Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

The problem with the straw men that people like to erect is that they end up actually reducing the credibility of the atheist movement. Let's say that you go to Aunt Margaret and point out to her all the lame pseudocontradictions that adorn the Bible, and let's say further that she takes you seriously enough that she actually starts to think and question. Well, the first person that Aunt Margaret will be asking questions of is probably her local priest or minister, who is familiar with these arguments and has the pat answers honed by centuries of apologetics. He takes her gently by the hand into his library, shows her how these questions have all come up within the Christian tradition a long time ago, and how it's based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of God, Christ, religion, what have you.

In other words, you've now given the priest an (ahem) "heaven-sent" opportunity to demonstrate, not only the fundamental truth of Christianity, but also to show that atheists and rationalists really don't know what they're talking about, and that rationalism is a position taken only from ignorance. Thanks a lot. It was bad enough talking to Aunt Meg before, when she actually thought that people could be smart and atheist. Now she knows -- 'cause you proved it to her -- that only idiots are atheists, and she has no reason to take further arguments from them seriously.
I don't disagree, though I do think the bolded portion betrays way too much faith in the learnedness of the modern clergy.
 
You think the Supreme Creator of the Universe could be just a little bit clearer in what he said?

I mean, after the goat herders had finished with their tales told round the camp fires at night and they had been written down to support the great lifestyles their priests ascribed to, it's taken 100s of years for the Great Theological Brains of the Apologists to figure out what he actually meant. And at that they cannot agree.
 
I don't disagree, though I do think the bolded portion betrays way too much faith in the learnedness of the modern clergy.

Fair enough. Or too much concern for brevity, in this case. I had written a paragraph or so about "case b, where her priest doesn't know the answer, so she starts shopping around for one who does -- and he pwns you instead," but decided to omit it.

This case is marginally better in that she's likely to drift out of one of the flat-headed snake-handling biblical literalist fundamentalist nutcase churches and into something more mainstream and less dangerous, where the clergy tend to be better educated. But still better would be simply not to hand the (learned) clergy ammunition to use against you in the first place.
 
Fair enough. Or too much concern for brevity, in this case. I had written a paragraph or so about "case b, where her priest doesn't know the answer, so she starts shopping around for one who does -- and he pwns you instead," but decided to omit it.

This case is marginally better in that she's likely to drift out of one of the flat-headed snake-handling biblical literalist fundamentalist nutcase churches and into something more mainstream and less dangerous, where the clergy tend to be better educated. But still better would be simply not to hand the (learned) clergy ammunition to use against you in the first place.
Brevity on my part plays a role, as well. Ideally, Aunt Margaret would never have to go anywhere else for her more sophisticated arguments, for I would present them to her myself. I think a good strategy (though I don't typically run around trying to convert believers) is to attack the weaker "strawman" type positions that likely do reflect Auntie's actual beliefs to get her into a questioning frame of mind initially. Then, introduce the sophisticated rebuttals to those arguments (which is why I said earlier one should be familiar with them), and work from there.

In other words, get her to acknowledge that some of this stuff at least seems like nonsense, then show her how theologians have defended the nonsense, and finally show her why the theologians are wrong.
 
You think the Supreme Creator of the Universe could be just a little bit clearer in what he said?

Possibly. Or perhaps He doesn't care that much as long as the overall message gets through.

Matthew 22 said:
37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
38 This is the first and great commandment.
39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.
40 On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.

As long as my Aunt Margaret and the rest of her congregation do these, the rest can be sorted out. Let the theologians argue; at least it keeps them off the streets.
 
Last edited:
Brevity on my part plays a role, as well. Ideally, Aunt Margaret would never have to go anywhere else for her more sophisticated arguments, for I would present them to her myself. I think a good strategy (though I don't typically run around trying to convert believers) is to attack the weaker "strawman" type positions that likely do reflect Auntie's actual beliefs to get her into a questioning frame of mind initially. Then, introduce the sophisticated rebuttals to those arguments (which is why I said earlier one should be familiar with them), and work from there.

I find a better approach is the nonoverlapping magisteria argument. Point out some of the obvious nonsense (if necessary) to persuade her that biblical literalism is naive and false and that other sources of evidence are necessary to come to an understanding of the world. Then gradually shrink the magisterium of the Bible and the minister and increase the magisterium of rationalism until you get to the point where she's comfortable with a rational analysis of ethics.

I see no reason to push her religion all the way out of metaphysics and ontology, because, frankly, they have no impact (although by the same token, she might decide to go all the way to full-fledged agnosticism or atheism) and because, as a strong agnostic, I have ethical problems myself with persuading people that there is no such thing as a God.

The worst downside that I can see is driving her into the arms of the Quakers or UU's --- a risk I'm, frankly, willing to take.
 
Possibly. Or perhaps He doesn't care that much as long as the overall message gets through.


Originally Posted by Matthew 22
37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
38 This is the first and great commandment.
39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.
40 On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.

As long as my Aunt Margaret and the rest of her congregation do these, the rest can be sorted out. Let the theologians argue; at least it keeps them off the streets.

But therein lies the rub, does it not?

Unless my child says, "Amen" he will go to Hell. I love him so much I don't want that to happen so I'll beat him until he says it.

The second can be responded to with the old joke about the masochist and the sadist.
 
Possibly. Or perhaps He doesn't care that much as long as the overall message gets through.
Matthew 22 said:
37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
38 This is the first and great commandment.
39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.
40 On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.

As long as my Aunt Margaret and the rest of her congregation do these, the rest can be sorted out. Let the theologians argue; at least it keeps them off the streets.


This is what makes the New Testament intolerable! In the old one you were supposed to fear God, which made some kind of sense if you consider the kind of vindictive, paranoid psychopath you were dealing with. But now you even have to love him??!
Come on, drkitten! You cannot be serious!
 
But therein lies the rub, does it not?

Not really.

There is no message that is so simple that it can't be misunderstood; for proof, I refer you to any number of threads on this board. Especially since in many cases, the misunderstanding is deliberate and people are trying, consciously or unconsciously, to twist the message to support what they had already decided they were going to do, say, or believe.

And to head you off, no, an Almighty God could not forcibly prevent free-willed humans from twisting His word. That's what "free will" means, among other things.
 
This is what makes the New Testament intolerable! In the old one you were supposed to fear God, which made some kind of sense if you consider the kind of vindictive, paranoid psychopath you were dealing with. But now you even have to love him??!
Come on, drkitten! You cannot be serious!

Aren't you running out of straw by now?
 
Not really.

There is no message that is so simple that it can't be misunderstood; for proof, I refer you to any number of threads on this board. Especially since in many cases, the misunderstanding is deliberate and people are trying, consciously or unconsciously, to twist the message to support what they had already decided they were going to do, say, or believe.

And to head you off, no, an Almighty God could not forcibly prevent free-willed humans from twisting His word. That's what "free will" means, among other things.

Well, he could, among other things, descend from the heavens and tell people to "knock that **** off", so to speak, and I don't believe that this would deny people their free will.
 
Not really.

There is no message that is so simple that it can't be misunderstood; for proof, I refer you to any number of threads on this board. Especially since in many cases, the misunderstanding is deliberate and people are trying, consciously or unconsciously, to twist the message to support what they had already decided they were going to do, say, or believe.

And to head you off, no, an Almighty God could not forcibly prevent free-willed humans from twisting His word. That's what "free will" means, among other things.

Ah. But you see, I interpret the Bible. You pervert the true words of the Holy God.

How far does one go to save a loved one who does not want to be saved? What happens when you want your hair cut but the other party does not?

These are not complicated (mis)understandings. They are differences that have set Christian against Christian and religion against religion down through the ages. It is not a question of "free will" it is a question of actions by humans on humans.

I attended a fumeral of a dear friend once and in the service the Minister quoted his 18-year old daughter as asking the (rhetorical) question, "What would the World be like if God never existed?" That set me thinking and, as far as I can tell, it would be (is) no different. Can you possibly tell me how it would be?
 
Last edited:
Death is a slow process. Perfect health is just the slowest possible way of dying.

It's called a metaphor, dude. Learn it, love it, live it --- or at least accept it.


Apologetics. You have no way of knowing what the original authors of some myth intended to convey... and it's a story... all interpretations are equally "valid"-- no matter how naive. This is not the same with evolution. Who cares who finds what deep meaning in Greek myths-- there is no "correct" interpretations. Jeez.

But even still, this apologetics fails. They didn't die-- really-- they got immortal souls that live forever and ever-- immortal souls that could be tortured forever... the opposite of actual death-- and a chance to get out of the hell dilemma.

No matter how you slice it, the god in the bible is a liar and a bastard... no matter how fancy you dress it up and claim literary license.

As multiple people have pointed out, your analogies and claims of "naive interpretation" are just spin. You can do that with any myth... it just sounds like your tap dancing around the obvious problems with the story as theists have learned to do to make it seem more "deep" and "wise" and "true".
 
As multiple people have pointed out, your analogies and claims of "naive interpretation" are just spin. You can do that with any myth... it just sounds like your tap dancing around the obvious problems with the story as theists have learned to do to make it seem more "deep" and "wise" and "true".
Read drkitten's first reply to me for the problem with this approach. I agree with you that it's all just spin, but if you don't have arguments which combat the extremes of this spin (the sophisticated theolgian's defenses), then what does it matter? If you knock down an easy target with an easy argument, and, like drkitten warns, your opponent goes off and finds that your argument has been dealt with already (however badly) by some dead saint from 500 years back, what have you gained?

If you don't attack the strongest position, people may well assume it is because you can't.
 
Last edited:
So what's the strongest argument in a myth-- other than to show it can be nothing more than a myth?

How do you address a "courtiers' reply" except to show it's a "courtier's reply".
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/12/the_courtiers_reply.php

It's just weird when someone goes on about what the bible "really meant"-- what is and isn't an "allegory" for what--because it assumes there can be some authority on the "imaginary". No one CAN be an expert on what the bible "truly means" or what god wants just as no-one can be an expert on the imaginary fabrics of the emperor's new clothes.

You don't need to be well studied in myths to understand that there can be no actual authority on what they "truly" mean. It's like claiming that someone who studied astrology for years actualyl knows something about the way the planetary alignment influences humans! I don't have to be an expert in planet alignment to understand that no one else is an expert on astrological influences either.

All creation stories can be retrofitted as parables to correspond with reality after the fact. We can always say, "yeah, but the true meaning is...." or "Nostradamus' statement of xyz, was clearly a prophesy of Q".

You may as well claim to be an expert on the really true true meaning of Aesop's fables.
 
Last edited:
I was trying to put the tree of knowledge story in the most literal terms possible.
There are other ways to look at it.
If you want to see it in a metaphorical light, you can.
The fallen angels can represent the affects of sin reaching into all aspects of creation, even to the point of bringing down the most powerful beings in it.
When they are cast out of heaven, that could represent earth and heaven being restored to the condition that it enjoyed, before the entrance of evil.

That is my point, it shows that christians believe their myths, they do not think them through, for if a being was create to be completely obedient to their god, why would it suddenly rebel. If their god is all power and all knowing, and Lucifer is suppose to be the smartest of all angels, then why rebel against a being that you know you cannot fight against much less win against. In any myth, there is grand holes of reason that the apologists of the religion cannot answer.
 
You don't need to be well studied in myths to understand that there can be no actual authority on what they "truly" mean. It's like claiming that someone who studied astrology for years actual knows something about the way the planetary alignment influences humans! I don't have to be an expert in planet alignment to understand that no one else is an expert on panetary alignment astrological influences either.
Whether anyone can be an authority on what the Bible really means is completely beside the point. What matters is whether anyone believes another to be such an authority. If Aunt Margaret believes Father O'Murphy to be an expert at Biblical interpretation, then it does not matter that you can batter Marge's defenses. You better hope your arguments are up to snuff for Murph, because Marge certainly thinks his arguments are good.
 
Yeah... my brother wanted me to talk to his priest regarding some Catholic teaching-- I said, "Great, and then I can talk to the Mormon prophet to find out if what his religion's "truth" is... and then I'll learn all about "suppressive people" and "thetans" from Tom Cruise".

I think it's funny that people go to experts on things they can't really have "expertise" in to tell them what to "believe" and why and what it all means.

Sure, I can learn all about what the lines on my palm mean from studying books on palmistry--but that doesn't mean the lines on my palm actually have any meaning or "predictive value".

I ridicule the argument to show that the argument is the equivalent of the courtier's reply-- it claims expertise on a subject that no one can have expertise in... there are no experts on the "supernatural". The arguments fail because they are built on a faulty premise anyhow... people run around looking for truth value in such statements don't make the statements more "true" or lend support to the underlying premise (whether it's writings inspired by gods or lines on one's hand revealing deep truths about someone.)

Dr. Kittens explanations are on par with the verbiage of imagined experts in palmistry, are they not? You can know what all the lines are supposed to mean-- but it doesn't mean that they MEAN anything at all.
 
The implication from reading the Bible is that eating once from the Tree of Life ensures eternal life. The implication in the Bible is also that Adam and Eve had not yet eaten from it. We must, therefore, assume that they were mortal, in which case eating from the Tree of Knowledge did not result in suddenly being mortal, and thus God's statement that they would die if they ate from it is at best totally dishonest, and at worst an outright lie.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom