Will Caroline Kennedy Be The Next NY Senator?

Kaylee

Illuminator
Joined
Feb 5, 2005
Messages
4,287
Caroline Kennedy has spoken to New York Gov. David Paterson about the Senate seat that will come open when Hillary Rodham Clinton becomes secretary of state, according to a person familiar with the conversation.

<snip>

As a prominent member of the Kennedy clan, Caroline Kennedy Schlossberg is the kind of high-profile, historic figure who could overshadow many other New York politicians hoping to be Paterson's choice.

The governor has said he is in no rush to make a decision, and Clinton is not giving up the seat before she is confirmed as President-elect Barack Obama's secretary of state.

"The governor has not yet reached out to any potential candidates," said Paterson's spokesman, Errol Cockfield. "He has been approached by several candidates. Any discussions related to that selection are private and the governor will not comment about speculation before a decision is made."

<snip>

Caroline Kennedy is easily the most famous contender for Clinton's Senate seat, but there are plenty of others. New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo is widely known in the state. Paterson could also pick Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown or Tom Suozzi, a Long Island elected official.

There are also a number of House members in the running, including Reps. Carolyn Maloney, Kirsten Gillibrand, Steve Israel, Brian Higgins, Nydia Velazquez and Jerrold Nadler.

My guess is that this is a done deal. If a member of such a politically powerful family wants to be appointed senator, than this is most likely what will happen.

I’d rather the job went to an experienced politician with a track record.

I’d like to know more about the other “candidates”, but so far I’m leaning towards Jerry Nadler. He started off as a state assembly member in my election district. I like his positions and he has taken public stands on positions that I care about including those that aren’t well understood such as election integrity.

Also, I still remember years ago when he was still an assembly member he went to a tenants' meeting in an apt. building after being informed that they had been told by their landlord that it was illegal for them to meet and form a union in the apt. building. He spoke to us and was there for the first 15, 20 minutes or so of the meeting. Yep, that was the same apt. building I lived in. Not that many political points or fundraising cash in it for him, but he still did it.
 
Last edited:
I’d rather the job went to an experienced politician with a track record.

Like a Senator from Idaho? That loves bathroom stalls? No.

Kennedy is a fine choice...she will have to run again soon, so the folks in NY will have their choice soon.

Well, she will vote Dem...and that is cool with me. She cares about the working people, and she is a Kennedy! enough said.

If she wants it, she is in. ;)
 
Like a Senator from Idaho? That loves bathroom stalls? No.

Kennedy is a fine choice...she will have to run again soon, so the folks in NY will have their choice soon.

Well, she will vote Dem...and that is cool with me. She cares about the working people, and she is a Kennedy! enough said.

If she wants it, she is in. ;)

Kennedy's entire political experience consists of writng a New York Times op-ed piece endorsing Obama. For this Camelot princess to leap frog over these other candidates for "Snipery" Hillary's Senate seat can only be considered a political pay-off:

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo
Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown
Tom Suozzi
Rep.Carolyn Maloney
Rep. Kirsten Gillibrand
Rep. Steve Israel
Rep.Brian Higgins
Rep. Nydia Velazquez
Rep. Jerrold Nadler
 
Ohmyed -- I agree with Cicero. /* Looks to see its raining fire in the streets */
 
My guess is that this is a done deal. If a member of such a politically powerful family wants to be appointed senator, than this is most likely what will happen.

Why do you hate America? Or is it just New York that you hate?

America is a democratic republic; it doesn't have a politically powerful aristocracy. Isn't that what the Revolution was about? We're not talking Canada here, we're talking senators of the USA, democratically elected by the people for the people.
 
I think she will be appointed to fill Clintons seat. Then I think she's going to either be chosen to run for president or vice president in 2016
 
I’d rather the job went to an experienced politician with a track record.

... because they've been doing such a great job lately? Is Barney Frank willing to make the move to NY, or Chris Dodd? John Edwards is available isn't he?

I'd rather have someone with less baggage, nothing owed to anyone, come in and kick tail. I don't really know what experience this Kennedy has, but she might be a good choice and name recognition isn't a bad thing. You are going to swap one liberal who doesn't give a rats rear end about NY for another one who might.
 
America is a democratic republic; it doesn't have a politically powerful aristocracy. Isn't that what the Revolution was about? We're not talking Canada here, we're talking senators of the USA, democratically elected by the people for the people.


Senators were not elected until the 17th Amendment, 1913. A bit before my time, but long after the Revolution.
 
Ms Kennedy is to my eye a case of regression to the mean. Is her status as "Kennedy Royalty" in some way a qualifying factor? The various complaints about George W Bush ought to be raised again in this case of borrowing Daddy's glamour.

DR
 
She has less experience than Jon Cooper (D, Suffolk legislator). We have worked on Jon's campaigns and I think he would be a great senator.
 
Ohmyed -- I agree with Cicero. /* Looks to see its raining fire in the streets */
Jesus, me too. Is there a disease spread via keyboard?

This potential appointment is disgusting. She has nothing to offer but her name recognition. I am sick and tired of our celebrity-dominated culture. In politics, names like Kennedy, Bush, Cuomo, etc. carry far more weight than the person behind them.
 
I may e-mail this to the Governor of NY. Hey, one of his staffers might read it! :D I thought I’d post it here first. Blast away and do your worse, I may end up with a better letter. :)

--

Dear Governor Paterson,

I was deeply disappointed to read that Ms. Caroline Kennedy may be appointed to the position of NY Senator.

I have a great deal of respect for her family’s contributions to our country. However, these are accomplishments made by other members of Ms. Kennedy’s family – they are not hers.

Celebrities have a place in our TV talk shows and entertainment magazines, but not in our Senate. Please consider one of our many representatives who have a known record and are a known quantity to NY voters. Make a statement on behalf of all New Yorkers and let the country know that here in New York we think that politics should be a place for people of substance.

I hope you will appoint my representative, the Honorable Jerrold Nadler*. He has an excellent record and I believe will make a great senator.

Thank you,


--

* For all the nonUSAsians – that’s how representatives are addressed – it's not my way of summarizing his character. :) Although I do believe that he's a good man.

To be fair, Caroline Kennedy does have a couple of accomplishments that are relevant to being senator. She was a co-author of two books:
  • In Our Defense: The Bill of Rights In Action
  • The Right to Privacy

While that offers concrete proof that she's more literate and knowledgable than George Bush, I still don’t think that’s reason enough to give her the job.
 
Last edited:
Senators were not elected until the 17th Amendment, 1913. A bit before my time, but long after the Revolution.

A relic of which is the Governor's power of appointment in this case. Originally, US senators were essentially ambassadors representing a state's interests, as determined by the powers-that-be in the state.

I agree with the sentiment that whoever is appointed in this day and age should at least have been elected to some significant position - State Senate, House of Representatives, Mayor of a major city. Governor, even.
 
I may e-mail this to the Governor of NY. Hey, one of his staffers might read it! :D I thought I’d post it here first. Blast away and do your worse, I may end up with a better letter. :)

--

Dear Governor Paterson,

I was deeply disappointed to read that Ms. Caroline Kennedy may be appointed to the position of NY Senator.

I have a great deal of respect for her family’s contributions to our country. However, these are accomplishments made by other members of Ms. Kennedy’s family – they are not hers.

Celebrities have a place in our TV talk shows and entertainment magazines, but not in our Senate. Please consider one of our many representatives who have a known record and are a known quantity to NY voters. Make a statement on behalf of all New Yorkers and let the country know that here in New York we think that politics should be a place for people of substance.

I hope you will appoint my representative, the Honorable Jerrold Nadler*. He has an excellent record and I believe will make a great senator.

Thank you,


--

* For all the nonUSAsians – that’s how representatives are addressed – it's not my way of summarizing his character. :) Although I do believe that he's a good man.

To be fair, Caroline Kennedy does have a couple of accomplishments that are relevant to being senator. She was a co-author of two books:
  • In Our Defense: The Bill of Rights In Action
  • The Right to Privacy

While that offers concrete proof that she's more literate and knowledgable than George Bush, I still don’t think that’s reason enough to give her the job.

It's the same over here. My local MP is The Honourable Fran Bailey MP, Member for McEwan. It's currently the most marginal seat in Australia, with a 12 vote swing needed to unseat the Liberals. Similarly, our Governors and Governor General are their excellency, as in this case: Australia's 25th Governor-General Her Excellency Ms Quentin Bryce AC
 
I hope it is not Caroline or Bobby Jr.

That would be dynastic politics and hereditary aristocracy.

Fine for a feudal society, not a democracy.
 
@ CapelDodger and PuppyCow: I worked your comments into my e-mail and just sent it now. I did not give you any credit in the letter. :p;)
 
Well, she will vote Dem...and that is cool with me. She cares about the working people, and she is a Kennedy! enough said.

If she wants it, she is in. ;)

She's a Kennedy?! Well why didn't you say so? That's all I needed to know.

While we're at it, can we get Jamie Kennedy as trade representative? He was so good in Son of the Mask.
 
@ CapelDodger and PuppyCow: I worked your comments into my e-mail and just sent it now. I did not give you any credit in the letter. :p;)

I'm glad you didn't; I've heard of the Kennedy Curse and I don't want it laid on me :eek:.

Regarding political dynasties in the US, I gather the Gore family is one, the Roosevelts obviously another, Kennedy and Bush have been mentioned. Are there any more that come to mind?
 
I'm glad you didn't; I've heard of the Kennedy Curse and I don't want it laid on me :eek:.

Regarding political dynasties in the US, I gather the Gore family is one, the Roosevelts obviously another, Kennedy and Bush have been mentioned. Are there any more that come to mind?

Adams.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom