Cain
Straussian
Keep slinking away. If clarification was the issue you would have asked for it from the beginning. Instead you tried to make funny by acusing me of thinking that Paris Hilton took her Chihuahua from the wild. Your initial misdirected hostitlity was annoying, but this born-again feigned reasonability is just pathetic.
Now it seems you're trying to save face on your chihuahua howler by mischaracterization and merger. You also have a knack for using more words than necessary to say what you mean, which is almost nothing at all.
Look at this meandering nonsense:
You're not doing any better, this is still silly. What do you think "benefit" means? I've given you plenty of analogies that you ignore. The trunkless elephants would likewise be facing very different conditions. They would either go extinct or evolve differently. I can still say that a trunk benefits elephants.
Here's another example involving human innovation. The discovery of fire benefited humans. If our ancestors never discovered how to manipulate fire, the subsequent genetic line would have played out quite differently. We either would have died or developed some other means of survival. Please explain EXACTLY how fire was not beneficial to human survival? Do I need to find a caveman in the modern world and hand him fire in order to understand the positive nature of the discovery?
Explain how fire was not beneficial to human beings? Rather than writing seemingly random ****, please try to construct a coherent argument. I have a question. If the options for fireless humans are die out or develop some other means of survival, then how did humans survive up to that point? Jesus, I suppose this is better than talking about Carlos Mencia or John McCain or Barack Obama, but it's still a waste of my time. Sorry, I'm not homing from work.
I think this is my favorite part though:
I am astonished that you missed the point of the analogy that badly. The state of being incarcerated is obviously not genetic. Once again, you're absurd literal nature has forced you into a strange, unfortunate position.
The prison example is meant to get to the heart of what you or I mean when we use the word "benefit." With respect to animals in the wild you are arguing that a beast must first live in the wild, then be brought under human care to BENEFIT from human stewardship. This is equally as silly as saying I must first serve time to understand that I benefit from my freedom.
The genetic line analogy would be either the elephant's trunk or man discovering fire. Your intepretation of the prison example fails because, as I said earlier, children do not inheret their parents' criminal record.
But look, let's say a society passed a law that said once a person entered prison they and all of their decendents would be in prison for all time. Thus making prison an inhereted trait like an elephant's trunk or animals domestically raised. Now that the analogy is accurate, I would say the Adam's genetic line benefited ENORMOUSLY should he stay out of prison.
That was an awesome misuse of a simple, simple analogy. You have to break yourself of this literal crap.
Well, I guess that's one way of disavowing your analogy. What's comical is that you accuse me of a literal interpretation while saying this has nothing to do with future offspring at all. You mean it's only purpose, the reason why you got a big penis over it in the first place, was because you wanted to demonstrate people outside of prison feel better than people inside prison? You're also reducing your claim, mischaracterizing my original objection in the process. If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence.
First of all, prairies do need grazing animals. The first article is from research done in a tall-grass prairie 10min from my parents' house. The second is a giant database of citations of articles and studies focused on grassland health, should you wish to read more.
http://news.bio-medicine.org/biology-news-2/Mowing--Grazing-Of-Tall-Grass-Prairie-Increases-14695-1/
http://www.jdburgessonline.com/grazing/research.html
As I said, I'll just accept all of this as true. I should think it's only fair to impose as many contrived handicaps on myself to make up for your natural deficits.
But, of course, that means we have to do something with the millions of cattle. Though cattle aren't as good for the ecosystem as buffalo (they graze differently), free ranging is a solid solution. That still means killing a certain number, reintroducing predators, or letting them destroy the grassland. Seems that slaughter is the best choice.
Well, assuming the government can capably manage those lands, and death-by-human is the least painful, then I have no problem with that scenario.
That doesn't escape the ethical issue. If you don't keep the numbers of the herd down both the local ecosystem and the animals themselves suffer. Look what has happened with the deer population in many parts of the country. They are overgrazing, killing young trees and other plant life, and have become weaker and more diseased. It is better both for the animals and the environment to control numbers. This means reintroducing predators or culling.
OK, that's another empirical claim. If that's in the best interests of animals in the area, then it's in the best interest of animals in the area.
Of course I need a compelling reason. I would advance the needs of the mother of the pre-sentient bundle of cells as sufficient. As the fetus' ability to survive on its own increases, the importnace of the mother's needs (save if her life is threatened) decrease. We can go back and forth on the specifics, but we are in agreement that a compelling reason must be given to justify abortion, thus it is an irrelevent issue.
Hold on a sec, Buttercup. Now you're comparing the needs of the mother against "the pre-sentient bundle of cells," a description used to diminish to the value of that life. Then you cross into the viability argument, claiming "the fetus' ability to survive on its own," which I should take as some sort of standard for life vis-a-vis the mother's interests? All of these contortions are not necessary and appear only because you're already invested in this potentiality idea.
Let me borrow a hypothetical from Peter Singer. A woman has been planning a mountain climbing trip in India for the better part of the year, though it's almost a life-long dream. She finds herself pregnant several months before the day she's set to depart. This woman has always wanted a baby, but now is the wrong time. She decides to have an abortion now and get pregnant next year. Is she doing anything wrong?
And please, provide me evidence of the majestic mental life of a cow.
Who says having a "majestic mental life" should be some sort of standard? My grandmother apparently forgets to toast her bread before buttering it.
Mother: That's not toasted.
Gmother: Nope
M: why didn't you toast it?
GM: I forgot! Hahahaha
Her life dose seem rather less meaningful, but not meaningless. Cows can enjoy eating and crapping as well as ****ing and walking.
Also, I should note that most human beings, contra your earlier claim, do not understand their own mortality. Most people believe in a life after this one -- that they possess an immortal soul.
Humans evolved to enjoy meat. We used to need it to survive. Now we don't. Thus, to justify the continued eating of meat there must be a good reason. Raising, controlling, and slaughtering meat-providing animals is good for both the animals themselves (better health, generally longer life-spans, humane deaths) and better for the environment. So when I choose to indulge my genetically bread tastes I am causing no harm. I see no compelling reason to stop.
I should say that in the real world, eating meat is not good for the environment, as admitted by even quasi-libertarian publications like WIRED. That's because animals are raised for human consumption, not environmental reasons. You're again saying that animals enjoy better health, but better compared to what? They could also... not exist at all, which would have all kinds of positive benefits for human beings and the globe.
More silliness. This is the devout hypocricy. You constantly whine about the tone of my posts, and yet you toss in killing 5 million people for no apparant reason. I'll put that in the same category as the useless reference to baby-eating.
But again, for humans to expend energy taking care of animals their must be some reimbursement. I am curious what you think should happen to the millions of domesticated cows. If we don't eat them, we won't have any money to care for them. They aren't like buffalo, they've been bread for docility, so letting them go free is a cruel idea. What should we do according to your morality?
I'm not sure why this always gets brought up in vegetarian threads. Assuming we did stop eating animals, there would be gradual fall off; we will not be left with the number of cows, pigs and chickens we have today. Assuming your scenario, even though it's not at all plausible, I agree with Lonewulf (not something I often say).
If you want to also insist that we need them to graze to protect the integrity of ecosystems, then that's a public good that should be financed and managed by the government.