Tree of Knowledge = "Knowing Stuff is Bad." Do Xtians realize this?

I disagree,

Your disagreement is noted, and ignored.

and as pointed out the shame was promptly dealt with anyway.

Covering up a problem is not dealing with it. The problem is that after eating the fruit, it is now possible for A&E to feel unhappy --- the Garden is no longer Edenic, because they are no longer guaranteed blissful happiness in it. Even if A&E are now wearing clothes, they now get the joys of worry (which is another thing that makes people "unhappy") about whether or not their clothes will fall off or open and reveal to much, and so forth.
 
To be fair, the tree was knowledge of good and evil, which in my armchair theology saddled humanity with knowing the difference and therefore being responsible for their own actions.
Yes, it is fundamental that it is the tree of the knowledge of good and evil - mean something entirely distinct from mere "knowledge".
 
They end up dying, one way or another. I do not see it so much as a deception, but an omission of how it was going to be enforced.

Come on!

- You'll die if you eat those red berries!
- No, I won't! It's a redcurrant bush! See? I just ate a handful, and they did not harm me!
- OK, do you see this gun?!!
 
Come on!

- You'll die if you eat those red berries!
- No, I won't! It's a redcurrant bush! See? I just ate a handful, and they did not harm me!
- OK, do you see this gun?!!

Sorry but that made me seriously laugh!

The whole Eden story is very disturbing. It has to come out making God look like a bad guy. What I like to say is that we exist because we are descended from those two poor people. So, lets be happy that they lived long enough to have children.
 
Interesting. Also prompts the thought that the search for the Philosopher's Stone, which could also be used IIRC to prolong life indefinitely, may have been inspired by this part of the Bible? No doubt someone with a bit more historical knowledge can confirm/refute this?

I think that the mere knowledge of the apparent inevitability of death and the subsequent longing for being the master of your own life and death makes you come up with all kinds of fairytales of things, procedures etc. to prolong life, if possible indefinitely, with or without the mortal coil ...

For this reason I think that the theme is probably eternal:

Philip José Farmer: Riverworld and World of Tiers
Larry Niven: Several books about boosterspice or similar stuff, for instance Ringworld and A World out of Time
Arthur C. Clarke: e.g. 2001 or Childhood’s End
Greg Bear: Blood Music
William Gibson: Neuromancer
Hollywood: Cocoon, Highlander etc.

Woo! Transhumanism!

For ever young, I want to be for ever young ...
 
It has to come out making God look like a bad guy.

I think that it's worse than that, actually! This god actually is a very bad guy, and we are supposed to obey him because he's omnipotent.
Jesus is a kind of rebel against this attitude - within the framework of religion. He changes the psychopathic god of original sin into a god of forgiveness and love-thy-neighbour, which is quite an accomplishment!
If you are a fan of the originial vindictive psycho, you interpret the story of Jesus as just another addition to the original sin: Now we're not only sinners, we've also killed the son of God!
If you are a fan of the Jesus god, however, you tend to feel embarrassed about his origins and reinterpret (or try to forget about) the stories of Adam and Eve, Abraham and Isaac etc: Jesus died for our sins, so we are no longer sinners and the god is so good that he actually sacrificed his own son to save us. In a weird psychological sense that is actually a giant step forward!
 
Last edited:
Covering up a problem is not dealing with it.
They aren't covering up the problem, they're solving it. Naughty bits exposed = shame; naughty bits covered = problem solved.

The problem is that after eating the fruit, it is now possible for A&E to feel unhappy --- the Garden is no longer Edenic, because they are no longer guaranteed blissful happiness in it.
Obviously, it was possible for A&E to feel unhappy before -- they were constantly exposed to something desirable which was forbidden to them. They wanted something they couldn't have. If they had been happy with this condition, they wouldn't have eaten the fruit. The fact that both of them ate the fruit proves that it was already possible for them to be unhappy with their state. Once again, we are forced to recognize that the only thing that changed as a direct result of eating the fruit is that they experienced a temporary feeling of shame, which they quickly eliminated. Then Mr. High and Mighty showed up, and turned "unhappy" up to eleven to punish them.
 
They aren't covering up the problem, they're solving it.

No. The problem is not that they feel shame. The problem is that they now have the capacity to feel shame, a capacity which is not removed by covering up.

Obviously, it was possible for A&E to feel unhappy before -- they were constantly exposed to something desirable which was forbidden to them.

Not only is that not "obvious," it's not even necessarily true. And in traditional theology, it's definitively UNTRUE.

Here we even have psychology on our side; the "forbidden fruit" effect (where a forbidden object becomes more desirable) is well-documented to develop relatively late in childhood. For very young children, a forbidden object becomes ipso facto less desirable. (Which evolutionarily is probably a good thing, since it serves to counteract natural curiosity.)


If they had been happy with this condition, they wouldn't have eaten the fruit. The fact that both of them ate the fruit proves that it was already possible for them to be unhappy with their state.

Er, no. It was the serpent's blandishments ("temptation") that led them to eat the fruit. You don't have to be unhappy to succumb to temptations.

Again, it's all in The Book.
 
Last edited:
I think that the mere knowledge of the apparent inevitability of death and the subsequent longing for being the master of your own life and death makes you come up with all kinds of fairytales of things, procedures etc. to prolong life, if possible indefinitely, with or without the mortal coil ...

For this reason I think that the theme is probably eternal:

Philip José Farmer: Riverworld and World of Tiers
Larry Niven: Several books about boosterspice or similar stuff, for instance Ringworld and A World out of Time
Arthur C. Clarke: e.g. 2001 or Childhood’s End
Greg Bear: Blood Music
William Gibson: Neuromancer
Hollywood: Cocoon, Highlander etc.

Woo! Transhumanism!

For ever young, I want to be for ever young ...

James Blish: Cities In Flight.
 
It just occurred to me:

A couple of times I've read a text with my students, Nyambe Leaves the Earth. I only have a copy of the text, I don't know the author or the book it was taken from, so I cannot credit anybody for it.

It is an African version of Genesis, but different:

Nyambe also creates the world, including a son and his wife, but they are much more annoying than Adam and Eve! They disobey him several times, kill his other creatures, lie about it, make a racket and piss off Nyambe so much that he finally .... leaves (along with Mrs. Nyambe!).

What do you do when you don't like your children's behaviour?

Well, in this book there are no threats, no punishment. The god gets rid of the problem by removing himself from the source! If you don't like the heat, get out of the kitchen!

If I have to choose, I sure as hell prefer the African Jehova to Adam's dad!
 
I think that it's worse than that, actually! This god actually is a very bad guy, and we are supposed to obey him because he's omnipotent.
Jesus is a kind of rebel against this attitude - within the framework of religion. He changes the psychopathic god of original sin into a god of forgiveness and love-thy-neighbor, which is quite an accomplishment!
If you are a fan of the original vindictive psycho, you interpret the story of Jesus as just another addition to the original sin: Now we're not only sinners, we've also killed the son of God!
If you are a fan of the Jesus god, however, you tend to feel embarrassed about his origins and reinterpret (or try to forget about) the stories of Adam and Eve, Abraham and Isaac etc: Jesus died for our sins, so we are no longer sinners and the god is so good that he actually sacrificed his own son to save us. In a weird psychological sense that is actually a giant step forward!
I guess this is one way to look at it. The problem is that despite Jesus giving us a better face of God, we still have that vindictive God lurking about. You pass over the part of Jesus dying, rather quickly. Jesus did not die an ordinary death but had the weight of the sins of the world placed on him. He stood in the presence of the Divine Judge when the curtain of the Temple was parted. He was cast into Hell at that moment, as his spirit passed out of him.

Hebrews 10: 28 Anyone who has set aside the Law of Moses dies without mercy on the testimony of two or three witnesses.

29 How much severer punishment do you think he will deserve who has trampled under foot the Son of God, and has regarded as unclean the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified, and has insulted the Spirit of grace?


So, you still end up with the psycho God.
 
By the way, to whom did god say "Let there be light"?
To the electricians of cource, we are the worlds oldest trade.:D

Luther is pretty clear on reason and knowlede, you ARE suposed to be ignorant.
 
It was the serpent's blandishments ("temptation") that led them to eat the fruit. You don't have to be unhappy to succumb to temptations.

Again, it's all in The Book.
If it's something that's clearly harmful (jump off this cliff), "temptation" isn't going to do it. In order to succumb to temptation, their unhappiness over being denied the fruit must overcome the happiness they derive by their obedience to god. Whether this was a fleeting feeling, or a gnawing ache, it's clear that they'd already experienced dissatisfaction (unhappiness) before fruit passed lips.
 
They aren't covering up the problem, they're solving it. Naughty bits exposed = shame; naughty bits covered = problem solved.


Obviously, it was possible for A&E to feel unhappy before -- they were constantly exposed to something desirable which was forbidden to them. They wanted something they couldn't have. If they had been happy with this condition, they wouldn't have eaten the fruit. The fact that both of them ate the fruit proves that it was already possible for them to be unhappy with their state. Once again, we are forced to recognize that the only thing that changed as a direct result of eating the fruit is that they experienced a temporary feeling of shame, which they quickly eliminated. Then Mr. High and Mighty showed up, and turned "unhappy" up to eleven to punish them.

I like this response. Though I see DrK has managed to come up with a convoluted response as to why it is not true. :boggled:
 
No. The problem is not that they feel shame. The problem is that they now have the capacity to feel shame, a capacity which is not removed by covering up.



Not only is that not "obvious," it's not even necessarily true. And in traditional theology, it's definitively UNTRUE.

Here we even have psychology on our side; the "forbidden fruit" effect (where a forbidden object becomes more desirable) is well-documented to develop relatively late in childhood. For very young children, a forbidden object becomes ipso facto less desirable. (Which evolutionarily is probably a good thing, since it serves to counteract natural curiosity.)




Er, no. It was the serpent's blandishments ("temptation") that led them to eat the fruit. You don't have to be unhappy to succumb to temptations.

Again, it's all in The Book.

My bolding. Fair enough, but surely you have to have knowledge that it is Evil to do so and for that you have to have eaten from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil.

:confused:
 
Eating a piece of fruit is "clearly harmful"?
No, and that's part of the point. It's booby trapped. It's telling your kids not to eat the candy, lacing it with cyanide, and leaving it on a table next to the comfy chair in front of the TV. Then, you leave a babysitter in charge, who (in loco parentis) says "Go ahead, we won't tell your folks."

It's a simple test of obedience, and A&E have been primed for failure. The tree was provided by God, the woman was provided by God (interestingly, she wasn't even created until AFTER God told Adam not to eat the fruit, so she may have only been disobeying Adam's hearsay account), the serpent was provided by God. It's absurd to read this as anything but allegory, but if we're going to treat it as history, let's look at what's written.
 
Covering up a problem is not dealing with it. The problem is that after eating the fruit, it is now possible for A&E to feel unhappy --- the Garden is no longer Edenic, because they are no longer guaranteed blissful happiness in it. Even if A&E are now wearing clothes, they now get the joys of worry (which is another thing that makes people "unhappy") about whether or not their clothes will fall off or open and reveal to much, and so forth.


This is entirely nonsensical. "Feeling unhappy" and "knowing right and wrong" are not the same thing.

Eating the fruit did not give them the ability to feel unhappy, it gave them the ability to distinguish right from wrong. If they had the ability to feel unhappy, it existed before they ate the fruit, therefore it was already in the garden.

AS for unhappiness...

After God made Adam he foresaw approaching unhappiness - it wasn't good for Adam to be alone and he needed a helper. So instead of declare unhappiness was unacceptable and banish Adam, he brought all of the animals to Adam to choose a helper. And Adam couldn't find an acceptable helper (you tell me if looking through every single animal on the planet for a helper to keep you company would make you "unhappy"?)

So in this dire situation of unhappiness was Adam banished? No. God fixed the problem and provided a helper for him - Eve.

The story of the Fall of Eden clearly illustrates that God is:
A) A Liar
B) A Bastard
C) A hypocrite
D) Incompetent
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom