Regarding welds used in construction of the Twin Towers

ElMondoHummus

0.25 short of being half-witted
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
12,288
Location
Somewhere north of the South Pole
Requesting info regarding details of Twin Towers construction:

Nearly all of us know about the ferrous microspheres with oxygen content that Jones has been touting. One of my counterarguments against this is that one of many possible alternate sources for such spheres is oxyacetylene welding (specifically joining, not cutting welding). In such a technique, an additional oxygen stream is added1 (thus accounting for Jones's argument against welding, as he based his dismissal on the comparison of oxygen content against samples from cutting welds).

Now, contrast oxyacetylene welding with a technique that I had not known about before: Electric arc welding. In that method, steps are taken to prevent the contamination of the weld with oxygen; specifically, a component of the welding electrode is covered in a material which evaporates into a gas and keeps air away from the molten bead of the weld until the slag hardens and protects it. So, compare and contrast: Oxyacetylene welding adds oxygen, arc welding does its best to exclude it. Jones's compared his microspheres against oxyacetylene cutting samples, where oxygen is not added, and it showed an oxygenation difference between the two. His spheres had a higher one than the cutting samples did. Now because of that, it is a logical assumption that arc welding - a technique that goes out of its way to exclude oxygen - would at worst show comparable levels of oxygenation in microspheres to acetylene cutting samples, if not lower.

So, the question is to what degree arc and oxyacetelyne welding was used in the Towers construction. In trying to determine that, I discovered this:

Characterization of Submerged Arc Welds from the World Trade Center Towers (Note: PDF file)


The fillet welds joining the various steel plates composing the built-up box columns were primarily deposited using submerged arc welding.​

Granted, it doesn't say that all the welding done was arc welding; that doc specifically identifies the joining of "steel plates composing the built-up box coumns". But, I'm still batting zero as far as discovering the extent of oxyacetylene welding as opposed to arc welding that was used. Does anyone have any idea to what extent one technique of welding is used over another? The answer can be in regards to construction in general as well as about the Twin Towers specifically. I ask because I may have to discard one of my arguments if it turns out that oxyacetylene welding was not done in significant enough amounts to account for the ferrous microspheres. Granted, that doesn't falsify the other possible sources, but if one of my counterarguments is wrong, it's wrong, and I should discard it.

I'm hoping Crazy Chainsaw will have something to say about this, as he's spoken up on welding before, but I'm casting this question out broadly. I have zilch knowledge of welding.

As a separate but related issue: Would anyone have an idea of the oxygenation levels of microparticles generated by arc welding, and an idea of how that compares against oxyacetylene welding? I'm of course not asking for specific quantified answers, since I'm not posing a quantitative question; rather, I'm just trying to get a general idea of whether I'm right in assuming that arc welding has significantly lower oxygenation in its generated particles as oxyacetylene welding does.

Thanks, all.

1 Additional source: http://64.78.42.182/sweethaven/BldgConst/Welding/lessonmain.asp?lesNum=4&modNum=1
 
I've done a lot of welding in my life, though not certified. I've personally welded steel up to 2" thickness. Takes a lot of juice and you get a real nice sunburn if you don't wear long sleeves.

Gas welding is only appropriate for thin steel, say 12 ga - 1/8" - or less.

All the welding on the columns were arc welded. Anything else would be wildly inefficient and wouldn't penetrate worth a damn.
 
In the 60's?
Most welds on the jobsite would likely have been "stick" welds--
or most people know it as "arc Welding"
yeah, there's a coating on the "stick", or weld metal, but it doesn't exclude all the oxygen.
That's why we (now) use TIG or MIG on precision stuff. Wasn't all that available, back then--and it is not all that great in the field on the really thick stuff
 
I have have never myself witnessed oxyacetylene or gas welding on a construction site. It is almost always electric arc stick welded with flux coated rods. Then you chip off the slag on the weld with a welders chipping hammer when you burn each new rod. You will see MIG welding for close up work like railings and details or automated welding in the shop. I have given myself welders burn on my arms a few times.
 
Ah. Okay. That pretty much decides it, then: Oxyacetylene welding is certainly not a technique widely used in the construction of the Twin Towers, so I need to discard that argument. Granted, that doesn't falsify all welding as being a source for his microspheres - after all, Jones did find what, 3 different and distinct compositions, something like that? - nor does it even address, let alone falsify all the alternate sources for such particles. But it does mean that I've been wrong in previous arguments, and I need to stop making that point about oxyacetylene welding. From what you guys said, the amount of times such a technique was used is probably utterly dwarfed by the amount of times arc welding was.

Thanks for the information, everyone. That's exactly what I needed.
 
I was going to add to rwguinn's post with regard to welding, but didn't have the time. However, I'll briefly add my 2p/2c. I'd be extremely surprised that oxyacetylene welding was used - I approach this firstly from a practical point of view: In order for oxyacetylene to be used (for welding) then you would need individual gas bottles to be hauled to individual stations. With the amount of welding required , then this would require huge numbers of gas cylinders to be moved as opposed to an electricity supply that would be far easier to set up and utilise as the tower(s) were constructed.

Secondly, technically, it would be very difficult to achieve the desired level of penetration used by Oxyacetylene welding to achieve the required strength in such welds. SMAW (or SAW) has been around for a long time and whilst it does not guarantee an oxygen-free weld considering the technology at the time of construction (and present), it does guarantee a level of oxygen content within the weld significantly lower than OA welding given a competent welder. This process would have been widely used as it was in other areas of heavy engineering; such as ship building etc as it continues to be.

There's no reason to believe that Oxyacetylene welding was not used in the construction, but this use would be limited compared with SMAW.

I'm not completely familiar with this "micro-sphere particle argument" which is just as well. I'd rather simply look at the evidence provided and not know of the ins and outs.

From what I can gather this is something to do with "iron rich" particles/particulates.
Can anyone point me in the direction of a paper with the analysis? Thanks.
 
You got the oxygen comsumption in oxyacetylene welding/cutting the wrong way around.

When welding/soldering you use a flame with slight surplus of gas to avoid oxygenating the material you are working on.

When cutting you use a different nozle, the flame heats the iron redhot, then you depress a lever on top to open for ekstra oxygen flow.
That ekstra flow is rather noisy and will burn the iron (or maybe the coal in it). The result is a hole/line and alot of hot slags.

I agree on next to no use of oa welding in building the towers.
 
SMAW processes would have definitely been used during he 60’s…and given that much of the onsite fabrication or assembly of the towers was done out in the elements oxygen contamination in the deposited material would not be a surprise at all. Electrodes (I’m assuming a 7018 electrode was used for onsite stick welding) absorb moisture from the air contaminating the weld puddle and the micro spheres unless some fairly strict rules are followed. Another relevant fact about welding with stick (assuming a 7018 electrode) is that the flux coating of the rod has iron in it for increased deposition rates.

Has anyone considered the possibility of air arcing or gouging as a source for iron rich micro spheres? This process uses a carbon or graphite electrode with a hole in the middle that allows air to be forced through it at a high enough pressure to remove the molten puddle. Air arc is used in edge preparation during the fabrication process (in other words it’s used to remove a wedge of material to facilitate deeper or complete penetration). Welds that fail visual inspection would either be ground out by mechanical means or air arced to base metal (air arcing being the most efficient in terms of time and consumable costs).

Rwguinn mentioned Mig (GMAW) in a previous post as well. It’s at least a possibility that some of the prefabricated components were fit together and tacked using this process before shipping to site. I mention this as relevant because mig welding uses what’s called a spray transfer of material where a solid metal wire is literally melted then sprayed onto the base metal in a protective gas environment. The problem with mig is that improper setting of gas pressures and/or gusts of wind can affect the protective gases in such a way that oxygen contamination is highly probable.

So in short, SMAW and air arcing are good possibilities for sources of iron rich micro spheres with traces of sulfur and aluminum (all three of the elements are inherent to the base and consumable materials). Mig, not so much…but possible.
 
I was going to add to rwguinn's post with regard to welding, but didn't have the time. However, I'll briefly add my 2p/2c. I'd be extremely surprised that oxyacetylene welding was used - I approach this firstly from a practical point of view: In order for oxyacetylene to be used (for welding) then you would need individual gas bottles to be hauled to individual stations. With the amount of welding required , then this would require huge numbers of gas cylinders to be moved as opposed to an electricity supply that would be far easier to set up and utilise as the tower(s) were constructed.

Secondly, technically, it would be very difficult to achieve the desired level of penetration used by Oxyacetylene welding to achieve the required strength in such welds. SMAW (or SAW) has been around for a long time and whilst it does not guarantee an oxygen-free weld considering the technology at the time of construction (and present), it does guarantee a level of oxygen content within the weld significantly lower than OA welding given a competent welder. This process would have been widely used as it was in other areas of heavy engineering; such as ship building etc as it continues to be.

There's no reason to believe that Oxyacetylene welding was not used in the construction, but this use would be limited compared with SMAW.

I'm not completely familiar with this "micro-sphere particle argument" which is just as well. I'd rather simply look at the evidence provided and not know of the ins and outs.

From what I can gather this is something to do with "iron rich" particles/particulates.
Can anyone point me in the direction of a paper with the analysis? Thanks.

Thanks for the info. Jones's paper can be found here:
http://journalof911studies.com/articles/WTCHighTemp.pdf

... and we had a thread about it here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=104926

Jones's argument about his microspheres sums up thusly: Iron rich microspheres found in dust immediately following the collapse of the towers disproves the NIST model of the temperature ranges in the fires. The specific microspheres could have only formed under certain conditions leading to the melting of steel and the evaporation of other elements discovered to be a component of the microspheres. Temperatures associated with jet fuel and office content combustion can not only not explain the formation, but cannot explain the characteristics of these particles as well.

---------------

I need to thank you for posting something that prompted me to look at the paper once again. I just noticed that I had completely misremembered and inverted Jones's characterization of the microspheres oxygen content. That's a bad screwup. To wit, here's one of his paragraphs:

Extremely high temperatures during the World Trade Center destruction said:
The RJ Lee report also provides a micrograph and XEDS data for iron-rich spheres observed in the WTC dust; for example, their figure 21 (below, left) shows an “SEM image and EDS of spherical iron particle [1].” We likewise observe high-iron, relatively low oxygen spheres (e.g., below right and Fig. 4), which we find are unlike spheres gathered from cutting structural steel with an oxyacetylene torch.​

So, GAAAACK! There's a perfect example of how I'm going senile and misremembering things. Anyway, you all can tell from the OP that I had thought I remembered his characterizations of the spheres as having relatively high oxygen content. He actually said the opposite. I'm really glad I brought this up now because this thread is correcting my misapprehensions regarding welding and its relation to the microspheres Jones discusses. Anyway, that calls for a starting-over on how we consider how welding is a possible source for the spherules:

Jones characterizes his microsphers as having "relatively low oxygen" content. He contrasts that to spheres gathered from oxyacetylene cutting, which are relatively higher in O2.

So does that exclude any sort of welding at all? Let's recall Toke's correction of my mischaracterization above:

You got the oxygen comsumption in oxyacetylene welding/cutting the wrong way around.

When welding/soldering you use a flame with slight surplus of gas to avoid oxygenating the material you are working on.

When cutting you use a different nozle, the flame heats the iron redhot, then you depress a lever on top to open for ekstra oxygen flow.
That ekstra flow is rather noisy and will burn the iron (or maybe the coal in it). The result is a hole/line and alot of hot slags.

So sure, cutting involves extra oxygen. But welding does not. However, OA welding is not a reasonable consideration given the relative dearth of usage during heavy construction, so oxyacetylene welding is out. But, since we're talking about low O2 content, that does still allow for arc welding to be a source. As noted above, such welding does not totally exclude oxygen, but it sure does cut down on the content. So, shielded arc welding (saw/smaw), tungsten arc welding (TIG/GTAW), and other sorts of welding that was presumably used during the construction of the Twin Towers is still a valid source for such microspheres (I'll let you guys tell me which ones were actually in use back when the towers were built). Jones's comparison of his microspheres to OA cutting particles is a red herring given that such a technique introduces additional oxygen. The real comparison would be against microspheres generated by arc welding.

Also, comparisons should be made to spheres generated by processes other than welding. People can go back and look up previous threads on that topic, but the act of diesel engines just running would also create ferrous microspheres. And, no consideration of spheres from the fly ash constituent of concrete has been made. But, all that's outside the scope of this thread. I'm merely considering whether welding could be one of the many possible sources of such spheres. I still believe it can be.
 
Last edited:
SMAW processes would have definitely been used during he 60’s…and given that much of the onsite fabrication or assembly of the towers was done out in the elements oxygen contamination in the deposited material would not be a surprise at all. Electrodes (I’m assuming a 7018 electrode was used for onsite stick welding) absorb moisture from the air contaminating the weld puddle and the micro spheres unless some fairly strict rules are followed. Another relevant fact about welding with stick (assuming a 7018 electrode) is that the flux coating of the rod has iron in it for increased deposition rates.

Has anyone considered the possibility of air arcing or gouging as a source for iron rich micro spheres? This process uses a carbon or graphite electrode with a hole in the middle that allows air to be forced through it at a high enough pressure to remove the molten puddle. Air arc is used in edge preparation during the fabrication process (in other words it’s used to remove a wedge of material to facilitate deeper or complete penetration). Welds that fail visual inspection would either be ground out by mechanical means or air arced to base metal (air arcing being the most efficient in terms of time and consumable costs).

Rwguinn mentioned Mig (GMAW) in a previous post as well. It’s at least a possibility that some of the prefabricated components were fit together and tacked using this process before shipping to site. I mention this as relevant because mig welding uses what’s called a spray transfer of material where a solid metal wire is literally melted then sprayed onto the base metal in a protective gas environment. The problem with mig is that improper setting of gas pressures and/or gusts of wind can affect the protective gases in such a way that oxygen contamination is highly probable.

So in short, SMAW and air arcing are good possibilities for sources of iron rich micro spheres with traces of sulfur and aluminum (all three of the elements are inherent to the base and consumable materials). Mig, not so much…but possible.

Good information. I really can't comment too deeply on it, since I'm a welding ignoramus, but I think contributions like this show just how possible alternate explanations for how spheres with the characteristics Jones describes could be generated mundanely, and without resort to stupidities like "highly energetic nanoparticles". To answer your question directly: No, I have not personally seen any mention of air arc welding being proposed as a possible source for the spheres. I've only heard of welding in general, not that specific method in particular, as being possible sources, as well as the other ones I noted above.

Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Arc welding splatter is small droplets of iron. The welding proces itself concist of small droplets traveling from electrode (stick) to material through the spark.

I dont think it is relevant what happened during construction.

Steel wool will burn if exposed to a butane lighter.
The collapse involved alot of energi, could the ends of steel collums have scaped against each other, producing dust?
Is jones number of 5,87% fe in dust acccurate?
 
You have the completely wrong approach. Collect some dust from comparable locations and see what you find...
 
Arc welding splatter is small droplets of iron. The welding proces itself concist of small droplets traveling from electrode (stick) to material through the spark.

I dont think it is relevant what happened during construction.

Steel wool will burn if exposed to a butane lighter.
The collapse involved alot of energi, could the ends of steel collums have scaped against each other, producing dust?
Is jones number of 5,87% fe in dust acccurate?
Just read through that pdf (Extremely high temperatures during the World Trade Center destruction), and on first impression it's a poorly thought out and structured paper. I would certainly be told by my colleagues and peers to redo it if I had produced such a paper. There is data in there, but it's not very well presented or argued. I'll have a more detailed response when I have more time to look at it, but there are some major flaws in their thinking given the data available.

A WTC dust sample acquired at 130 Liberty Street shows a “mean of composition” of “Fe
spheres” of 5.87% which is very high compared with “Fe spheres” found in ordinary building dust of only
0.04%
Page 4.

This is not "spheres show an Fe content of 5.87%", but Fe (rich) spheres make up 5.87% of the dust collected. (compared with "ordinary" building dust, whatever that is). Ordinary building dust wouldn't contain dust from the collapsed building would it!

Their argument goes; we find theses spheres in the dust. Spheres need very high temperatures to form (higher than melting point of steel), higher than what the fires could produce if @1000°C is taken as maximum fire temperature. Concludes that spheres where produced in the event and collapse. Hypes this as fact and asks for this process to be understood so as to save future lives.
 
Yes, Sunstealer, that's all correct. The paper is poorly done. I find his argument overly credulous myself, especially in that he locks in on only one possible source for the spheres.

Jones may have tied the spheres to the towers, but he didn't even try to tie them to the collapse. He merely took for granted that's when they formed and launched his argument from there (I'm torn between thinking Jones honestly believes this, or that he intentionally glossed over the obvious hole in his argument firm in the belief that conspiracy addicts would buy it; I really don't know for certain). As many here have pointed out, there's zero proof that the spheres were created during the collapse, or during supposed events causing the collapse (i.e. thermite), and ample opportunity for such to have been created either during construction, or have accumulated from brake dust, diesel emissions, and other spherule-causing sources over the decades the towers stood. That, by the way Smackety, was why I would have liked to have seen comparisons against particles generated by other methods like arc welding: I would have liked to have seen how they match up with those mundane sources.

At any rate, there are more leaps in Jones's argument than in the Olympic's Triple Jump event. But his work is quality compared to other conspiratorial theses.
 
What quantity of steel would have to be turned into microspheres to increase the concentration of iron-rich ones in dust from 0.04% to 5.87% in the radius determined by where Jones took his samples? Even assuming all his leaps are somehow correct, I don't think there was enough steel in the towers.
 
I came across this post the other day.

Thanks RedIbis....

I am not questioning Jones' data, I am questioning his interpretation of said data.

You need to take a look at Volume III of the famous "Particle Atlas" by Walter McCrone. This provides scanning electron micrographs and EDX spectra for thousands of common materials. The section from pages 760 - 780 is most interesting since it shows flyash microspheres from large domestic waste incinerators burning paper, wood and plastics as well as flyash from coal-fired furnaces. The EDX spectra show major peaks from Al, Si, K, Ca, and Fe together with smaller peaks from Ti, S and Cl.

Jones' spectra are a perfect match for FLY ASH!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3269290#post3269290

which is where I was going to head next, i.e that there wouldn't be enough spheres produced by welding (or thermite) to account for the higher concentration and therefore it would be logical to look elsewhere, namely the materials that the buildings were constructed from. "Iron microspheres" as part of flyash which is used as a constituent in cement would be a very good source and explain why "office dust" would contain so low a concentration of "Iron microspheres" in comparison.

Flyash has been used in concrete for most of the 20th century http://www.ukqaa.org.uk/Papers/AshTechA01ChangesInCoalFiredPowerStationJonesEtAl.pdf
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom