Child bride beaten in Yemen

...Islam has to some extent been involved in reducing its prevalence...
I honestly don't know but I would be surprised. Muslims, AIU, take such an extreme view of chastity and such a dim view of women I would think Islam quite conducive to the practice. What am I missing? What about Islam would reduce the prevalence? I'll confess that my knowledge of Islam is not that good and I've been taken to task on these forums in the past for getting facts wrong about the Muslims. Also I concede that there are many different Muslim peoples, cultures, sects, etc.. From Turkey to Pakistan which tend to be more secular to Saudi Arabia and Somalia which tend to be less secular and Iran where the people love much of western culture but the country is cracking down on dress codes and conduct and of course many other nations and people in between.

So, if you know, tell me why you think Islam is a force of good to end this insidious practice.

Female Circumcision in ISLAM - many girls bleed to death
 
Last edited:
Good thing she did, since her role was a stripper. Wouldn't have made much sense if she didn't.

Just like her role in G.I. Jane, she undertook intensive physical training, that's what actors do.
I am sure that disrobing was very physically demanding and required alot of training.
 
I honestly don't know but I would be surprised. Muslims, AIU, take such an extreme view of chastity and such a dim view of women I would think Islam quite conducive to the practice. What am I missing? What about Islam would reduce the prevalence?

Take a look at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_cutting#Islam

One Sunni sect promotes it, most of the rest seem to tolerate it at best and often oppose it, and Muslim leaders have been condemning the practise in groups since at least 1998. (I may be wrong in thinking many condemned it much earlier, since I can't find a source that backs that up with a cursory search, but I do think I remember reading about it).

Similarly governments in Muslim areas have been active in trying to get rid of FGM.

What about Islam would reduce the prevalence? To me that's like asking what about Christianity would reduce slavery. Some of the time, some of the people following these religions actually read and act on the good bits. Not often enough for my taste, but it happens.
 
This isn't a fair criticism - many mainstream Islamic clerics were condemning FGM and trying to stamp it out long before it even got into the Western consciousness as far as I can remember my reading about the topic. Other Islamic clerics, of course, defended it, but by and large most Islamic-influenced governments are trying to stamp the practise out one way or another and most of the arguments given for FGM by practitioners are based on cultural ideals of cleanliness, hygiene, attractiveness and so on rather than claiming an Islamic basis for the practise.

FGM is an African cultural practise (and a vile one). It was around before Islam, Islam has to some extent been involved in reducing its prevalence, and I'm not aware of any evidence that Islam has been a significant factor in promoting the practise.

To put it another way, the relationship between FGM and Islam is a lot like the relationship between slavery and Christianity in the 1800s. Lots of Christians opposed it on religious grounds, some Christians supported it on religious grounds, but the practise didn't have anything directly to do with Christianity.

I really wasn't referring to FGM here. I was referring to the general treatment of women as slaves to be forcibly married and abused by their husbands in general.

The topic drifted to FGM, but I was referring to the OP.
 
I really wasn't referring to FGM here. I was referring to the general treatment of women as slaves to be forcibly married and abused by their husbands in general.
Do you know this to be a fact?

Do you know any Muslim women?

If so, have you talked to them about their marriage and husbands?
 
Do you know this to be a fact?

Do you know any Muslim women?

If so, have you talked to them about their marriage and husbands?

I know a few. I know one chap who wouldn't dare cross his wife - she a real dragon. I recall a couple a few years ago where the husband tried the "head of the household" thing. He hit her and she kicked the living crap out of him and it all ended in divorce. I know a couple of others who seem as happy as any other married couple. In truth I can't say Islam seems to make a jot of difference to the usual range of martial experiences.
 
Wow!! Who made you God, judge, and jury for the people of the world?

A policeman and a fireman have different roles to play in society. But yet they are equal.
There's a big difference. They chose their professions. And they actually do have equal rights. You post a big lie claiming women are equal in Muslims societies.

Same with men and women the world over. It's just that in Islamic culture the lines are still drawn up as to what is acceptable and not acceptable.

The West has let their young women become loose sluts and dress and act like blatant whores

While in Islamic society women are still raised pure and protected.
I am pleased and completely unashamed to have had the privilege of growing up in a Western culture during the 'sexual revolution'. Sex is great fun. Only a selfish man thinks he has to have some woman who has not been with anyone else. And while I don't begrudge the choice of a woman to be a real "whore" if the woman so chooses to make money by those means, the vast majority of prostitutes in the world today are only prostitutes because their unequal status often leaves them with no education, extreme poverty, vulnerable to exploitation by men and with no options but to sell their body or starve.

I have an education and am not dependent on any man. I own my own home, have a successful business, raised a wonderful son who I am now putting through college. I live in a very nice house that is now paid for. My car is paid for. I don't need to worry about buying the best food in the grocery store. Clearly women are better off in my situation than one in the culture you claim is so 'equal'.

Women in hijabs 'need sunlight or risk illness'

Human Rights Watch - Women's Rights
Millions of women throughout the world live in conditions of abject deprivation of, and attacks against, their fundamental human rights for no other reason than that they are women.

Combatants and their sympathizers in conflicts, such as those in Sierra Leone, Kosovo, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Afghanistan, and Rwanda, have raped women as a weapon of war with near complete impunity. Men in Pakistan, South Africa, Peru, Russia, and Uzbekistan beat women in the home at astounding rates, while these governments alternatively refuse to intervene to protect women and punish their batterers or do so haphazardly and in ways that make women feel culpable for the violence. As a direct result of inequalities found in their countries of origin, women from Ukraine, Moldova, Nigeria, the Dominican Republic, Burma, and Thailand are bought and sold, trafficked to work in forced prostitution, with insufficient government attention to protect their rights and punish the traffickers. In Guatemala, South Africa, and Mexico, women's ability to enter and remain in the work force is obstructed by private employers who use women's reproductive status to exclude them from work and by discriminatory employment laws or discriminatory enforcement of the law. In the U.S., students discriminate against and attack girls in school who are lesbian, bi-sexual, or transgendered, or do not conform to male standards of female behavior. Women in Morocco, Jordan, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia face government-sponsored discrimination that renders them unequal before the law - including discriminatory family codes that take away women's legal authority and place it in the hands of male family members - and restricts women's participation in public life.
(Emphasis mine.)
 
Last edited:
The man was brought before a Yemeni court of law. Their decision has already been rendered and the case is closed. So I am not going to loose sleep over it.

The people on this forum used the incident to attack ALL of Islam and Muslims.

I was just defending some of the misinformed things said about the religion and it's people.
You can't seem to make up your mind. Out of one side of your mouth you claim not "ALL of Islam and Muslims" should be painted with the same brush, while out of the other side you defend the practice.

I don't believe for a minute that "ALL of Islam and Muslims" would condone this atrocity. Being Muslim in no way requires you to be a backward unsophisticated stuck in the past creep.
 
Last edited:
Really? There is the PGA and the WPGA.

And the MBA and the WMBA

Have you ever seen a real life woman who was a Navy Seal? Green Beret? Ranger?

(the slut Demi Moore doesn't count, it was just a movie!)
So you are claiming men get the privilege of treating women like property because men have a different physical build on average?
 
I am pleased and completely unashamed to have had the privilege of growing up in a Western culture during the 'sexual revolution'. Sex is great fun. Only a selfish man thinks he has to have some woman who has not been with anyone else. And while I don't begrudge the choice of a woman to be a real "whore" if the woman so chooses to make money by those means, the vast majority of prostitutes in the world today are only prostitutes because their unequal status often leaves them with no education, extreme poverty, vulnerable to exploitation by men and with no options but to sell their body or starve.

I have an education and am not dependent on any man. I own my own home, have a successful business, raised a wonderful son who I am now putting through college. I live in a very nice house that is now paid for. My car is paid for. I don't need to worry about buying the best food in the grocery store. Clearly women are better off in my situation than one in the culture you claim is so 'equal'.
There is very little difference between your outlook on life and a common prostitute.

Saddly, you don't realize how immoral you have become in yor thinking and way of life.

Then again, you are a typical Western woman.
 
Last edited:
Are you really that lame??

It wasn't a stupid secular court like your kind believe in.

It was an Islamic Court governed by Sharia Law.
There you go again trying to have it both ways. If it was an Islamic court how can you then whine when we complain about the religious beliefs that make this kind of atrocity common?
 
I only respect good women with morals and modest behaviour.

Demi Moore is a nasty slut and a stripper who has NO morals and is basically a whore. What should she be respected for?
So you respect women who let men dominate them? I respect a woman more who has the courage to make a better life for herself and fight back against the injustice of male domination.
 
To immoral and perverted people who have no values. Everything is acceptable no matter how decadent or debasing.
Goodness. Forcing a 10 yr old child to marry a pedophile who then rapes and beats her and a society that tolerates such behavior is fine. But a women like Demi Moore who to my knowledge has simply had 2 long term relationships is immoral and perverted.

Wow.
 
There is very little difference between your outlook on life and a common prostitute.

Saddly, you don't realize how immoral you have become in yor thinking and way of life.

Then again, you are a typical Western woman.
You don't seem to understand what true morality is.


This is immorality:
Nujood's parents say they were trying to do what was best for their daughter and didn't even receive a dowry, a claim many Yemenis don't believe. The parents say the groom had promised he wouldn't have sex with her until she reached puberty. ...

The trouble started on the first night, when he demanded that they share a mattress. She resisted, walking out of the room, only to have him follow. Sometimes he beat her into submission. For weeks, she cried all day and dreaded the nights, when he would enter the room, blow out the oil lamp and demand sex....

On a visit weeks later to her parents' house in the capital, she wept, saying that her husband was doing unmentionable things to her.

Her father said there was nothing he could do.

This is morality:
But her mother's sister discreetly advised her to go to court.
...

Nujood says that at first, she felt ashamed about what had happened to her. "But I passed through that," she says, eyes narrowing beneath her black head scarf.

"All I want now is to finish my education," she adds, her mouth curling into a smile. "I want to be a lawyer."...

When the controversy died down, Nujood insisted on going back to live with her parents, most likely because she is very close to her sister Haifa, 8. ...

She says she's had enough of marriage and domestic life, and looks forward to beginning third grade and pursuing dreams she never knew she had.

"I want to defend oppressed people," she says. "I want to be like Shada. I want to be an example for all the other girls."
 
There is very little difference between your outlook on life and a common prostitute.

Saddly, you don't realize how immoral you have become in yor thinking and way of life.

Then again, you are a typical Western woman.

Isn't your mother a Western woman?

BTW, how was the man punished for his crime of rape? You never got to tell me.
 
Muslims, like most religious types, are gullible fools.
It's not surprising you would see such savage, backwards practices from believers in silly tales.
 
Child bride gets divorced after rape, beatings

SANAA, Yemen (CNN) -- Nujood Ali is 10 years old, but she already has been married and divorced. It was an arranged marriage in which she said a husband three times her age routinely beat and raped her.

Read the rest

The 10-year old was granted a divorce, but the abusive husband was compensated, not prosecuted. "Based on based on the principles of Islamic Sharia law."

Muslims try to say that Islam is a religion of peace and completely compatible with a modern democratic society. WTF is up with this madness? Please tell me what I'm missing here.
Your intolerance is sickening. Your failure to appreciate the legitimacy of other cultures and values is very sad. It's all good, it's just different - don't you know that? You and your smug western values. Who are you to judge the forced marriage and rape of children? For all you know, she was probably asking for it. Just because you think women and children are legitimately people with basic rights doesn't mean that they are. :boggled:

I have to add that rejecting the idea that we are all endowed with certain rights by virtue of our existence and championing the idea that we only get our rights from society is the path to this kind of injustice. This idea that we all automatically are entitled to certain rights regardless of what society or culture or the law says is a vastly superior and more humane approach to existence and why anyone would feel the compulsion to reject that idea - which, to my mind, is the great gift to humanity of the enlightenment - is beyond me.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom