The atheists favorite bible verses

I recently saw the film, The God Who Wasn't There. That guy made the point that only the fundamentalist Christians have the guts to profess what their Bible actually says.

I wouldn't go that far, but I do think liberal Christians have a basic problem with their professions of faith especially in regard to the Bible. At the very least, they have to admit that even though they see the Bible as a collection of documents written by fallible humans in different ages, the people who preserved and handed them down to them didn't see it that way.

It's a big issue, and maybe only tangential to whatever the topic of this thread is, but here's a pretty decent essay on it.
 
Matthew 5:19 said:
19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.

It seems the people Jesus is talking to are people who teach the law and commandments. And all he's saying is a) it doesn't matter how small of a commandment you break don't teach others to break it too and b) if you do teach - make sure you are practicing what you preach.
That's all, huh? In that case, it shouldn't matter how large of a commandment you break, as long as you don't teach others to break it too. For that matter, if you practice without teaching, you'll still get the table by the pay phone at the heavenly banquet.

How are some of you going from that and coming to the conclusion that all Christians have to follow all the laws?
If we're going to be pedantic here, he isn't addressing Christians at all, he's addressing Jews.

It seems like your interpretation hinges on the appearance of the word "and" rather than the word "or". I read it as "Whoever breaks the least of these laws, and whoever teaches others to break the least of these laws..." but if you're willing to bet your eternal soul on your rationalization...
 
There's plenty of things in the Bible that most christians ignore, what's your point?

Which, by the way, is our point. And the OP's observation that "most Christians don't go around quoting this or that obscure and uncomfortable passage", is also exactly the point. Face what your religion believes is Truth, and what the "kind, loving, fatherly" god you worship actually did in the past.
 
I recently saw the film, The God Who Wasn't There. That guy made the point that only the fundamentalist Christians have the guts to profess what their Bible actually says.

I wouldn't go that far, but I do think liberal Christians have a basic problem with their professions of faith especially in regard to the Bible. At the very least, they have to admit that even though they see the Bible as a collection of documents written by fallible humans in different ages, the people who preserved and handed them down to them didn't see it that way.
Even fundamentalists don't really have the guts to stone children for being disrespectful, which is why some of them get this doublethink going, interpreting Jesus' claim that he has come to fulfill the law as "I follow the law so you don't have to." I don't think there is any account of Jesus stoning children either, so even that claim is suspect.

I'm all for Christians "picking and choosing," because if anyone let the bible be a literal prescription for life, he'd be one sociopathic mama. My impatience is with those who refuse to acknowledge that this is what they're doing, and instead claim that the bible is the perfect plan for moral living. Most who do this are only interested in pointing fingers at behaviors they can't rationally argue against, but wish to suppress anyway. "Bible tells me so" is the only argument they have to pull from their arsenal. At that point, "Bible tells you this too" gets pulled from mine.

The fact is, anyone who isn't a sociopath has a functioning conscience which provides a workable (if not always perfect) guide for behavior. We all pick and choose, and open discussion provides a better yardstick than biblical dogma for measuring right and wrong.
 
Question from an ignorant bystander:

Did Jesus himself actually break the laws? I seem to recall he worked on the Sabbath, but I believe Jews allow that under certain circumstances. So was he a practicing Jew, or was he not?

Seems to me what he did should clarify what he said.
 
I have listed some good texts above. I recommend you take some time to investigate Christianity's historical origins and the very specifically Jewish message of Jesus, rather than simply demanding answers from largely anonymous contributors to a discussion forum.

I'm not demanding anything - but I am asking people who have brought these verse up here on this forum how they are coming to the conclusion and asking them for some Christians writings on it.

Seems like if people bring up those verses HERE in this forum and then say they know how to interpret them it's appropriate for me to ask them how HERE.
 
Last edited:
Out of curiosity at the time claimed for Christ's preaching what was the law that he was referring to? How close was it to what was codified into what we see in the OT today?
 
Actually Jesus was talking to the crowd of people who had assembled on a hillside. This was part of the famous Sermon on the Mount.

Well if it's only applicable to the people he physically spoke to ...

Actually - he spoke to the crowd of people ABOUT people who teach. How do I know this - because he uses the word TEACH.

Back to the passage in question:
You think Jesus was saying it's OK to break any of the commandments as long as you don't teach others to break them? Really? You actually think that's what the passage means?

I didn't use the word OK anywhere.

The whole context of the passage points to the obvious meaning. "I come not to abolish the law or the prophets" somehow turns into something like, "in fact, you don't have to follow all those little commandments as long as you don't teach others to do what you're doing".

If you're not going to read what I wrote then how can we go on with this conversation?
 
Because that is what he said. He strengthened one or two and altered another couple, but it seems pretty clear that is what he meant - the law stays in force until all is accomplished.

Where is he saying "stays in force"?
How do Prophets "stay in force"?
Until what "all is accomplished?"

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Where is he saying "stays in force"?
How do Prophets "stay in force"?
Until what "all is accomplished?"

Thanks.

According to the quoted verses, Jesus said: "I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished".

What does this mean, if not that the "Law" will stay in force until heaven and earth disappear?
 
Can you explain what it means to fulfill a law? I can understand fulfilling a prophecy or an obligation, but the idea that you can fulfill a law is odd, to say the least.

My understanding of the statement, and I'm certainly not a Biblical scholar, is that the laws were needed to bring the people to a certain point, and that Jesus was that point. <shrug>

Michael C said:
What does this mean, if not that the "Law" will stay in force until heaven and earth disappear?

Jesus gives an either/or statement. Either the law will stay in place or they will be fulfilled. Jesus claims to have done the latter, thus the law is no longer in need of being enforced. He then supplies new laws that extend some of the old ones . . . which becomes problematical in deciphering his intent, but there it is.
 
Last edited:
According to the quoted verses, Jesus said: "I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished".
Come to think of it, why are there two "until"s in that passage?

Isn't that like "Until the stars fall from the sky, we guarantee Native Americans will have the right to live on this land, until we kick them off of it."?

I'm Jesus "Doubletalk" Christ, and I approve this message.
 
My understanding of the statement, and I'm certainly not a Biblical scholar, is that the laws were needed to bring the people to a certain point, and that Jesus was that point. <shrug>



Jesus gives an either/or statement. Either the law will stay in place or they will be fulfilled. Jesus claims to have done the latter, thus the law is no longer in need of being enforced. He then supplies new laws that extend some of the old ones . . . which becomes problematical in deciphering his intent, but there it is.

Here is the verse Matthew 5:17 in Greek.

http://scripturetext.com/matthew/5-17.htm

Here is the greek word which in some translations is fulfil (others use the word complete):
http://www.studylight.org/lex/grk/view.cgi?number=4137

Transliterated: Pleroo

Here's the definitions:
Definition
1. to make full, to fill up, i.e. to fill to the full
a. to cause to abound, to furnish or supply liberally
1.I abound, I am liberally supplied
2. to render full, i.e. to complete
a. to fill to the top: so that nothing shall be wanting to full measure, fill to the brim
b. to consummate: a number
1. to make complete in every particular, to render perfect
2. to carry through to the end, to accomplish, carry out, (some undertaking)
c. to carry into effect, bring to realisation, realise
of matters of duty:
1. to perform, execute
2. of sayings, promises, prophecies, to bring to pass, ratify, accomplish
3. to fulfil, i.e. to cause God's will (as made known in the law) to be obeyed as it should be, and God's promises (given through the prophets) to receive fulfilment
 
Last edited:
I recently saw the film, The God Who Wasn't There. That guy made the point that only the fundamentalist Christians have the guts to profess what their Bible actually says.
...
.
Make that "some" fundamentalist Christians... I know a few who are as "sinful" in dealings with others as anyone.
Count-your-fingers-after-shaking-their-hand types.
But they are noisy about their faith, while not practicing it.
 
Where is he saying "stays in force"?
How do Prophets "stay in force"?
Until what "all is accomplished?"

Thanks.


'Until all is accomplished' is an apocalyptic reference. Until the consummation of history is accomplished, after the world has passed through a final period of tribulation, with the coming of the Kingdom of God - the Kingdom of God on earth, spoken of in the 'Lord's Prayer'.

"I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished."

Also in this passage we see the early Christian belief that when the Kingdom of God comes (which was seen to be an imminent 'event'), the earth will be made anew. We also see this in Revelation, where we read of the coming of a new heaven and a new earth.
Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth; for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more.
Revelation 21:1

The point of Matthew's Jesus seems to be that until this apocalyptic transformation occurs, the Law remains fully binding. Some scholars have suggested that Matthew placed these words on Jesus' lips specifically to respond to others in the early Christian communities (particularly followers of Paul's brand, and perhaps antinomian believers who went further than Paul) who were proclaiming the opposite, i.e. the notion that Jesus had abolished the Law. Historically speaking, whether Jesus actually spoke these words or not, they are fully consistent with the Jewish apocalyptic message running through much of the NT, and the idea that Jesus, who appears every bit a Jew, would advocate the abrogation of the Law seems highly unlikely. Regardless, this passage is clear in its meaning, no matter what Christians might want it to mean.
 
Here is the verse Matthew 5:17 in Greek.
[snip]

Ok. So does that confirm my understanding or deny it?

Which, by the way, is our point. And the OP's observation that "most Christians don't go around quoting this or that obscure and uncomfortable passage", is also exactly the point. Face what your religion believes is Truth, and what the "kind, loving, fatherly" god you worship actually did in the past.

And then what? I mean, if I'm a theist and I decide, for instance, to become Mormon, acknowledging that the God of the Old Testament was a mean and jealous bastard, what kind of regard will you hold me in? Where will that put me on the scale of "blind-fundies" and "enlightened atheists"? What advice would you give me in regards to the practice of my faith?
 
Last edited:
It seems to me to confirm it.
He's the fullfillment, the completion of all it (the Law and the Prophets) points to.

Again...

I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear...

'Heaven' and earth haven't disappeared. Therefore your interpretation fails. The Law remains valid for the followers of Jesus until the apocalyptic transformation that was expected to be coming soon; the same transformation referred to in Revelation, the same transformation which, as it didn't happen in Jesus' lifetime, or even shortly afterwards, was then projected to be coming when Jesus 'returns', which, of course, was due to happen in or around the author's lifetime:

The revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave him to show his servants what must soon take place
Revelation 1:1
The one who testifies to these things says, ‘Surely I am coming soon.
Revelation 22:20


You may want Jesus in Matthew to be somehow relevant to the lives of modern Christians, but the passages under discussion show quite the opposite. The author, and Jesus himself, would no doubt be astounded to discover that 2,000 years on, the Kingdom of God still hasn't arrived. They'd probably also be pretty astounded to find out that illness is actually caused by germs and not demons... The reality is that not a single word of the Bible was written for people living in 2008, and not a single word has any relevance to us today. The great mistake of Christians, such as ACS, is the belief that it's actually important to know whether or not Jesus advocated ending the observance of the Law in terms of how one should live one's life today. It's also clear how much ACS needs that passage to confirm his personal beliefs. He doesn't want to follow the Jewish Law, but he wants to hang on to Jesus - solution: biblical passages don't really mean what the author manifestly intended them to say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom