ElMondoHummus
0.25 short of being half-witted
Requesting info regarding details of Twin Towers construction:
Nearly all of us know about the ferrous microspheres with oxygen content that Jones has been touting. One of my counterarguments against this is that one of many possible alternate sources for such spheres is oxyacetylene welding (specifically joining, not cutting welding). In such a technique, an additional oxygen stream is added1 (thus accounting for Jones's argument against welding, as he based his dismissal on the comparison of oxygen content against samples from cutting welds).
Now, contrast oxyacetylene welding with a technique that I had not known about before: Electric arc welding. In that method, steps are taken to prevent the contamination of the weld with oxygen; specifically, a component of the welding electrode is covered in a material which evaporates into a gas and keeps air away from the molten bead of the weld until the slag hardens and protects it. So, compare and contrast: Oxyacetylene welding adds oxygen, arc welding does its best to exclude it. Jones's compared his microspheres against oxyacetylene cutting samples, where oxygen is not added, and it showed an oxygenation difference between the two. His spheres had a higher one than the cutting samples did. Now because of that, it is a logical assumption that arc welding - a technique that goes out of its way to exclude oxygen - would at worst show comparable levels of oxygenation in microspheres to acetylene cutting samples, if not lower.
So, the question is to what degree arc and oxyacetelyne welding was used in the Towers construction. In trying to determine that, I discovered this:
Characterization of Submerged Arc Welds from the World Trade Center Towers (Note: PDF file)
Granted, it doesn't say that all the welding done was arc welding; that doc specifically identifies the joining of "steel plates composing the built-up box coumns". But, I'm still batting zero as far as discovering the extent of oxyacetylene welding as opposed to arc welding that was used. Does anyone have any idea to what extent one technique of welding is used over another? The answer can be in regards to construction in general as well as about the Twin Towers specifically. I ask because I may have to discard one of my arguments if it turns out that oxyacetylene welding was not done in significant enough amounts to account for the ferrous microspheres. Granted, that doesn't falsify the other possible sources, but if one of my counterarguments is wrong, it's wrong, and I should discard it.
I'm hoping Crazy Chainsaw will have something to say about this, as he's spoken up on welding before, but I'm casting this question out broadly. I have zilch knowledge of welding.
As a separate but related issue: Would anyone have an idea of the oxygenation levels of microparticles generated by arc welding, and an idea of how that compares against oxyacetylene welding? I'm of course not asking for specific quantified answers, since I'm not posing a quantitative question; rather, I'm just trying to get a general idea of whether I'm right in assuming that arc welding has significantly lower oxygenation in its generated particles as oxyacetylene welding does.
Thanks, all.
1 Additional source: http://64.78.42.182/sweethaven/BldgConst/Welding/lessonmain.asp?lesNum=4&modNum=1
Nearly all of us know about the ferrous microspheres with oxygen content that Jones has been touting. One of my counterarguments against this is that one of many possible alternate sources for such spheres is oxyacetylene welding (specifically joining, not cutting welding). In such a technique, an additional oxygen stream is added1 (thus accounting for Jones's argument against welding, as he based his dismissal on the comparison of oxygen content against samples from cutting welds).
Now, contrast oxyacetylene welding with a technique that I had not known about before: Electric arc welding. In that method, steps are taken to prevent the contamination of the weld with oxygen; specifically, a component of the welding electrode is covered in a material which evaporates into a gas and keeps air away from the molten bead of the weld until the slag hardens and protects it. So, compare and contrast: Oxyacetylene welding adds oxygen, arc welding does its best to exclude it. Jones's compared his microspheres against oxyacetylene cutting samples, where oxygen is not added, and it showed an oxygenation difference between the two. His spheres had a higher one than the cutting samples did. Now because of that, it is a logical assumption that arc welding - a technique that goes out of its way to exclude oxygen - would at worst show comparable levels of oxygenation in microspheres to acetylene cutting samples, if not lower.
So, the question is to what degree arc and oxyacetelyne welding was used in the Towers construction. In trying to determine that, I discovered this:
Characterization of Submerged Arc Welds from the World Trade Center Towers (Note: PDF file)
The fillet welds joining the various steel plates composing the built-up box columns were primarily deposited using submerged arc welding.
Granted, it doesn't say that all the welding done was arc welding; that doc specifically identifies the joining of "steel plates composing the built-up box coumns". But, I'm still batting zero as far as discovering the extent of oxyacetylene welding as opposed to arc welding that was used. Does anyone have any idea to what extent one technique of welding is used over another? The answer can be in regards to construction in general as well as about the Twin Towers specifically. I ask because I may have to discard one of my arguments if it turns out that oxyacetylene welding was not done in significant enough amounts to account for the ferrous microspheres. Granted, that doesn't falsify the other possible sources, but if one of my counterarguments is wrong, it's wrong, and I should discard it.
I'm hoping Crazy Chainsaw will have something to say about this, as he's spoken up on welding before, but I'm casting this question out broadly. I have zilch knowledge of welding.
As a separate but related issue: Would anyone have an idea of the oxygenation levels of microparticles generated by arc welding, and an idea of how that compares against oxyacetylene welding? I'm of course not asking for specific quantified answers, since I'm not posing a quantitative question; rather, I'm just trying to get a general idea of whether I'm right in assuming that arc welding has significantly lower oxygenation in its generated particles as oxyacetylene welding does.
Thanks, all.
1 Additional source: http://64.78.42.182/sweethaven/BldgConst/Welding/lessonmain.asp?lesNum=4&modNum=1