Show me that Science proves there is no god

Definition: Dough proofs when it is allowed to sit in a warm spot, usually for several hours. The dough expands and rises because of yeast fermentation and production of carbon dioxide. The gas is trapped within gluten strands which form out of protein in the flour as the bread is kneaded.

Straight forward Biotechnology, Zymurgy is wonderful, it helps me to make bread and beer

This is evidence that I can use science and scientific principals and method to prove something.
 
I actually recommend to leave the technical details to next generations of engineers and scientists.
From what I understand the expansion of the universe means that some parts of it are (and others will be) receding from us faster than the speed of light. So, at least those parts are impossible for us to ever reach.
Moreover, if you're talking about a vehicle that could take live humans, I think that's pretty likely impossible for a number of reasons. Not least of which is the acceleration forces that would be required to get it up to such a high percentage of the speed of light before your 1 hour was up.
 
Says who? What I mean is the planets, have we not discovered just a few of them?
Good point! Speaking of which, people keep suggesting to me that I have kidneys, but I really don't feel like letting them cut me open to find out. I really don't understand what makes them think I have kidneys! It's ridiculous!
 
Good point! Speaking of which, people keep suggesting to me that I have kidneys, but I really don't feel like letting them cut me open to find out. I really don't understand what makes them think I have kidneys! It's ridiculous!

:D
 
It also fails to refute Athena's existence. Athena is a limited goddess: She has only a defined portfolio and an amount of personal power. Neither evil nor turtles are under her aspect.

Yes, but as I said before, there's absolutely no point in having this conversation if "god" isn't defined at least vaguely. (Well OK, maybe there's no point in having it even if it is...)

Since the OPs name has "Christian" in it, I think we should assume the god in question is the christian god. The christian god has several defining characteristics, among them perfect goodness and omnipotence. The simple observation of evil in the world then rules him out. Until that has been addressed, there is nothing more to say - and christian theologians have been trying and failing to address it for the last 2,000 years.
 
Last edited:
Not to be misunderstood - That's not evidence.
I have to disagree. The term evidence is not limited to objective repeatable observations.
Evidence is not subject to interpretation and considerations.
Yes it is. Have you never watched courtTV? Have you never heard of scientists debating whose theory is the correct one?
 
Not to be misunderstood - That's not evidence.

Evidence is not subject to interpretation and considerations. If I say elephants exists and here is the proof and proceed to show you a living elephant, you'd be a damn fool to not consider that evidence.
This is a good point, and CS should think carefully about it.

There is a way in which you go a little too far though. The idea that the evidence of "personal experience" is stronger for the person experiencing it than for those hearing about it is of course true. For example:

Say that Mike watches Jim murder Kim. Mike is afraid and runs off. A week later, he gets up the nerve to tell you about it. But by this point Jim has had a chance to clean up, and neither you or Mike can find any other evidence of the murder than his testimony.
Now, from Mike's perspective he had good evidence that Jim killed Kim - he saw him do it. But there are other hypothesis that explain this evidence as well:
- Mike misremembers the events and didn't actually see the kiling, he just saw things that he interpreted that way, and his memory has filled in the details.
- Mike had a halucination.
- Mike dreamed this, but remembers it as if it happened.
You, on the other hand, have one more possible hypothesis that explains the evidence just as well, but which isn't available to Mike - Mike is lying.
Of course there are many reasons why he might lie, but this is the extra hypothesis that is available to you. In that sense, because it eliminates this hypothesis for Mike, but not for you, Mike's evidence is stronger for him than you.

Now, CS, here's the thing, if your evidence is something of this sort, I will admit that it is stronger for you. But it's also true that many of the possible explanations that I have, which don't include god, are also available to you.

And being testable by science mean little more than "If someone else does the same things they will get the same results"
I don't really see how that's true. Being testable means that there is some test we can run, or thing we can look at, wherein if the claim is true we expect result X whereas if the claim is false we expect result Y.

Why would it not, how can an entity exist or influence a system where laws of physics exist without either sticking to those laws or annihilating the universe.

(this is a serious question with deep implications, please think about it deeply, don't just brush it aside. If you don't understand the problem, please be honest about that too).
I don't understand the problem. Could you explain it?
 
This is evidence that I can use science and scientific principals and method to prove something.

...and this is why they have unleavened bread in the bible. They had to wait for the scientific revolution and the enlightenment before they could get a rise out of their dough.

Point taken.
 
I think Zeus' is a poor addition to the list because the Olympians were given a precise location. Humans have scaled it to it's peak and not found any bearded deities in togas lounging around.
You have a far too literal interpretation of Zeus! Just as the garden of eden isn't a real place, neither is the home of the gods really mount Olympus. That's just a metaphor! :P

Also... I seem to remember from the Odyssey that the Greek gods could turn invisible when they felt like it - Athena walking around watching Odysseus, for example. It's been a while since I read it though.

If they can do so at will, what makes you think they can't? Do you think you know the minds of the gods?

etc. etc. rant rant...

:boxedin:
 
Not to be misunderstood - That's not evidence.
Wrong: You probably mean that's not scientific evidence. But by these definitions this and more are evidence:

EVIDENCE:
1. A thing or things helpful in forming a conclusion or judgment: The broken window was evidence that a burglary had taken place. Scientists weigh the evidence for and against a hypothesis.
2. Something indicative; an outward sign: evidence of grief on a mourner's face.
3. Law The documentary or oral statements and the material objects admissible as testimony in a court of law.
tr.v. ev·i·denced, ev·i·denc·ing, ev·i·denc·es
1. To indicate clearly; exemplify or prove.
2. To support by testimony; attest.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/evidence

I hope you understand there is an awful lot in the natural world I believe in that scientific evidence can not apply to. I'm sure you do. It has it's limits.

Evidence is not subject to interpretation and considerations. If I say elephants exists and here is the proof and proceed to show you a living elephant, you'd be a damn fool to not consider that evidence.

Yes it is - especially when it comes to belief in God. Maybe I'll start a seperate thread where you can all share with me what you consider evidence against the existence of God. I bet I'll interpret or consider it differently.


You'd be wise to withold your opinions on Dawkin's untill you at least have shown him the courtesy of reading his books.

I think I already stated I was. I'm excited to read his book, although after reading his first chapter I don't think it's going to be as provoking as I was hoping.

Trust me, he's read your book(the bible) before offering his opinion.

I have no doubt about this. I also have no doubt he's come to alot different conclusion than I have. He also doesn't believe the same things I do. Does he use his interpretation of the bible to argue against God? I sure hope he doesn't.

He added "depending on the defenition for god", which you've chosen to ignore probably because it's inconvenient.

Then why even make such a statement - Something breaks the law of physics unless it doesn't? I know what Bels was attempting to get at even though his statement made no sense.

Why would it not, how can an entity exist or influence a system where laws of physics exist without either sticking to those laws or annihilating the universe. (this is a serious question with deep implications, please think about it deeply, don't just brush it aside. If you don't understand the problem, please be honest about that too).

I don't see any deep implications. I would be interested in what you think though.
I personally don't expect anything in the universe (or outside for that matter) to behave in ways I expect.


I'm getting a bit confused, could we either merge the threads or stick to the points brought up in this one?

I can stop responding if you want - but I thought it prudent to correct my viewpoint so as not to be misunderstood.


You're not making sense, and I'm not sure you know enough about all of science to make the above statement with any degree of certainty.


You think it's wrong for me to think that if one thing in the universe has a property something else can't?



I have to echo the sentiment of some people here, you seem to have ulterior motives, and aren't really interested in the issue asa presented in the OP.

While I will not yell troll as soon as some others on this board, beware that there's very little tolerance for these kind of underhanded tactics on this board.

I don't know what to say except if you think I'm a troll ignore me or stop responding. Does it make any sense to post to someone you think is a troll and tell them they are a troll?
 
Wrong: You probably mean that's not scientific evidence. But by these definitions this and more are evidence:

EVIDENCE:
1. A thing or things helpful in forming a conclusion or judgment: The broken window was evidence that a burglary had taken place. Scientists weigh the evidence for and against a hypothesis.
2. Something indicative; an outward sign: evidence of grief on a mourner's face.
3. Law The documentary or oral statements and the material objects admissible as testimony in a court of law.
tr.v. ev·i·denced, ev·i·denc·ing, ev·i·denc·es
1. To indicate clearly; exemplify or prove.
2. To support by testimony; attest.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/evidence

I hope you understand there is an awful lot in the natural world I believe in that scientific evidence can not apply to. I'm sure you do. It has it's limits.

Absolute rubbish. You are arguing of the existence of something. No matter how many statements or testimonies are made to a court, the court's decision is not actually going to affect reality.
Think about it.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what to say except if you think I'm a troll ignore me or stop responding. Does it make any sense to post to someone you think is a troll and tell them they are a troll?

ps when people stopped posting on your last thread, you started a new one, again with pre-prepared arguments. This doesn't sound like someone with an open mind. Suggest you remove sceptic from your name for accuracy?
 
I hope you understand there is an awful lot in the natural world I believe in that scientific evidence can not apply to. I'm sure you do. It has it's limits.
Can you give an example? I'm not suggesting that such things can't or don't exist, but at the moment I'm coming up short in thinking of any.


Yes it is - especially when it comes to belief in God. Maybe I'll start a seperate thread where you can all share with me what you consider evidence against the existence of God. I bet I'll interpret or consider it differently.
The fact that you would interpret it differently doesn't suggest, however, that your interpretation is valid. For instance, if you showed me a red sweater, I could say it was blue all I wanted, I might even beleive it to be blue (maybe I had some weird sort of brain damage, or colour-blindness, etc) but that wouldn't change the fact that it was red, and my conclusion was simply wrong.
Similarly, I agree that there can be valid disagreements about what is implied by a particular peice of evidence, but the fact that there is a disagreement doesn't suggest that that particular one is valid. We have to actually look at it and see.



I think I already stated I was. I'm excited to read his book, although after reading his first chapter I don't think it's going to be as provoking as I was hoping.
Yeah, I thought it was an okay book, but not that amazing. In my opinion it was his worst book. He makes some valid points, and I still haven't seen a decent criticism of his arguments, but it's not the best book out there to challenge your viewpoint.


I have no doubt about this. I also have no doubt he's come to alot different conclusion than I have. He also doesn't believe the same things I do. Does he use his interpretation of the bible to argue against God? I sure hope he doesn't.
I wouldn't use my interpretation of the bible to argue against the existance of some sort of god at all. But of course it can be used to argue against the idea that the bible itself was divinely inspired.
 
This is lame in too many ways to address, not the least of which is that the word "God" means nothing in particular.
 
Wrong: You probably mean that's not scientific evidence. But by these definitions this and more are evidence:

EVIDENCE:
1. A thing or things helpful in forming a conclusion or judgment: The broken window was evidence that a burglary had taken place. Scientists weigh the evidence for and against a hypothesis.
2. Something indicative; an outward sign: evidence of grief on a mourner's face.
3. Law The documentary or oral statements and the material objects admissible as testimony in a court of law.
tr.v. ev·i·denced, ev·i·denc·ing, ev·i·denc·es
1. To indicate clearly; exemplify or prove.
2. To support by testimony; attest.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/evidence

I hope you understand there is an awful lot in the natural world I believe in that scientific evidence can not apply to. I'm sure you do. It has it's limits.

This is nonsense.

If a reality that has a God in it is identical to that same reality without a God in it, it doesn't really matter whether there is a God or not.

If a reality that has a biddable God in it is identical to that same reality with an indifferent God in it, it doesn't really matter whether there is religion or not.

If a reality that has religions in it is not any better than a reality without religions in it, we have all been taken for a ride.

Note: Teddy is short for Theodore. Theodore means "Gift from God". If something is chemically indistinguishable from nonsense, it probably is nonsense. They should have called the bear "Gift from Allah" - it being the same thing. I didn't see God doing anything about his cock-up in the Sudan.
 
Carb free communion wafers available on request

...and this is why they have unleavened bread in the bible. They had to wait for the scientific revolution and the enlightenment before they could get a rise out of their dough.

Point taken.


Or it could just be that they deny proof even when offered :p :scarper:
 
Don't be silly.
Why not?

First of all, his name has christian in it, and goodness and omnipotence are certainly defining characteristics of the christian god. Second, if we're not allowed to assume even the most basic attributes, the question becomes even stupider than ever - it's like asking someone to disprove the existence of aslknaklfnaf, never mind what it is.
This is not a question of his username. Yes, he is a Christian, but he did not ask for scientific proof that his god did not exist. He asked for scientific proof that no god existed. Further, omni- anything hardly qualifies as a "most basic" attribute. Thousands of gods have happily not existed without them. If there is a "most basic" aspect of a god, it would probably be creation, but even that is not ubiquitous to god myths.

You are right, of course, that it is a silly question if no further definition of god is given or allowed. But it is the question that was asked, and you did not answer it.
 
You are right, of course, that it is a silly question if no further definition of god is given or allowed. But it is the question that was asked, and you did not answer it.

But I did answer the question in the case of a christian god?

If I have disproven the existence the the christian god (and I think I took two decent shots at it here) I'll happily rest on my laurels. :)

Come to think of it my second argument didn't depend on either omnipotence or goodness... only on the agreement that a universe without an interfering god is conceivable. The existence of an omnipotent god is sufficient for that, but not necessary.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom