autism-vaccine link?

Ivor, I didn't need a definition of a "club". I needed your definition of who you were including in the imagined conspiracy you expressed in the following sentence, "You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat"

Who said anything about a conspiracy? Do you think people behave differently when operating from a group perspective opposed to an individual one? I do.

To answer your question, I think the ACIP could be considered a sub-group within the larger group of medical professionals.
 
Who said anything about a conspiracy? Do you think people behave differently when operating from a group perspective opposed to an individual one? I do.

To answer your question, I think the ACIP could be considered a sub-group within the larger group of medical professionals.
It never ceases to amaze me how people can maintain false beliefs by simply flitting from one concept to another when that concept is challenged.

Let's backtrack here, Ivor. Here is the exchange:

Linda: "Bias alone won't do it unless we all have the exact same biases."

Ivor: "You do share many of the same biases and you club together when you perceive an outside threat. All individuals who are members of a group do.

ETA: How often do you see one doctor criticizing another in public? Most professional organizations would consider this sort of behaviour as "bringing the profession into disrepute".

Your rationale for why the ACIP and any vaccine medical recommendations did not have effective oversight was due to these shared biases. I ask you, who is in this homogeneous group with shared biases? Because I think that is incredibly short sighted. There are waaaay too many scientists involved in vaccine research and medical providers who take the time to look at the research for there to be any homogeneous group with shared biases as you assert.

So I ask you again, who is this homogeneous group with shared biases that you are referring to? Define the parameters for inclusion in this group and explain how within the entire medical profession there are only these clones?
 
Last edited:
<snip>

So I ask you again, who is this homogeneous group with shared biases that you are referring to?

I did not say medical professionals were a homogeneous group, just that they share a significant set of common values (or biases).

Define the parameters for inclusion in this group and explain how within the entire medical profession there are only these clones?

The first step in the filtering process would be being accepted into medical school by passing a clinical aptitude test and an interview. Next would be actually graduating from medical school. Then you have the initiation rite of being made* to work ridiculously long hours for a few years. Finally, you have the hierarchy of the medical system to keep subordinate members of the group in check and teach them how to behave if they want to progress within it.

*This is being challenged in Europe by the working time directive, so no doubt the medical profession will have to think up some other ritual to indoctrinate new members of the group.
 
I did not say medical professionals were a homogeneous group, just that they share a significant set of common values (or biases).



The first step in the filtering process would be being accepted into medical school by passing a clinical aptitude test and an interview. Next would be actually graduating from medical school. Then you have the initiation rite of being made* to work ridiculously long hours for a few years. Finally, you have the hierarchy of the medical system to keep subordinate members of the group in check and teach them how to behave if they want to progress within it.

*This is being challenged in Europe by the working time directive, so no doubt the medical profession will have to think up some other ritual to indoctrinate new members of the group.
I didn't go to medical school. I went to nursing school, as did a few thousand other advanced practice nurses. All biologists didn't go to medical school. All microbiologists and virologists didn't go to med school. Not all med schools in all countries are the same. Not all doctors who did go to medical school have the same biases.

Your have an imaginary view of health care researchers and providers that is invalid.
 
I didn't go to medical school. I went to nursing school, as did a few thousand other advanced practice nurses. All biologists didn't go to medical school. All microbiologists and virologists didn't go to med school. Not all med schools in all countries are the same. Not all doctors who did go to medical school have the same biases.

Your have an imaginary view of health care researchers and providers that is invalid.

Hmmm. Let's have a look at which group dominates the ACIP:

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/recs/acip/members.htm

I count ten MDs, one JD (he must be a member at the same tennis club) and one NP (presumably there to clean up any mess, provide sexual favours to the doctors and make the coffee).

The vast majority of the other names on that page have MD tagged on the end of them too.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm. Let's have a look at which group dominates the ACIP:

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/recs/acip/members.htm

I count ten MDs, one JD (he must be a member at the same tennis club) and one NP (presumably there to clean up any mess, provide sexual favours to the doctors and make the coffee).

The vast majority of the other names on that page have MD tagged on the end of them too.

Beth distrusts them because they are doctors who may have "financial ties" to industry.
Seems like you distrust them just because they are doctors.

ETA:
Potential conflict of interest: Author of the above post has MD after his name.
 
Last edited:
Beth distrusts them because they are doctors who may have "financial ties" to industry.
Seems like you distrust them just because they are doctors.

ETA:
Potential conflict of interest: Author of the above post has MD after his name.

Not 'distrust', just expect their recommendations to be influenced by the values doctors share having gone through a filtering process of medical school and post-graduate training to become doctors.
 
Hmmm. Let's have a look at which group dominates the ACIP:

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/recs/acip/members.htm

I count ten MDs, one JD (he must be a member at the same tennis club) and one NP (presumably there to clean up any mess, provide sexual favours to the doctors and make the coffee).

The vast majority of the other names on that page have MD tagged on the end of them too.
Round and round the mulberry bush,
skeptigirl chased the weasel.....

We know who is on the ACIP Ivor. We are talking about the entire medical community of providers and researchers who have been surprisingly :rolleyes: silent in noticing much is wrong with the ACIP conclusions.
 
Last edited:
Not 'distrust', just expect their recommendations to be influenced by the values doctors share having gone through a filtering process of medical school and post-graduate training to become doctors.
God that must be an amazing brain washing process. :rolleyes:

I didn't go to med school Ivor. How did I become a clone?
 
OK, let's see, by Ivor's version of reality going through med school makes you ..... wait for it....










-

Biased toward the idea of practicing medicine.
 
BTW, regarding that influenza vaccine recommendation, Deetee,

Staph-caused pneumonia more common: CDC
A team led by the CDC's Dr. Alexander Kallen identified 53 children, average age 8-1/2, with pneumonia caused by this bacterium -- more than they expected -- at the three hospitals over seven months during the 2006-2007 flu season. Of these, 22 involved MRSA, the CDC said.

Of six children who died, three had pneumonia involving MRSA, the CDC said. Death occurred an average of 13 days after the onset of symptoms.....

The findings were presented at an infectious diseases conference in Atlanta.
MRSA USA300 is more frequently turning up, more frequently causing invasive disease, and more frequently occurring secondary to influenza.
 
Round and round the mulberry bush,
skeptigirl chased the weasel.....

We know who is on the ACIP Ivor. We are talking about the entire medical community of providers and researchers who have been surprisingly silent in noticing much is wrong with the ACIP conclusions.

Doesn't that make my point for me?

:)
 
God that must be an amazing brain washing process. :rolleyes:

It's both selection bias and "brain washing", also known as education and experience.

I didn't go to med school Ivor. How did I become a clone?

Osmosis?

Clone is your word, not mine, BTW.

Wouldn't you find it more amazing if people who train and often work closely together did *not* have a set of common values/biases?
 
So education and experience are really a disadvantage in evaluating a source?

And I don't know where you work, but I consider myself quite unique in the work settings I practice in.
 
Last edited:
I think it would be an interesting experiment to let groups of experts from different fields review the same evidence and see if they reach the same conclusion.

It's just as well we are generally not as unique as we like to think we are. EBM would be a lot less useful if individual responses to treatment could not be inferred from studies of populations.

That's not to say we do not have lots of idiosyncratic features, just we also tend to share lots of things in common with groups we are members of.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom