FWIW, here are some comments from trying to read more about this topic. They aren't a complete reaction, and they aren't in very readable form, just notes.
(
I added the quote code in response to skeptigirl's post.)
another quote from the paper:
This shift to a predominantly plant-based diet has resulted in
the dramatic evolution of intestinal morphology. Morphological
analysis of preserved specimens shows the presence of cecal
valves (Fig. 4) in all individuals, including a hatchling (26.4-mm
snout-vent length, umbilical scar present) and a very young
juvenile (33.11-mm snout-vent length) examined from Pod Mrc
ˇaru. These valves are similar in overall appearance and structure
to those found in herbivorous lacertid, agamid, and iguanid
lizards (13, 14) and are not found in other populations of P. sicula
(13) or in P. melisellensis. Cecal valves slow down food passage
and provide for fermenting chambers, allowing commensal
microorganisms to convert cellulose to volatile fatty acids (15,
16). Indeed, in the lizards from Pod Mrcˇaru, nematodes were
common in the hindgut but absent from individuals from Pod
Kopisˇte. The fact that 1% of all currently known species of
squamates have cecal valves (13, 14) illustrates the unusual
nature of these structures in this population. The evolution of
these structures has likely gone hand in hand with a novel
association between P. sicula on Pod Mrcˇaru and a set of
microorganisms assuring the digestion of cellulose as is suggested
by the presence of nematodes in the hindgut of individuals
from Pod Mrcˇaru.
It looks from their chart like the population of lizards on the other island (from which the lizards came initially) ate maybe 8% of plant matter. I don't know what that might mean - does it suggest that there is a baseline tendency for the lizards to eat plant matter that could be increased through natural selection?
There's another paper they cited which looked at some South American lizards, saying that herbivory had evolved a number of times in those lizards. I didn't read that paper. It would be interesting to know what kinds of anatomical or genetic changes go along with that kind of dietary change in other lizards.
I hope they can look at genetic changes in these lizards.
I predict Ken Ham etc. would just respond that they're STILL LIZARDS.
To really understand the issue, I'd want to know a lot more about normal variation in the different lizard species and populations.
There was another species of lizard on the island, Podarcis melisellensis, that disappeared during the 36 years. Is there any chance the two species could have hybridized? The mtDNA of the sampled lizards on the island all matched the P. sicula species, but I don't think that in itself rules out inbreeding initially.
(looking at another paper by Gorman from '75, it sounds like hybridization might be possible).
The Podarcis melisellensis lizard that was initially on the island, but disappeared, was also an insect eater. I wonder why it disappeared from that island. Was there a change in insect populations on the island (or not) during that time? Was it out-competed by the P. sicura? Before , during, or after the P. sicura adapted to eating more plant material?
This island doesn't sound that different from other habitats where P. sicura is found in that area. The new island looks like it's about 5 km from the previous habitat. In what ways was this a novel environment?
I looked at a paper from these researchers about the Podarcis melisellensis lizard species that has disappeared from that island during the 36 years. This study was based on another island nearby, Lastovo Island. There were three color morphs in the males, and they listed the dimensions of their heads. I've tried to list parts of the tables from the two papers to show the kind of variation in the P. sicula lizards after being put on the island, and the differences in head sizes of the other lizard species (measured on a different location). It seemed like it might help to see what the actual size differences were and what size differences you might see in a single species with different variations.
For comparison, here's the variation between head measurements from the current lizards Podarcis
sicula on the island and the Podarcis sicula lizards on the island from which the original pairs were taken (means +/- SD):
(from the paper referenced in my previous post, the one being discusssed in this topic). So there's an increase in the transplanted lizards, but it is not a huge change. How does it compare to variation in different populations of the lizard on other islands?
Pod Kopište (original island) Pod Mraru (new island)
Male Female *** Male Female
SVL, mm ( snout-vent length) M=63.06 +/- 4.68 F=56.80 +/- 5.30 ***M=69.54 +/- 2.86 F=64.08 +/- 2.93
Mass, g M=5.07 +/- 1.37 F=3.36 +/- 1.16 ***M=6.38 +/- 1.42 F=4.72 +/- 1.24
Head length, mm M=14.67 +/- 1.08 F=12.25 +/- 0.84 *** M=16.33 +/- 0.77 F=13.75 +/- 0.64
Head width, mm M=8.09 +/- 0.67 F=6.55 +/- 0.46 ***M=9.13 +/- 0.42 F=7.51 +/- 0.38
Head height, mm M=6.29 +/- 0.59 F=5.12 +/- 0.46 ***M=7.35 +/- 0.43 F=5.95 +/- 0.38
Lower jaw length, mm M=15.70 +/- 1.23 F=12.80 +/- 0.94 ***M=17.45 +/- 0.72 F=14.44 +/- 0.71
---------------------------------------------------
Variation between three color morphs of males of the species Podarcis melisellensis (the species no longer found on the Pod Mraru island in the above paper. This study was done on lizards on Lastovo Island, which looks like it's another 5 km away on amap, if I'm seeing the right island.):
Trait: White *** Yellow *** Orange
x SE n x SE N x SE n
SVL (mm) W=63.64 0.27 187 ***Y=63.02 0.46 78 ***O=64.67 0.23 148
Mass (g) W=5.41 0.21 69 ***Y=4.69 0.31 23 ***O=5.31 0.16 66
Head length (mm) W=14.84 0.07 168 *** Y=14.60 0.12 61 *** O=15.13 0.05 133
Head width (mm) W=8.75 0.07 97 8*** Y=8.43 0.12 45 *** O=9.04 0.07 91
Head height (mm) W=6.99 0.06 97 *** Y=6.74 0.09 45 *** O=7.20 0.05 91
Lower jaw length (mm) W=15.80 0.09 97 *** Y=15.48 0.15 45 *** O=16.19 0.07 91
From:
Morphology, performance, behavior and ecology of three color
morphs in males of the lizard Podarcis melisellensis
Katleen Huyghe,1,* Bieke Vanhooydonck,* Anthony Herrel,* Zoran Tadic´,†
and Raoul Van Damme†
Integrative and Comparative Biology, volume 47, number 2, pp. 211–220
http://webh01.ua.ac.be/funmorph/publications/Huyghe%20et%20al%202007%20ICB.pdf