The atheists favorite bible verses

YES or NO?
Already answered--repeatedly. Your question is purposely ambiguous, and I've answered both versions.

According to me, NO. According to the passage in Matthew you cited, YES.

So it's your turn still.

YES or NO--are Christians supposed to obey every last bit of the New Testament teaching?

(See, I can repeat the same question and act like it's a discussion as well.)
 
There's nothing ambiguous about the phrase "supposed to".
Your turn then.

YES or NO--are Christians supposed to obey every bit of the New Testament teachings?

ETA: FWIW the ambiguity in "supposed to" is that it's a passive voice construction with no agent. Supposed by whom? By me, NO. By the author of Matthew, YES. (This makes at least 10 times your question has been answered in a very consistent way. It's more like 20 times that this position has been spelled out to you.)
 
Last edited:
Already answered--repeatedly. Your question is purposely ambiguous, and I've answered both versions.

According to me, NO. According to the passage in Matthew you cited, YES.

So it's your turn still.

YES or NO--are Christians supposed to obey every last bit of the New Testament teaching?

(See, I can repeat the same question and act like it's a discussion as well.)

Maybe the question was worded wrong.

How about this:
When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
 
Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
No.

They're also not supposed to follow new testament laws.

They're supposed to do what's right. Like everyone who is not a sociopath, they are capable of determining this for themselves, without requiring biblical authority. The fact that they reject so much of what is written in the bible and do so much that is not written there, demonstrates this.
 
Last edited:
So - YES or NO. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?
According to the Bible? Yes. According to me, keeping in mind that I know some of the disgusting rules therein? Absolutely not. You're being inconsistent when you pick and choose, but please, please be. It's better by far than you stoning adulterers and homosexuals.
 
And I never said they were did I?

Then you shouldn't have brought them up about quotes from other posters.




The OP doesn't answer the question I asked:

So - YES or NO. I presume you will say that you still will not provide the evidence that enables you to make this claim?

From the OP:
A Christian Sceptic said:
But I have come across atheists using these verses alot here. (And no - Darat - I won't post a link to all the examples in the forum so don't bother asking me to prove that statement)


Why ask me?
You're in this thread and that's what this thread is about.
 
Maybe the question was worded wrong.

How about this:
When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?
Quit playing stupid.

Already answered.

On this page alone, here are some of the answers that are all saying the same thing:
I think others have made it perfectly clear that we're arguing about what the Bible says, not if we want you to follow its teachings or not.

If you want to know what I think people should do, here's my personal stance:

Christians shouldn't follow Old Testament Laws. Jews shouldn't follow Old Testament laws. Nobody should follow Old Testament laws. The New Testament does say that people should follow Old Testament laws, so I don't agree with it.

If you are asking if I personally want Christians to follow the commandments a fictional bronze-age God then of course not. And I would very much appreciate if they would quit trying to foist Leviticus style values onto the rest of us. Very much.
<snip>

If, on the other hand, you are asking if I think the intention of Matthew 5 is to reaffirm the authority of the Mosaic law over Christians (with a handful of variations), then I have already answered, yes, I think that is the intention of those words. I am not sure why you need to ask again.

I suspect that none of us here (none of us that you quoted) advocate anyone following the Old Testament laws. What we have said is that the passage that includes the purported words of your Lord and God incarnate says that you should.

Do you understand the difference?

NO: I don't think anyone should follow all the Old Testament Laws.

YES: I think the passage in Matthew that you cited does say that you should follow every last one of the Old Testament Law.

According to the New Testament, YES.

According to me, you shouldn't follow the New Testament.



I'm not telling any Christian to obey O.T. laws. The passage in Matthew is saying that you should obey every last commandment of the old law.

So your question has been answered repeatedly (on this page alone).

You haven't addressed any of the questions I've asked. In particular this one:

YES or NO--are Christians supposed to obey every last bit of New Testament teaching?
 
Could someone clarify how telling a Christian that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws is not saying Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

Let's keep this simple:
Give me a Yes or No - are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws?

I don't care whether they follow the OT laws or not, and that was never the point. The bible is a ridiculous hodge-podge of myths and I have a poor opinion of anyone who gets any kind of guidance from it. My point is that if you use the bible as justification for your actions, you can't ignore the rest of it without being a hypocrite. If you are a believer that claims homosexuality is wrong because the bible says so, and you believe the bible is the word of god, I have no quarrel with you as long as you don't try to force your beliefs on others. What I have a problem with is people trying to restrict the behavior of others on the authority of the bible, while claiming that other parts of the bible don't apply because "Jesus fulfilled the law". Nowhere in the bible do I see a list of which OT laws are nullified and which remain in force, except in the verse in question where it clearly says not one bit of the law will change as long as heaven and Earth exist.
 
Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws? YES or NO?
I asked you to clarify the question.

Why did you simply repeat the question without the requested clarification? That is very peculiar.

Are they supposed to, according to whom?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testment laws according to the words of Jesus reported in Matthew 5?

Yes.

Clearly.

As I have already said.

He is clearly supposed to be the Redeemer prophesied in Isaiah. And clearly that prophecy cannot be fulfilled until Heaven and Earth have passed away, as his audience would have understood.
 
Maybe the question was worded wrong.

Hallelujah!

How about this:
When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

It's closer but still not correct, try this version:

When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian that according the Bible they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws?
 
How about this:
When you post or show or argue those verses are you telling a Christian they are supposed to be following the Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

Still ambiguous. Here's what we're saying when we argue that verse: we're pointing out that the Bible commands Christians to obey the Old Testament, and they're being hypocritical if they ignore the OT. Of course, we don't think they should obey what's in the Bible, but should use their own moral sense.

You can interpret that as a YES or NO depending on what question you were asking. It was ambiguous.
 
Then you shouldn't have brought them up about quotes from other posters.

I didn't.

From the OP:

Nope that still has not answered my question.

So - YES or NO. I presume you will say that you still will not provide the evidence that enables you to make this claim?



You're in this thread and that's what this thread is about.

Not according the opening post it isn't....


....Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them......
 
You can read through the thread if it matters to you that much.

I take it an answer that would have satisfied you in regards to these questions:

So - YES or NO. Are Christians supposed to follow the Old Testament Laws?

So - is that a YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament laws? YES or NO?

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

There's nothing ambiguous about the phrase "supposed to".

Are Christians supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

Was "You can read through the thread if it matters to you that much."

So the "YES or NO?" part was a bit of a red herring?
 
How about we chose something even less vague that the christians love to ignore:

Matt 6:5-6
"And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men. I tell you the truth, they have received their reward in full. But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.

I'd like to see how christians can justify their insistance on pubic prayer given this.

I know it's a very familiar passage, but that's because it's so blatently unambiguous.

when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father
 
I take it an answer that would have satisfied you in regards to these questions:

Was "You can read through the thread if it matters to you that much."

So the "YES or NO?" part was a bit of a red herring?

Yeah - not sure what you're saying. That was to Lothian.
 
How about we chose something even less vague that the christians love to ignore:

Matt 6:5-6


I'd like to see how christians can justify their insistance on pubic prayer given this.

I know it's a very familiar passage, but that's because it's so blatently unambiguous.

when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father

How about you start a thread and see what they say then.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom