Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

Er, wrong. The Fall was not a punishment, merely a consequence.

Even if my niece feels she's being punished (because she now has to get histamine shots, which she hates).
I don't think so. The "consequence" in your example is a direct result of the child's immune system and the proteins present in the peanut butter sandwich.

In the Adam & Eve story, the only direct consequence of eating the fruit is realizing they're naked, and deciding that's bad. Being evicted and sentenced to forced labor of one kind or another is not a direct consequence of acquiring knowledge, it's a punishment for disobedience. It's as though you, discovering that the peanut butter sandwich you'd planted in the playpen had been eaten with no ill effects (because your niece had outgrown her allergy) decided to administer histamine shots anyway.
 
Just to nitpick... Adam and Eve were not banished from the Garden of Eden for eating from the Tree of Knowledge. They were banished from the Garden of Eden to prevent them eating from the Tree of Life.

If your kid wanders into the laundry and eats some soap you don't lock them out of the laundry as punishment, you do it to prevent them eating the ammonia that's also in there.

Of course this metaphor has a comeback... you shouldn't be leaving Trees of Life and Knowledge lying around for your children to eat. That's just bad God-ing.
 
This sums it up nicely...

ETA... Some naughty words!



"Look Eve, I'm God, I wouldn't lie to you, right. You will die if you eat from the tree. If a snake comes along, he's a lying little ****"
 
Last edited:
Angels are the servants of God and know nothing except obedience.
This right here, shows that there would be no way of Lucifier rebelling against God or be disobedient to God. So it shows the falsehood of fallen Angels.
 
Just to nitpick... Adam and Eve were not banished from the Garden of Eden for eating from the Tree of Knowledge. They were banished from the Garden of Eden to prevent them eating from the Tree of Life.
One can accomplish the same thing by banishing the Tree of Life from the garden.
 
This sums it up nicely...

ETA... Some naughty words!

"Look Eve, I'm God, I wouldn't lie to you, right. You will die if you eat from the tree. If a snake comes along, he's a lying little ****"

Thanks. That Gervais video was really funny. I like his one on "gay animals" too.

By the way, to whom did god say "Let there be light"?
 
I don't think so.

And, um, since when are you qualified to hold an opinion? You think A&E are being punished -- my niece thinks she's being punished. Neither of you are necessarily in possession of all the facts.

Dig deeper. In this case, there are something like 2000 years of theological writings on this particular subject.

In the Adam & Eve story, the only direct consequence of eating the fruit is realizing they're naked, and deciding that's bad. Being evicted and sentenced to forced labor of one kind or another is not a direct consequence of acquiring knowledge, it's a punishment for disobedience.

Since when are indirect consequences not consequences? By discovering the concept of bad stuff, unhappiness has entered the Garden of Eden, basically wrecking it. More importantly, disobedience has entered the garden of Eden, making it no longer safe for A&E to be there.

You don't have to accept the traditional narrative, but for Pete's sake at least learn the real version of it. There is a strong tendency on this forum for people to post the most ridiculously straw-man versions of quite sophisticated theological arguments and then laugh at them. If I were to post something about "if monkeys turned into people, why are there monkeys left," I'd rightly be ridiculed for my ignorance. People would tell me, correctly, that I don't know enough about the theory of evolution even to frame a legitimate question.

But this forum has a tendency to do exactly the same in the opposite direction. Gumboot has it at least partly right -- banishment from the Garden was not punitive, but preventative (it even says so in the Book). But it's hardly an original discovery on his part, precisely because it's been known to every sophisticated theologian since well before the birth of Christ.
 
One can accomplish the same thing by banishing the Tree of Life from the garden.

Where do you put it, then?

Given that unhappiness had (demonstrably) already entered the Garden when A&E were banished, it would no longer have been "Edenic" even if they were permitted to stay.
 
But it's hardly an original discovery on his part, precisely because it's been known to every sophisticated theologian since well before the birth of Christ.


Obviously it's not an original discovery... how on earth would I know it if it was? I detest the Christian faith, but that doesn't mean I need to make stuff up about it.

I tend to agree that people who are critical of the Bible can often misrepresent it for their agenda - for example the whole "two conflicting version of creation" thing. I've had to "defend the bible" numerous times on that point.

Taking a literal interpretation of the story (Beerina is quite right, it's an allegory, but many modern Christians don't understand that) it implies to me some nastier motives behind God's creation of man. Almost like a science experiment. Consider.

*He creates animals and plants, without souls, so no affinity to God
*He creates man with a soul, but gives man free will and no concept of right or wrong

Now, let's look at motive. Why? Why would God do this? Consider, without knowing right or wrong man cannot know if any of his actions are right or wrong - including doing what God says.

He has essentially created a perfect model of anarchy.

What possible reason could God have for creating an anarchy model?
 
Obviously it's not an original discovery... how on earth would I know it if it was? I detest the Christian faith, but that doesn't mean I need to make stuff up about it.

A surprising number of people on this board seem to have that need, though. They often seem not even to be aware of it.

Taking a literal interpretation of the story (Beerina is quite right, it's an allegory, but many modern Christians don't understand that) it implies to me some nastier motives behind God's creation of man. Almost like a science experiment. Consider.

*He creates animals and plants, without souls, so no affinity to God
*He creates man with a soul, but gives man free will and no concept of right or wrong

Now, let's look at motive. Why? Why would God do this? Consider, without knowing right or wrong man cannot know if any of his actions are right or wrong - including doing what God says.

He has essentially created a perfect model of anarchy.

What possible reason could God have for creating an anarchy model?

The usual answer for this is that God (for whatever inscrutable reason He has) wants our "love," which can only be given freely. True love cannot be forced.

I don't think that knowledge of right and wrong is necessary in order to feel love, and I am quite sure that love will often trump knowledge of right/wrong (I've seen too many fools do the wrong damnfool thing in in the name of "love").

But the ultimate answer to your question, from the Christian tradition, is "what makes you think you understand God's motives"? Remember, my niece doesn't understand why she has to go to the doctor, and probably feels I'm being unfair and unjust....
 
Just to nitpick... Adam and Eve were not banished from the Garden of Eden for eating from the Tree of Knowledge. They were banished from the Garden of Eden to prevent them eating from the Tree of Life.

If your kid wanders into the laundry and eats some soap you don't lock them out of the laundry as punishment, you do it to prevent them eating the ammonia that's also in there.

Of course this metaphor has a comeback... you shouldn't be leaving Trees of Life and Knowledge lying around for your children to eat. That's just bad God-ing.

If I leave food out, and my dog gives into temptation and eats it-- I blame myself, not the dog.

Bad god-ing, indeed.

Who knows who wrote the original story or when or why-- but it's a lame story with a lame lesson about a lame god. In legal terms God would be liable for leaving around an "attractive nuisance". Thankfully, humans have evolved morality beyond the gods they created and the primitive allegories of yesteryear. Some of us have, anyhow.

I feel sorry for those who believe there is deep meaning or wisdom in the Genesis story, and I'm glad not to have to pretend it makes sense or is deep or meaningful. It gets even more twisted when this is supposed to be the reason god kills his kid (who is him)-- to atone for "original sin", right? So, did he kill Jesus for a "parable"--or is Jesus a parable too? A lot of wonton cruelty had been done unto others on the basis of that "allegory" it seems to me.
 
Last edited:
The usual answer for this is that God (for whatever inscrutable reason He has) wants our "love," which can only be given freely. True love cannot be forced.

And yet he repeatedly does just that - look at the sacrifice of Isaac.


But the ultimate answer to your question, from the Christian tradition, is "what makes you think you understand God's motives"?


Well the obvious answer to that is "Because I've eaten from the Tree of Knowledge".
 
Who knows who wrote the original story or when or why-- but it's a lame story with a lame lesson about a lame god.


I suspect the original story was intended for a different reason that didn't mesh well with the new Christian faith regarding God. The Christian God is actually pretty abnormal for being of the "Loving" kind. Most Gods aren't - in fact historically talking most Gods were a menace to mankind - a horrific angry force that you had to placate.

I think originally the Tree of Knowledge was about answering the question "Why are we not like animals?" It would have been clear enough that there were both strong similarities between man and animal, and also strong differences. The solution was the Tree of Knowledge. And funnily enough in a very primitive way it's right.

The talking snake, the wrathful God, stealing a powerful benefit from the Gods and getting punished for it (Prometheus, anyone?) they're perfectly in keeping with early non-Christian beliefs.
 
God and child-rearing

You have to teach your children not to do a lot of stuff, without necessarily explaining why. "No, you can't have a peanut butter cookie (because you're allergic to peanuts). No, I'm not going to explain histamine reactions to you. Shut up and have a banana instead."

You should never tell your children "not to do a lot of stuff, without necessarily explaining why", except in an emergency where you just don't have the time. And in this case you actually do explain: "you're allergic to peanuts".
Most grownups who are allergic to peanuts (and I'm one of them) don't understand histamine reactions and they don't have to.
And Adam and Eve were punished. The conseqence of eating the apple was the opening up of their eyes and the subsequent (but not very logical!) shame of being naked. What followed when their heavenly father noticed this was punishment. They were not only sinners, this was the original sin passed on to all of their descendants.

This is how the story goes:

God not only does not explain the consequences, he actually lies:

“And the LORD God commanded the man, saying, "You may freely eat of every tree of the garden; 17 but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die." 18”

The snake, however, tells them the truth about the consequences (but not about the consequences of the consequences: shame and punishment):

“But the serpent said to the woman, "You will not die. 5 For God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil." 6 So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was a delight to the eyes, and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate; and she also gave some to her husband, and he ate. 7 Then the eyes of both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig leaves together and made themselves aprons. 8 ”

So death is not a consequence, it's a death sentence, part and parcel of God’s punishment:

”To the woman he said, "I (!!!) will greatly multiply your pain in childbearing; in pain you shall bring forth children, yet your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you." 17 And to Adam he said, "Because you have listened to the voice of your wife, and have eaten of the tree of which I commanded you, 'You shall not eat of it,' cursed (!!!) is the ground because of you; in toil you shall eat of it all the days of your life; 18 thorns and thistles it shall bring forth to you; and you shall eat the plants of the field. 19 In the sweat of your face you shall eat bread till you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken; you are dust, and to dust you shall return." 20“

- - - - - -

I can really empathize with these guys, the children of a psychopathic parent. When I was a child my mother taught me about traffic by telling me that if I was ever involved in an accident she would beat me up and send me to a children's home. So when I was hit by a car at the age of six, I did the only logical thing to do in a situation like that: Like Adam and Eve I fled the scene of the 'crime' and went into hiding.

Don't try to make sense of God. I hate that evil bastard.
 
Last edited:
(With this kind of parent isn't it somehow logical that the one who reveals the truth to the children is described as evil and punished too?)
 
And, um, since when are you qualified to hold an opinion?

Wow, that's the rudest thing I've seen in at least a week. In fact, I keep looking for the irony because it's hard to believe anyone would say such a thing in all seriousness.

Neither of you are necessarily in possession of all the facts.

Nor are you!

If I were to post something about "if monkeys turned into people, why are there monkeys left," I'd rightly be ridiculed for my ignorance. People would tell me, correctly, that I don't know enough about the theory of evolution even to frame a legitimate question.

Yes, but I doubt anyone would have the gall to imply that you had no right to hold an opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom