The atheists favorite bible verses

Critical thinkers value certain types of approach and we believe that the truth is the same for everyone and that knowledge can be based on hard evidence and replicable findings.

So do believers. They constantly appeal to logic and evidence; on top of which, most of them are able to function in every day life.

They have no justification to claim that their religion should be excepted from these rules and I see no reason to do it, either.

That is great for the fields where it applies; but it does not apply to morality (and I personally believe it has been overextended into what is called social science, but that is a whole other argument).

It applies to everything. If evidence and logic tell me that a moral code doesn't work or is incoherent, i will not follow it. (Or how else should a rule like "Do not wear mixed fibres" be justified? Or do you think it doesn't need justification?)

I think that the religious use a lot of the same tools we do when they come to "unscientific" issues. It is true that they have often used their set of tools inappropriately in fields where science works better: but I think some so-called sceptics do that too, and we see fundie evolutionists who think there is no moral or political question which cannot be answered by the tenet "survival of the fittest" (see reverbision's recent thread "biology and government" for a prime example).

Do you disagree with the conclusion, or with the selection of tools used to reach it?

Do you think that stance is based on evidence and logically sound? (I haven't read the thread in question...)
 
When you make that claim to a Christian you are telling them they need to follow the Old Testament Laws. You're intent to show them it's contradictory is only apparent if you include other verses. If you post these Matthew verses solely you're telling the Christian they are obviously not obeying those verses, which Christians take as meaning they should.

But apart from this thread, you haven't given any examples of atheists using that verse. Did they use it in isolation? Or did they also point to other parts of the NT which say the old law is replaced?

Egg in post 19:
I agree that it's a good point, but we also need to take into consideration "he who is without sin cast the first stone" and the "the Sabbath is for man, not man for the Sabbath" where in both cases Jesus would appear to be going against what was written in Leviticus.

So it didn't take long for the contrary view to make an appearance in this thread -- and that's an off-topic appearance, according to you.
 
So do believers. They constantly appeal to logic and evidence; on top of which, most of them are able to function in every day life.

Yes. I did not mean to imply that they are wholly different. In fact I thought that part of what I have been arguing is that they are much more similar to non-believers than they are different. Obviously that did not come across.

They have no justification to claim that their religion should be excepted from these rules and I see no reason to do it, either.

Oh dear. My whole intent was to show that they make no such claim and in fact spend an awful lot of time and effort applying those rules. I do not seem to be very articulate today.

It applies to everything. If evidence and logic tell me that a moral code doesn't work or is incoherent, i will not follow it. (Or how else should a rule like "Do not wear mixed fibres" be justified? Or do you think it doesn't need justification?)

Again this is exactly what Christians do. It is why they have try so hard to get to the real intent. The premise is that the word of god is true. If the fallible human thinks he knows what it means yet the outcome does not "work" (in whatever terms we are using that word) he does what you and I do: he seeks to find out where he has gone wrong.

Do you disagree with the conclusion, or with the selection of tools used to reach it?

Do you think that stance is based on evidence and logically sound? (I haven't read the thread in question...)

The OP is just a succession of unsupported assertions. It is impossible to to tell what tools have been used to reach the conclusions but there is neither logic nor evidence. Have a look :)
 
Last edited:
Eons of picking and choosing--

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/04/AR2006030401369.html

"Sometimes Christian apologists say there are only three options to who Jesus was: a liar, a lunatic or the Lord," he tells a packed auditorium here at the University of North Carolina, where he chairs the department of religious studies. "But there could be a fourth option -- legend."

Ehrman's latest book, "Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why," has become one of the unlikeliest bestsellers of the year. A slender book of textual criticism, currently at No. 16 on the New York Times bestseller list, it casts doubt on any number of New Testament episodes that most Christians take as, well, gospel.

Example: A crowd readies itself to stone an adulterous woman to death. Jesus leans down, doodles in the dust. Says, let the one without sin cast the first stone. The crowd melts away. It's one of the most famous stories in the Bible.

And it's most likely fiction, says Ehrman, seconding other scholars who say scribes added the episode to the biblical canon centuries after the life of Christ.
 
Last edited:
Christians do not follow the bible. It's not like the inconsistencies and problems and utterly reprehensible laws and rules it contains are new.

If Christians on average had even a trace of desire to actually follow the Bible, they would follow the Bible.

But they aren't. At large, they ignore these issues. When they are pointed out specifically, Christians tend to deny them, or explain them away.

Where are all the Christians that do follow the bible? Even if some passages are ambiguous, there should be large numbers of Christians that favour the interpretation that demands that they should follow Old Testament laws. Where are they?

ACS is, perhaps, not the best example.
But there used to be other posters on this forum who did better at explaining how they interpreted certain passages of the Bible. PotatoStew springs to mind, but he was probably before your time. I always regarded him as an intelligent and honest poster -- I was even on his side in some debates against my fellow atheists.

Unfortunately, I don't recall this quote from Matthew being discussed with him.
 
But apart from this thread, you haven't given any examples of atheists using that verse. Did they use it in isolation? Or did they also point to other parts of the NT which say the old law is replaced?

Here is the posts that led to this thread. He actually said Mark 5:18-19, but meant Matthew 5:18-19. He also posted other verses and he was countering my advice to a person who appeared to be wondering about Christianity.
I posted that if he's interested in Christianity he might not want to start with the Old Testament like he appeared to be doing, but instead start with what Jesus actually taught since what he teaches, for Christians, supersedes and reinterprets Old Testament teachings.

HERE

FREETHINKER responded to me.

FREETHINKER said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic

By the way - if you're interested in being a Christian you might want to first stick with Jesus teachings first since He's the founder and Teacher - his teachings, for Christians, supersede and reinterpret the Old Testament teachings. (Well - actually, He put the intention of many of the laws back in line to their original purpose). Just my two cents.
They do? I think that the bible itself disagrees with you. Try Mark 5:18-19 [NOTE: by ACS - this was meant to be Matthew 5:18-19] and Luke 16:17 to start with.


The Matthew verses were used in this case as a rebuttal to me where he was saying that Christians are still bound by the Old Testament Laws. This wasn't a case of showing contradictions but countering my claim that Jesus teachings for Christians are what Christians go by and that his teachings for Christians supersede and reinterpret the Old Testament Laws. [NOTE: Often by adding to the Laws. But I didn't go that specific in my advice in the post]

I recognized those Matthew verses because they've been used numerous other times by themselves here in this forum.

My post back:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3697334#post3697334

That is how I decided on the name for this thread and the idea for this thread. Because a short while later different posters pipe in about the Matthew Verses.

Here ROBIN posts

ROBIN said:
A Christian Sceptic said:
Originally Posted by A Christian Sceptic
You've decided that verse means "Christians must take the Old Testament laws literally".
I assume you mean Matthew 5:17-18. That is what it seems to mean.

ROBIN then clarifies He's simply saying it's a statement spoken for some reason. To which I replied HERE

I reiterate how those Matthew verses have been used towards me and others on this forum in the past:
A Christian Sceptic said:
You might, but most atheists who use that verse do not simply say "this was spoken for some reason". They interpret it as meaning you need to follow Old Testament laws literally. They then say "You eat shellfish, you're a hyporcrite, not-a-Christian, or even less faithfull".

So then Jon hops in with his interpretation which was:
JON said:
To me, they mean that, according to Jesus, a person who wishes to enter the kingdom of heaven has to surpass the Pharisees and teachers of law in righteousness (which might not have been difficult); that the Law (which I take to refer to the rules set out in the first five books of the OT, and in particular Leviticus and Deuteronomy) remains in force; and that those who break it will be scorned and rejected while those who follow and teach it will be exalted.

And here I give what I think those verses might mean.
What then followed was a debate much like the debate on my other interpretation here. Where Jon defended the reading that it meant that the Old Testament Laws still apply.

You might want to note - in that post I actually give a slightly different interpretation as the one I posted here in this thread. Why?

Because I have at least three different interpretations of those particular verse that all lead to a NO or INCONCLUSIVE on whether Christians are supposed to follow Old Testament Laws. I also have the majority's here interpretation of a YES. And I also have an interpretation that is interpretted in much the same way Fiona posted (I Think), although a bit different, but coupled with other parts of the New Testament leads me to a YES, and by following Jesus Christians are.

So I have at least 5 different interpretations of those verses that all seem like they might be right which leads me to the position I've had throughout this entire thread. A position where it's been implied I'm blind, dishonest, and even stupid for not seeing how obvious the right interpretation is - which is the atheist's interpretation.

I was curious if the consensus atheists seemed to have was based on some Christian teachings I was unaware of or their own interpretation on their own. It appears it was the latter although at the beginning of this thread some people Googled (Not what I intended them to do, but thanks) and found me some Christians who do or partially do agree with them. A very small minority and most of them don't seem to follow all the Old Testament Laws.

My only conclusion at all on these verses still is (and sorry for shouting this):

IT'S NOT APPARANT AND OBVIOUS TO ME THAT ACCORDING TO THESE VERSES CHRISTIANS ARE SUPPOSED TO FOLLOW ALL THE OLD TESTAMENT LAWS.
 
Last edited:
But if, as you maintain, the message was intended only for the apostles, then Xtians may be in serious apostasy for having assumed all this time it was intended for everyone. Reciting the pater noster, for example, could be heresy, according to your... 'novel'... interpretation. :)
Forgot almost to admit that you are right. I tried to show that one might draw pretty wrong conclusions when considering just one verse in isolation.
 
Not exactly. I have my Bible here, and it is the Fireside Family Edition of the New American Bible,published in the 1970s under the supervision of His Holiness, Pope Paul VI. It is extensively footnoted with explanatory introductions from a Catholic perspective.

In the introduction to the Book of Ecclesiastes, it says, "The moral teaching of the book is imperfect, like the Old Testament itself (Heb 7, 19), yet it marks an advance in the development of the doctrine of divine retribution. While rejecting the older solution of earthly rewards and punishments, Ecclesiastes looks forward to a more lasting one. The clear answer to the problem was to come with the light of Christ's teaching concerning future life."

So, according to Catholics, it is not true that God was wrong in the OT, but it is true that some of the OT is wrong, or, to be generous, incomplete and misleading.

As it turns out, that little phrase played a key role in my conversion from Catholic to atheist. The realization that even the Church could spot holes in the Bible made me reconsider whether it made sense to believe any of it, and a few weeks after I read that passage, I concluded it did not.

P.S. For those who can't find a Bible handy, Heb 7, 19 says, "for the law brought nothing to perfection. But a better hope has supervened, and through it we draw near to God."

Thanks Meadmaker, that's really curious. I'm definitely not used to the idea that margin commentaries can carry such authority. If the Pope said that about the OT, I think he is speaking against what Paul says in the NT. I shall look it up...

I have a Catholic Bible from the 1850's that calculates back to the specific year that the world was created. (It was wrong and does not appear in later editions.) If my memory serves, God is not mentioned even once in Ecclesiastes, I've seen at least one commentary that asserts it is of non Judeo origin.

Hehehe... atheists trying to make sense of the Bible. This is fun.
 
If my memory serves, God is not mentioned even once in Ecclesiastes, I've seen at least one commentary that asserts it is of non Judeo origin.

God is mentioned in Ecclesiastes. The only book where God is not mentioned is Esther...except in the Catholic version. The Catholic version has some material not found in Jewish or Protestant versions, and in the additional material, God gets mentioned.

Margin comments do carry that much weight because, as others have pointed out, in Catholicism, it is taught that only the Church has authority to really interpret the Bible. To the extent that margin comments represent Church teaching about the text, they are just as important as the text itself. Perhaps more accurately, the text is not to be fully understood without reference to the Church teaching about the text. If something in the text doesn't appear right to a Catholic, he is encouraged to find out what the Church teaching is, so that he can get the "correct" interpretation.
 
OK, I'll give it a shot. How about what wins in an argument -- the interpretation that works best and makes most sense of the words in sequence and in context within the larger language community and not simply the interpretation preferred by a group with vested interests?
I wouldn't necessarily disagree, but I think the two definitions do hardly differ. One is a reformulation of the other.
 
Last edited:
So I have at least 5 different interpretations of those verses that all seem like they might be right which leads me to the position I've had throughout this entire thread. A position where it's been implied I'm blind, dishonest, and even stupid for not seeing how obvious the right interpretation is - which is the atheist's interpretation.
I wonder why it's supposed to be the atheist's interpretation. I'm atheist and my view on this Sermon is totally different.

It's practically the only biblical passage I really tried to analyse and comprehend. Not just the passage about law, which I can only understand within the overall context of the Sermon. And this context is anything but about painstakingly following the letters of old laws, it's more about the laws' spirit as taught by JC, hence god.

I was curious if the consensus atheists seemed to have was based on some Christian teachings I was unaware of or their own interpretation on their own.
My personal interpretation (of the Sermon) does not follow any christian school, I think. Regarding the particular passage about the law, I agree to your remarks on it. Again, I don't think there's any atheist consensus, like there's not a christian one. We're talking about passages discussed heavily for 2K years. Hence, the popular assertion in this thread about its "unambiguity" is really bizarre.
 
Last edited:
You are both right. If a Christian comes to believe a statement is truly part of Christ's teaching, and satisfies himself as to what it means, either through thought;or argument; or his church's doctrine; or his Ph.D research or in any other way, then he is bound to do what it tells him to do.

I don't know that even THAT is always the case. Aren't there some Christians who don't believe Jesus was divine? They would say his teachings were therefore subject to human error as well. (What do you make of the story of Jesus cursing the fig tree? Seems like a very human and imperfect thing that has no value whatsoever as a moral example.)

ETA: At any rate, my larger point is still valid: just saying that a passage means x is not the same as me saying that a Christian should follow x. And there are plenty of Christians who would agree. It sounds like some Christians have a huge problem with the Matthew passage in question because they think if it really means what it says that they are bound by it. That's not my issue. I don't think they should be bound by it.

Mainstream Christians do, to a greater or lesser extent, accept that not everything in the bible is to be taken literally, for all the reasons already mentioned: error by the writer; translation error; interpretation error etc etc etc.
Just a nitpick: you seem to be treating the concepts of literalism and inerrancy as if they were the same. Whether a passage should be taken literally or not is one thing; whether it might be wrong (or have errors in it) is another issue.
 
Last edited:
My favorite bible verses are Genesis 3:22 to 3:24!

And the LORD God said, "The man has now become like one of us, knowing good and evil. He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever." So the LORD God banished him from the Garden of Eden to work the ground from which he had been taken. After he drove the man out, he placed on the east side of the Garden of Eden cherubim and a flaming sword flashing back and forth to guard the way to the tree of life.

"He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever." and "... and a flaming sword flashing back and forth to guard the way to the tree of life." make it seem like God is scared of Man!

Though Revelations is a pretty good read, too! Man, John was sooooooo hiiiiiigh when he wrote that!
 
I wouldn't necessarily disagree, but I think the two definitions do hardly differ. One is a reformulation of the other.

They differ in terms of inclusiveness. Your formulation (similar to ACS's, which only makes sense, since you were explicating his view) includes only the view of the church and/or believer. The other view includes everyone within a particular language community, allowing other viewpoints to interpret the text. There is a danger allowing only believers to interpret a particular text because hidden assumptions will remain hidden.

I don't think it a good idea to argue that a text says what the church says it does. The church has a vested interest in certain outcomes.

The Habermasian marketplace of ideas should decide.
 
I don't know that even THAT is always the case. Aren't there some Christians who don't believe Jesus was divine?
Eh .. Christians who think Jesus was not Christ? Trinity no more? Sounds like an interesting concept, you've got more about it?
 
Last edited:
I wonder why it's supposed to be the atheist's interpretation. I'm atheist and my view on this Sermon is totally different.

Sorry if it wasn't clear.
I'm talking as mainly argued in this thread. Up until recently all the people arguing what the right interpretation was were atheists and when it's used towards Christians on this forum it's by certain atheists with certain intent and the consensus in that case is their interpretation is right.

I don't think all atheists have the same an opinion on it. I'd be surprised if most atheists don't have a view on it other than probably "Who knows? Who Cares?".

My personal interpretation (of the Sermon) does not follow any christian school, I think. Regarding the particular passage about the law, I agree to your remarks on it. Again, I don't think there's any atheist consensus, like there's not a christian one. We're talking about passages discussed heavily for 2K years. Hence, the popular assertion in this thread about its "unambiguity" is really bizarre.

My remarks were in reference to this thread and the way it's used towards arguments with Christians. I appreciate the other atheists views and thoughts on the matter who've posted. Thanks.

And Herz: I really liked those Wikipedia links. Thanks. I have been noticing your posts.
 
Last edited:
Here is the posts that led to this thread.

Thank you for your detailed response.

So I have at least 5 different interpretations of those verses that all seem like they might be right which leads me to the position I've had throughout this entire thread. A position where it's been implied I'm blind, dishonest, and even stupid for not seeing how obvious the right interpretation is - which is the atheist's interpretation.

I apologise for my comments on your honesty. I still think that some of your comments were unfair in the context of this thread.

I only saw your responses to the subject in this thread. And your allegation didn't make sense to me in a thread where people had pointed out alternatives to Matthew 5 -- thereby leaving it up in the air regarding what Christians are supposed to do.

I still think that, if someone honestly believes that Matthew 5 advises following the OT, then they should argue that position -- regardless of what they WANT Christians to do. It seems like a good way to understand WHY so many Christians view those verses in a different way.
 
Last edited:
...
In the cases where atheists use this it's to show that Christians need to take the Old Testament Laws literally. I'm sure you know why they would like to make that case. ;)

Now - the only place I've ever come across that teaching is here and the only people I've ever heard insist that's how to interpret those verses are atheists.

So - if you'd like to play along and take up the challenge -

Please find me some references and literature where Christians use those verses to insist that Christians must follow all the Old Testament laws literally. I'd like to read them.

Thanks.
Let me get this straight. Are you claiming here that it is not hypocritical for Christians to cherry pick from the Bible while claiming it is the inerrant word of God at the same time?

My favorite discrediting words from the Bible are not contained in a single verse, but rather two stories. The disgusting story of Lot and the claim, "God said to", made by the Hebrew religious zealots at the time they killed all the Amalkites including all the babies and children in order to justify stealing the Amalkite lands. The Hebrews of course also said God told them they could keep all the young virgin girls as sex slaves, (or was that in one of the other similar stories?).
 
Just so my post doesn't require you repeat too much of what you already posted on this matter...

So from your claim in this post, ACS, I take it you just cherry pick interpretations rather than cherry picking verses?
Don't breaks God's commandments and teach others to do the same. If you teach people the commandments make sure you're also following them. In other words - don't be a hypocrite.

(By the way - it appears to me when he says commandments he very well might be talking about the commandments He gives that follow this introduction)
By twisting the interpretation of the Bible into what you want it to say rather than reading what it actually does say, you are being the very hypocrite you are warning against.

If you were a scholar of the actual language the original Biblical texts were found in, and you were using that expertise to interpret the meaning here of the original text rather than the English translation, I might give you more credit. But you are simply twisting words here to fit your preconceived beliefs rather than actually attempting to decipher what is really being said in these verses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom