then get certified to "treat" people. It cost her $500. --and everyone who coughed up the $$$ received the "certification" regardless of whether or not they mastered the practice (not that it would make a difference).

What concerns me is that the nursing home where my mother works (in Connecticut) actually pays her to provide this Chinese woo stuff to the patients --along with "Healing Touch" (which she also got certified for).

I feel that this is criminal. Not only is it the tax-payers' money that is funding my mother's salary to provide these woo woo treatments, but more importantly, I can see how these elderly people might easily neglect or delay proper care if they are convinced that my mother's work is actually helping them (which, according to my mother, they do). :rs:
 
You folks are getting a tad desparate.

Wilsontown makes reference to Shang's 18 (!) studies, and yet, the final analysis only included 8 homeopathic studies and 6 allopathic ones.

In actual fact, he NEVER provided any analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic studies. However, the International Journal of Epidemiology is solving this question, and a review will be published shortly. Be prepared for Mea culpas.

As for Mr. Monkey...because I have made it clear that I do not treat patients myself, your question is a tad silly. You don't seem to or care to listen.

Jaana...if you really believe what you believe, then you should turn-in your mother and get her arrested. To you, she is conducted a criminal act on a daily basis.

Mojo...thanx for providing a little sanity in your posting. The UK has not yet fallen into the ocean despite having common law in which anyone can engage in a health care relationship as long as there is no claim that the health practitioner is a physician when that is not true (In California, fraud is a felony, while "medicine medicine without a license" was previously a misdemeanor, until the new law was passed that allow freedom of choice.)

I'm still waiting to hear anyone explanation for the EEG reading in that fibromyalgia study.

I'm still waiting to hear ANY critique of the Canova formula that I previously discussed.

I'm still waiting for some GOOD critique of the RHEUMATOLOGY study.
 
I'm still waiting for him to post any evidence to back up his claim that Darwin supported homoeopathy.
 
I'm waiting for him to test homoeopathic toilet paper and present the results.
 
You folks are getting a tad desparate.

Wilsontown makes reference to Shang's 18 (!) studies, and yet, the final analysis only included 8 homeopathic studies and 6 allopathic ones.

In actual fact, he NEVER provided any analysis of the 21 high quality homeopathic studies and the 9 high quality allopathic studies. However, the International Journal of Epidemiology is solving this question, and a review will be published shortly. Be prepared for Mea culpas.

This point I already addressed here. A review of those studies doesn't matter because Shang demonstrated that significant bias was present in those studies. Any significant differences cannot be assumed to be due to special water when we know that bias accounts for those differences.

I'm still waiting to hear anyone explanation for the EEG reading in that fibromyalgia study.

You have not made that information available to us.

I'm still waiting to hear ANY critique of the Canova formula that I previously discussed.

Please provide that information in the other thread.

I'm still waiting for some GOOD critique of the RHEUMATOLOGY study.

It is not really necessary to provide any further critque of the Rhematology study since it did not show a difference between the homeopathy treated group and the placebo group.

Linda
 
Jaana...if you really believe what you believe, then you should turn-in your mother and get her arrested. To you, she is conducted a criminal act on a daily basis.

Don't be silly. It's not a criminal issue, but an ethical one.

It is pathetic to see people who should know better trying to justify batty ideas as ethical.

You do it, Mr. Gully. I just want you to know what it looks like.
 
Darwin and his homeopathic doctor...

For those of you who want to see a Cliffnotes version of my book's info on Charles Darwin, go to this short article on Darwin and his homeopathic physician.

The above article includes links directly to Darwin's letters.

You will see that the Quackometer's previous article on this subject shows that he conducted superficial research on this subject and was simply shooting from the hip. I also show that Mr. Duck's quotes about homeopathy from Darwin were not in context (how convenient).

Jaana herself wrote that she felt that her mother's actions were "criminal." Whether Jaana feels that her mother's actions are truly criminal or simply unethical, I'm curious why she is doing nothing about it (hopefully, she is doing nothing about it because on a deeper level, Jaana feels that there are and must be certain personal freedoms that we all must have in making decisions in own lives in which governments and other people should not intervene).
 
As for Mr. Monkey...because I have made it clear that I do not treat patients myself, your question is a tad silly. You don't seem to or care to listen.
Dana, HOW MANY AIDS PATIENTS HAVE YOU CURED?

ANSWER = NONE

Well, we got there in the end. So, we piddle away the time examining trivial findings at the margins of statistical significance. It's not much to show for 200 years of allegedly huge clinical benefits. Dana, do you really not understand that by fighting on this territory you have already lost the argument?

Now, for the question from the OP.

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.

Perhaps light works differently on Planet Homeopath and they only see in Big Bold Purple Underlined Light. BBPUL vision is only seen here on badly designed websites. No wonder we've been failing to communicate.
 
For those of you who want to see a Cliffnotes version of my book's info on Charles Darwin, go to this short article on Darwin and his homeopathic physician.

The above article includes links directly to Darwin's letters.

You will see that the Quackometer's previous article on this subject shows that he conducted superficial research on this subject and was simply shooting from the hip. I also show that Mr. Duck's quotes about homeopathy from Darwin were not in context (how convenient).

How can you possibly imagine that those quotes from Darwin show that he endorsed homeopathy? I read both your article and the Quackometer one: the Quackometer article is well thought-out, well researched and demonstrates clearly that Darwin was skeptical of homeopathy. Your article doesn't make sense.
 
Posted by Orac today...

Sadly, thanks to Steve Novella, I've learned that Ullman's back, and he's badder than ever (and not in a good way) with an article entitled How Scientific Is Modern Medicine? Given how well Steve has deconstructed Ullman's blather, I was almost tempted to let this cup pass. Almost. Unfortunately, because I feel a bit responsible for apparently inspiring Ullman to run amok on the JREF discussion boards, I also feel an obligation to dive into the muck that is Ullman's prose again.

Read on...

http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2007/12/the_return_of_dana_ullman_clueless.php
 
I left a comment.

He's a braver man than I. I only read the first page. I could feel myself becoming dumber and had to stop.

Linda
 
For those of you who want to see a Cliffnotes version of my book's info on Charles Darwin, go to this short article on Darwin and his homeopathic physician.

The above article includes links directly to Darwin's letters.

You will see that the Quackometer's previous article on this subject shows that he conducted superficial research on this subject and was simply shooting from the hip. I also show that Mr. Duck's quotes about homeopathy from Darwin were not in context (how convenient).

Jaana herself wrote that she felt that her mother's actions were "criminal." Whether Jaana feels that her mother's actions are truly criminal or simply unethical, I'm curious why she is doing nothing about it (hopefully, she is doing nothing about it because on a deeper level, Jaana feels that there are and must be certain personal freedoms that we all must have in making decisions in own lives in which governments and other people should not intervene).


Mr. Gully, are you the only one who has not noticed that you fail to directly or effectively address the question of this thread?

I find it interesting that you have avoided me until I stopped asking you to cure me...
:pigsfly​
The anecdote about my mother was to fill the void here until you return with your answer. My use of the word "criminal" cannot be taken literally or obviously my mother would be arrested. If i were in a nursing home with dementia, i should hope that the facility would provide me effective treatment and knowledgable practitioners -not witch doctors waving $500 "certifications" that even a chimpanzee can obtain.

I will from hereon step aside and refrain from going off topic & distracting you, so that you can answer the question of this thread.
 
Darwin's Experiments with Solutions of Ammonia Salts

From this article: http://www.homeopathic.com/articles/view,128


Dana Ullman claims that these were experiments using "homoeopathic doses", presumably demonstrating homoeopathic effects.
However his own account of those experiments contradicts him.
In fact, there is absolutely nothing in his account that has anything at all to do with homoeopathy!

The only connection to homoeopathy is that

"Drosera...happens to be a commonly used homeopathic medicine."


Extracts of Drosera was not the active substance being investigated. The active substance being investigated was ammonia salts. Darwin was testing the effect of ammonia salts on Drosera. So the fact that Drosera is a homoeopathic "medicine" is completely irrelevant.

Darwin said:

1/4,000,000 of a grain had a demonstrable effect upon the Drosera and “the 1/20,000,000th of a grain of the crystallised salt does the same.


What he clearly did not say is that the 1/20,000,000th of a grain had a greater effect than 1/4,000,000 of a grain. What he clearly did not say (or demonstrate) is that increasingly dilute preparations of ammonia salt had increasing potent affect on Drosera.
So, what has this to do with homoeopathy?
Absolutely nothing of course!

Dana adds:

Astonished by his observation, Darwin likened this exceedingly small dose to a dog that perceives the odor of an animal a quarter of a mile distant. He said: “Yet these particles must be infinitely smaller than the one twenty millionth of a grain of phosphate of ammonia”.


He then says:

"Darwin confirmed an important homeopathic observation that living systems are hypersensitive to only certain substances"


This is laughable!
This is a scientific observation.
Now, if he had observed that increasingly dilute preparations of ammonia salt had increasing potent affect on Drosera, that would be a homoeopathic observation.

The important point about living organisms is that each living thing has certain hypersensitivities to what it needs for its very survival. It seems that homeopaths have discovered a method to finding the substance to which a person or animal is hypersensitive, and they have developed a pharmacological method to apply this medicine to augment immune response.


After all this, is that the only point Dana Ullman wants to make about Darwin's experiments?
That certain substances have potent effects on certain recpetors?
Talk about grasping at straws!

Despite the efforts of the antagonists to homeopathy to continually provide mis-information about the plausibility of the extremely small doses that homeopaths use....even if there is not yet consensus from everyone on how these nanodoses precisely work


No one denies that extremely small concentrations can have an effect.
The scientific observations about the sense of smell, and the effect of solutions of ammonia salts on Drosera are examples direct from Dana Ullman's article.
What this part of his article fails completely to demonstrate is that Darwin demonstrated that:

- increasingly dilute preparations have increasingly potent effects.
- that zero concentrations have any effect at all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom