Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. It extends for quite a ways onto the shoulder blade area.

2. What do you mean 'you can't see the left shoulder'? Is the shoulder blade considered part of the shoulder, or should I have said 'upper back'?

3. GT/CS has another suit flaw on which to plead with Sweaty for an answer
 
Is that the famous braid that MK davis thinks he sees on the film?
Or is BOBH wearing a coonskin cap?
 
Last edited:
One option is that the Patterson subject may be a real Bigfoot.

Is that not true?

Of course it is an "option". However, one has to weigh which is more likely. Since there have been no bigfoot bodies, no convincing bigfoot film/videos (other than this supposedly), no convincing bigfoot photographs (other than stills from this film), etc. etc, one begins to wonder how one can consider this option very likely. To consider it a likely option, one has to assume that all bigfoot are very good at not being seen even with civilization continuously encroaching on their environment or that this was one of the last bigfeet in existence. The other option of it being a clever hoax has a more likely nature to it because it assumes something that is more probable. Until more substantial evidence (not stupid plaster casts of their footprints) can be provided that bigfeet exist, the more likely option of a hoax is the default position.
Therefore, I suggest you start working on gathering more evidence (other than this film, which appears highly suspect) if you want to get people other than the bigfoot faithful to side with your position. Just remember, this evidence isn't going to magically appear on your desktop. Spend some of your hard earned cash and go out and get it. If you sincerely believe that bigfoot exists, then it would be a worthy venture and expenditure of funds. It certainly should be more fruitful than arguing a forty year old film on the internet.
 
Of course it is an "option". However, one has to weigh which is more likely. Since there have been no bigfoot bodies, no convincing bigfoot film/videos (other than this supposedly), no convincing bigfoot photographs (other than stills from this film), etc. etc, one begins to wonder how one can consider this option very likely. To consider it a likely option, one has to assume that all bigfoot are very good at not being seen even with civilization continuously encroaching on their environment or that this was one of the last bigfeet in existence. The other option of it being a clever hoax has a more likely nature to it because it assumes something that is more probable. Until more substantial evidence (not stupid plaster casts of their footprints) can be provided that bigfeet exist, the more likely option of a hoax is the default position.
Therefore, I suggest you start working on gathering more evidence (other than this film, which appears highly suspect) if you want to get people other than the bigfoot faithful to side with your position. Just remember, this evidence isn't going to magically appear on your desktop. Spend some of your hard earned cash and go out and get it. If you sincerely believe that bigfoot exists, then it would be a worthy venture and expenditure of funds. It certainly should be more fruitful than arguing a forty year old film on the internet.

Well actually real investigations can't happen because the government clamps down on anyone who actually makes headway into proving Sasquatch exists. As far as the PGF could have been one of the last, assuming for a moment its real. But the men in BROWN will knock on your door if you bag a BIgfoot or even get good photos. The MIBR are real and they're out there look behind you, sleep with one eye open.......
 
smokey-only-you.jpg


CAN PREVENT BIGFOOT PHOTOS
 
Of course it is an "option".
However, one has to weigh which is more likely.
Since there have been no bigfoot bodies, no convincing bigfoot film/videos (other than this supposedly), no convincing bigfoot photographs (other than stills from this film), etc. etc, one begins to wonder how one can consider this option very likely. To consider it a likely option, one has to assume that all bigfoot are very good at not being seen even with civilization continuously encroaching on their environment or that this was one of the last bigfeet in existence. The other option of it being a clever hoax has a more likely nature to it because it assumes something that is more probable. Until more substantial evidence (not stupid plaster casts of their footprints) can be provided that bigfeet exist, the more likely option of a hoax is the default position.
Therefore, I suggest you start working on gathering more evidence (other than this film, which appears highly suspect) if you want to get people other than the bigfoot faithful to side with your position. Just remember, this evidence isn't going to magically appear on your desktop. Spend some of your hard earned cash and go out and get it. If you sincerely believe that bigfoot exists, then it would be a worthy venture and expenditure of funds. It certainly should be more fruitful than arguing a forty year old film on the internet.


That's a very thoughtful response, Astrophotographer. :)

I agree with some of what you said...but not all of it.

Here are a few things that I disagree with...

Therefore, I suggest you start working on gathering more evidence (other than this film, which appears highly suspect) if you want to get people other than the bigfoot faithful to side with your position.


My main purpose in posting on Bigfoot threads is not to "get people to agree with me" or to get others to "believe Bigfoot exists".
I'm not taking part in any "belief wars"....which, apparantly, all the skeptics on this board are.
They seem obsessed with what other people think, and "believe".

The reason why I analyse the PG film, and the Memorial Day Video, is simply because I think there is a high probability that both those videos are videos of real Bigfoot creatures....and I'm trying to find out what the most likely explanation for them is...real or hoax.

In other words....it's all about BIGFOOT, or, the evidence for Bigfoot....not what skeptics, or anyone else, thinks.

Quote:
It certainly should be more fruitful than arguing a forty year old film on the internet.


I'm not "arguing" anything about the PG film. I'm posting some analysis of the film...like animated gif's, and comparisons of Bob Heironimus' and Patty's body proportions, etc.
What the skeptics think about any of it, is their perogative.
I'm much more interested in their counter-analysis, than I am in their opinions of the evidence....or their opinions of me, personally.


The other option of it being a clever hoax has a more likely nature to it because it assumes something that is more probable.


Can you elaborate on that a little?

Do you mean that "hoaxes" are always the more probable explanation for any and all types of Bigfoot evidence?

If so, why is that?


Spend some of your hard earned cash and go out and get it. If you sincerely believe that bigfoot exists, then it would be a worthy venture and expenditure of funds


If I had the time, and the money...I'd spend a good amount of time hiking in the scenic :eye-poppi mountains...looking for Bigfeet. :jaw-dropp
 
leader tape

It is my understanding that the copy of the film that Olsen had for ANE pictures had "American Bigfoot" on the leader tape, I cannot remember where that info came from and I am not sure what copy we are dealing with anymore anyway :boggled:
 
Last edited:
It is my understanding that the copy of the film that Olsen had for ANE pictures had "American Bigfoot" on the leader tape, I cannot remember where that info came from and I am not sure what copy we are dealing with anymore anyway :boggled:

Ahh, OK. That does make sense even if you cannot yet make a reference. The written words "American Bigfoot" probably are not meant to denote that the film contains a Bigfoot filmed in America. It more likely is shorthand writing meant to indicate "American (National Enterprises) Bigfoot". The alpha-numeric writing probably indicates an internal stock number for the PGF footage (or possiblt it specifies this particular edited film copy of the PGF). ANE may have produced multiple versions of the PGF, and kept track of them all using special number codes. This version shows the "driftwood scene" twice among other differences that we see, when compared other available versions of the PGF. I have never seen any other version of the PGF which shows this repeated scene. It is quite obvious that this particular version of the PGF has received creative editing. The repeated driftwood scene can be observed in the NG program as well as the Henry May YouTube clip.

Repeated "driftwood scene"...
eb238399.jpg
 
Can you elaborate on that a little?

Do you mean that "hoaxes" are always the more probable explanation for any and all types of Bigfoot evidence?

If so, why is that?

Exactly how many bigfeet have been captured on film in the past forty years? What evidence is there that there is a bigfoot/are bigfeet? Is there only one and this was it? Since there is very little (if any) good evidence that bigfoot/bigfeet exists/exist, then the more likely scenario is the film was a hoax. It is the razor that implies you look for the most probable/simplest answer. We have no solid evidence that Bigfoot exists, therefore, a hoax is more likely because it assumes that a man (which exists) was filmed in a suit (which can be made despite your protests to the contrary). Skeptics will assume this position until better and more definitive evidence supporting bigfoot's existence can shift opinions regarding the PGF to your preferred answer. From what I have read, your arguments are just demonstrating a will to believe and not critical thinking.
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
Skeptics will assume this position until better and more definitive evidence supporting bigfoot's existence can shift opinions regarding the PGF to your preferred answer.


That's fine with me. :)

Like I said in my previous post....help yourself to whatever thoughts you want to have! You're free to assume and think that Patty is a man....but that 'position' is nothing more than a "peferential belief"...a meaningless thought...on the part of whoever takes it...unless it can be supported by evidence which proves the position to be factual.

Exactly what Patty IS is still unproven...and ambiguous. It could be a man-in-a-suit....or it could be a real Bigfoot.
Patty is too realistic-looking ;) to say with 100% certainty that it's a human.

Even some skeptics here will admit that.
Earlier today, kitakaze wrote this, concerning the possibility of Patty being a real Bigfoot....

The least likely, yes.

But, it is an option...

So, think whatever you like....but your opinion, or assumption, concerning Patty is worth no more than anyone else's...including mine....just 2 cents. :)


From what I have read, your arguments are just demonstrating a will to believe and not critical thinking.


By your own words, Astro....your default position is simply a "will to believe", on your part.

Specifically...
Skeptics will assume this position....
 
Thank you, LTC. But, Homey don't play that, quite yet. Find me a part in NG where those leader markings are seen before, and after the clip.

May/Davis are not off the hook yet.

Hello, William. I do not think that is anything M.K. did. According to what M.K. told me, he examined that clip frame by frame, and at the end he said he saw writing on it that said "American Bigfoot." He speculated that it may have been the original movie film because American National Enterprises (ANE) had possession of the original film, and someone from the National Geographic may have gone to ANE while they still had the film in their possession and made a 1-inch tape copy of it, the entire film. You can tell that it is from NG because the NG logo is on the bottom right-hand corner, so it is safe to assume that this copy of the film that I got from YouTube is from the National Geographic special that was done a few years ago which somebody probably extracted from the DVD copy (yes, there is a DVD of this production, I have it). The Bigfoot program was put together on a promotional DVD with two other National Geographic Programs, one on Tattoos and the other on Hurricanes. Hope this clears things up for you, William.
 
Astrophotographer, let me show you how the loop with Sweaty works. Sweaty likes to attempt to present his credulity as unbiased reason but it's very simple to show his bigfoot enthusiasm:

You're free to assume and think that Patty is a man....but that 'position' is nothing more than a "peferential belief"...a meaningless thought...on the part of whoever takes it...unless it can be supported by evidence which proves the position to be factual.
Thinking that Patty is a man in a suit is not nothing more than a preferential belief with the same weight as Patty being a real bigfoot because:

1) Patterson is known to have created illusions and presented them as reality.

2) The subject of the PGF shows no features that are unable to be accounted for by a man in a suit.

3) Nobody saw Patty before or since despite the fact that 'she' was in an area being worked by a logging crew.

4) Patty is supposed to represent a species for which there is not one shred of reliable evidence.

People that are not possessed of a will to believe in bigfoot look at this an conclude that the film shows a person in a suit.

Exactly what Patty IS is still unproven...and ambiguous. It could be a man-in-a-suit....or it could be a real Bigfoot.
Patty is too realistic-lookingto say with 100% certainty that it's a human.
And out it comes. This is where you ask Sweaty to define what makes Patty realistic. You ask him if he has an example real bigfoot to compare to. You tell him that the goofy she-thing with the ridiculous hairy missiles in the middle of the torso and the diaper butt does not inspire the word 'realistic'.

This where I ask Sweaty for the millionth time what makes the Harley Hoffman video easily identifiable as a man in suit, he pulls a scared turtle, and his raging footer status is reiterated.

Sweaty says:

By your own words, Astro....your default position is simply a "will to believe", on your part.

Specifically...
Then truncates your statement and bolds the word 'assume' thinking he's doing something clever. You simply post the full statement again and bold the part that he truncated:

Skeptics will assume this position until better and more definitive evidence supporting bigfoot's existence can shift opinions regarding the PGF to your preferred answer.
Yes, Sweaty. Skeptics will assume, adopt, take on that position based on the facts. The fact that there is not one single thing supporting a living bigfoot over a man in a suit being key.

Still waiting for the answer of what makes the Hoffman video easily identifiable as a man in a suit and wondering if that is the case then why does it take a lengthy post to explain it.
 
So, think whatever you like....but your opinion, or assumption, concerning Patty is worth no more than anyone else's...including mine....just 2 cents. :)

Still getting this wrong Sweaty? The whole *every possible imagined scenario, no matter how convoluted or ridiculous, is as valid as any other* point of view?

Seriously dude, its time to give that one up. If not, you should also investigate the possibility that Patty is 150kgs of mouldy swiss chocolate.......

Once again, for the peanut gallery - we have evidence men exist, we have evidence monkey suits exist, we have no evidence bigfoot exists - therefore, the default scenario of the patty film is that it is a man in a suit. Any alternative scenarios must be *backed by evidence*, something all BFers are still failing to provide.

And no Sweaty, "I think it looks real" is not evidence.
 
I am simply wondering how you can look at things like MDF, and PGF, and conclude that that is an Unclassified, Hairy, Bipedal, Swimming, Primate. Pointing out flaws in your thinking is not intended to get you to switch teams, but to realize how un-critically you've been approaching the subject.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom