But apart from this thread, you haven't given any examples of atheists using that verse. Did they use it in isolation? Or did they also point to other parts of the NT which say the old law is replaced?
Here is the posts that led to this thread. He actually said Mark 5:18-19, but meant Matthew 5:18-19. He also posted other verses and he was countering my advice to a person who appeared to be wondering about Christianity.
I posted that if he's interested in Christianity he might
not want to start with the Old Testament like he appeared to be doing, but instead start with what Jesus actually taught since what he teaches, for Christians, supersedes and reinterprets Old Testament teachings.
HERE
FREETHINKER responded to me.
FREETHINKER said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
By the way - if you're interested in being a Christian you might want to first stick with Jesus teachings first since He's the founder and Teacher - his teachings, for Christians, supersede and reinterpret the Old Testament teachings. (Well - actually, He put the intention of many of the laws back in line to their original purpose). Just my two cents.
They do? I think that the bible itself disagrees with you. Try Mark 5:18-19 [NOTE: by ACS - this was meant to be Matthew 5:18-19] and Luke 16:17 to start with.
The Matthew verses were used in this case as a rebuttal to me where he was saying that Christians are still bound by the Old Testament Laws. This wasn't a case of showing contradictions but countering my claim that Jesus teachings for Christians are what Christians go by and that his teachings for Christians supersede and reinterpret the Old Testament Laws. [NOTE: Often by adding to the Laws. But I didn't go that specific in my advice in the post]
I recognized those Matthew verses because they've been used numerous other times by themselves here in this forum.
My post back:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3697334#post3697334
That is how I decided on the name for this thread and the idea for this thread. Because a short while later different posters pipe in about the Matthew Verses.
Here ROBIN posts
ROBIN said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
You've decided that verse means "Christians must take the Old Testament laws literally".
I assume you mean Matthew 5:17-18. That is what it seems to mean.
ROBIN then clarifies He's simply saying it's a statement spoken for some reason. To which I replied
HERE
I reiterate how those Matthew verses have been used towards me and others on this forum in the past:
A Christian Sceptic said:
You might, but most atheists who use that verse do not simply say "this was spoken for some reason". They interpret it as meaning you need to follow Old Testament laws literally. They then say "You eat shellfish, you're a hyporcrite, not-a-Christian, or even less faithfull".
So then Jon hops in with his interpretation which
was:
JON said:
To me, they mean that, according to Jesus, a person who wishes to enter the kingdom of heaven has to surpass the Pharisees and teachers of law in righteousness (which might not have been difficult); that the Law (which I take to refer to the rules set out in the first five books of the OT, and in particular Leviticus and Deuteronomy) remains in force; and that those who break it will be scorned and rejected while those who follow and teach it will be exalted.
And
here I give what I think those verses
might mean.
What then followed was a debate much like the debate on my
other interpretation here. Where Jon
defended the reading that it meant that the Old Testament Laws
still apply.
You might want to note - in that post I actually give a slightly different interpretation as the one I posted here in this thread. Why?
Because I have at least three different interpretations of those particular verse that all lead to a NO or INCONCLUSIVE on whether Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws. I also have the majority's here interpretation of a YES. And I also have an interpretation that is interpretted in much the same way Fiona posted (I Think), although a bit different, but coupled with other parts of the New Testament leads me to a YES, and by following Jesus Christians
are.
So I have at least 5 different interpretations of those verses that all seem like they might be right which leads me to the position I've had throughout this entire thread. A position where it's been implied I'm blind, dishonest, and even stupid for not seeing how obvious the right interpretation is -
which is the atheist's interpretation.
I was curious if the consensus atheists seemed to have was based on some Christian teachings I was unaware of or their own interpretation on their own. It appears it was the latter although at the beginning of this thread some people Googled (Not what I intended them to do, but thanks) and found me some Christians who do or partially do agree with them. A very small minority and most of them
don't seem to follow all the Old Testament Laws.
My only conclusion at all on these verses still is (and sorry for shouting this):
IT'S NOT APPARANT AND OBVIOUS TO ME THAT ACCORDING TO THESE VERSES CHRISTIANS ARE SUPPOSED TO FOLLOW ALL THE OLD TESTAMENT LAWS.