Would you pray to Satan to save your child?

:eek: Yipers!... epistemic determinism: the paradox of God's foreknowledge and free will.

Notwithstanding, do you speak up? On J-Day, would you be willing to go to hell as an act of protest for Mr. Big's sending your friends & family to hell?

Well, I've never quite understood what my condition is when I am resurrected. I know that my body is supposed to be healed so that any pain or deformity is gone, but what knowledge and abilities do I have? Do I know everything I ever knew before alzheimers set in, or more? Are my logical faculties what they were at my peak, or are they now perfect along with my perfect body? For example, those little aborted embryos: are their consciousnesses hanging around with no knowledge or judgment, or are they now equal to everyone else? If they are now sentient, that would suggest that resurrected people have knowledge and reasoning skills that they never acquired during life. If this includes the knowledge of all the sins that my friends and family committed, and I now have a perfectly healed brain along with my perfect body, I will presumably come to the same conclusion that God did, that they deserve to suffer for all eternity for their horrible sins. So no protest under this set of assumptions.
 
If the dying person is an atheist, why would Satan want to cure him? He's on his way to hell, that's where Satan wants him in the end.

But God also wants him there, as it is apparently a part of His plan that the child dies. If Satan can mess with Gods plan by healing the kid, maybe it will lead more people into hell in the future. Plenty of motivation for Satan.
 
Satan can not mess with God's plan. No one can mess with God's plan. If Satan cures your kid, then God planned for that to happen.
 
Satan can not mess with God's plan. No one can mess with God's plan. If Satan cures your kid, then God planned for that to happen.

So.... what was the point of Satan again?

It sounds like you are saying that it is part of Gods plan for some people to go to hell.
 
So.... what was the point of Satan again?

It sounds like you are saying that it is part of Gods plan for some people to go to hell.

Well, what are the alternatives? People go to Hell when God's plan called for them to go to heaven? Or where people end up is not part of God's plan?
 
Jews wouldn't pray to Satan, because they generally don't believe in him. The book of Job is the only place he appears in the Jewish scriptures, and in that book, he isn't God's arch rival that he later became in Christian myth. Very, very, few Jews would consider that book to be anything other than a literary device. It is not considered to be an account of an historical event. FWIW, Catholics say the same thing about the Book of Job, although they do teach that the literary character depicted therein is meant to be an accurate depiction of the all-evil, Satan/Lucifer/Serpent/Devil familiar to Christians and those who have grown up in mainstream Christian influenced cultures.

In general, Jews would consider any prayer to Satan to be a form of idolatry, which, these days, means praying to a false god, i.e. a non-existent one, as opposed to praying to the "wrong" god. Therefore, praying to Satan, or Baal, or Asherah, would be considered by Jews to be both blasphemous and ineffective.


Also, to the OP, Catholics are Christians, so your question should not be addressed to Catholics "and" Christians.
 
Last edited:
Where did you get those ideas from?

Satan created himself via rebellion. Prior to that he was a holy angel called Lucifer of cherubim rank.

<snip>

Neither he nor his angels are provided with any domain where they can torture people. The only place rebel angels are said to be confined is tartarus and it is a prison-restricted condition of darkness mentioned in the book of Jude and humans are not described as being sent there.


Radrook,

I was responding to the following post (relevant parts bolded):


I don't think God wants lies, destruction and evil to exist. I think God wants us to have a choice between good and evil. With out there being a choice between good and evil, we are just slaves to God. Anyone could believe in God if he proved his existance. I believe in free will. I have also come to see this world as a test. If you pass you go to heavin or purgatory. If you fail you go to hell.


I understand that your interpretation of the Bible excludes hell, but many Christians (including skepticalbeliever) believe hell to be very real.

When you say Satan created himself via rebellion prior to which he was a holy angel called Lucifer, would you disagree with the following:

1. God is the creator of all things.
2. God created Lucifer.
3. God is omniscient.
4. Therefore, God knew that Lucifer would rebel and become Satan.
5. God also knew that Satan would tempt the first humans to commit sin.
6. God also knew free will would lead to humans committing sin.
7. Therefore, by creating Lucifer and by giving humans free will, God wants evil to exist.

Your comment that:

Satan created himself via rebellion. Prior to that he was a holy angel called Lucifer of cherubim rank.


would indicate that God was unaware that creating Lucifer would lead to the creation of Satan.
 
Last edited:
Well, what are the alternatives? People go to Hell when God's plan called for them to go to heaven? Or where people end up is not part of God's plan?

I'm just not sure what people are talking about when they say things about 'gods plan'.

If it really is a 'plan' than it could go wrong. If it can't go wrong then it is predestined, and thus all life has predetermined outcomes.

Or, god is constantly changing and updating the goal of his plan in order to deal with our choices. I would tend to call that 'stuff happening' and not a 'plan'
 
I'm just not sure what people are talking about when they say things about 'gods plan'.

If it really is a 'plan' than it could go wrong. If it can't go wrong then it is predestined, and thus all life has predetermined outcomes.

Or, god is constantly changing and updating the goal of his plan in order to deal with our choices. I would tend to call that 'stuff happening' and not a 'plan'

The underlying problem is that premises of Christianity as they have been explained to me are contradictory. God is supposed to have a plan that is beyond our understanding, and thus when anything bad happens we are supposed to believe it is OK since it is all part of God's plan. Yet we are also supposed to have free will and thus be responsible for our actions. I cannot reconcile the two.

We are asked to answer a question based on a system that is self-contradictory, so any answer is nonsense. It's like trying to answer the question "is a person who always lies who says he is a liar lying or telling the truth?" The only possible answer is to challenge the underlying premises of the question. Before it can be answered, the questioner has to give you a logically consistent explanation of God, satan, and their powers.
 
Well, I've never quite understood what my condition is when I am resurrected. I know that my body is supposed to be healed so that any pain or deformity is gone, but what knowledge and abilities do I have? Do I know everything I ever knew before alzheimers set in, or more? Are my logical faculties what they were at my peak, or are they now perfect along with my perfect body?

I think St. Aquinas is your authority here. In the Summa Theologica, appendix to Part 3, he goes into all this in excrutiating detail, even devoting sections to whether you will be resurrected with perfect hair and teeth (you will), or having to go to the bathroom if that was your condition at death (you won't be). I don't know that he explicitly deals with this question. Given his affinity for Aristotle, however, and Aristotle's notion of soul as the governing principle of the body, I'd say having the body restored to its prime would restore the soul, including the intellect, to its prime as well.

For example, those little aborted embryos: are their consciousnesses hanging around with no knowledge or judgment, or are they now equal to everyone else? If they are now sentient, that would suggest that resurrected people have knowledge and reasoning skills that they never acquired during life.

Again, according to Aquinas in the ST, everyone is resurrected in perfect health in the prime of youth (25?). I don't see how accelerating embryos to 25 would give them reasoning skills either, let alone basic motor skills: one might find them strewn about the resurrection venue, full-grown foetuses curled up in balls; staring, empty eyes.

If this includes the knowledge of all the sins that my friends and family committed, and I now have a perfectly healed brain along with my perfect body, I will presumably come to the same conclusion that God did, that they deserve to suffer for all eternity for their horrible sins. So no protest under this set of assumptions.

Sounds like a safe bet. Unless God expects you to behave like JC, offer to die for the sins of your fellows? This might be His final test of one's readiness for heaven. Or not. Jesus does ask followers to relinquish family ties. I'd go with protest if I had the choice; though absent several eschatological longshots I probably won't.
 
Sounds like a safe bet. Unless God expects you to behave like JC, offer to die for the sins of your fellows? This might be His final test of one's readiness for heaven. Or not. Jesus does ask followers to relinquish family ties. I'd go with protest if I had the choice; though absent several eschatological longshots I probably won't.
Jesus died for the sins of his fellows because it was God's will. According to the Apostle's creed he descended into hell for 3 days, and then was resurrected, and now sits at the right hand of God. I think I'd put up with 3 days in hell for the #2 job for all eternity. But of course, Jesus was God--not just the son of God, but an inseparable aspect of God himself. So I don't recall Jesus ever questioning God's judgment: perhaps this is the real test. Have you really given yourself up completely to God's will?
 
Radrook,

I was responding to the following post (relevant parts bolded):

Thank you for the excellent questions! Yes, I know you were responding to those comments.


I understand that your interpretation of the Bible excludes hell, but many Christians (including skeptical believer) believe hell to be very real.

Despite popular belief, the Bible isn't open to any and all interpretations whether it be from Christians or non-Christians. I can provide you with a host of interpretations which just don't fit in with the bible's message or theme and are untenable based on that.

The concept of a loving God sending people to be tortured forever is one of them because it makes him out to be some type of sadistic maniac in the eyes of people who have their moral detectors adjusted properly.

But of course if indeed that's the interpretation preferred by the skeptics on this forum that's understandable since it falls right in with their anti-biblical modus operandi. So I stand corrected.

When you say Satan created himself via rebellion prior to which he was a holy angel called Lucifer,

First, I don't say it and that's why I quoted scriptures so that I wouldn't be accused of making things up as I go along. The scriptures say it. That's a big difference.


would you disagree with the following:

1. God is the creator of all things.
2. God created Lucifer.
3. God is omniscient.
4. Therefore, God knew that Lucifer would rebel and become Satan.
5. God also knew that Satan would tempt the first humans to commit sin.
6. God also knew free will would lead to humans committing sin.
7. Therefore, by creating Lucifer and by giving humans free will, God wants evil to exist.

Your comment that:
would indicate that God was unaware that creating Lucifer would lead to the creation of Satan.

The creation of any creature with free will can lead to the abuse or misuse of free will.
It doesn't have to, especially when the creature is created perfect with no sinful tendencies
to sway him in that direction as Lucifer was.

1. God is the creator of all things.

In their original condition of goodness. Things became warped later.

2. God created Lucifer.

He created a holy angel called Lucifer.


3.God is omniscient.

He knows all that can be known. As for knowing the unknowable-or choosing to know the knowable, that's an unknown.


4. Therefore, God knew that Lucifer would rebel and become Satan.

There are three possibilities here. One is that he knew and permitted it. The second is that he didn't know because some things are unknowable even to Him. The third is that he knew about the possibility based on freedom of choice but saw it as a necessary in granting freedom of choice. The one that is biblically unsupported is the one which claims that he definitely knew the outcome and WANTED it that way.


5. God also knew that Satan would tempt the first humans to commit sin.

He might have known the possibility but free will might have made the outcome unclear. You know, as when one throws the dice and knows the statistics but beyond that the certainty can't be pinned down.

Actually, that is the consequence of creating free willed creatures unlike automatons, or creatures guided entirely by instinct-they can be unpredictable. The dilemma then is between creating unpredictable creatures and automatons. If God would prevent existence of free will in order to prevent the possibility of its misuse, then he'd be stuck with machines.

Also, the Bible indicates that Satan's efforts weren't restricted to earth. The book of Job has Satan challenging God in heaven itself before all other angels by raising issues about human motives in serving God. In short the rebellion itself posed certain challenges that needed to be met. Questions concerning God's right to rule the universe. The righteousness of his ways. The reasons why creatures choose to serve him The quality of their loyalty whether based on self interest alone or on materialism.

Such issues demanded a response. He could either obliterate the rebels, or give the rebels a chance to prove their point. Putting it down the rebellion without resolving those issues might have played right into Satan's hands since he could then say he wasn't allowed a chance because God feared to be proven wrong. So that solution wasn't tenable. Allowing it on the other hand would give God's loyal servants a chance to provide an answer to Satan's challenges. Prove him to be a liar when he stated that all men would falter or curse God to his face when tested.

Job 1:11
But put forth thine hand now, and touch all that he hath, and he will curse thee to thy face.

6. God also knew free will would lead to humans committing sin.

Might lead is a better description since perfect free-willed creatures might very well be unpredictable.


7. Therefore, by creating Lucifer and by giving humans free will, God wants evil to exist.

That's not a biblical concept. To the contrary, the Bible portrays God as being offended by sin and doing his best to wipe it out of existence. His plan for mankind is stated clearly. They should multiply fill the earth and extend the paradise worldwide as the population grew. Only

BTW
Does a king enjoy creating rebellion against himself? Or does a person surround himself with people who vilify and mock him because he WANTS to. The idea goes contrary to the personality of God and even contrary to logic itself.
 
Last edited:
The concept of a loving God sending people to be tortured forever is one of them because it makes him out to be some type of sadistic maniac in the eyes of people who have their moral detectors adjusted properly.

Nice to hear a Christian say that!

What, in your opinion, will happen to me when I die, if not hell?
 
Despite popular belief, the Bible isn't open to any and all interpretations whether it be from Christians or non-Christians. I can provide you with a host of interpretations which just don't fit in with the bible's message or theme and are untenable based on that.

The concept of a loving God sending people to be tortured forever is one of them because it makes him out to be some type of sadistic maniac in the eyes of people who have their moral detectors adjusted properly.

But of course if indeed that's the interpretation preferred by the skeptics on this forum that's understandable since it falls right in with their anti-biblical modus operandi. So I stand corrected.


I don't think skeptics prefer any particular interpretation of the Bible. I certainly don't. Skeptics respond - or at least should respond - to the interpretations presented by the varying denominations of Christian religions. Each person's arguments must be considered independently, which is why I clarified my previous post was aimed at skeptical believer.

By answering my questions though, you have given me a clearer picture of your own beliefs. Thank you.


First, I don't say it and that's why I quoted scriptures so that I wouldn't be accused of making things up as I go along. The scriptures say it. That's a big difference.


Poor choice of words on my part. I wasn't implying that you were making it up.


3.God is omniscient.

He knows all that can be known. As for knowing the unknowable-or choosing to know the knowable, that's an unknown.

There are three possibilities here. One is that he knew and permitted it. The second is that he didn't know because some things are unknowable even to Him. The third is that he knew about the possibility based on freedom of choice but saw it as a necessary in granting freedom of choice. The one that is biblically unsupported is the one which claims that he definitely knew the outcome and WANTED it that way.

He might have known the possibility but free will might have made the outcome unclear. You know, as when one throws the dice and knows the statistics but beyond that the certainty can't be pinned down.

Actually, that is the consequence of creating free willed creatures unlike automatons, or creatures guided entirely by instinct-they can be unpredictable. The dilemma then is between creating unpredictable creatures and automatons. If God would prevent existence of free will in order to prevent the possibility of its misuse, then he'd be stuck with machines.

<snip>

Might lead is a better description since perfect free-willed creatures might very well be unpredictable.


Very intriguing. Defined in wikipedia as inherent omniscience (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omniscience):

wikipedia said:
There is a distinction between:

inherent omniscience - the ability to know anything that one chooses to know and can be known

and

total omniscience - actually knowing everything that can be known.

Some modern theologians argue that God's omniscience is inherent rather than total, and that God chooses to limit his omniscience in order to preserve the freewill and dignity of his creatures. Certain theologians of the 16th Century, comfortable with the definition of God as being omniscient in the total sense, in order for worthy beings' abilities to choose freely, embraced the doctrine of predestination.


What of Jesus knowing he would be betrayed by Judas, that Peter would deny him and that he would be crucified by the Romans? This would indicate a switch to total omniscience - at least during the time of Jesus. I assume Judas and Peter had free will like the rest of us, but Jesus told them of choices they would make in the future. Does God interfere with the free will of some or does he switch between inherent and total omniscience as he so desires?
 
Last edited:
....What of Jesus knowing he would be betrayed by Judas, that Peter would deny him and that he would be crucified by the Romans? This would indicate a switch to total omniscience - at least during the time of Jesus. I assume Judas and Peter had free will like the rest of us, but Jesus told them of choices they would make in the future. Does God interfere with the free will of some or does he switch between inherent and total omniscience as he so desires?


Interference isn't necessarily an evil. In fact, lack of interference might very well be an evil. Is free will a virtue? that depends on how it is use. There is such a thing as an abuse of free will via the violation of other people's rights or even our own rights via self abuse. So the morality of interference is subject to circumstances.

That having been said, God does Interfere with free will in the sense of preventing certain things from happening or continuing to happen. For example, he promises to interfere with the free will of sinners by creating a New Heavens and New Earth where righteousness will predominate.

2 Peter 3:13
Nevertheless we, according to his promise, look for new heavens and a new earth, wherein dwelleth righteousness.


Only those who are willing to abide by the laws a regulations of that new order will be permitted to live. So we see here an interference with sinners. But we have governments which do the same. They tell us what we can and cannot do within their jurisdiction and we try to abide by it in order not to be punished. Since God is the universal sovereign he has the right to say what will be and will not be allowed within his realm-which is the realm of existence itself. The question really is, is it righteous for God to permit evil to go rampant in order to respect free will. Or is it righteous for him to interfere with free will in order to prevent the existence of evil. I would go with the latter.

About Judas

In Juda's case it was foretold that he would make that choice. A choice which would lead to the crucifixion of Jesus. Now, did it need to be Judas? Since the Ransom sacrifice was God's plan it would have inevitably have happened without a Judas if necessary. But since Judas was there with his particular predispositions, we are told that he was a thief who robbed the contribution box, it happened that way.


John 12:2-8 “There they made Him a supper; and Martha served, but Lazarus was one of those who sat at the table with Him. Then Mary took a pound of very costly oil of spikenard, anointed the feet of Jesus, and wiped His feet with her hair. And the house was filled with the fragrance of the oil. Then one of His disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, who would betray Him, said, “Why was this fragrant oil not sold for three hundred denari and given to the poor?” This he said, not that he cared for the poor, but because he was a thief, and had the money box; and he used to take what was put in it....

BTW
Thanks for the link. Very interesting article!
 
Last edited:
God does Interfere with free will in the sense of preventing certain things from happening or continuing to happen. For example, he promises to interfere with the free will of sinners by creating a New Heavens and New Earth where righteousness will predominate.

<snip>

The question really is, is it righteous for God to permit evil to go rampant in order to respect free will. Or is it righteous for him to interfere with free will in order to prevent the existence of evil. I would go with the latter.


But many modern theologians would argue that God has inherent omniscience to preserve free will. In effect, free will is more important to God than the prevention of evil. You entertained the idea here:


3.God is omniscient.

He knows all that can be known. As for knowing the unknowable-or choosing to know the knowable, that's an unknown.

There are three possibilities here. One is that he knew and permitted it. The second is that he didn't know because some things are unknowable even to Him. The third is that he knew about the possibility based on freedom of choice but saw it as a necessary in granting freedom of choice. The one that is biblically unsupported is the one which claims that he definitely knew the outcome and WANTED it that way.


Few believers would deny that God has allowed evil to exist since the beginning of creation with only a handful of exceptions. Why is evil allowed to exist even temporarily - since it would be "righteous for him to interfere with free will in order to prevent the existence of evil"?


About Judas

In Juda's case it was foretold that he would make that choice. A choice which would lead to the crucifixion of Jesus. Now, did it need to be Judas? Since the Ransom sacrifice was God's plan it would have inevitably have happened without a Judas if necessary. But since Judas was there with his particular predispositions, we are told that he was a thief who robbed the contribution box, it happened that way.

<snip>


Again, the foretelling of the ransom sacrifice, the crucifixion and Peter's denial - as well as other predictions - contradicts the position of inherent omniscience. Prophecies of nations rising against nations, etc. also contradict inherent omniscience. I don't think it's a reasonable position to hold considering some of the content of the Bible.

If it is an interference with free will rather that total omniscience, that would mean God is deliberately forcing nations to rise against nations to fulfill prophecy, which contradicts the idea of omnibenevolence.
 
I don't think God wants lies, destruction and evil to exist. I think God wants us to have a choice between good and evil.
God could have made us much more likely to do evil, but he didn't. He could make us much likely to, but he didn't. Why not? Having the choice to do evil and being inclined to are two totally different things. Doing evil would be entirely possible, even if we were all born with such 'good hearts' that in practice we never did it.
With out there being a choice between good and evil, we are just slaves to God. Anyone could believe in God if he proved his existance.
That would suck. Then believing in god wouldn't be special!

...


I believe in free will. I have also come to see this world as a test. If you pass you go to heavin or purgatory. If you fail you go to hell.
If you believe in free will then you believe that you could have chosen to do things other than the way you did them. Which means that you have free will in spite of your in born (or situationally dependant) inclinations. If that's true, then no matter how god changed those inclinations, you would still have free will. Given that, you still have to ask why God chose to make those inclinations as they are, and not some other way.
 
But many modern theologians would argue that God has inherent omniscience to preserve free will. In effect, free will is more important to God than the prevention of evil. You entertained the idea here:

That would require us to ignore all the scriptures and prophecies condemning evil as intolerable in God's universe and which tell us that his permission of evil is temporary.


Psalm 37:11
But the meek shall inherit the earth; and shall delight themselves in the abundance of peace.

Isaiah 65:17
For, behold, I create new heavens and a new earth: and the former shall not be remembered, nor come into mind.


Revelation 21
4And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away.

2 Peter 3:13
Nevertheless we, according to his promise, look for new heavens and a new earth, wherein dwelleth righteousness.


In short, it would require us to obliterate a biblical theme and substitute one of our own.
Of course nothing prevents us from doing that. However, such an attempt is counseled against in the Bible which states that we shouldn't add or subtract from what has been written.


Few believers would deny that God has allowed evil to exist since the beginning of creation with only a handful of exceptions.

Revelation 4:11
Thou art worthy, O Lord, to receive glory and honour and power: for thou hast created all things, and for thy pleasure they are and were created.

That depends on where we choose to define the beginning of creation of all things. Creation didn't begin with the earth much less with mankind-and not even with the material universe itself. Prior to human existence. There was the creation of the spiritual heavens where God resides and the creation of the Word and angels. Then came the material universe which preceded the earth. Then the earth, and finally mankind. All of which involved eons of time and all of which was sinless. That's stated clearly in the Bible regardless of denial by the believers you mention.

BTW
To believe doesn't guarantee accuracy. It merely indicates belief.

Why is evil allowed to exist even temporarily - since it would be "righteous for him to interfere with free will in order to prevent the existence of evil"?

Because it would be more unrighteous for him to leave the issues which cropped up by the rebellion unanswered. Morality requires that we choose between and among options and sometimes our choices must be guided by consequentialist factors. In fact it is the preferable method since deontological or rule-thinking inevitably leads to injustice
due to its inflexibility and the shortsightedness involved.


Again, the foretelling of the ransom sacrifice, the crucifixion and Peter's denial - as well as other predictions - contradicts the position of inherent omniscience.

Prophecies of nations rising against nations, etc. also contradict inherent omniscience. I don't think it's a reasonable position to hold considering some of the content of the Bible.

[/QUOTE]

He could easily shift between the twain. Why do you feel he's obligated to function on one level only? Don't we shift our modus operandi in response to varying circumstances? I would say that biblical content indicates that he chooses his modus operandi in response to circumstances. Saying otherwise generates a host of contradictions so why would I choose that option?


If it is an interference with free will rather than total omniscience, that would mean God is deliberately forcing nations to rise against nations to fulfill prophecy, which contradicts the idea of omnibenevolence.

Nations rise against nations and behave in beastly ways because they are under Satan's control. At least that's how they are biblically depicted.

1. As enemies of God scheduled to be removed and substituted by God's kingdom.

Daniel 2:44
44And in the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed: and the kingdom shall not be left to other people, but it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand for ever.


Revelation 19:15
And out of his mouth goeth a sharp sword, that with it he should smite the nations:....


2. Under Satanic control

2 Corinthians 4:4
In whom the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not, lest the light of the glorious gospel of Christ, who is the image of God, should shine unto them.

Luke 4:4-6

4And Jesus answered him, saying, It is written, That man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word of God.

5And the devil, taking him up into an high mountain, shewed unto him all the kingdoms of the world in a moment of time.

6And the devil said unto him, All this power will I give thee, and the glory of them: for that is delivered unto me; and to whomsoever I will I give it.

===================================================================

That's the reason why we are counselled in the following way:

James 4:4
Ye adulterers and adulteresses, know ye not that the friendship of the world is enmity with God? whosoever therefore will be a friend of the world is the enemy of God.






.
 
Last edited:
But many modern theologians would argue that God has inherent omniscience to preserve free will.

That would require us to ignore all the scriptures and prophecies condemning evil as intolerable in God's universe and which tell us that his permission of evil is temporary.

<snip>

In short, it would require us to obliterate a biblical theme and substitute one of our own.
Of course nothing prevents us from doing that. However, such an attempt is counseled against in the Bible which states that we shouldn't add or subtract from what has been written.


I still don't think we have a reasonable answer to why God allows evil to exist. I agree that a preference for inherent omniscience to preserve free will and thus allowing the existence of evil is contradictory to a main biblical theme.

If we are to believe the Bible is inerrant, we would have to believe - for whatever reason - that, for the time being, God allows evil to exist and it is not because he holds free will above all else.

The alternative, of course, is to not believe the Bible is inerrant - which is where I sit at the moment. If there is a deity, I don't think it is possible to assign it properties based on any text written by men. I understand that you disagree with this position, but I figure we may as well get both positions out on the table.


Why is evil allowed to exist even temporarily - since it would be "righteous for him to interfere with free will in order to prevent the existence of evil"?

Because it would be more unrighteous for him to leave the issues which cropped up by the rebellion unanswered. Morality requires that we choose between and among options and sometimes our choices must be guided by consequentialist factors. In fact it is the preferable method since deontological or rule-thinking inevitably leads to injustice
due to its inflexibility and the shortsightedness involved.


But why not answer the rebellion immediately? Why allow evil to exist for thousands and thousands of years without answer? Virtually every generation of the faithful believe the last judgment to be near, and yet, generation after generation after generation lives and dies and on and on evil goes.


He could easily shift between the twain. Why do you feel he's obligated to function on one level only? Don't we shift our modus operandi in response to varying circumstances? I would say that biblical content indicates that he chooses his modus operandi in response to circumstances. Saying otherwise generates a host of contradictions so why would I choose that option?


I don't feel he's obligated to function on one level only, but his choices when to interfere and when not to are confusing and seem contradictory to an omnibenevolent deity.

When the Hebrews were slaves to the Egyptians, God sent plagues, formed a pillar of fire and drowned Egyptians in the Red Sea, but when the African Americans were slaves in the United States it took the free will of human beings to free them. Why does God interfere to free slaves in Egypt, but then condones the ownership of slaves by those former slaves, and then doesn't interfere to free yet more slaves in other parts of the world?

Did he free the Hebrew slaves because he condemns evil or did he free them to form a covenent with his chosen people?


Nations rise against nations and behave in beastly ways because they are under Satan's control. At least that's how they are biblically depicted.


And, yet again, we are left with the problem of free will. If nations are under Satan's control, then they do not have free will. If free will is important to God and God does not want evil to exist, why does he allow Satan to exist?

If nations are under Satan's control because they have chosen to follow him, this was still prophesied and again removes free will. And round and round it goes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom