Darwin's Experiments with Solutions of Ammonia Salts
From this article:
http://www.homeopathic.com/articles/view,128
Dana Ullman claims that these were experiments using "homoeopathic doses", presumably demonstrating homoeopathic effects.
However
his own account of those experiments contradicts him.
In fact, there is absolutely nothing in his account that has anything at all to do with homoeopathy!
The only connection to homoeopathy is that
"Drosera...happens to be a commonly used homeopathic medicine."
Extracts of Drosera was
not the active substance being investigated. The active substance being investigated was ammonia salts. Darwin was testing the effect of ammonia salts
on Drosera. So the fact that Drosera is a homoeopathic "medicine" is completely irrelevant.
Darwin said:
1/4,000,000 of a grain had a demonstrable effect upon the Drosera and “the 1/20,000,000th of a grain of the crystallised salt does the same.
What he clearly did not say is that the 1/20,000,000th of a grain had a greater effect than 1/4,000,000 of a grain. What he clearly did not say (or demonstrate) is that increasingly dilute preparations of ammonia salt had increasing potent affect on Drosera.
So, what has this to do with homoeopathy?
Absolutely nothing of course!
Dana adds:
Astonished by his observation, Darwin likened this exceedingly small dose to a dog that perceives the odor of an animal a quarter of a mile distant. He said: “Yet these particles must be infinitely smaller than the one twenty millionth of a grain of phosphate of ammonia”.
He then says:
"Darwin confirmed an important homeopathic observation that living systems are hypersensitive to only certain substances"
This is laughable!
This is a
scientific observation.
Now, if he had observed that increasingly dilute preparations of ammonia salt had increasing potent affect on Drosera,
that would be a
homoeopathic observation.
The important point about living organisms is that each living thing has certain hypersensitivities to what it needs for its very survival. It seems that homeopaths have discovered a method to finding the substance to which a person or animal is hypersensitive, and they have developed a pharmacological method to apply this medicine to augment immune response.
After all this, is that the
only point Dana Ullman wants to make about Darwin's experiments?
That certain substances have potent effects on certain recpetors?
Talk about grasping at straws!
Despite the efforts of the antagonists to homeopathy to continually provide mis-information about the plausibility of the extremely small doses that homeopaths use....even if there is not yet consensus from everyone on how these nanodoses precisely work
No one denies that extremely small concentrations can have an effect.
The
scientific observations about the sense of smell, and the effect of solutions of ammonia salts on Drosera are examples direct from Dana Ullman's article.
What this part of his article fails completely to demonstrate is that Darwin demonstrated that:
-
increasingly dilute preparations have
increasingly potent effects.
- that zero concentrations have any effect at all.