Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can't find the left hand.

It's right at the end of the left arm. :D

I'm at home on dial up, so I can't fool around with that World's Greatest Hoaxes video right now or I'd capture a few more frames. It's from a scene shown around the time that other guy does his Patty walk across the screen and then denies any knowledge of participation in the PGF.
 
Yeah, ok, I can see it in WGH right about when Romney walks. The hand is mitten-like and not large (or at least not disproportionate).

Here is a Dahinden Cibachrome of Frame 350. This one has an odd left hand (is it an open palm, or background wood?)...

dc60010b.jpg


For comparison from PGF copy. That is a weird hand...

93dda747.jpg
 
William are there more Cibachrome frames available? The top one is light years better quality than most otheres out there. The thumb seems to be higher up than a human thumb. I've never seen this frame in this detail before.
 
William are there more Cibachrome frames available? The top one is light years better quality than most otheres out there. The thumb seems to be higher up than a human thumb. I've never seen this frame in this detail before.

"Thumb"? Or background?
 
Last edited:
here's how it works.

If the costume has a surface like cloth, leather, or any similar "fabric" or looks like apparrel a person wears, it's under Costume Design jurisdiction.

But if the costume suit is intended to look like the real skin or fur of a living creature, it's Makeup effects. It's still a costume inside, but the outside is what makeup effects people do best, and costumers hate to do, so they let the makeup people do it.

In a strict union job, costume people work on the makeup crew, making the undersuit, padding, suit closures, etc. while the makeup people make the outer skin or fur.

added: So by Hollywood rules, the apes weren't costumes. They were makeup effects, and then, there was no regular Oscar for Makeup as today.

The 'early man' apes in 2001: A Space Odyssey were not eligible for Best Costume Design, but the apes in Planet of the Apes were? POTA was nominated in 1968 for Best Costume Design, and 2001 won Best Visual Effects. Also for POTA at the Academy Awards, John Chambers received an Honorary Award for Outstanding Achievement in Makeup.
 
WP

Planet of the Apes won for best costume because the Apes wore clothing. It wasn't the ape features (the makeup), it was the cloth and leather garments they wore which got best costume.

John Chambers got a Special Academy Award for makeup on the Apes film, Like Bill Tuttle, a few years before, but a regular makeup award year after year was not introduced until 1981, Rick Baker for Americal Werewolf.

Bill
 
Last edited:
"Thumb"? Or background?

The dark line sticking out from the hand may actually be a backround artifact. If that's so then the dark portion of the hand on the right may be the back top side of the thumb and we're seeing the dark fur covering that side of the digit. Seems the inside of fingers can be seen as the bluish grey area. A good fram before this one would settle the sticking out thumb issue
 
Crow, the Dahinden Cibachromes (DC) are the Holy Grail of PGF Still Frames. I think I read that there are about a dozen of them. These are held tightly to the vest and you are lucky to see them anywhere. When you catch them on the web, they are already diminished in resolution because of copying and conversion to jpeg or gif. I have a strong feeling that if anyone were to actually hold an original DC in their hands, they would be stunned by the clarity and color rendition.

Here is an animated gif that alternates between two DCs (Frame 350 & 352). There is no way that those hands are the size of baseball mitts. As far as I'm concerned, they look like sea otter paws.

deeba473.gif
26686.jpg
 
Misc. responses

Crowlogic said:
I'm glad you posted the link to the Hoffman video. I've seen it before but never knew who made it. That's the best looking thing of all but as usual it shoots itself in its own "bigfoot" by being not more than a snippit of creature. Yet even within that snippit I saw enough to condemn it to the fake pile. There is a brief moment where the back of the creatures right hand is visible. It appears dark as if fur covered. Even dark primate skin shows up light of the way light can reflect off of it. Also I seem to remember Hoffman offering the full length video for sale to viewers. No he's not in it to make a buck lol!

I'm glad that you like the video. As I recall, he created that Bigfoot video as part of/to promote a mockumentary about finding scientific evidence for Santa Claus. I suspect that the full length video you're referring to is his Santa movie and not the Bigfoot video (but I'd imagine the Bigfoot clip would be included). You could be right about the fur-covered nature of the hand; it'd be interesting to see if anyone could contact him and get him to show us/describe the costume.

As Bill Munn's costume assesments continue and Dfoot continues to dig up evidence it looks to me more and more that Patterson and his cowboys didn't mastermind this thing.

That depends on what you mean by "mastermind." If you mean that in a "Patterson and Co. didn't build the suit" sense, that's definitely a possibility. However, you'd be forgetting that someone in Hollywood would need a guideline of what Patterson wanted the suit to look like. In my opinion, Patterson would be the "mastermind" in that scenario since he'd most likely be providing the design. On the other hand, it's also possible that certain aspects of a Patty costume could've been due to the nature of the construction/materials and not due to the design submitted to them. After all, concept art for a costume doesn't always look exactly like the end product.

sgoodman72 said:
Also this is the first time I've noticed it, but I see a large thumb on Patty's hand that I've circled, and even what would appear to be the thumb-nail. I also see her other fingers curled underneath into a semi-clenched position. Any other viewpoints?

I recall this point being brought up earlier here, with it being found that the "thumb" was really background debris. Page 216 of this thread seems to touch on this. Hopefully, mangler can repost his missing pictures from that and/or others can pipe in on the matter.

Similarly, here's a video of a log/stick floating in Lake Champlain. Personally, I think that the poor video quality, combined with the bobbing waves and dark waves in the background blending in with the branch sticking out of the log is what's creating the illusion of the "head" moving.

RayG said:
Not sure if this is the problem or not, but next time you open a thread there, click on 'Options' in the upper right (on the same line as the thread title), then, under 'Display Modes', ensure you have 'Standard' selected.

Thanks, I'll give that a try.

Oh, and I noticed something interesting in a .gif by SweatyYeti on page 216. During the brief view of Patty (as opposed to close-ups of a hand), one might get the impression that the view of Patty's side and and arm are actually two legs and a hunched-over back. I suspect this is what MK Davis was talking about when he claimed to have found a scene when Patty briefly dropped down on all fours.
 
Yes, it looks good, but is it representative of the original film?

Is it the color correction and enhancement that makes them look good?

What is left of the original film detail?

Consider that the original master is not available and the absoloute best still around is the first generation copy of the master in Patricia Patterson's custody. What we're seeing in the enhancment of a second generation copy just may be close to the master itself. As good as the Patterson copy almost certanily. In any event the other photo below the enhanced shows the hand to good effect too. Its also fairly easy to see the way the fur is laying on the thigh. I'd really like to know the position of the thumb. If its non opposable or semi opposable then there was real talent at work. Too bad MK didn't do up this thing in color.
 
William with any luck you'll have Cibachromes of the left palm after frame 352 as Patty is partially eclipsed by the trees. I've added an arrow that is just at the tip of the fingers. I'm not sure if you're seeing the light inside of the hand which shows as the greyish blue area.



acibachrometuarrow.jpg
 
Last edited:
Consider that the original master is not available and the absoloute best still around is the first generation copy of the master in Patricia Patterson's custody.

Don't bet money on it. It is possible that Green and/or the Dahinden brothers are holding PGF copies that are superior to what Pat Patterson has.

I'd really like to know the position of the thumb.

Join the club. If the thumbs are there to be seen at all, they're stubby.

Too bad MK didn't do up this thing in color.

Yeah right. Then he would tell us that Patty is wearing a gold and benitoite ring.

William with any luck you'll have Cibachromes of the left palm after frame 352 as Patty is partially eclipsed by the trees.

You are talking about this one. I doubt that there is a DC of that still frame. Bruce Bonney made the Cibachromes for Rene Dahinden in 1978. I'm pretty sure they chose specifically important "classic" frames. The "catcher's mitt among the trees" was probably not one of them. Maybe LTC can grab some frames from WGH so we can get a look-see at that left hand before she hits the trees.
 
Last edited:
Crow, I'm certain that it's already been shown that it's not a thumb. I remember discussons of it a while back.

There was another clip where it was claimed that Patty opened and closed her hand. That was also shown to be noise, iirc.
 
William with any luck you'll have Cibachromes of the left palm after frame 352 as Patty is partially eclipsed by the trees. I've added an arrow that is just at the tip of the fingers. I'm not sure if you're seeing the light inside of the hand which shows as the greyish blue area.

Matches the face.
 
Last edited:
Crow, I'm certain that it's already been shown that it's not a thumb. I remember discussons of it a while back.

There was another clip where it was claimed that Patty opened and closed her hand. That was also shown to be noise, iirc.

I'd like to see an explanation of how the thumb is just noise. I guess I don't understand the point of contention around the thumb in general, it's not as if that would either validate or invalidate the legitimacy of the film as a whole. Now if you could see a joint and it appeared to be odd or there was some other strange feature to it, then that's a different story.

We've discussed the clip of the hand opening and closing multiple times, still don't understand how that is noise either. But once again, it neither proves the film real or hoax..
 
Last edited:
This film is the gift that just keeps on giving. That Roger was generous to a fault in that he he left us with untold hours of entertainment, wonder and I can't imagine how many barroom fist fights. And now just when I thought it was safe to not think about his master work any more this evening sgoodman72 draws attention that the unfurred parts of the face match the color of the unfurred skin of the hand. Excellent observation!
 
Well, you have things in the background and the foreground and they occasionally merge and blend with the subject due to the poor film quality and lack of resolution. They can look like all sorts of things in stills. Usually when you view the area in question in an animation, you can then distinguish that the protrusion or whatever is not really part of Patty.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom