Black Coshosh: Another herbal cure proves worthless

Tricky

Briefly immortal
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Messages
43,750
Location
The Group W Bench
Much to nobody's surprise, yet another herbal cure has proved to be no better than placebo for treating symptoms. This time the culprit is black cohosh which was shown to be ineffective in the treatment of hot flashes, a menapause-related symptom.
After 3, 6, and 12 months, black cohosh was no better than placebo in reducing the frequency or severity of hot flashes or night sweats, the team found. The same was true for the other herbal products.

As expected, women who received hormone therapy had significantly fewer hot flashes and night sweats than women given placebo. However, "While hormone therapy is still the most effective treatment for hot flashes, recent studies have shown that it poses serious risks," Newton noted, such as the risk of heart disease, stroke, and some types of cancer.

But always eager to put a good face on things...
The "good news" from this study, according to Dr. Carol M. Mangione of the University of California, Los Angeles, is that women in the placebo group experienced about a 30 percent reduction in the severity and frequency of hot flashes and night sweats during the yearlong study.

That's right. They just discovered the placebo effect.

Oh and yes, don't forget this other amazing discovery:
It is "easy and probably safe" for women experiencing hot flashes and night sweats to increase their intake of soy and see whether it helps, Mangione adds.
Yep. You can take a worthless medecine and, ta-daa! It won't hurt you! Actually, that is important, since so many quack remedies actually do hurt you. And since hot flashes are rarely fatal, failing to do something useful will not have severe consequences.
***
eta. Thread title should be "cohosh", not coshosh. Curse the unforgiving thread title software.
 
Last edited:
Black Cohosh

One (perhaps) interesting thing to point out is that Black Cohosh / Cimicifuga racemosa (syn. Actaea racemosa) has no traditional usage among First Nations peoples as a remedy for hot flashes. The origin of this idea is comparatively modern and simply isn't supported by the empirical and traditional evidence. There are several examples of poor research done on botanicals in which the researchers fail to accurately ascertain and analyze the range of important traditional uses. For example, the popular herb Echinacea has very little traditional use in cold and flu, and was traditionally used for septic conditions and poisonous insect/snake bites. If anyone is interested, you can review the literature on these two North American species by querying the ethnobotanical database at the University of Michigan: herb(dot)umd(dot)umich(dot)edu
 
The problem with herbal remedies is that even the ones that do something cannot be dosed in a standard way. I mean look at Foxglove. Just the right amount and it helps your heart condition. Too much and your heart stops forever.
 
The problem with herbal remedies is that even the ones that do something cannot be dosed in a standard way. I mean look at Foxglove. Just the right amount and it helps your heart condition. Too much and your heart stops forever.

Black Cohosh is a good example, it is standardised according to 26-deoxyacetein content although it also contains fukinolic acid (estrogenic), triterpene glycosides (including actein and cimicifugoside), resins (including cimicifugin), and caffeic and isoferulic acids. It is improbable that all these active chemicals are present in the same ratio with respect to plant, climate, soil and extraction variations.
 
There are lots more herbs other than Black Cohosh that have been proven to reduce hot flushes and other menopausal symptoms.

People who do not understand what they are doing with herbs should go and see a fully qualified and registered medical herbalist who will take a full case history from them and perform a clinical examination if needed. They will then prescribe a personalised herbal formula suitable for that particular client. Personalised formulas are best, as they suit that individual.
 
Black Cohosh is an example of a phytoestrogen. A phytoestrogen is a naturally occurring plant nutrient that exerts an estrogen-like action on the body.

Other examples of phytoestrogens are listed below:

Dong Quai, Licorice, Red Clover, Sarsaparilla, soybeans, whole grain cereals, seeds (especially flax), nuts (especially walnuts), alfalfa, Korean ginseng, American ginseng, Kudzu root, Saw Palmetto, Fenugreek and Vitex.
 
Black Cohosh is an example of a phytoestrogen. A phytoestrogen is a naturally occurring plant nutrient that exerts an estrogen-like action on the body.

In Black Cohosh, fukinolic acid (sounds slightly rude :blush:) has been shown to have estrogenic activity in vitro. Unfortunately it is standardised by something completely different, so you will not know how much you are prescribing.

And incidentally, what do all those other chemicals do?

The clinical trials with Black Cohosh have mixed results, some showing a significant difference over placebo, most showing no difference.

If it does have estrogenic activity in vivo would any responsible person prescribe it for hot flushes when estrogens have been implicated in adverse changes to breast and uterine tissue? Black Cohosh itself has also been associated with liver damage.
 
Ok. I believe that you are confused between Phytoestrogens - naturally occurring plant nutrients and Xenoestrogens - chemically derived estrogen-like substances.

As stated in my previous post, a phytoestrogen is a naturally occurring plant nutrient that exerts an estrogen-like action on the body. These substances compete for and fill empty estrogen binding sites in the body. Phytoestrogens are less potent than the estrogen that occurs in the body. If there is a lack of estrogen, then the phytoestrogens will fill the empty sites and increase estrogen. If there is too much estrogen, then phytoestrogens will complete for the sites and decrease the effect of the estrogen produced by the body, because it is not as strong.

Xenoestrogens are chemically derived estrogen-like substances that come from plastics, hormones in dairy, meat and many other synthetic materials. Xenoestrogens are stronger than the body's own estrogen, so if consumed, they compete for binding sites and increase the body's estrogen level in an unbalanced way that can then cause the problems such as you describe in your post.

Xenoestrogens are strong and can increase estrogen levels in an unbalanced way, whereas Phytoestrogens are extremely helpful in many female conditions, such as PMS and menopausal hot flushes, having a gentle balancing effect on estrogen levels.
 
Ok. I believe that you are confused between Phytoestrogens - naturally occurring plant nutrients and Xenoestrogens - chemically derived estrogen-like substances.

As stated in my previous post, a phytoestrogen is a naturally occurring plant nutrient that exerts an estrogen-like action on the body. These substances compete for and fill empty estrogen binding sites in the body. Phytoestrogens are less potent than the estrogen that occurs in the body. If there is a lack of estrogen, then the phytoestrogens will fill the empty sites and increase estrogen. If there is too much estrogen, then phytoestrogens will complete for the sites and decrease the effect of the estrogen produced by the body, because it is not as strong.

Xenoestrogens are chemically derived estrogen-like substances that come from plastics, hormones in dairy, meat and many other synthetic materials. Xenoestrogens are stronger than the body's own estrogen, so if consumed, they compete for binding sites and increase the body's estrogen level in an unbalanced way that can then cause the problems such as you describe in your post.

Xenoestrogens are strong and can increase estrogen levels in an unbalanced way, whereas Phytoestrogens are extremely helpful in many female conditions, such as PMS and menopausal hot flushes, having a gentle balancing effect on estrogen levels.

You are making a distinction where no difference exists. Estrogenic chemicals are chemicals which show an estrogen type activity. It doesn't matter whether the chemical was synthesised in a plant or a flask. The cell receptor is either triggered or inhibited. The concentration of estrogenic activity to achieve say a 50% activity (more to the point the slope of the dose response) in all of a single type of receptor is an indication of the binding energy in that receptor-ligand complex, it has nothing to do with source of the chemical. As you do not determine the concentration of the estrogenic chemicals in Black Cohosh, you cannot make claims about its effects in any single person.
BTW the word xenoestrogen means foreign estrogen. That is foreign to the human body. That means that all estrogens not made in the body are xenoestrogens including the chemicals made in plants.
 
Good grief.

Is it really necessary to frame these substances as gentle and natural vs. artificial and harsh, instead of simply talking about their properties and what can reasonably be inferred about their actions? What's the point of erecting a psychological barrier to rational discussion right from the get go?

Linda
 
Are there any studies pointing to efficacy for any herbal preparation in the treatment of menopausal hot flashes?

I have a cure for them, which works in around 90% of cases*.
Ask the affected patient to howl at the full moon each month for 10 minutes.

*Disclaimer: This cure may, like most CAM therapies, take some time to work. Well- documented responses have been documented up to 5 years after starting treatment.
 
Black Cohosh is one of those sCAMs that recycles every generation. It was recommended as an herbal remedy for menopausal symptoms in the 1920s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1950s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1970s, didn't work, and came around again in the late '90s. My impression is that the '90s rehash had basically died out by 2005.
 
black cohosh which was shown to be ineffective in the treatment of hot flashes, a menapause[sic]-related symptom.

...
Oh and yes, don't forget this other amazing discovery:

Yep. You can take a worthless medecine[sic] and, ta-daa! It won't hurt you!

Link doesn't work. But I'm pretty sure Black Cohosh can damage the liver, and is by no means a safe substance to take at will. German research that showed it enhanced hormone therapy also advised not using it for more than six months.
 
Black Cohosh is one of those sCAMs that recycles every generation. It was recommended as an herbal remedy for menopausal symptoms in the 1920s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1950s, didn't work, was recommended in the 1970s, didn't work, and came around again in the late '90s. My impression is that the '90s rehash had basically died out by 2005.

please provide evidence that BC was prescribed in the 1920's for menopausal sx - i have never seen it and i have done an extensive review of the literature

as for latter usage (notably by the Germans), what literature have you surveyed to support your claims?

Mills and Bone in Principles and Practices of Phytotherapy (2000) describe several clinical trials of its efficacy for menopause over the last 50 years

however, it doesn't change the fact that the Germans, not knowing a whit about BC or North American plants generally, often got the indications or plant parts wrong in their studies, as do many modern researchers

but this is besides the point: as any open-minded rationalist should know, just _one_ or a few clinical trials with negative results does not therefore obliterate all previous positive evidence - however, the people that pounce on such studies certainly demonstrate their own knowledge of science (or lack thereof), not to mention their obvious bias

Look Ma! three most recent clinical trials from 2007 picked off from PubMed in about 0.2 seconds that shows BC IS efficacious in menopause

hmmm, what in the world is a skeptic to do? wring their hands i guess? are you getting sweaty? maybe you're just hormonal - a nice cup of sage tea should settle that my friend

Maturitas. 2007 Aug 20;57(4):405-14. Epub 2007 Jun 21.

Black cohosh with or without St. John's wort for symptom-specific climacteric treatment--results of a large-scale, controlled, observational study.

Briese V, Stammwitz U, Friede M, Henneicke-von Zepelin HH.

Department of Gynecology at the Universitaets Klinikum Suedstadt, Suedring 81, D-18059 Rostock, Germany.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate usage pattern, effectiveness and safety of Black cohosh alone or in fixed combination with St. John's wort on menopausal symptoms in general clinical practice. METHOD: Prospective, controlled open-label observational study of 6141 women at 1287 outpatient gynecologists in Germany. Subjects were treated with recommended doses of study therapies, with treatment chosen by the participating physicians. Patients were followed up for 6 months, optionally 12 months. The primary effectiveness variable was Menopause Rating Scale (MRS) subscore PSYCHE at Month 3 evaluated by ANCOVA. RESULTS: The treatment groups were comparable at baseline, excepting the main MRS score and the PSYCHE score (monotherapy: 0.31+/-0.22; combination therapy: 0.42+/-0.23). Reductions from baseline were seen with both regimens for all variables. The changes in the primary variable remained significantly different between groups (p<0.001) when adjusted for differences at baseline with the combination therapy being superior: from 0.37 (adjusted) to 0.25 (95% CI: 0.24-0.25) and 0.23 (95% CI: 0.22-0.23) at Month 3 in the monotherapy and combination-therapy groups, respectively. The improvement by both therapies was maintained at 6 and 12 months. The rate of possibly treatment-related adverse events was 0.16%, all non-serious. CONCLUSION: The results support the effectiveness and tolerability profiles of two Black cohosh-based therapies for menopausal symptoms in general practice. They were used differentially: the monotherapy for neurovegetative symptoms, the combination for patients with more pronounced mood complaints. The fixed combination of Black cohosh and St. John's wort was superior to Black cohosh alone in alleviating climacteric mood symptoms.

Adv Ther. 2007 Mar-Apr;24(2):448-61.

Black cohosh and fluoxetine in the treatment of postmenopausal symptoms: a prospective, randomized trial.

Oktem M, Eroglu D, Karahan HB, Taskintuna N, Kuscu E, Zeyneloglu HB.

Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Baskent University, School of Medicine, Maltepe, Ankara, Turkey. [email protected]

The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of fluoxetine and black cohosh in the treatment of women with postmenopausal symptoms. A total of 120 healthy women with menopausal symptoms were recruited to this prospective study with a follow-up period of 6 mo. They were randomly assigned to 1 of 2 groups and were treated with fluoxetine or black cohosh. After entry into the study, patients were examined at the first, second, third, and sixth months of the treatment period. The women kept diaries in which they reported the daily number and intensity of hot flushes and night sweats. In addition, at the beginning and end of the third month, they completed questionnaires consisting of a modified Kupperman Index, Beck's Depression Scale, and a RAND-36 Quality-of-Life Questionnaire. Statistically significant differences were noted in the Kupperman Index and Beck's Depression Scale at the end of the third month in both groups compared with baseline values. In the black cohosh group, the Kupperman Index decreased significantly compared with that in the fluoxetine group by the end of the third month. On the other hand, in the fluoxetine group, Beck's Depression Scale decreased significantly compared with that in the black cohosh group. Monthly scores for hot flushes and night sweats decreased significantly in both groups; however, black cohosh reduced monthly scores for hot flushes and night sweats to a greater extent than did fluoxetine. At the end of the sixth month of treatment, black cohosh reduced the hot flush score by 85%, compared with a 62% result for fluoxetine. By the sixth month of the study, 40 women had discontinued the study--20 (33%) in the fluoxetine group and 20 (33%) in the black cohosh group. Compared with fluoxetine, black cohosh is more effective for treating hot flushes and night sweats. On the other hand, fluoxetine is more effective in improvements shown on Beck's Depression Scale.

Yonsei Med J. 2007 Apr 30;48(2):289-94.

Black cohosh and St. John's wort (GYNO-Plus) for climacteric symptoms.

Chung DJ, Kim HY, Park KH, Jeong KA, Lee SK, Lee YI, Hur SE, Cho MS, Lee BS, Bai SW, Kim CM, Cho SH, Hwang JY, Park JH.

Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Yonsei University College of Medicine, 134 Sinchon-Dong, Seodaemun-Gu, Seoul, Korea.

PURPOSE: This study was conducted to investigate the efficacy of black cohosh (Cimicifuga racemosa) and St. John's wort (Hypericum perforatum) in women with climacteric symptoms, and to assess their effects on vaginal atrophy, hormone levels, and lipid profiles. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this double-blind randomized, placebo-controlled, multicenter study, 89 peri- or postmenopausal women experiencing climacteric symptoms were treated with St. John's wort and black cohosh extract (Gynoplus), Jin-Yang Pharm., Seoul, Korea) or a matched placebo for 12 weeks. Climacteric complaints were evaluated by the Kupperman Index (KI) initially and at 4 and 12 weeks following treatment. Vaginal maturation indices, serum estradiol, FSH, LH, total cholesterol, HDL- cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, and triglyceride levels were measured before and after treatment. From the initial 89 participants, 77 completed the trial (42 in the Gynoplus group, 35 in the placebo group). RESULTS: Baseline characteristics were not significantly different between the two groups. Mean KI scores and hot flushes after 4 and 12 weeks were significantly lower in the Gynoplus group. Differences in superficial cell proportion were not statistically significant. HDL levels decreased in the control group from 60.20 +/- 16.37 to 56.63 +/- 12.67, and increased in the Gynoplus group from 58.32 +/- 11.64 to 59.74 +/- 10.54; this was statistically significant (p=0.04). CONCLUSION: Black cohosh and St. John's wort combination was found to be effective in alleviating climacteric symptoms and might provide benefits to lipid metabolism.
 
Link doesn't work. But I'm pretty sure Black Cohosh can damage the liver, and is by no means a safe substance to take at will. German research that showed it enhanced hormone therapy also advised not using it for more than six months.

being "pretty sure" is not a substitute for adequate knowledge
i will go easy on you robinson, because i think you are a fine fellow

Mills and Bone (Principles and Practice of Phytotherapy) as well as Newall et al (Herbal Medicine: A Guide for Health-Care Professionals) provide extensive toxicological info on BC in their monographs and there is NO evidence that it damages the liver

in fact, it appears to be relatively non-toxic
somewhere around here I have Jim Duke's CRC Guide which gives LDs, but that would mean i would have to clean my library and that is a new years resolution on hold for about a week or so...

contraindications include pregnancy and lactation, which is pretty much of a no-brainer for almost all herbs and drugs, although it does have a very long history of use as a partus preparator to ensure easy delivery (as it has oxytoxicic activities)
 
Last edited:
one reported case "without a clear causality relationship" is no better than random, and for the sheer number of people taking BC across the world without such effects, its _almost_ irrelevant

you might be interested to know that in differential assessment herbalists typically prescribe on the basis of typology - and BC, is probably not indicated for your asthenic type

in addition, medical herbalists will compound herbs together, to take advantage of synergistic functions, and also to ameliorate the possibility of side effects

for e.g., in Chinese medicine, Gan cao (Glycyrrhiza glabra) is specifically added to formulas for this purpose

of course there is no way to quantify this practice, since modern research cannot even quantify the synergism of hundreds of secondary plant metabolites that fluctuate depending on seasonal, climactic or diurnal rhythms, so i wouldn't hold out much hope them understanding polyherbal pharmacy (esp. when they continue to get the species and plant parts wrong)
 
one reported case "without a clear causality relationship" is no better than random, and for the sheer number of people taking BC across the world without such effects, its _almost_ irrelevant

More adverse affects are mentioned here. If the efficacy is in doubt, and in this case it is, the risk benefit from even a small number of adverse events should preclude its use.


you might be interested to know that in differential assessment herbalists typically prescribe on the basis of typology - and BC, is probably not indicated for your asthenic type

Only from nym and avatar, I would think Robinson unlikely to suffer PM hot flushes but I'll leave it to him/her to answer definitively.

in addition, medical herbalists will compound herbs together, to take advantage of synergistic functions, and also to ameliorate the possibility of side effects

for e.g., in Chinese medicine, Gan cao (Glycyrrhiza glabra) is specifically added to formulas for this purpose

of course there is no way to quantify this practice, since modern research cannot even quantify the synergism of hundreds of secondary plant metabolites that fluctuate depending on seasonal, climactic or diurnal rhythms, so i wouldn't hold out much hope them understanding polyherbal pharmacy (esp. when they continue to get the species and plant parts wrong)

Let me get this straight.
1) Chinese medicine adds an herb and that eliminates all side effects from all other herbs? This is remarkable, I wonder why it's not used for every drug.
2) Medical herbalists (whatever that means) mix herbs for synergy even though they don't know what is happening?

Please tell me I have misunderstood that last quote of yours.
 
one reported case "without a clear causality relationship" is no better than random, and for the sheer number of people taking BC across the world without such effects, its _almost_ irrelevant

Are you saying that you are unaware of the multiple case reports published in the medical literature, or of the many ADR reports to the relevant monitoring bodies in different countries where liver toxicity occured in patients taking black cohosh? Or of the precautionary statements issued by these monitoring bodies after investigating the possibility of whether the hepatotoxicity was related to the Black Cohosh?

Interesting.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom