More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

A summary of Dana's latest book:

Some famous people may have used homepathy. They are still dead.

Film at 11.

(And no, I am not taking this seriously. Why do you ask? I am only devoting a homeopathic dilution of attention to this matter for my own entertainment.)
 
Mr. Duck first threatened to close off discussion just after I posted a link to the famous book that Dr. James Manby Gully wrote (in 5 editions). My link was to the 5th edition, where he stated quite emphatically that homeopathic medicines were effective in various chronic ailments, either alone or with water-cure.


Would that be the 5th edition in which he wrote, at page 48, "although I might be induced to try to subdue a passing but troublesome symptom, I could not trust to remove the essential nature of a chronic malady by homœopathic means" (Gully, The Water Cure in Chronic Disease 5th ed., London, John Churchill, 1856)?

What an emphatic statement of the effectiveness of homoeopathy!
 
Here are some quotes from Dr. Gully's book (5th edition).

“I could show by not a few illustrations how this complex medication, this polypharmacy, necessitates the employment of each of the medicines comprehended in it, to obviate the effects of another; how the effect of the mercurials have to be combated by the opiates; how these, again produce a necessity for the purgatives (drugs that induce vomiting); these, for the remedies for flatulence; and these again, producing heart-burn, call for alkalis and opiates…the whole plan is radically wrong.” (page 46)

Gully poses the question of how can a physician find the “precise stimulus” to a real cure for the patient. He then asserts that homeopaths provide “a more rational plan.” Drawing from his own experiences, he affirms that despite the use of infinitesimal doses used in homeopathy, “It is well and wise to observe and investigate these things before laughing at them” (page 47).

In 1856 when this book was published in its fifth edition, he added the following strong statements about the value of homeopathic medicines. He writes that distinct from the use of conventional medicines in the treatment of chronic constipation where drugs do not cure and lead to relapse, it is significantly different with homeopathic care: “In fact, cases abound in which homeopathic treatment alone has effectually and permanently cure habitual costiveness” (page 48).

In reference to the treatment of headaches, the use of homeopathic medicines is “not only justifiable but desirable.”

Finally, Gully continues by asserting, “Homeopathic practitioners have observed that patients under the water cure are more susceptible to the action of their remedies than other persons, and that therefore the results may be more accurately calculated. I have found this assertion to be substantially correct; and it confirms the vivifying influence of the water cure over the bodily functions” (page 48).
 
Reference for this evidence please.

Evidence that James Manby Gully became a member of the British Homoeopathic Society in 1848.

Evidence that Gully was still a member in 1870.

Anyone who doesn't refer to Dr. James Manby Gully as a water-cure doctor as well as a "homeopathic physician" is choosing to provide misinformation and is rewriting history. Now...let's move on.

And let's get out of the rut of saying or writing that my book is only of "dead people." Between 20-30% of the people discussed in this book are alive. Only your critique of it is dead and is simply evidence that you haven't seen it or read it. Whooops.
 
Evidence that James Manby Gully became a member of the British Homoeopathic Society in 1848.

Evidence that Gully was still a member in 1870.

Anyone who doesn't refer to Dr. James Manby Gully as a water-cure doctor as well as a "homeopathic physician" is choosing to provide misinformation and is rewriting history. Now...let's move on.

And let's get out of the rut of saying or writing that my book is only of "dead people." Between 20-30% of the people discussed in this book are alive. Only your critique of it is dead and is simply evidence that you haven't seen it or read it. Whooops.


Well, I'm impressed that they let people who were "deceased" continue as members. I didn't realise that the idea of equal opportunities had made so much progress in the 19th century.
 
Anyone who doesn't refer to Dr. James Manby Gully as a water-cure doctor as well as a "homeopathic physician" is choosing to provide misinformation and is rewriting history.


You have consistently referred to Gully as Darwin's "homeopathic physician" without referring to him as a water-cure doctor.
 
Huh? Gully died in 1883 according to this.


On the first page Dana linked to, John C Charles, ----- Goodshaw and Harris Dunsford are marked with an asterisk. At the bottom of the page it says "those marked thus * are deceased." One way of boosting the membership numbers, I suppose...
 
Huh? Gully died in 1883 according to this.
I see the wikipedia entry talks of Gully's affair with Florence Bravo and how he was a suspect in the poisoning of Charles Bravo.

I am sure we can posthumously exonerate Gully from any involvement. An overdose of of 30C Arsenicum would have had no effect on Mr Bravo whatsoever.
 
On the first page Dana linked to, John C Charles, ----- Goodshaw and Harris Dunsford are marked with an asterisk. At the bottom of the page it says "those marked thus * are deceased."

Oh, I see. Far be it from me to see it as a typical hom ruse to collect membership dues from dead people.
 
Your critiques of these scientists are so weak that no serious journal has published your critiques. Please provide references to the published critiques of .... Roy .... in peer-review journals. ..... As for Roy's work, is there anyone here who has published a similar body of research as Roy has (and thus, has shown some "scientific chops") and who has provided some solid critique of Roy's work on homeopathy? Put up or shut up.


Oh Dana, you must be so proud of us!

KERR, M., MAGRATH, J., WILSON, P. & HEBBERN, C. (2008) Comment on "The defining role of structure (including epitaxy) in the plausibility of homeopathy". Homeopathy 97, 44-45.

OK, I'd accept that Homeopathy isn't what I'd call a "serious journal", but you seem to have some regard for its publications. The authors of that reference are us. For some reason the journal omitted our degrees, but three PhDs and one about-to-be. I think you might find a reasonable body of research covered there, if you were to look. Enough "scientific chops" for you?

So, you wanted a "serious journal" to publish our critique. Check (to certain definitions of "serious").
You wanted a reference to a critique of Roy's work in a peer-reviewed journal. Check, two birds with one stone.
You wanted confirmation that we have similar research backgrounds to Roy. Well, you can start with the 4 PhDs, and work it out.
And you wanted us to provide some solid critique of Roy's work on homoeopathy. Check.

Your little breast must just be bursting with pride!

You see, Dana, you pretty much caused that publication all by yourself. I admit Gavinimurthy was also banging on about Roy's work, which is when we first demolished his results, but we'd kind of lost interest, and we might not even have noticed its appearance in Homeopathy if you hadn't come along and told us.

So, Roy and his co-authors have been shredded in public, and it's all down to you. Great work.

(And don't bother reading Rao's reply. She hasn't got one. She must be pretty embarrassed to have come out with that lameness, is all I can say.)

Rolfe.
 
I was trying to find where Dana first told us that this paper was going to "knock our socks off" (or similar). Anyone got it?

I have to say my socks stayed on.
 
I was trying to find where Dana first told us that this paper was going to "knock our socks off" (or similar). Anyone got it?

I have to say my socks stayed on.

He was going to drop a bomb:

I am getting ready to drop the big big bomb on you folks, and I predict that many of you will be singing another tune. Some of you have suggested that 99.9% of scientists don't believe in homeopathy, as though this is proof of something because it wasn't too long ago that 99.9% of physicians believed in bloodletting and mercury and on and on and on (and "scientists" have been not only the biggest promoters of allopathic medicine but also their best "PR" persons).

See the whole of that post here.
 
I was trying to find where Dana first told us that this paper was going to "knock our socks off" (or similar). Anyone got it?

I have to say my socks stayed on.


That was the post I started out looking for, but I came across the one I quoted first, and I have to say it was irresistable.

Rolfe.
 
The pity of it is that this is probably the end of JamesGully's posting career here. The howls of derisive laughter would be so voluble should he ever slink back.
Nah, he is so self-engrossed that he will not even notice his blunders. We have howled our derisive laughters ever since he was exposed as the only intellectually dishonest person around here, and yet he has come back for more, and he still holds the original intellectually dishonest opinions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom