Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
20-30 feet?

In the story that Roger phoned in that evening, it's already known that the film of bigfoot is 20-30 feet long, and Roger seems pretty certain that he has filmed bigfoot.
This is that same night, before the film has even made it to DeAtley to be developed.

Supposedly Roger ran out of film because they were goofing off and shooting scenery and other junk, and Roger did not know how much film he had left in the camera. Had he known, supposedly he would not have been caught with only 24 feet left.

Yet the reporter already knows Patty's bit is between 20 and 30 feet long.

If Roger was paying attention to the film he had left, he should have known he was low, and not been caught out, and he should have known he had ~24 feet left, not 20-30 feet left.

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/firstpgf.htm

Sanderson repeatedly asserts the 30 foot figure for the length of the film. 6 feet more than usual, along with the 3:30 time.

Remember that Jim McClarin called Sanderson right after the PGF was supposedly filmed to tell him that Roger had film of bigfoot and that Roger was on his way to getting it processed. The word is already being spread immediately.
 
If you were on this trip, filming scenery and pack horses and each other riding, etc., would you film a bear?

It's hard to say for sure....but it's bearly possible. :p


Now that I think about it, though....the fact that they did NOT have any footage of a bear makes it almost a certainty this whole thing was a damn hoax!! :boggled:
 
3000th post and it's about Sweaty's dodging... meh.
Correa Neto wrote:



"Realism"....it's easy enough to know, when you see it...and when you don't.

Here is a great example....

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg[/qimg]





Noted.

Question for the skeptics....which right leg looks MORE realistic?
What on Earth makes you think anyone should answer any question asked by you when you offer empty mocking in response and evade answering questions for you?

First of all, Sweaty, get some manners. The proper courtesy and correct way to avoid looking like a hypocrite brat would be to answer the things I asked of you at least prior to your original question if not up to the post complaining that that question was answered. This is adult conduct. Furthermore, If you are unsatisfied with my response to your question please keep in mind that this is not the first time you have asked poorly thought questions in an attempt to make a point.

Let's break it down:

You say that Patty is realistic. Many others, bigfoot believers included, say the opposite. That in it's very nature shows that the realism you claim is subjective in it's nature. Do you understand?

Now you've asked me to say if I can see a difference in the realism of the legs of the subjects of both images. I have explained the problem and asked you to define that realism you claim and how it excludes my submission of the Harely Hoffman movie. I'm pointing out to you the erroneous nature of the question. Think about this- Does one leg being shaggier make it less realistic? Do living creatures never have shaggy legs? The yes or no answer to your flawed question is 'no'. There is nothing about the BBC subject's leg that disqualifies it from being a real leg in comparison to the PGF. IMO, you understood this point from the first time I alluded to it and your are simply being obtuse.

There is simply nothing about the question to run from and once again you are projecting your own behaviours on to others. Do you deny having avoided answering questions for extended periods of time?

Regardless, I have answered your question as you requested it to be answered. I now expect you to answer the things I have asked of you at least prior to this post. If you do not you will confirm to all the people following this thread, believer, skeptic, fence-sitter alike, that you are completely without integrity and a detriment to your cause.


Oh boy, look out. Sweaty's drawing on pictures again. Sweaty, can you draw on these ones too?

Shag-itis:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/sherseydc/1143822058/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/-jon-/111128277/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/theeclecticartisan/751555592/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/ytse-jam/539953423/

Whacked-out arm proportions:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/labimposter/419961355/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/kirtonmrandrew/471835259/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/floridapfe/460785848/

Now for the last one, you're gonna need to throw us a bone, Sweat. I'm not quite sure what this is supposed to mean:
...beautifully correct body contour, without all the shaggy edges
Care to explain?

Joyce's BFRO report:

http://www.bfro.net/GDB/show_report.asp?id=5245

Sweaty, if something was indeed seen, please detail for us how bigfoot was the most likely answer. And no, I'm not talking about bears.

The illusion of long arms is impossible to hoax?

...Tell us, Sweaty, what are Patty's body proportions?
Originally Posted by kitakaze
Sweaty, name the regular JREF BF skeptic posters who have said the PGF is pathetically easy to duplicate.

...Hey buddy,

40 years and that's the best you got!?

Truly ROTFLMAO.
 
Thoughts on PGF

a. There can be no realism comparison with regards to PGF. Reasons: There is no baseline to compare features, any statement of 'Look how real it looks', is nonsense without a comparitive specimen.

b. An assumption of 'PGF is a fake' must be made, until existence of such a creature is proven. Any other assumptions are based on emotion and or the belief of faulty evidence.

c. An attempt to replicate the footage, using 1967 technology, and the exact camera positions/settings, would be futile, since every time it would be performed, the PGF proponents would find faults with the attempt, and move the bar.

d. I think the most promising branches of debunking the PGF (outside the flaws in the costume apparent in the film) are the DFOOT mask, and the claim that 'patterson was laying a fake trackway' angle, and we have videos of him casting a trackway, with no assurances that this is video of him casting 'Patty's' tracks.

e. Where is the rest of the film roll? and what is on it? Can anyone find someone who has seen the entire roll of film? i.e. the developer of the film? Were there any copies made of the entire roll? or just the 23 feet of the Patty sighting?
 
Don't forget the (anedoctal) report of Patterson buying and modifying a Morris gorilla suit to play a prank on someone...
 
reply:

I have a copy of that settlement and the master is on degraded microfiche in Yakima. But it is not relevant since the film is in the public domain.

So back off.

M
You would not also happen to be a guy named Beckjord, who claims to own an early-generation copy of PGF and tried to sell it some time ago, would you?
 
There may have been at least three rolls of film involved based on the various footages and testimonies.

Reel 1: Riding scenes from Washington, including Bob Heironimus. Taken months before the trip to Bluff Creek.

Reel 2: Riding scene(s) from Bluff Creek and the Patty encounter.

Reel 3: Casting the Patty trackway, the Gimlin stomp test and the cast display scene.

If Reel 1&2 are actually a single reel, then Roger left the partially exposed reel in the camera for months. This would be true if riding scenes from Washington and Bluff Creek were on the same reel.

Interestingly, there may have been three different filmed scenes of pouring plaster into tracks.

A: A filmed demo trackway casting in Washington before the trip to Bluff Creek (source Dahinden).

B: A filmed demo trackway casting at Bluff Creek days before the Patty encounter (source Krantz).

C: A filmed Patty trackway casting at Bluff Creek after the encounter (source Patterson and Gimlin).

We have only seen one casting scene but have no good way to determine which of the three possible scenes it is.
 
Last edited:
e. Where is the rest of the film roll? and what is on it? Can anyone find someone who has seen the entire roll of film? i.e. the developer of the film? Were there any copies made of the entire roll? or just the 23 feet of the Patty sighting?


Finding someone who saw the whole film, would be useless, because their testimony as to the contents would be shouted down as hearsay, simply the same way the costume makers, and Bob H arguments are all shouted down.

I would revise the above to say;
Where is the rest of the film roll? What is on it? Can anyone provide a chain of custody on the film? is there anyone still around who may have seen it or made a copy of it for themselves? Were those people paid to keep quiet? do they have cancelled checks of the payments? Can they help to locate copies of the entire film?
 
Last edited:
Regarding the subjectivity of perceived 'realism' in regards to Sweaty's ever-evolving request for a movie comparable to the PGF (now we gotta make it ourselves huh, Sweat?) and my submission of the Harley Hoffman video I offer the following viewer testimonies:

The video:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=ERdW5IiWHGA&search=bigfoot

gridbug responds:
July 7th, 2006 at 6:32 pm
Did anyone else notice Harley Hoffman’s Bigfoot video is on YouTube as well? (It’s the one called “BIGFOOT Video WTF Insane!!!”) I’d never heard of it until today… personally, it reminded me of the Freeman footage, though I was immediately struck by how much it reminded me of the Patterson/Gimlin subject. If it’s a guy in a suit, it’s a pretty good job.

stompy responds:
July 7th, 2006 at 6:49 pm
it has the “Patterson arm swing” which tells me- NO

Subject: Re: Memorial Day Footage
From: JordanLocksley posted 2006年11月27日 0:58:50
That "Bigfoot Video WTF Insane!" clip on the menu bar is much more convincing then that running dot.

Jordan

CrimsonGoblin at BFF said:
...well...it's a damn good hoax, if that's what it is, or it is the best since P/G imo. Considering the videos relation to a seach for santa clause...well that makes it a hard pill to swallow. I watched the youtube version a dozen times and it is a pretty damn good vid. The posture, hair pattern, arm swing...all pretty convincing.

JVDBogart at BFF said:
Looks sort of like Patty reincarnated huh ??

Jon

FanofSquatch at BFF said:
WOW! I have not seen this before it does look like it has the potential to be real, I am going to read up on old posts on this one. Everyone seems to concentrate on the muscular features and overall build of Patty this Hoffman creature or "Hoffy" (sorry) looks to have the same body structure and mechanics of Patty just wish it were longer. Wonder how old the video is.

Finally let's check in with Sweaty's sunshiney buddy Lyndon/carcharodon:
Lyndon at BFF said:
Undoubted hoax in my view.
Grumpy.
 
Finally let's check in with Sweaty's sunshiney buddy Lyndon/carcharodon:Grumpy.
Undoubtedly Hoax

This is what I mean by it would be impossible to make a video that would satisfy the proponents. They could arbitrarily discount it, without giving a reason. They would say 'it doesn't look real', and I would say, but 'it isn't supposed to be real', and they would say 'well then it's not comparible to the PGF'
 
You're right, Drewbot...I believe...or, more properly, think that there is evidence for Bigfoot's existence.

That "belief" is based on the meaning of the word "evidence".
I don't "believe" Bigfoot necessarily exists, though, just because there is evidence for it.

In other words...there's a difference in believing the evidence indicates a "degree of probability" of Bigfoot's existence, and believing that Bigfoot exists, as a definite.


In a reply to kitakaze's post a while back about a "default position" of believing that Bigfoot doesn't exist, until proven....I explained my thoughts, that the only correct way of looking at the possibility of Bigfoot's existence is not simply "believing" one way or the other....but rather thinking about it in terms of probabilities....based on the weight of the evidence.
The evidence does carry a certain weight, above the level of zero....and therefore Bigfoot's existence should be thought of in terms of a certain "degree of probability".

Since I wrote that reply to kitakaze's post, I've avoided using the terms "believe" or "belief"". They're misleading...they carry the connotation of "thinking based on faith...or personal preference"....whereas the only proper way of thinking about Bigfoot's existence is that which is based on the true weight of the evidence.

You say that the believidence that you subscribe-to points to a degree of probability that bigfoot exists, what quantitative value would you apply to this degree of probability? 'A certain degree' obviously leaves a lot of possibilities, can you quantify that for me? (i.e. an 'x' percent chance that there is a bigfoot.) I am trying to figure out what weight you give the believidence that you subscribe to.

It's not a default position of 'believing bigfoot doesn't exist' it is a default position that 'Bigfoot does not exist'
 
The best that PGF skepticism can do is present a case from the position that the filmed subject is a person in a costume. A variety of evidences, testimonies and deductions are used to support the (hoax) position. Anyone can say that they don't agree with parts or the whole of the skeptical position. It's just that at any given time the status of PGF belief is defined by those that remain as believers. If a decent Patty recreation were made you could predict that there still would be some believers. But at that point, the status of PGF belief becomes one of rejecting the recreation. But even a person who agrees that the recreation is good could go on to say that that only means it could be a guy in a suit.

All PGF skepticism can do is make a public case against the authenticity in forums and publications. Individuals have to decide what they make of it in parts or whole. Hard-hitting PGF skepticism forces the believers to adjust or fortify their counterposition. This changes the state of PGF belief theories. There are a number of new discoveries about the PGF and surrounding events. I can't think of any new discoveries that are supportive of authenticity (possibly Sweaty's finger flex?). If anything they are 'neutral' or could be used to support the hoax theory. But what is happening in the real world is that PGF believers now need to account for a whole range of skeptical claims. Many of them appear to be ignorant of what the current skeptical claims are.

If the body of evidences against authenticity continues to grow then the profile of a PGF believer will be forced to change. At some point, all remaining PGF believers could look like blind idiots.
 
You say that the believidence that you subscribe-to points to a degree of probability that bigfoot exists, what quantitative value would you apply to this degree of probability? 'A certain degree' obviously leaves a lot of possibilities, can you quantify that for me? (i.e. an 'x' percent chance that there is a bigfoot.) I am trying to figure out what weight you give the believidence that you subscribe to.

It's not a default position of 'believing bigfoot doesn't exist' it is a default position that 'Bigfoot does not exist'


You're wasting your time. Sweaty refuses to quantify his "certain degree of probability." He just likes savoring the phrase.
 
People who wear dark sunglasses, especially when sunglasses are not required, may very well be concealing something like their facial expressions.

Would you buy a used car from this man?

Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this man?

Would you then, trust him for any reason whatsoever?

But the skeptics on James Randi, base 241 pages of futile arguments, on this semi-illiterate cowboy who flunked high school, to for perhaps the first and last time in his life, to suddenly be "Bob the upstanding citizen" who is bringing the truth out for all the world to see. Does Bob have any possible motive, like "to be noticed" like a high school kid gone postal, or like a rude 20something year old with a computer and an internet connection?

All Hail Bob Heironimus, the new spiritual leader for James Randi Forums.
 
Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this man?

LOL

thum_2004947681d2287283.jpg
 
Oh, there's something else we can do. We can point out the bad metodology, the bad science used in some of the attempts to validate PGF.

For example, Patty's digital skeleton, derived from PGF... It proves nothing. Its evidence of nothing.

Check this out:
MywoonthropologyPhD.jpg


I can force Patty's digital skeleton inside a vintage gorilla costume! It took me some 20 min of cut-and-paste job. Articulations, the propper pose, proportions, its all there! And heck, its something I made just for fun, without any special care.

It is not evidence that the pic shows some real giant ape (instead of a human in a gorilla suit) holding a gorgeous scream queen! Its evidence that (any)one can draw a bipedal ape skeleton, and with inhuman proportions, over an image of a guy in a gorilla suit. Its evidence that human proportions can be easilly masked by costumes. Its evidence that some PGF defenders are using sloppy methodologies and try to sell it all as sound procedures.

Yes, there are alternative possibilities, such as:
1. That's a real gorilla (or bigfoot);
2. I used some NSA's powerfull über computer coupled with NSA's bigfoot anatomy database to render that image to discredit bigfoot research.

If you accept any of the above, you must also contemplate the possibility that I am pretty good at primate anatomy, perhaps at least as good as those who created that Patty skeleton (or had the collaboration of shady NSA staff).
 
Last edited:

Notice that Heironimus forgot to put ears on the above so called Bigfoot costume, forgot to make a cone head, forgot to cover the lower face in hair, forgot to make it 7'-3" tall, and forgot to provide a compliant hair weave. Yet, he is apparently proud enough of this Halloween costume to parade in front of cameras for 15 more minutes of undeserved attention. Can we spell attention seeker boys and girls? Does a need to have attention brought to oneself, ever cause that person to tell lies in order to gain that attention boys and girls? How does Heironimus's costume differ from the real Patty? A skeptic will see no difference. A pro-footer will see that there is virtually nothing similar. Yet skeptics are still allowed to be out of the psych ward during the weekday, are still allowed to hold driver's licenses, are still allowed to vote, are still allowed to chew gum and perhaps the scariest of all, are still allowed to have internet access. Just thinking of these gross injustices, sends chills up my spine.

 
Last edited:
Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this Roger Paterson?

Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this guy who claims to talk with invisible telepathic bigfeet and four-legged interdimensional little people?

Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this guy who tries to sell a fake bigfoot pic?

Would you then, trust your daughter to go out on a date with this guy who writes about interdimensional shapeshifting bigfeet and was accused of physically assaulting a woman?

No.

I would trust her to go out and date with a rational skeptic.
Specially if he is a NSA agent.
 
This is what real Bigfoot footprints look like. Out of a family of at least 4, 2 sizes are visible in this shot. One mile from the nearest parking lot, yet bare feet bipedal footprints in mud are clearly evident, with no accompaning shoed print. Gee, I wonder what it could possibly be? A hoaxer perhaps, that by using mental telepathy, positioned these tracks in front of a group of bigfoot researchers? If you believe that then I have some swampland .......
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom