bokonon
Illuminator
- Joined
- Aug 30, 2007
- Messages
- 4,438
Since I was born with a working brain, and acquired the ability to read and to reason. You?And, um, since when are you qualified to hold an opinion?
A&E are clearly being punished. They are denied eternal life, and forced to labor instead of idle in idyllic paradise.You think A&E are being punished -- my niece thinks she's being punished. Neither of you are necessarily in possession of all the facts.
2000 years of spin doctoring doesn't necessarily convert nonsense into sense. If you have encountered a compelling argument in your studies of theological writings, feel free to prop it up here.Dig deeper. In this case, there are something like 2000 years of theological writings on this particular subject.
They ARE consequences, but they're consequences of an act of will rather than a force of nature. In this case, god's act of will is to punish A&E for their disobedience.Since when are indirect consequences not consequences?
Nothing has changed about the garden. The only change has been in the minds of A&E: they have become ashamed to be naked. They have donned clothes. Problem solved.By discovering the concept of bad stuff, unhappiness has entered the Garden of Eden, basically wrecking it. More importantly, disobedience has entered the garden of Eden, making it no longer safe for A&E to be there.
Rather than reward their initiative, god chooses to punish them.
The "real version" I'm referencing is in the bible. If there is some problem in the translation, I apologize for not reading Greek. There is no sophisticated theological arguments in my edition, but again, if you have something you regard as convincing, bring it on.You don't have to accept the traditional narrative, but for Pete's sake at least learn the real version of it. There is a strong tendency on this forum for people to post the most ridiculously straw-man versions of quite sophisticated theological arguments and then laugh at them.
Yeah, and when I ground my kids, that's preventative -- it prevents them from going to the movies. It's still a punishment. In the case of Genesis, what is being prevented is eternal life, and effortless pleasure. Where I come from, we'd consider that a punishment, but maybe we're not as "sophisticated" as you doctor types.Gumboot has it at least partly right -- banishment from the Garden was not punitive, but preventative (it even says so in the Book).
One can accomplish the same thing by banishing the Tree of Life from the garden.
Well, if you put it on the moon, you wouldn't have had to worry about men getting their hands on it until the 1960s, at the earliest. If you put it on Pluto, it would probably be safe for awhile longer. Stick it in "a galaxy far, far away" and it would likely be safe forever. Would that be too unsophisticated?Where do you put it, then?
And while we're on the subject of "where," tell me: where can I go on Google Earth to get a peek at that flaming sword that turns this way and that to prevent us from sneaking back in?
Sorry to voice another opinion, but I disagree that unhappiness had demonstrably already entered the garden. A&E weren't unhappy, they were just ashamed to be seen naked (and they'd already solved that problem). I'm not unhappy when I wear clothes, and I see no reason to assume that they were. Unless there is some other indication of unhappiness that my lack of sophistication has overlooked, I think your case is a little weak on evidence.Given that unhappiness had (demonstrably) already entered the Garden when A&E were banished, it would no longer have been "Edenic" even if they were permitted to stay.