Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I understand it Pat Patterson holds the rights to the film and the Dahinden family holds the rights to certain still images.
If the film is going to be broadcast in a commercial venue (TV, theater, etc...) Patterson would have to authorize it, at a price I'm sure.
Noll, Green and the others that might have a copy don't have rights to license the film or images for commercial use. EB has a copy and he's always trying to sell it. If he was legally able to make money off of its broadcast I'm sure he would have done so by now.

I'm not sure what NG clip Henry is showing or where he got it but I doubt he got permission from NG, his blog isn't in the money making business so he is probably using his fair use rights.

Does his blog allow comments? You might want to ask him.
 
LTC, do you mean the one that is misleading and incomplete?

18bd8796.jpg
 
Last edited:
I suspect the film marked "To CA" is Beckjord's copy.

Yeah, I mentioned that here a few months ago.

The reason it says "To CA", instead of "Beckjord", is probably based upon him being "the one who will not be named". So much for meaningful PGF history. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I am using English.

[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/6c251322.jpg[/qimg]


Glad you brought up Jethro Tull. Ean Anderson is an average sized man. However many people have never seen his live think that he's tall. The reason for this is he has a preference for small acoustic guitars better known as Parlor Guitars. Once again size can be decieving. In any event Mr. Anderson I doubt would fill out Bob H's tailored suit. Living In The Past gets my vote for Tulls best song.
 
About the chart showing PGF copies:

Where is Saint Grover's copy?

Altho it has been a while since I read Big Footprints I seem to recall Saint Grover claiming ownership of a second generation copy? Who provided Saint Grover with HIS copy?

Has Saint Grovers copy changed hands or is it still in the posession of his heirs?

Off Topic:

Why is this Beckjord guy "the one who shall not be named"? Is this the "one who shall not be named" over on the BFF? I never could figure out what was going on over there about that!
 
Crowlogic wrote:
Living In The Past gets my vote for Tulls best song.


An excellent choice, CL! :)

Their Christmas album has some great music on it, also. (Just thought I'd promote it a little bit.)
 
Sweaty spook time:
I'm willing to bet that if those scientists from the University had been shown a video of this fella, back in '67.....

PattyandJoke3.jpg


....they WOULD have had an official comment...about 10 seconds after the screening started. ;)
What makes the subject in the bottom photo clearly identifiable as a man in a suit?

What makes the subject in the Harley Hoffman video easily identifiable as a man in a suit?

Can you give a clear, unambiguous, detailed explanation of what makes these subjects easily identifiable as men in suits?

Someone interested in sincere critical inquiry, not scoring points, appeals to authority, appeals to ignorance, would not evade these questions.
 
kitakaze wrote:
What makes the subject in the bottom photo clearly identifiable as a man in a suit?

What makes the subject in the Harley Hoffman video easily identifiable as a man in a suit?

Can you give a clear, unambiguous, detailed explanation of what makes these subjects easily identifiable as men in suits?

Someone interested in sincere critical inquiry, not scoring points, appeals to authority, appeals to ignorance, would not evade these questions.


Don't worry, kitty...I'll answer those questions. It'll take me a while, though...I'm very busy, and I'm working on a rather long answer.

I don't evade questions. I'll answer ANY question that anyone asks me...but the time I have available to post here is very limited.
I don't have the time to answer all the questions asked of me, but if there's an important question that someone wants answered...just keep after me, and I WILL answer it.
Unlike skeptics....I will never refuse to answer a question.

As an example of a skeptic REFUSING to answer questions....you did, kitty...on Melissa's board.
I tried to start a debate with you concerning your use of the phrase "reliable evidence"....but you outright declined to discuss and debate it with me. You REFUSED to explain and discuss the phrase in detail, on a board that supposedly wouldn't allow the game-playing that is allowed on boards like this. (Unfortunately, Melissa did allow the garbage that skeptics engage in, on her board.)

Bottom line.....you refuse to answer questions, kitty. I don't.
 
Don't worry, kitty...I'll answer those questions. It'll take me a while, though...I'm very busy, and I'm working on a rather long answer.

No, I think you just know you'll pooch yourself if you try and explain what makes the Harley Hoffman video easily identifiable as a man in a suit. Bring on your lengthy post with a response. I and any others interested in what you don't have a ready answer for will be waiting.

I don't evade questions. I'll answer ANY question that anyone asks me...but the time I have available to post here is very limited.
I don't have the time to answer all the questions asked of me, but if there's an important question that someone wants answered...just keep after me, and I WILL answer it.
Unlike skeptics....I will never refuse to answer a question.

You do evade questions and I have an easy time of showing it. I just happen to know exactly what questions to ask that show Sweaty isn't interested in sincere critical debate. Sweaty games are really simple.

As an example of a skeptic REFUSING to answer questions....you did, kitty...on Melissa's board.
I tried to start a debate with you concerning your use of the phrase "reliable evidence"....but you outright declined to discuss and debate it with me. You REFUSED to explain and discuss the phrase in detail, on a board that supposedly wouldn't allow the game-playing that is allowed on boards like this. (Unfortunately, Melissa did allow the garbage that skeptics engage in, on her board.)

Bottom line.....you refuse to answer questions, kitty. I don't.
Nice try...

1) I made it clear that when I participated on that board, I wasn't coming to debate bigfoot's existence.

2) I made it clear to the ladies that run that forum that I wouldn't rehash baggage with you from another forum.

3) You've been given countless times a very clear explanation of how I define reliable evidence.

4) I considered my self a guest at Melissa's board. I don't go into host's place and encourage irritating behaviour from someone they find irritating. They, like many others, find you irritating.

Keep it up, Sweaty. I'll just post the pattern of questions you evade and an admission from you of evasion.
 
kitakaze wrote:
1) I made it clear that when I participated on that board, I wasn't coming to debate Bigfoot's existence.
*****

Explaining what the phrase "reliable evidence" actually means is NOT the same thing as debating "Bigfoot's existence".

The phrase "relaible evidence" has the EXACT SAME meaning whether or not Bigfoot exists.

That response of yours is meaningless
Edited by tim: 
Please don't try disguise to get around rule 10 violations


2) I made it clear to the ladies that run that forum that I wouldn't rehash baggage with you from another forum.
*****

An explanation of what "reliable evidence" means is NOT "baggage".

It's intellectual debate. Melissa's board has different members on it. You used the phrase on her board. You should be able to stand behind, and explain, terms that you use....WHEREVER you use them.

That response, like the first one, was pure
Edited by tim: 
see above

3) You've been given countless times a very clear explanation of how I define reliable evidence.
Edited by tim: 
and again


You have yet to thoroughly explain what "reliable evidence" means.

You've avoided answering my questions when it comes down to thoroughly explaining how "easily attributable" is determined.

That response, like the first two...is pure
Edited by tim: 
that's four


4) I considered my self a guest at Melissa's board. I don't go into host's place and encourage irritating behaviour from someone they find irritating.
You are a guest on this board, as well as Melissa's board....and on both boards, kitty....you are FULL of
Edited by tim: 
five
:)


The fact remains.....you are afraid of a lengthy debate over the exact meaning of the phrase "relaible evidence".....and you refused to debate it with me on Melissa's board, simply because you were afraid to.

The reasons you gave in your post are nothing more than excuses. Pure BS.
Edited by tim: 
Please read the rules again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You do evade questions and I have an easy time of showing it. I just happen to know exactly what questions to ask that show Sweaty isn't interested in sincere critical debate.
.
Bingo.

3) You've been given countless times a very clear explanation of how I define reliable evidence.
.
Like, nearly a year ago, when you wrote:

reliable evidence of sasquatch = information that is not easily attributable to a mundane answer that helps form the conclusion sasquatches do indeed exist(ie. quality photo unsuspected of being fabricated)

proof of sasquatch = factual information that verifies a conclusion (ie. actual sasquatch body)
.
Jeebus, if Sweaty still blathering on about definitions for 'reliable evidence' I have to question his reading comprehension. What exactly is this reliable evidence he keeps trumpeting on about that skeptics, scientists, academics, and large numbers of bigfooters keep missing?

Does he have any reliable evidence for bigfoot or not?

RayG
 
Last edited:
Perhaps if the leader can be read it would be a clue? You'll recall that was the first thing I wanted. :D
Not that it's worth much, but I managed to pull this out of the leader (at the end of the footage).

Leader.jpg



Also at the beginning and repeated after the 'creature' footage appears to be the scrawl '~ u c 5946'.

ETA:

Leader2-1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Thank you, John. That is really great work. I don't have the software to do that kind of thing.

You found the word "Bigfoot", and the marking "~UC 5946". The "~" may be something else (like another "U"), but it doesn't matter much.

I'm going to start using a terminology for this discussion:

Leader = stuff found on the film frames before the Patty walk.
Trailer = stuff found on the film frames after the Patty walk.

It looks like you grabbed your frames from the Henry May Version (HMV), which contains a leader and a trailer. The National Geographic Version (NGV) has a trailer (and no seen leader), but I will leave that version out of this post because you only evaluated the HM version.

When you watch the HMV, you are presented with this order:

"~UC 5946"
Patty Walk
"Bigfoot"
"~UC 5946"

You already know this by now - but the lettering as it presents itself in the HMV must be flipped and rotated to be readable. You had to do that to present your above-posted written scripts as they appear. That took some time and effort, I suppose. Thanks again.

The yellow rectangle (NG logo) serves as a functional 'landmark', because it is always in the lower right as seen in the HMV.

I think we can all agree that a person writing on a 16mm filmstrip (assuming that it what we are seeing, or a copy of such), would not intentionally write backwards or upside-down. The Patty walk scene appears normal and is not flipped as it presents itself in the HMV, and the NGV.

If you can imagine having an ink marker in your hand, and then also a strip (or reel) of 16mm celluloid film laid out in front of you... you can try to understand what may have gone into writing the "~UC 5946", and "Bigfoot" upon that film. You have you choice of which 'side' of the film to write on, as well as the 'direction' that you write relative to the 'direction' that the film is to be projected. Suddenly, you are faced with multiple variables that could be compounded if the ink writer decided to switch their writing orientation and/or a producer/copier decided to do some editing of what was presented to them. That all becomes very complicated if you are trying to figure out the exact 'forensic' nature of the source material (16mm film?) as compared to exactly what you are seeing in the HMV, and/or the NGV.

I don't have anything to say about this yet, but these things are important if one wishes to comparatively analyze different versions of the PGF that contain this leader and/or trailer. I'm mostly interested in learning of direct relationships to different versions and if any editing occured to these directly related versions. There is a distinct limitation to this kind of analysis. Anybody can edit or modify whatever is in their hands, and this can be done at any time in the 'chain of custody'.

I also noticed that there appears to be some more writing that comes before "Bigfoot" when the trailer starts. I can't tell what it says, or if it is a complete word.
 
Correa Neto wrote:



I'll be as "unbiased" in my work as I can be. But if anybody thinks there's something wrong with my analysis, they're completely free to do their own counter-analysis.

Also, I'll be more than happy to show whatever results I get. I don't have anything to hide, or to lose.
I'm not trying to prove Patty can't be a guy-in-a-suit...I'm simply trying to determine if she is or not. I'm much more interested in finding the truth than I am in playing make-believe. :)
Well, the first -and main- question is if being as unbiased as you can will be unbiased enough. For example, are you sure you are looking for the truth? Or you are just seeking for informations that, in your mind, will corroborate a preconceived idea of truth?

As for the counter-analysis, they've been made several times, in case you haven't noticed.

Here is a sound, and reliable measurement for you, Correa...;)...
The slope of Patty's forehead, in this profile view, is approx. 60 degrees from the vertical...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/PattyHD4lined.jpg[/qimg]


Since 45 degrees is halfway between vertical and flat horizontal.....Patty's head slants back at an angle closer to the horizontal plane than it does to the vertical. Very un-humanlike....I must say!

That helmet must have had some mighty thin padding in it.
Sorry, but I don't see how measurements made over a small blurry image without taking in to account the effects of perspective and scaling can be regarded as reliable...

Whatever measurements you make must be made with perspective and scaling taken in to account. Please expose the methods you used to deal with these issues.
 
Originally Posted by SweatyYeti
Here is a sound, and reliable measurement for you, Correa......
The slope of Patty's forehead, in this profile view, is approx. 60 degrees from the vertical...
http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w...tyHD4lined.jpg


Since 45 degrees is halfway between vertical and flat horizontal.....Patty's head slants back at an angle closer to the horizontal plane than it does to the vertical. Very un-humanlike....I must say!

That helmet must have had some mighty thin padding in it.


images
 
The fact remains.....you are afraid of a lengthy debate over the exact meaning of the phrase "relaible evidence".....and you refused to debate it with me on Melissa's board, simply because you were afraid to.
Please don't project your willful ignorance on me. I don't like spiders but I fear nothing where bigfoot is concerned. If there is any reliable evidence for bigfoot then we all win. Happy. Yay. If that happens, I'll suffer the 'I told you so's of bigfoot enthusiast just fine. If that happens it won't change that all the evidence put forth beforehand was unreliable.

See, I'm no 'denialist' or 'scoftic' for thinking hairy cans, diaper butt is not a real bigfoot or Joyce didn't see a bigfoot in New York in '83. You can't understand 'easily attributable'? Not my problem. I'm not cowering in fear from some shining bigfoot truth. It takes me very little time to look at the PGF and easily attribute it to a man in a suit. Do I know it as a fact that it's a man in a suit? No I don't. Does that matter? No it doesn't. You know why? Because nothing about it can't be accounted for by a man in a suit. Therefore it is not reliable evidence. You wanna play dense? Not my problem. You wanna pretend you're being objective? Enjoy the dream.

Did Joyce see a bigfoot at the corner of State Farm and 203 in Valatie? I can easily attribute it to a man in a suit or nothing at all for reasons that others and myself have thoroughly explained. You wanna play dense? Not my problem.

Was the Memorial Day Footage a real diminutive bigfoot running on the hill? Nope. Crazy easy.

I know your games, I know your tricks, and I know your excuses. You are not interested in sincere critical debate where bigfoot is concerned and I've become very adept at showing it.

Hey buddy, thanks for taking the time to post. Watch me take you down to Chinatown:

All other suits are easily identifiable as a man in a suit? I guess if the Harley Hoffman video is easily identifiable as a man in a suit, then it doesn't require much effort to stick it to me with a post explaining why. I guess if I kept raising the issue with you and you kept responding without putting forth that explanation then it would look like you were evading the question. It would look like you know that the moment you try and explain why the Harley Hoffman video is easily identifiable as a man in a suit you pooch yourself. And that, Sweaty, is not a person interested in sincere critical inquiry. That's a dude with a chub for bigfoot and a bad case of denial. That's a guy looking to try and score some points on some evil skeptics for taking the sparkle of his bigfoot dreams.

You, Sweaty, are as predictable as ever.

I await your easy identification of the Harley Hoffman video as a man in a suit.
 
NG used a full frame version, correct? How many people supposedly had full frame, unenlarged, film copies of the PGF.

Maybe we can narrow this down a bit?

Watch Part 5 of the NG episode. Pause at 7:22. Here are the credits (sources?) for the 'stock' Patty footage used by National Geographic. Then look at the "Special Thanks" credits after that. The usual suspects. :D

NG got punked by Bigfooters and PGF promoters multiple times when they were putting together this episode of Is It Real? Never trust a Bigfooter to give it to you straight.

Juicy!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom