The atheists favorite bible verses

How about you start a thread and see what they say then.

Hey, you are the one who titled the thread "The atheist favorite bible verses"

(emph added)

So you aren't willing to talk about verses? Just one you pick?

Of course, given how you have shown yourself to be a sleazy piece of turd in this thread, if I did start a thread I wouldn't want to hear what you have to say.
 
Sure, but if the parents are mass-murdering nut jobs it might raise certain questions as to the soundness of the moral advice they would pass on.

What about if the the just thought a book advocating and honoring such mass-murdering nut jobs was the work of an omniscient omnibenovolent being?

What if they told their kids to believe in this being and his incarnate son (who was really him) or they could be punished forever?
 
You can read through the thread if it matters to you that much.
I just want to be happy and happy is the man that findeth wisdom, and the man that getteth understanding. (Proverbs 3:13) or did Jesus's arrival mean that is no longer relevant?

I want to getteth an understanding whether Christians should to follow all some or none of the rules in the old testament. All, some or none? A one word answer will do.
 
I just want to be happy and happy is the man that findeth wisdom, and the man that getteth understanding. (Proverbs 3:13) or did Jesus's arrival mean that is no longer relevant?

I want to getteth an understanding whether Christians should to follow all some or none of the rules in the old testament. All, some or none? A one word answer will do.

Start a thread if you're asking what Christians think. If you want to know what atheists think - hang out in this thread - hopefully they'll answer with a one word answer.
 
No, Robin thinks the words of Jesus reported in Matt indicate that Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws.

However, your sleazy attempt to twist it is noted.

OK. So when Robin (or anyone) tells a Christian they're supposed to follow Old Testament Laws because Matthew says so is Robin telling Christians they're supposed to follow Old Testament Laws? YES or NO?

And if Robin (or anyone) doesn't think or even want Christians to, why the hell (irony!) are they telling them too?
 
Last edited:
I'm saying your behaviour in this thread regarding the "yes or no" requirement is hypocritical in light of your response to Lothian.

Nope. I'm not making a claim about a verse and telling him that he needs to believe it. He can believe whatever he wants.

But atheists using Matthew are making a claim as noted in the OP and argued through this thread - only now they appear to be saying, "but we don't really mean it."
 
Last edited:
Nope. I'm not making a claim about a verse and telling him that he needs to believe it.


...snip...

Neither has Lothian made a claim about a verse and told you you need to believe it. So now we've cleared up you misunderstanding will you now answer his question? Or will you continue to act in a hypocritical manner?


(Mind you no one at all has told you that you need to believe any verse.)


He can believe whatever he wants.

I am fairly confident that he will say the same to you (caveat excluding certain metaphysical positions regarding ducks). As do I and I bet most people in this thread will say the same to you. Believe what you want.

But atheists using Matthew are making a claim as noted in the OP and argued through this thread - only now they appear to be saying, but we don't really mean it.

No they are not.
 
Faith makes a person impenetrable to reason.

"Christian Skeptic"-- Q.E.D.

Faith is a catalyst for both ignorance and arrogance--while imagining oneself morally superior.

No Atheist is telling Christians what they "should do" or "should believe". We are showing you what your supposed god is telling you to do and asking you to justify your failure to do it. Make no mistake, we are glad that you have failed to obey your imaginary friend-- but we want to know how you know what bits and pieces and iinterpretations of the bible you've come to find true or "from god" and why you find yourself any less of a moral relativist than an atheist? How do you know which feelings and "subjective truths" are more than wishful thinking or delusions or garden variety woo confirmation bias?

And we also want to know how your reasoning has become so convoluted and flawed. Oh, and the hypocrisy thing-- you demand answers to vague questions that you refuse to answer?? You always ask loaded inane questions you don't want answered... you are trying to imply what you want to believe with the question. You want to imply that atheists are being hypocritical to avoid examining your own hypocrisy. We are not. You are either too stupid or too blinded by faith or too dishonest to understand that you are projecting faults much more evident in yourself onto others who could actually help you out of the morass if you weren't so damn certain that we needed to learn "lessons" from you!

Oh, and the part in the bible about it being harder to get into heaven then for a camel to get through the eye of a needle-- how are assorted Christians apolgizing that one away these days?
 
But atheists using Matthew are making a claim as noted in the OP and argued through this thread - only now they appear to be saying, "but we don't really mean it."
Again, I think you're just playing stupid.

I've delineated the argument where atheists cite the passage in Matthew. That argument does NOT depend in any way whatsoever on atheists thinking that Christians should obey the laws of the Old Testament.

In fact, as I said in my first post in this thread, most of us consider a lot of the Old Testament morality to be abominable.

Would you like for me to review the argument that atheists usually make regarding this passage, or can you not read one of the many times it's been stated in this thread?

Please, get off of the notion that atheists think anyone ought or should or must obey the laws of the Old Testament. We've all been pretty clear that we don't think that's a good thing.

The issue is whether or not the argument often put forth by Christians that Old Testament law is no longer valid because Jesus replaced it with a new law.

Do you think that Jesus replaced Old Testament law with a new law? Do you think that that new law made the old laws invalid? If so, you are running contrary to the passage in Matthew that you cited and the one in Luke that I cited.

I'm certain if you tried, you could find contrary passages in the letters of Paul and maybe even in the Gospel of John.
 
I am fairly confident that he will say the same to you (caveat excluding certain metaphysical potions regarding ducks). As do I and I bet most people in this thread will say the same to you. Believe what you want.
I haven’t answered the question because I don’t know what Christians are supposed to do. That is what I am trying to find out.

I find the bible a very confusing document. I read Luke 16:17 & Mathew 5:18-19 as saying keep all the old rules and Titus 1-14 and Hebrews 13:9 as suggesting they should be ignored.

I know Christians refer to the 10 commandments but they are old testament are they not.

Confused. That smee.

It does seem a very easy question however I and I would have thought all Christians would be able to answer the question. Should Christians follow all some or none of the OT.
 
Last edited:
Nope. I'm not making a claim about a verse and telling him that he needs to believe it. He can believe whatever he wants.

But atheists using Matthew are making a claim as noted in the OP and argued through this thread - only now they appear to be saying, "but we don't really mean it."

Perhaps you've always misunderstood the argument. It's more along the lines of "Why do you ignore the OT when Matthew tells you to follow it?" To which the answer is normally "But Matthew doesn't say that."

Followed by: "But it does say that"
"No it doesn't"

etc -- but with a bit more padding.

It's not about what people should do, it's about what a book says.

Just out of interest...
Are there any non-Christians who think that Matthew says the old law doesn't apply?
 
Sorry, I'm right :D

Still wrong! :D

Do you really think Christian doctrine is that Jesus accomplished everything two thousands years ago? Can you not think of anything else that was supposed to be accomplished?

Don't know. Don't care. :)

But Jesus made the statement that he fulfilled the law. :D

Oh, just little things like Heaven and Earth passing away before the establishment of the Kingdom of God?

This has been addressed several times. Please feel free to review up above, I'll wait here.:cool:

Not either/or. Both.

"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them."

Either/or. But thanks for playing! :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom