Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Keep slinking away. If clarification was the issue you would have asked for it from the beginning. Instead you tried to make funny by acusing me of thinking that Paris Hilton took her Chihuahua from the wild. Your initial misdirected hostitlity was annoying, but this born-again feigned reasonability is just pathetic.

Now it seems you're trying to save face on your chihuahua howler by mischaracterization and merger. You also have a knack for using more words than necessary to say what you mean, which is almost nothing at all.

Look at this meandering nonsense:
You're not doing any better, this is still silly. What do you think "benefit" means? I've given you plenty of analogies that you ignore. The trunkless elephants would likewise be facing very different conditions. They would either go extinct or evolve differently. I can still say that a trunk benefits elephants.

Here's another example involving human innovation. The discovery of fire benefited humans. If our ancestors never discovered how to manipulate fire, the subsequent genetic line would have played out quite differently. We either would have died or developed some other means of survival. Please explain EXACTLY how fire was not beneficial to human survival? Do I need to find a caveman in the modern world and hand him fire in order to understand the positive nature of the discovery?

Explain how fire was not beneficial to human beings? Rather than writing seemingly random ****, please try to construct a coherent argument. I have a question. If the options for fireless humans are die out or develop some other means of survival, then how did humans survive up to that point? Jesus, I suppose this is better than talking about Carlos Mencia or John McCain or Barack Obama, but it's still a waste of my time. Sorry, I'm not homing from work.

I think this is my favorite part though:
I am astonished that you missed the point of the analogy that badly. The state of being incarcerated is obviously not genetic. Once again, you're absurd literal nature has forced you into a strange, unfortunate position.

The prison example is meant to get to the heart of what you or I mean when we use the word "benefit." With respect to animals in the wild you are arguing that a beast must first live in the wild, then be brought under human care to BENEFIT from human stewardship. This is equally as silly as saying I must first serve time to understand that I benefit from my freedom.

The genetic line analogy would be either the elephant's trunk or man discovering fire. Your intepretation of the prison example fails because, as I said earlier, children do not inheret their parents' criminal record.

But look, let's say a society passed a law that said once a person entered prison they and all of their decendents would be in prison for all time. Thus making prison an inhereted trait like an elephant's trunk or animals domestically raised. Now that the analogy is accurate, I would say the Adam's genetic line benefited ENORMOUSLY should he stay out of prison.

That was an awesome misuse of a simple, simple analogy. You have to break yourself of this literal crap.

Well, I guess that's one way of disavowing your analogy. What's comical is that you accuse me of a literal interpretation while saying this has nothing to do with future offspring at all. You mean it's only purpose, the reason why you got a big penis over it in the first place, was because you wanted to demonstrate people outside of prison feel better than people inside prison? You're also reducing your claim, mischaracterizing my original objection in the process. If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence.

First of all, prairies do need grazing animals. The first article is from research done in a tall-grass prairie 10min from my parents' house. The second is a giant database of citations of articles and studies focused on grassland health, should you wish to read more.

http://news.bio-medicine.org/biology-news-2/Mowing--Grazing-Of-Tall-Grass-Prairie-Increases-14695-1/

http://www.jdburgessonline.com/grazing/research.html

As I said, I'll just accept all of this as true. I should think it's only fair to impose as many contrived handicaps on myself to make up for your natural deficits.

But, of course, that means we have to do something with the millions of cattle. Though cattle aren't as good for the ecosystem as buffalo (they graze differently), free ranging is a solid solution. That still means killing a certain number, reintroducing predators, or letting them destroy the grassland. Seems that slaughter is the best choice.

Well, assuming the government can capably manage those lands, and death-by-human is the least painful, then I have no problem with that scenario.

That doesn't escape the ethical issue. If you don't keep the numbers of the herd down both the local ecosystem and the animals themselves suffer. Look what has happened with the deer population in many parts of the country. They are overgrazing, killing young trees and other plant life, and have become weaker and more diseased. It is better both for the animals and the environment to control numbers. This means reintroducing predators or culling.

OK, that's another empirical claim. If that's in the best interests of animals in the area, then it's in the best interest of animals in the area.

Of course I need a compelling reason. I would advance the needs of the mother of the pre-sentient bundle of cells as sufficient. As the fetus' ability to survive on its own increases, the importnace of the mother's needs (save if her life is threatened) decrease. We can go back and forth on the specifics, but we are in agreement that a compelling reason must be given to justify abortion, thus it is an irrelevent issue.

Hold on a sec, Buttercup. Now you're comparing the needs of the mother against "the pre-sentient bundle of cells," a description used to diminish to the value of that life. Then you cross into the viability argument, claiming "the fetus' ability to survive on its own," which I should take as some sort of standard for life vis-a-vis the mother's interests? All of these contortions are not necessary and appear only because you're already invested in this potentiality idea.

Let me borrow a hypothetical from Peter Singer. A woman has been planning a mountain climbing trip in India for the better part of the year, though it's almost a life-long dream. She finds herself pregnant several months before the day she's set to depart. This woman has always wanted a baby, but now is the wrong time. She decides to have an abortion now and get pregnant next year. Is she doing anything wrong?

And please, provide me evidence of the majestic mental life of a cow.

Who says having a "majestic mental life" should be some sort of standard? My grandmother apparently forgets to toast her bread before buttering it.
Mother: That's not toasted.
Gmother: Nope
M: why didn't you toast it?
GM: I forgot! Hahahaha

Her life dose seem rather less meaningful, but not meaningless. Cows can enjoy eating and crapping as well as ****ing and walking.

Also, I should note that most human beings, contra your earlier claim, do not understand their own mortality. Most people believe in a life after this one -- that they possess an immortal soul.

Humans evolved to enjoy meat. We used to need it to survive. Now we don't. Thus, to justify the continued eating of meat there must be a good reason. Raising, controlling, and slaughtering meat-providing animals is good for both the animals themselves (better health, generally longer life-spans, humane deaths) and better for the environment. So when I choose to indulge my genetically bread tastes I am causing no harm. I see no compelling reason to stop.

I should say that in the real world, eating meat is not good for the environment, as admitted by even quasi-libertarian publications like WIRED. That's because animals are raised for human consumption, not environmental reasons. You're again saying that animals enjoy better health, but better compared to what? They could also... not exist at all, which would have all kinds of positive benefits for human beings and the globe.

More silliness. This is the devout hypocricy. You constantly whine about the tone of my posts, and yet you toss in killing 5 million people for no apparant reason. I'll put that in the same category as the useless reference to baby-eating.

:rolleyes:

But again, for humans to expend energy taking care of animals their must be some reimbursement. I am curious what you think should happen to the millions of domesticated cows. If we don't eat them, we won't have any money to care for them. They aren't like buffalo, they've been bread for docility, so letting them go free is a cruel idea. What should we do according to your morality?

I'm not sure why this always gets brought up in vegetarian threads. Assuming we did stop eating animals, there would be gradual fall off; we will not be left with the number of cows, pigs and chickens we have today. Assuming your scenario, even though it's not at all plausible, I agree with Lonewulf (not something I often say).

If you want to also insist that we need them to graze to protect the integrity of ecosystems, then that's a public good that should be financed and managed by the government.
 
Now it seems you're trying to save face on your chihuahua howler by mischaracterization and merger. You also have a knack for using more words than necessary to say what you mean, which is almost nothing at all.

My Chihuahua howler? Haha, ok. You began this by trying to mock me for thinking Paris Hilton took her chihuahua directly from the wild. Why are you trying to blame me for that pathetic misinterpretation?


Look at this meandering nonsense:


Explain how fire was not beneficial to human beings? Rather than writing seemingly random ****, please try to construct a coherent argument. I have a question. If the options for fireless humans are die out or develop some other means of survival, then how did humans survive up to that point? Jesus, I suppose this is better than talking about Carlos Mencia or John McCain or Barack Obama, but it's still a waste of my time. Sorry, I'm not homing from work.

Are you serious? The analogy is perfectly apt. I am arguing that animals have BENEFITED from domestication. You are arguing that animals can only be said to benefit from domestication if the individual creature was once wild, then it was pulled under human control.

This is equally as dumb as saying I need to find a caveman living without fire, then introduce him to fire in order to claim fire is beneficial.

You then claim that domestication cannot be said to benefit the subsequent genetic line of animals because they never would have existed without domestication. Similarly, humans with control over fire never would have existed without the initial discovery. Knowledge of fire was passed down through generations of man JUST like knowledge of domestication. One difference (to sooth your literal mind) is that the animals' genetic material passes down parallel to the human activity.

Please explain why that analogy doesn't hold. It is perfectly apt. You don't want to deal with it because you know it shows you retarded "removal" thesis to be hog wash.

I think this is my favorite part though:

Well, I guess that's one way of disavowing your analogy. What's comical is that you accuse me of a literal interpretation while saying this has nothing to do with future offspring at all. You mean it's only purpose, the reason why you got a big penis over it in the first place, was because you wanted to demonstrate people outside of prison feel better than people inside prison?

I did not disavow the analogy. Do you really not understand this? An analogy can be used as a thought experiment to approach a problem from a different perspective. A problem with many facets, like the one we're currently discussing, will have many analogies that apply to various parts.

You have offered at least two separate understandings of how domestication operates:

1) you have said that an animal must be rescued directly from the wild in order to have benefited from domestication. This is your "removal" thesis.

2) you have said that generations of animals living under domestication do not benefit from that domestication because if the original domesticated ancestor was left wild, they would never have existed.

The prison analogy applies to point 1. I do not need to serve time in prison, then be let out to say I benefit from my freedom.

Humans discovering fire and the example of the elephant's trunk are analogies for point 2. In both cases the phenomenon in question will originate at a point similar to the first domesticated animal and pass through subsequent generations.

You bizarrely took an analogy for point 1 an comically tried to apply it to point 2. The state of being incarcerated is not inhereted like knowledge of fire, an elephants trunk, or animals born into domestication.

This is really quite simple. I disavow neither analogy and challenge you to actually show what's wrong with them, instead of badly conflating two obvious points.

You're also reducing your claim, mischaracterizing my original objection in the process. If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence.

So here is an analogy I don't understand. What was Paris Hilton's initial violence against her chihuahua? Or do you mean to say the first instance of domestication was a violent act? This may or may not be true. The domestication of wolves, for example, is thought to have happened as wolf packs trailed fabulously successful human hunting groups to scavenge the kills. The more docile pack members moved closer, and closer to humans until, as generations passed, they became domesticated. I don't see any violence there.

I assume you're talking about something like the way wild horses are broken. I will say two things about this. 1) Domestication does benefit the animal, so breaking them, even if it is violent, will ultimately prove beneficial. This is analogous to giving an animal a shot of medication. If I beat the crap out of someone for no reason, then nurse them back to health, the initial violence has no justficication.

2) We have learned more humane methods of controlling wild horses, so there seems to be no reason to go through a harmful process anymore. Just like humane slaughter, to the extent that it is actually useful, I will support such practices.

As I said, I'll just accept all of this as true. I should think it's only fair to impose as many contrived handicaps on myself to make up for your natural deficits.

Well, assuming the government can capably manage those lands, and death-by-human is the least painful, then I have no problem with that scenario.

OK, that's another empirical claim. If that's in the best interests of animals in the area, then it's in the best interest of animals in the area.

I don't understand what you're trying to do here. Do you have contrary evidence? Did you not find those scientific papers convincing?


Hold on a sec, Buttercup. Now you're comparing the needs of the mother against "the pre-sentient bundle of cells," a description used to diminish to the value of that life. Then you cross into the viability argument, claiming "the fetus' ability to survive on its own," which I should take as some sort of standard for life vis-a-vis the mother's interests? All of these contortions are not necessary and appear only because you're already invested in this potentiality idea.

Let me borrow a hypothetical from Peter Singer. A woman has been planning a mountain climbing trip in India for the better part of the year, though it's almost a life-long dream. She finds herself pregnant several months before the day she's set to depart. This woman has always wanted a baby, but now is the wrong time. She decides to have an abortion now and get pregnant next year. Is she doing anything wrong?

Let me reiterate that this is irrelevent for the purpose of this discussion. You charged me with taking a pro-life stance when I argued that removing a few years from a cow's life was not morally wrong because they lacked the brain capacity to even comprehend such a thought. I distinguished the cow from an infant based on potentiality. So, you argue, why should I allow abortion when a fetus has the same potentiality as an infant?

First, for the purposes of establishing intellectual consistency all I need to do I show that abortion is somehow different than killing an infant. You don't have to agree with that as a justification for legal abortion. That's a unique discussion. Therefore I must establish a need sufficient to trump the rights of the potential human in gestation. I am arguing that the needs of the mother, however mockable they might be, are sufficient. Again, you can disagree with this, but my corpus of beliefs does not contain any contradictory elements with respect to the slaughter of cattle.

Now, as far as abortion itself goes, I would argue that the rights of the potential child inside of the mother are inferior so long as the mother is needed for the fetus' survival. Unless the act of childbirth itself endangers the mother's life, as the fetus nears independent survival, the mother's rights lessen. The Supreme Court chose the end of the second trimester as a cutoff, and I agree with that reasoning.

One reason I think early-term abortion is justified, in contrast to killing an infant, is that a bundle of cells has not even reached the point of being able to experience suffering. In both cases the potential is the same, but the act of taking life itself will be different.

You are trying to imply that there's some confusion in these statements. You can disagree, fine, but however you thought this applied to my approach to cattle, even you have to admit you're grasping at straws.

Who says having a "majestic mental life" should be some sort of standard? My grandmother apparently forgets to toast her bread before buttering it.
Mother: That's not toasted.
Gmother: Nope
M: why didn't you toast it?
GM: I forgot! Hahahaha

Her life dose seem rather less meaningful, but not meaningless. Cows can enjoy eating and crapping as well as ****ing and walking.

Also, I should note that most human beings, contra your earlier claim, do not understand their own mortality. Most people believe in a life after this one -- that they possess an immortal soul.

Sigh, even though I should have been conditioned, I'm still AMAZED by how literal your mind is. Sarcasm. That's all. I sarcastically described a cow's mental life as "'majestic."

And notice that even in the midst of your grandmother's senior moment, she is displaying mental capabilities that are as far above a cow's as a cow's thoughts are a bove a carrot's

Again, I never argued that cow's don't feel pain or happiness. That's why I argue for humane treatment. The question is whether they suffer when deprived of a few years of their life. That, unlike eating and crapping, they lack the ability to comprehend.

And I hope you're making a joke with that point about the souls. The mere fact that humans developed the concept of a death-surviving soul proves that they understand their mortality. They know the body will cease at some point, so they are thinking beyond.

I should say that in the real world, eating meat is not good for the environment, as admitted by even quasi-libertarian publications like WIRED. That's because animals are raised for human consumption, not environmental reasons. You're again saying that animals enjoy better health, but better compared to what? They could also... not exist at all, which would have all kinds of positive benefits for human beings and the globe.

And now we're back to where we started. Of course the meat industry as it exists right now is bad for the environment. But that isn't an argument against the type of practices I've advanced. You have to show that free-range ranching is bad for the evironment in order to get that argument to stick against me. I will stand along side you and press for the end of feed-lots and other inhumane, anti-environmental institutions.

"You're again saying that animals enjoy better health, but better compared to what? They could also... not exist at all, which would have all kinds of positive benefits for human beings and the globe."

You HAVE to see how silly that argument is. Free range cattle enjoy a better life than their wild grazing counterparts. I enjoy a better life than many unfortunate citizens of Darfur.

And once again, if you eliminate all grazing animals you are destroying the environment. You're just going around in circles, reiterating the same nonsense over and over.


:rolleyes:


I'm not sure why this always gets brought up in vegetarian threads. Assuming we did stop eating animals, there would be gradual fall off; we will not be left with the number of cows, pigs and chickens we have today. Assuming your scenario, even though it's not at all plausible, I agree with Lonewulf (not something I often say).

If you want to also insist that we need them to graze to protect the integrity of ecosystems, then that's a public good that should be financed and managed by the government.

So let's say it's financed by the government. Once more, the herd will have to be periodically culled in order to protect the integrity of the ecosystem. Should we just destroy the carcasses and not eat the meat?
 
Oh yeah, we have a BIG problem with that now.

We can't support our cows now, nosirree... at least, not if we let them live a few more years on until old age! :D

Seriously, if you believe that we can't support the system NOW, why are we even talking about this?

Uh...we support the system now because we slaughter animals and sell the resultant products. You're suggesting an end to such practices, ergo you're suggesting the end to the resources we expend caring for the animals.



Cute stuff.

Right, and constituting the "genetic need to reproduce" as a harm isn't anthropomorphism at all. :rolleyes:

So humans are the only animals with a genetic need to reproduce? Anthopomorphism is the often rediculous habit of imposing human characteristics on animals. All living things reproduce. So, I don't even know what you meant to say here.

Sure. But as long as they exist in the numbers that they're in, they constitute damage to the environment. So you're saying we humanely slaughter all of them now, and not breed in a new generation.

Well hot damn, okay. We go with your plan.

Right, which is why we need to end the bad practices (feed-lots and such) and move to a free-range only system. We have no argument there.

Interestingly, I'm not sure it's completely a numbers issue.

http://www.ext.nodak.edu/extnews/newsrelease/2003/101603/06livstk.htm

That article places the total number of cattle in the US at about 100million. The most conservative estimates of the number of bison prior to the 19th century were around 60million. There very likely could have been 100 million buffalo on the plains.

So the issue is one of proper practice.
 
I'm going to shorten these bloc quotes since they're mostly filler that needlessly repeat; I will simply note where they begin and end, including highlights.

My Chihuahua howler?

...
You have offered at least two separate understandings of how domestication operates:

1) you have said that an animal must be rescued directly from the wild in order to have benefited from domestication. This is your "removal" thesis.

2) you have said that generations of animals living under domestication do not benefit from that domestication because if the original domesticated ancestor was left wild, they would never have existed.

The prison analogy applies to point 1. I do not need to serve time in prison, then be let out to say I benefit from my freedom.

...
You bizarrely took an analogy for point 1 an comically tried to apply it to point 2. The state of being incarcerated is not inhereted like knowledge of fire, an elephants trunk, or animals born into domestication.

I suggest you revisit my original criticism, and I'll remind you in thirty seconds to wipe the dumb expression off your face:

Are you going out into nature and and raising animals you have personally rescued? If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming. Those animals still endure injury and suffer disease. What you're likely doing is bringing animals into the world who otherwise would not exist, which is something entirely different than the self-congratulatory, borderline Messianic nonsense printed above.

The problem is that you're fragmenting one point, my point. The argument is that we would not have 100 million more cattle in nature if not for domestication, so the idea that those animals would suffer, starve etc. is mistaken. I'm not sure why it has taken three pages and tens of thousands of words for you to understand such a basic point. Instead you choose to jump wildly between analogies, from elephant trunks to prisons. OK, I'm a man of my word, you can now wipe the dumb expression off your face.

So here is an analogy I don't understand. What was Paris Hilton's initial violence against her chihuahua?

I did not say Paris Hilton visited violence upon her dog (geez, talk about an "impoverished" or "frivolous" literal mind :rolleyes:). I'm making a distinction between phases.

I assume you're talking about something like the way wild horses are broken.

No, I'm not. Jesus Christ, I don't come here to play charades.

I don't understand what you're trying to do here. Do you have contrary evidence? Did you not find those scientific papers convincing?

It does not matter. People can agree on a set of facts in order to see how their moral responses diverge.

Let me reiterate that this is irrelevent for the purpose of this discussion. You charged me with taking a pro-life stance when I argued that removing a few years from a cow's life was not morally wrong because they lacked the brain capacity to even comprehend such a thought. I distinguished the cow from an infant based on potentiality. So, you argue, why should I allow abortion when a fetus has the same potentiality as an infant?

First, for the purposes of establishing intellectual consistency all I need to do I show that abortion is somehow different than killing an infant. You don't have to agree with that as a justification for legal abortion. That's a unique discussion. Therefore I must establish a need sufficient to trump the rights of the potential human in gestation. I am arguing that the needs of the mother, however mockable they might be, are sufficient. Again, you can disagree with this, but my corpus of beliefs does not contain any contradictory elements with respect to the slaughter of cattle.

Now, as far as abortion itself goes, I would argue that the rights of the potential child inside of the mother are inferior so long as the mother is needed for the fetus' survival. Unless the act of childbirth itself endangers the mother's life, as the fetus nears independent survival, the mother's rights lessen. The Supreme Court chose the end of the second trimester as a cutoff, and I agree with that reasoning.

This is fine, but then there's a detour.

One reason I think early-term abortion is justified, in contrast to killing an infant, is that a bundle of cells has not even reached the point of being able to experience suffering. In both cases the potential is the same, but the act of taking life itself will be different.

Earlier you had staked your case on viability outside the womb. So, let's say you're in a fertility clinic and there's a fire. You can pick up an infant, or carry a smallish freezer containing hundreds of embryos, hundreds of mortality-envisioning potential lives. Who/what do you save? If you're claiming potentiality, then you "save" the freezer. If you pick up the infant, than you're ceding there's something important in that life apart from potentiality. This is a critical distinction.

You are trying to imply that there's some confusion in these statements. You can disagree, fine, but however you thought this applied to my approach to cattle, even you have to admit you're grasping at straws.

Hardly. It directly applies because we can establish the standards for respecting a life.

Sigh, even though I should have been conditioned, I'm still AMAZED by how literal your mind is. Sarcasm. That's all. I sarcastically described a cow's mental life as "'majestic."

Really?

Again, I never argued that cow's don't feel pain or happiness. That's why I argue for humane treatment. The question is whether they suffer when deprived of a few years of their life. That, unlike eating and crapping, they lack the ability to comprehend.

And yet that happiness and continued interest in living is somehow outweighed by my meal.

And I hope you're making a joke with that point about the souls. The mere fact that humans developed the concept of a death-surviving soul proves that they understand their mortality.They know the body will cease at some point, so they are thinking beyond.

Ah, so the standard has become, one must be able to understand one's earthly existence.

"You're again saying that animals enjoy better health, but better compared to what? They could also... not exist at all, which would have all kinds of positive benefits for human beings and the globe."

You HAVE to see how silly that argument is. Free range cattle enjoy a better life than their wild grazing counterparts. I enjoy a better life than many unfortunate citizens of Darfur.

How does growing your herd of domesticated cattle reduce suffering of animals in the wild? Those animals are still there, still suffering. You never seem to make this elementary connection.

And once again, if you eliminate all grazing animals you are destroying the environment. You're just going around in circles, reiterating the same nonsense over and over. So let's say it's financed by the government. Once more, the herd will have to be periodically culled in order to protect the integrity of the ecosystem. Should we just destroy the carcasses and not eat the meat?

No, we can eat that meat. As I may have said earlier, I'm a fan of roadkill. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with eating meat.
 
I suggest you revisit my original criticism, and I'll remind you in thirty seconds to wipe the dumb expression off your face:

Are you going out into nature and and raising animals you have personally rescued? If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming. Those animals still endure injury and suffer disease. What you're likely doing is bringing animals into the world who otherwise would not exist, which is something entirely different than the self-congratulatory, borderline Messianic nonsense printed above.

Oh dear lord. I take this as a white flag of surrender. Holy Christ.

"If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming."

No kidding. I am not talking about animals in nature, I am arguing that domesticated animals benefit from human stewardship. Your point is amazingly stupid and completely beside the point.

Not to mention that with proper maintenance of grazing areas, which includes both insuring that there are healthy herd animals AND keeping those numbers controlled, benefits wild animals in prairie ecosystems enormously. But as I said, that is completely irrelevent.

"What you're likely doing is bringing animals into the world who otherwise would not exist, which is something entirely different than the self-congratulatory, borderline Messianic nonsense printed above."

Again, and again, and again, you evade my response to this issue. You have still never described to me what sense ANYTHING can be said to benefit. Let's bring it down to a level you're more comfortable with: what do you think the word "benefit" means?

If those domesticated herd animals were not brought into existence, there would be some wild corollary. As someone concerned about the environment I cannot imagine that you would want the elimination of all grazing animals on the planet. Thus, there must be some grazing animals because of all the ecosystems that have evolved to depend on them. So the animals in those ecosystems will either be domesticated or not. If they are domesticated they will BENEFIT tremendously when compared to the alternative. Please don't just reiterate your stupid removal thesis. I understand it. It's dumb.


The problem is that you're fragmenting one point, my point. The argument is that we would not have 100 million more cattle in nature if not for domestication, so the idea that those animals would suffer, starve etc. is mistaken. I'm not sure why it has taken three pages and tens of thousands of words for you to understand such a basic point. Instead you choose to jump wildly between analogies, from elephant trunks to prisons. OK, I'm a man of my word, you can now wipe the dumb expression off your face.

You have approached the issue from at least two positions. I broke them down in the last post. It is amazing that you think an issue can only be approached from a single perspective.

The question at hand is whether free range cattle benefit from domestication. Of course there wouldn't be 100 million cattle without domestication. There wouldn't have been millions of generations of people able to manipulate fire if it had never been discovered. That does not mean we did not BENEFIT from fire. Likewise, cattle benefit from domestication.

Your point is simple and stupid. You say it over and over with no comprehension for it's obvious, fatal flaws. You ignore the analogies because you're either too literal and rediculous to perform the mental task of analogizing, or you know they destroy your case.

Answer these simple questions without regard for the previous argument. After, we can decide if they're relevent:

1) Do I benefit from my freedom even though I've never been in prison?
2) Do I benefit from living in the United States even though I've never lived in Darfur?
3) Did man benefit from the discovery of fire?
4) Does an elephant benefit from its trunk?

I did not say Paris Hilton visited violence upon her dog (geez, talk about an "impoverished" or "frivolous" literal mind :rolleyes:). I'm making a distinction between phases.

As evidence of my unique abililty in this interlocution to understand analogy, I would ask you to reread my response to your goofy comment. Of course I realized you didn't mean Paris Hilton herself which is why I discussed the process by which wolves were domesticate. Did you not read that part, or was it just a little too much for you to understand?

You said:
"If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence."

I stated clearly that I don't understand this analogy. What is the act in domestication, analagous to the "initial violence" in your example, that cannot be retroactively justified? I gave you two interpretations of what I thought you could mean, and dealt with those possibilities. If there is another that I have missed, please produce it or just clarify your analogy.


It does not matter. People can agree on a set of facts in order to see how their moral responses diverge.

Fine, but recognize that there are few methods of arguing more cowardly then throwing up your hands in hystrionics (note the number of "eyerolls" in your posts), acting as though you're only accepting scientific studies in the midst of ad hoc placation. The empirical work is the basis of my position, so either challenge it (which you cannot) or accept it without the snide, childish nonsense.


Earlier you had staked your case on viability outside the womb. So, let's say you're in a fertility clinic and there's a fire. You can pick up an infant, or carry a smallish freezer containing hundreds of embryos, hundreds of mortality-envisioning potential lives. Who/what do you save? If you're claiming potentiality, then you "save" the freezer. If you pick up the infant, than you're ceding there's something important in that life apart from potentiality. This is a critical distinction.

Once again, this has little to do with anything we've been arguing.

Of courese there's a critical distinction, but the positions aren't mutually exclusive. The justifications for legalized abortion, in my mind, have to do with viability. One reason I do not lament early abortions is because the fetus is pre-sentient. So no matter the violence of the procedure, no pain will be caused. This is perfectly consistent with my position in regard to the humane treatment of animals.

And in your fire example, those frozen embryos are a special case of potentiality: it requires a whole lot of external activity to realize the potential of those frozen cells. The infant, however, has already passed through those stages. In that example I see the frozen embryos more like an unfertalized egg or unused sperm cell in so far as some potential for life clearly exists, but our ethical obligations are lessened. More importantly, here you're asking me to chose between two entities with the same ultimate potential. So I can acknowledge, without cognitive dissonance, that there is something other than potential involved. An active human life vs. a potential human life. This poses no difficulty to anything I've said. Cows obviously have a different potential, so we can adjust our behavior and remain ethically consistent.

In general, trying to suss out proper morality from instances of immediate, sometimes impossible ethical peril, doesn't usually lead to generally viable concepts. For example, the current torture regime our government has surreptitiously established horrifies me. Yet, I cannot say with 100% certainty that I wouldn't cross some of those same lines if such action were required to save a loved one. But that is an extreme, cosmically unlikely scenario, even on the governmental level. Thus my behavior in such a situation reveals relatively little about how we should construct our society.

Hardly. It directly applies because we can establish the standards for respecting a life.

That was true to a point, but once intellectual consistency is established, details concerning my views on abortion are irrelevent.


And yet that happiness and continued interest in living is somehow outweighed by my meal.

This is just a worthless, throw-away barb meant to upset me. If the only reason for slaughtering cattle or other herd animals was to satisfy my tastes, I wouldn't support the activity. You have now placed yourself in the category of endless idiots, most recently championed by Bush administration officials, who are either consistently too stupid to understand an issue or are simply lying about it. You can decide for yourself which category you fall under.

Ah, so the standard has become, one must be able to understand one's earthly existence.

Nice try. You made another really, really dumb statement when you argued that people who believe in souls have no conception of mortality. This is hilariously dumb as merely discussion the idea of an immortal soul shows your familiarity with human frailty.

Count up the number of animal species on this planet who pass their time theorizing about what happens after death. It has nothing to do with "understanding one's earthly existence," as such a low bar can be met by anything with a biological drive to obtain nutrients. The issue is whether a cow has anything more than a subsistent mental life. Lying or stupidity. Which one were you participating in there?

How does growing your herd of domesticated cattle reduce suffering of animals in the wild? Those animals are still there, still suffering. You never seem to make this elementary connection.

Why does it have to reduce suffering of wild animals in order to justiable behavior towards the domesticated animals themselves? If I make sure to feed and care for my child, am I not benefiting that child because someone is starving in Darfur?

Once again, you're just spewing out idiotic tripe. We can have another discussion about the best way to handle wilderness and wildlife, but this is a conversation about proper behavior towards controlled animals.

No, we can eat that meat. As I may have said earlier, I'm a fan of roadkill. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with eating meat.

Good, then we agree on this. Practically we would have to figure out how much meat this amouted too, and adjust national consumption based that amount. Fine, that's settled.
 
Last edited:
Tranewreck said:
Right, which is why we need to end the bad practices (feed-lots and such) and move to a free-range only system. We have no argument there.
Which assumes that this clears up all the problems...

Interestingly, I'm not sure it's completely a numbers issue.

http://www.ext.nodak.edu/extnews/new...3/06livstk.htm

That article places the total number of cattle in the US at about 100million. The most conservative estimates of the number of bison prior to the 19th century were around 60million. There very likely could have been 100 million buffalo on the plains.
Assuming, of course, that the vast numbers of pork and chicken that we grow have no effect on the environment as well...?

That's even suggesting that buffalo and cattle are exactly alike and the numbers match up evenly, not to mention the suggestion that it still means that there wasn't the 12.5% of global warming gasses from methane and nitrogen back then (there may have been, just without the 87.5% of other man-made gasses expounding on it).

So the issue is one of proper practice.

Perhaps it is. It'll take more than the say-so of a few internet arguers and a silly numbers game for me to go for it, though.
 
Which assumes that this clears up all the problems...

I don't know any other ways to say this: If you are concerned about the environment, you must protect local ecosystems. This means keeping waterways clear of pollutants, it means stopping the clear-cutting of rainforests, and it means protecting endangered species.

The Great Plains of North America NEED grazing animals to be healthy. I linked a bunch of papers in an earlier post that made this point. Without some form of herding animals, whether free-range cattle or tended buffalo herds, the prairies and plains will suffer in the same way a polluted waterway suffers.

Assuming, of course, that the vast numbers of pork and chicken that we grow have no effect on the environment as well...?

I don't know what you mean to prove here. There is some level of animal population that is healthy for the environment. I don't know what that is for pigs and chicken. I was simply making the point that the Great Plains held an AWESOME number of animals before we began destroying them. Whatever that number is for whatever animal, maintaining an healthy ecosystem (and ensuring quality of life for the animals) requires finding that balance.


That's even suggesting that buffalo and cattle are exactly alike and the numbers match up evenly, not to mention the suggestion that it still means that there wasn't the 12.5% of global warming gasses from methane and nitrogen back then (there may have been, just without the 87.5% of other man-made gasses expounding on it).

Bison and cattle are very different. Buffalo are significantly better for the Great Plains ecosystem because the plant and animal life evolved based on their grazing patterns. That being said, in plains areas grazed by cattle an acceptible level of health can be achieved.

Given that the number of cattle today is roughly the same as the number of bison in the 19th century, it's not far-fetched to guess that the methane excretion was similar. Excess greenhouse gases are a human problem. If we change our habits, that percentage from animals will be irrelevent.

Perhaps it is. It'll take more than the say-so of a few internet arguers and a silly numbers game for me to go for it, though.

Fine, go read all of the papers I linked earlier. I never asked anyone to take my word for it.
 
My Internet and this forum take turns dying, and they've been in rhythm recently.

Oh dear lord. I take this as a white flag of surrender. Holy Christ.

So now you're reduced to Palinisms. White flag of surrender, indeed.

"If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming."

No kidding. I am not talking about animals in nature, I am arguing that domesticated animals benefit from human stewardship. Your point is amazingly stupid and completely beside the point.

You know what's fitting here? The Captain Picard facepalm.

Again, and again, and again, you evade my response to this issue. You have still never described to me what sense ANYTHING can be said to benefit. Let's bring it down to a level you're more comfortable with: what do you think the word "benefit" means?

If those domesticated herd animals were not brought into existence, there would be some wild corollary. As someone concerned about the environment I cannot imagine that you would want the elimination of all grazing animals on the planet. Thus, there must be some grazing animals because of all the ecosystems that have evolved to depend on them. So the animals in those ecosystems will either be domesticated or not. If they are domesticated they will BENEFIT tremendously when compared to the alternative. Please don't just reiterate your stupid removal thesis. I understand it. It's dumb.

...
Of course there wouldn't be 100 million cattle without domestication.

QED. Thanks for playing.
P.S. Apart from the inadvertent truth spasm, it seems as though you still insist on committing the fallacy of uninterrupted trends.

Your point is simple and stupid. You say it over and over with no comprehension for it's obvious, fatal flaws. You ignore the analogies because you're either too literal and rediculous to perform the mental task of analogizing, or you know they destroy your case.

Answer these simple questions without regard for the previous argument. After, we can decide if they're relevent:

1) Do I benefit from my freedom even though I've never been in prison?
2) Do I benefit from living in the United States even though I've never lived in Darfur?
3) Did man benefit from the discovery of fire?
4) Does an elephant benefit from its trunk?

I'm going to answer "yes" to all of those, but let me just restate now that the elephant example is particularly stupid, even for you.

And can I just say one other thing? Ridiculous is not spelled with an 'E'. I let that go a dozen times because rarely do I correct spelling errors (that is, unless someone wants to play "literary police"), but I want to spare you further embarrassment of that self-imposed "jackass" sign on your back.

I stated clearly that I don't understand this analogy. What is the act in domestication, analagous to the "initial violence" in your example, that cannot be retroactively justified? I gave you two interpretations of what I thought you could mean, and dealt with those possibilities. If there is another that I have missed, please produce it or just clarify your analogy.

Keep in mind that there is a generational dynamic at work. Consider for example slavery. There was a person writing for some Ayn Rand website claiming he was happy his ancestors were slaves because it meant he got to be an American. He benefited from slavery because without slavery he would not exist. And the same could be said for any child conceived via rape.

Let me help you out, as I'm feeling generous this afternoon. If you want to make a half-way decent argument, you can claim that perhaps there were some road bumps on the way to domestication, especially, as noted, with modern factory farms. However, all of that is a sunk cost because animals on free range farms enjoy a wonderful life, and their happiness matters. Oh, you bet it does, but we must make a crucial distinction: these animals lead biological lives, not biographical ones, so they are completely replaceable; their replaceability means we can slaughter them (painlessly), eat them (maximizing happiness), and replenish their stock.

I've argued this topic with people a lot smarter and more informed than you.

Fine, but recognize that there are few methods of arguing more cowardly then throwing up your hands in hystrionics (note the number of "eyerolls" in your posts), acting as though you're only accepting scientific studies in the midst of ad hoc placation. The empirical work is the basis of my position, so either challenge it (which you cannot) or accept it without the snide, childish nonsense.

:rolleyes:

Once again, this has little to do with anything we've been arguing.

That you do not see its relevance is instructive.

Of courese there's a critical distinction, but the positions aren't mutually exclusive. The justifications for legalized abortion, in my mind, have to do with viability. One reason I do not lament early abortions is because the fetus is pre-sentient. So no matter the violence of the procedure, no pain will be caused. This is perfectly consistent with my position in regard to the humane treatment of animals.

And in your fire example, those frozen embryos are a special case of potentiality: it requires a whole lot of external activity to realize the potential of those frozen cells. The infant, however, has already passed through those stages. In that example I see the frozen embryos more like an unfertalized egg or unused sperm cell in so far as some potential for life clearly exists, but our ethical obligations are lessened. More importantly, here you're asking me to chose between two entities with the same ultimate potential. So I can acknowledge, without cognitive dissonance, that there is something other than potential involved. An active human life vs. a potential human life. This poses no difficulty to anything I've said. Cows obviously have a different potential, so we can adjust our behavior and remain ethically consistent.

The suspect lines have been kindly underlined. I think most of the above is perfectly reasonable, but it clashes with statements you made earlier. First of all, it's not a matter of two entities but many versus one born human. Looking at generational impact alone, you're choosing the small benefit. More important is this new distinction between an "active" human life and a potential life, but according to your own standard the only real value arises when it gets older, when it's capable of "theorizing about death," otherwise it's a replaceable being that merely eats and craps.

In general, trying to suss out proper morality from instances of immediate, sometimes impossible ethical peril, doesn't usually lead to generally viable concepts.

This is generally a good rule, but wrong in this case, and a wrong comparison. That element is added here precisely to clarify a hierarchy of values. In many cases we might be able to save the city, capture the bad guy and get the girl. That's usually not very interesting though, nor is how you could realistically be expected to act. There's a fire at your kid's school and he could be in one of two rooms. You only have enough time to open one of the doors. There are fifty kids in one room, and 5 in the other. Since the odds are more likely your child is in the room with fifty, you open that one. Fine, but what if you know your child is in the room with five? People would probably understand. Morality, however, forces us to try to assume an impartial point of view.

That was true to a point, but once intellectual consistency is established, details concerning my views on abortion are irrelevent.

Again, this is mistaken. You will note the last example is not even about abortion at all.

This is just a worthless, throw-away barb meant to upset me. If the only reason for slaughtering cattle or other herd animals was to satisfy my tastes, I wouldn't support the activity. You have now placed yourself in the category of endless idiots, most recently championed by Bush administration officials, who are either consistently too stupid to understand an issue or are simply lying about it. You can decide for yourself which category you fall under.

It's all about you, isn't it? What are the other reasons?

Nice try. You made another really, really dumb statement when you argued that people who believe in souls have no conception of mortality. This is hilariously dumb as merely discussion the idea of an immortal soul shows your familiarity with human frailty.

Count up the number of animal species on this planet who pass their time theorizing about what happens after death. It has nothing to do with "understanding one's earthly existence," as such a low bar can be met by anything with a biological drive to obtain nutrients. The issue is whether a cow has anything more than a subsistent mental life. Lying or stupidity. Which one were you participating in there?

Lying or stupidity -- I think that's a false dichotomy. Perhaps you should add esotericism. The underlined sentence is false. The one that follows not only lacks justification, but has the misfortune of inconsistent application (see above in the freezer example).

Why does it have to reduce suffering of wild animals in order to justiable behavior towards the domesticated animals themselves? If I make sure to feed and care for my child, am I not benefiting that child because someone is starving in Darfur?

What I'm saying is that wild animals' welfare remains constant regardless, so why do you insist upon making a comparison to them (I should say it remains constant given your contestable assumption that domesticated grazing does not consume resources or emit pollutants that harm animals in the wild). The example that you follow up with is like shooting yourself in the foot for fun. It's as if you're volunteering to be corrected on a separate issue.
 
So now you're reduced to Palinisms. White flag of surrender, indeed.

I'm sorry, I didn't realize Sarah Palin invented the use of a white flag to symbolize surrender.

You know what's fitting here? The Captain Picard facepalm.

What would be fitting here was an actual response. You still think it's significant that without domestication there wouldn't be this number of animals. I have argued I don't need to prove those SAME animals would exist to say that the current animals under domestication have benefited. You still haven't offered any description of what you think the word "benefit" means. This is evasive and pathetic.

QED. Thanks for playing.
P.S. Apart from the inadvertent truth spasm, it seems as though you still insist on committing the fallacy of uninterrupted trends.

Sigh. No, I am commiting no such fallacy. I recognize fully that without domestication any number of occurences were likely.

You really have to play at being a moron in order to accpt your silly removal thesis. Certainly we don't know EXACTLY what would have happened to that specific genetic line of, say, cattle if they hadn't been domesticated. But we have a pretty good idea. There are herds of cattle that have been wild during that entire period, so it's a safe bet that those in question would have turned out similarly. Compare the life of a wild herd of cattle to a domesticated group and it is easy to see that the domestic herd has benefited.

I am making a historical statement, thus I am observing a past trend and making a solid comparisson based on the similarity of species. In order to commit the fallacy of uninterupted trends I would have to project some phenomenon under the assumption that it would continue with unbroken regularity. I have said over and over that I have no idea what would happen to the undomesticated genetics. But don't let that get in the way of an opportunity to misapply something you read about on wikipedia.

Please explain why I cannot make that comparisson. Forget about any concept of genetic heritage, just tell why I can't say that domestic cattle are better off than wild cattle.

I'm going to answer "yes" to all of those, but let me just restate now that the elephant example is particularly stupid, even for you.

Why? Please explain why it isn't analagous. The trunk is a genetic development. We can easily conjur up a vision of a world where elephants never evolved such a feature. Something would have happened to that genetic line: extinction, a new feature, pre-trunk stasis. But all of that is irrelevent, it is simply a tool that benefits an elephant tremedously.

For once in this discussion try actually wading into the conceptual argument. You simply reiterate your goofy nonsense without responding to any of the challenges. None of your comments develop your thought in any way, they're merely the same dumb statement over and over. Explain why, with an understanding of the analogy at hand, the elephant example fails.

But now finally we've gotten somewhere. If you think all those scenarios represent a benefit, explain why and how domestication is different. This will be tough for you as it requires focused, specific discussion. I even put numbers in front of them to help organize that mess of a mind you drag about.


And can I just say one other thing? Ridiculous is not spelled with an 'E'. I let that go a dozen times because rarely do I correct spelling errors (that is, unless someone wants to play "literary police"), but I want to spare you further embarrassment of that self-imposed "jackass" sign on your back.

I knew it was a only a matter of time before you returned to something this petty. You are completely incapable of dealing with or grasping basic concepts like analogy. Thus your petulant brat of an intellect cannot resist harping on frivolous matters.

And I LOVE the idea that you rarely correct spelling errors. That's rich indeed. Your first three responses, until I berated you for acting like a frustrated punk, were based around mispelled words.

Amusing too is the idea that my highlighting of your awesome conceptual failures amounts to "literary police." You don't understand basic analogy. Analogy is a fundamental reasoning tool used by all Western thought since at least Socrates. Yet you can't even get beyond its basic construct. Literary police indeed.

Keep in mind that there is a generational dynamic at work. Consider for example slavery. There was a person writing for some Ayn Rand website claiming he was happy his ancestors were slaves because it meant he got to be an American. He benefited from slavery because without slavery he would not exist. And the same could be said for any child conceived via rape.

So you were making the exact point that, when I discussed it in the last post, you accused me of misinterpreting your words. Why, once again, do you think I brought up the example of the domestication of dogs? That is honestly stunning. I am now convinced that from moment to moment YOU have no idea what you're saying.


Let me help you out, as I'm feeling generous this afternoon. If you want to make a half-way decent argument, you can claim that perhaps there were some road bumps on the way to domestication, especially, as noted, with modern factory farms. However, all of that is a sunk cost because animals on free range farms enjoy a wonderful life, and their happiness matters. Oh, you bet it does, but we must make a crucial distinction: these animals lead biological lives, not biographical ones, so they are completely replaceable; their replaceability means we can slaughter them (painlessly), eat them (maximizing happiness), and replenish their stock.

I dealt with this two posts ago. Instead of responding, you tried to berate me for approaching Paris Hilton's dog with the same mind-boggling literality you cannot escape.

I will say two things about this "initial violence."

First, it is not always the case that such violence is present. As I described a while ago, the domestication of wolves is thought to have been a slow, organic process. Less aggressive wolves moved closer to humans and were thusly placed in an evolutionarily beneficial position as ice-age humans were awesomely successful hunters. Many cattle and herd animals like sheep probably went through a similar process.

Second, and more importantly, your point is completely off-base for the purposes of justifying CURRENT domestication practices. Let's assume that there exists a group of animals whose ancestors were brutalized during the initial domestication procedure thousands of years ago. I agree with you that no matter how well we treat those decendants, initial brutality is not justified. Slavery is a perfect analogy (funny how when you make an analogy I can actually deal with it).

Fine, but how is that an argument against treating the animals well now? Certainly, you wouldn't toss out a program like afirmative action because it didn't justify slavery. Slavery, in your analogy, would be the sunk costs that eventually led to a life supported by afirmative action in the United States, as a pose to Africa.

I do not have to argue that domestication justifies an initial brutal act (I disagree with you factually that domestication was a brutal procedure) in order to argue in favor of domestication now. It would be as rediculous to condemn free-range ranching on those grounds as it would be to toss away afirmative action because it doesn't make up for slavery.

Let me end this little section by once again reiterating that inhumane practices whenever and however they occured are wrong. I have never argued differently, but I find it perpetually amusing that your case is so weak you need to try to slip in references to "factory farms" at every turn. Plenty of domesticated animal herds throughout the world have never gone throught that misery.


I've argued this topic with people a lot smarter and more informed than you.

And I've argued this topic with few as petty and frivolous as you.

See next quote.


That you do not see its relevance is instructive.

What's funny about you is that there is no such thing as moving on. When you first introduced the idea of abortion it was an obvious, simplistic response to my advance of potential as a crucial element. Fine. It was initially relevent, though weak, and I immediately explained why it wasn't inconsistent with my earlier arguments. All discussion after has been a tangential debate about the internal consistency of my views on abortion.

The suspect lines have been kindly underlined. I think most of the above is perfectly reasonable, but it clashes with statements you made earlier. First of all, it's not a matter of two entities but many versus one born human. Looking at generational impact alone, you're choosing the small benefit. More important is this new distinction between an "active" human life and a potential life, but according to your own standard the only real value arises when it gets older, when it's capable of "theorizing about death," otherwise it's a replaceable being that merely eats and craps.

I will (despite what I've learned about your ability to argue) give you the benefit of the doubt and hold myself responsible for lack of clarity.

"...but according to your own standard the only real value arises when it gets older, when it's capable of "theorizing about death..."

This is not at all what I'm arguing, with the key word of emphasis being "only." I have never argued that potential was the ONLY value, just that it separates humans from cows. There we have an example of different potential.

When it comes to comparing humans to humans I can asses them with a different measuring stick. In the case of the embryos and the child, if forced to decide I would chose the entity with feelings and thoughts, primitive as they are, over the non-sentient bundle of cells. This does not contradict anything I've said.

Your difficulty is in assuming that the relevent factor in distinguishing A from B has to be the relvent factor in distinguishing B from C (or in this case B1 from B2). That is an absurd assumption on your part.

This is generally a good rule, but wrong in this case, and a wrong comparison. That element is added here precisely to clarify a hierarchy of values. In many cases we might be able to save the city, capture the bad guy and get the girl. That's usually not very interesting though, nor is how you could realistically be expected to act. There's a fire at your kid's school and he could be in one of two rooms. You only have enough time to open one of the doors. There are fifty kids in one room, and 5 in the other. Since the odds are more likely your child is in the room with fifty, you open that one. Fine, but what if you know your child is in the room with five? People would probably understand. Morality, however, forces us to try to assume an impartial point of view.

The example itself is just melodrama. You don't need a burning building to establish the idea that a society has more obligations to a living child than they do towards a bundle of non-sentient frozen cells. Change the example a little and the point becomes clear: What if you had to choose between a two year old and a four year old? Does that choice say anything about your hierarchy of values? How about a four year old and a twenty year old with a broken leg?

Those absurd scenarios either assume the answer before it's asked or establish a scenario with no right or wrong answer based on anyone's morality. The one you gave above, of the school, is a perfect example. Would you find the person choosing morally repugnant for either decision?

Again, this is mistaken. You will note the last example is not even about abortion at all.

No, it's more of your ham-fisted attempt to expose some sort of contradictory element to my thought structure. It's still irrelevent to the point at hand.

It's all about you, isn't it? What are the other reasons?

Have you been paying attention at all? Why do you ask questions that have been answered twenty times?

The other reason is the necessary maintenance of local grazing-based ecosystems. You remember, the part you said you had no problem with? I am astonished that your memory is that weak.

Lying or stupidity -- I think that's a false dichotomy. Perhaps you should add esotericism. The underlined sentence is false. The one that follows not only lacks justification, but has the misfortune of inconsistent application (see above in the freezer example).

Only if you think I need to apply the same reasoning for distinguishing a cow from a human to distinguishing a potential human from a human. You are making a fallacious argument that falls well in line with your habit of being completely incapable of breaking down lines of reasoning.

What I'm saying is that wild animals' welfare remains constant regardless, so why do you insist upon making a comparison to them (I should say it remains constant given your contestable assumption that domesticated grazing does not consume resources or emit pollutants that harm animals in the wild). The example that you follow up with is like shooting yourself in the foot for fun. It's as if you're volunteering to be corrected on a separate issue.
[/QUOTE]

You have this silly habit of claiming an example is bad without bothering to explain why. The reason for this is obvious: you lack the ability to both understand and challenge the example presented. I do not need to grow up in Sudan, live in Sudan, or even travel to Sudan in order to benefit from life in the United States. Sudan is how things could be, but aren't, therefore I benefit.

The wild is how things could be for domesticated animals, but are not, therefore they benefit. All wild grazing animals in the history of planet Earth have faired worse than free-range bred cattle. That is simply an empirical statement based on health and safety.

As for your hare-brained parenthetical, "I should say it remains constant given your contestable assumption that domesticated grazing does not consume resources or emit pollutants that harm animals in the wild," grazing animals ARE the ecosystem. I have stated clearly that the best case scenario is managed buffalo herds, but removing grazing animals from the prairies is like killing all the whales in the ocean. Just imagine what would happen to Africa if all the wildabeast were removed. The health of the prairie REQUIRES grazing.

And if you think it's so "contestible" find an article or something. Because your abilities are inferior, you like to create the impression that something is argumentatively insufficient without having the skill or courage to deal with it directly. It's sad.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, I didn't realize Sarah Palin invented the use of a white flag to symbolize surrender.

Larry Craig didn't invent foot-tapping and Dan Quayle wasn't the first (or last) person to say stupid things. Also can you please sharpen your arguments? Your posts tend to drone on and on and this one is no exception. If only your tenacity could somehow be used to compensate for your writing and reasoning abilities.

[quote[What would be fitting here was an actual response. You still think it's significant that without domestication there wouldn't be this number of animals. I have argued I don't need to prove those SAME animals would exist to say that the current animals under domestication have benefited. You still haven't offered any description of what you think the word "benefit" means. This is evasive and pathetic.[/quote]

I'm not sure what I can say apart from what I have said already, more than once. You're mistaking my central objection. *shrug*

Sigh. No, I am commiting no such fallacy. I recognize fully that without domestication any number of occurences were likely.

You really have to play at being a moron in order to accpt your silly removal thesis. Certainly we don't know EXACTLY what would have happened to that specific genetic line of, say, cattle if they hadn't been domesticated. But we have a pretty good idea. There are herds of cattle that have been wild during that entire period, so it's a safe bet that those in question would have turned out similarly. Compare the life of a wild herd of cattle to a domesticated group and it is easy to see that the domestic herd has benefited.

I am making a historical statement, thus I am observing a past trend and making a solid comparisson based on the similarity of species. In order to commit the fallacy of uninterupted trends I would have to project some phenomenon under the assumption that it would continue with unbroken regularity. I have said over and over that I have no idea what would happen to the undomesticated genetics. But don't let that get in the way of an opportunity to misapply something you read about on wikipedia.

Please explain why I cannot make that comparisson. Forget about any concept of genetic heritage, just tell why I can't say that domestic cattle are better off than wild cattle.

Um, earlier you had written: If you only understand the domestication process in terms of the present, it may not make sense. But those animals were domesticated over thousands of years. If they hadn't been domesticate [sic], that entire genetic line would have existed in the wild. Instead, it was cared for by humans.

This is/was your argument, and I have rebutted it, multiple times, and it encapsulates a crucial difference between you and me: You have to shift, move, change, restate, restate again, whereas I can refer to my mostly untouched arguments.

For once in this discussion try actually wading into the conceptual argument. You simply reiterate your goofy nonsense without responding to any of the challenges. None of your comments develop your thought in any way, they're merely the same dumb statement over and over. Explain why, with an understanding of the analogy at hand, the elephant example fails.

But now finally we've gotten somewhere. If you think all those scenarios represent a benefit, explain why and how domestication is different. This will be tough for you as it requires focused, specific discussion. I even put numbers in front of them to help organize that mess of a mind you drag about.

What "goofy nonsense" is that? I answered your questions, but I don't think you have the slightest understanding of what's being said. Again, you need to focus your argument.

I knew it was a only a matter of time before you returned to something this petty. You are completely incapable of dealing with or grasping basic concepts like analogy. Thus your petulant brat of an intellect cannot resist harping on frivolous matters.

And I LOVE the idea that you rarely correct spelling errors. That's rich indeed. Your first three responses, until I berated you for acting like a frustrated punk, were based around mispelled words.

Well, I'm not placing much emphasis on these mistakes. You can be the worst speller in the world and still have the right argument. You're not the worst speller in the world, and you're probably wrong... I do rarely correct spelling errors, and I have thousands of posts to my credit. I do see a correction in the second of my first three responses, the passing remark "You can't even spell 'prairies' let alone..." I guess I was provoked by the now-standard "thoughtless," "nonsense," "ejaculate" boilerplate , which I find really energizing, by the way. I did make a more conscious effort after the "literalist" hype. Now I'm a "petulant brat" and "frustrated punk." Your flaming is just so... bad. Thankfully it's mildly amusing, and hopefully cathartic for your sake.

Amusing too is the idea that my highlighting of your awesome conceptual failures amounts to "literary police." You don't understand basic analogy. Analogy is a fundamental reasoning tool used by all Western thought since at least Socrates. Yet you can't even get beyond its basic construct. Literary police indeed.

You don't need to defend the practice of analogies. I use analogies quite often, and they're peppered throughout this thread. What you need to defend are your own particular analogies. Geez, get a clue.

So you were making the exact point that, when I discussed it in the last post, you accused me of misinterpreting your words. Why, once again, do you think I brought up the example of the domestication of dogs? That is honestly stunning. I am now convinced that from moment to moment YOU have no idea what you're saying.

This is verbiage without supporting quotes, reminiscent of how my first three responses were allegedly "based around" on mis-spelled words.

I dealt with this two posts ago. Instead of responding, you tried to berate me for approaching Paris Hilton's dog with the same mind-boggling literality you cannot escape.

I will say two things about this "initial violence."

First, it is not always the case that such violence is present. As I described a while ago, the domestication of wolves is thought to have been a slow, organic process. Less aggressive wolves moved closer to humans and were thusly placed in an evolutionarily beneficial position as ice-age humans were awesomely successful hunters. Many cattle and herd animals like sheep probably went through a similar process.

Second, and more importantly, your point is completely off-base for the purposes of justifying CURRENT domestication practices. Let's assume that there exists a group of animals whose ancestors were brutalized during the initial domestication procedure thousands of years ago. I agree with you that no matter how well we treat those decendants, initial brutality is not justified. Slavery is a perfect analogy (funny how when you make an analogy I can actually deal with it).

As for the tail end of this, I think the writer deserves the credit as well as the blame for analogies and whole posts in general, so thank you very much. You're also mistaking the time-frames. In the case of domestication, the period of brutalization is approximately now (the age of the modern factory farm).

Fine, but how is that an argument against treating the animals well now?

Simple: I never intended it as such an argument. Look again at your original post, my response, and your follow-up tantrums.

"...but according to your own standard the only real value arises when it gets older, when it's capable of "theorizing about death..."

This is not at all what I'm arguing, with the key word of emphasis being "only." I have never argued that potential was the ONLY value, just that it separates humans from cows. There we have an example of different potential.

When it comes to comparing humans to humans I can asses them with a different measuring stick. In the case of the embryos and the child, if forced to decide I would chose the entity with feelings and thoughts, primitive as they are, over the non-sentient bundle of cells. This does not contradict anything I've said.

Your difficulty is in assuming that the relevent factor in distinguishing A from B has to be the relvent factor in distinguishing B from C (or in this case B1 from B2). That is an absurd assumption on your part.

I'm not impressed with your dancing. You keep pre-emptively insist that it does not contradict what you said earlier, probably because it does contradict what you said earlier. When we were talking about killing a cow, you said that all it does is eats and craps; it's not going to miss its own life. You claimed the crucial difference between it and a similarly functioning human being is that a human being will be able to theorize about its own death. Now when talking about humans with this potentiality the crucial difference becomes these primitive feelings and thoughts.

The example itself is just melodrama. You don't need a burning building to establish the idea that a society has more obligations to a living child than they do towards a bundle of non-sentient frozen cells. Change the example a little and the point becomes clear: What if you had to choose between a two year old and a four year old? Does that choice say anything about your hierarchy of values? How about a four year old and a twenty year old with a broken leg?

Not really. I think it's reasonably clear we owe an obligation to child that we do not owe to a freezer full of embryos. I think when it comes to choosing between a two, four, and handicapped twenty year old, those distinctions become much less clear. Notice here your own language, obligation to the child.

The other reason is the necessary maintenance of local grazing-based ecosystems. You remember, the part you said you had no problem with? I am astonished that your memory is that weak.

I almost mentioned this, but wrongly gave you the benefit of the doubt: we already established that grazing need not involve slaughtering. Weak memory, indeed.

Only if you think I need to apply the same reasoning for distinguishing a cow from a human to distinguishing a potential human from a human. You are making a fallacious argument that falls well in line with your habit of being completely incapable of breaking down lines of reasoning.

This requires clarification.

You have this silly habit of claiming an example is bad without bothering to explain why.

You mean how I referred to your gratuitous example as a "separate issue"? Am I gonna have to John Madden this one for you?

The reason for this is obvious: you lack the ability to both understand and challenge the example presented. I do not need to grow up in Sudan, live in Sudan, or even travel to Sudan in order to benefit from life in the United States. Sudan is how things could be, but aren't, therefore I benefit.

It's possible for you to go to Darfur, steal whatever food they have, eat it yourself, and you're benefitting. It's a trivial, unenlightening example.

The wild is how things could be for domesticated animals, but are not, therefore they benefit. All wild grazing animals in the history of planet Earth have faired worse than free-range bred cattle. That is simply an empirical statement based on health and safety.

Pay close attention to my response because I think you're finally back on issue. Another alternative for domesticated animals is to never have existed at all.

As for your hare-brained parenthetical, "I should say it remains constant given your contestable assumption that domesticated grazing does not consume resources or emit pollutants that harm animals in the wild," grazing animals ARE the ecosystem. I have stated clearly that the best case scenario is managed buffalo herds, but removing grazing animals from the prairies is like killing all the whales in the ocean. Just imagine what would happen to Africa if all the wildabeast were removed. The health of the prairie REQUIRES grazing.

*sigh* I, unlike you, make a distinction between domesticated grazing (that is grazing animals to be slaughtered and consumed) and grazing. I thought we had already established that it's possible to have all of the necessary grazing without the unnecessary slaughtering for purposes of consumption.

And if you think it's so "contestible" find an article or something. Because your abilities are inferior, you like to create the impression that something is argumentatively insufficient without having the skill or courage to deal with it directly. It's sad.

Ending with a laugh line. Good job.
 
Larry Craig didn't invent foot-tapping and Dan Quayle wasn't the first (or last) person to say stupid things. Also can you please sharpen your arguments? Your posts tend to drone on and on and this one is no exception. If only your tenacity could somehow be used to compensate for your writing and reasoning abilities.

Please, my arguments are fine. My posts would be shorter if you would make specific points instead of coming up with goofy counters that I have to explain away. The excess writing is soley in response cogent argumentation.

[quote[What would be fitting here was an actual response. You still think it's significant that without domestication there wouldn't be this number of animals. I have argued I don't need to prove those SAME animals would exist to say that the current animals under domestication have benefited. You still haven't offered any description of what you think the word "benefit" means. This is evasive and pathetic.

I'm not sure what I can say apart from what I have said already, more than once. You're mistaking my central objection. *shrug*
[/QUOTE]

Again, a non-response. I understand exactly what you're saying. Without domestication the currently domesticated animals would never have existed, thus they cannot be said to have benefited from human stewardship.

I have given you a number of counterarguments that you have slithered away from, avoided, conflated, and generally bungled so dramatically that you're forced to dribble out single sentence evasions. Either provide actual content or drop the point.

Um, earlier you had written: If you only understand the domestication process in terms of the present, it may not make sense. But those animals were domesticated over thousands of years. If they hadn't been domesticate [sic], that entire genetic line would have existed in the wild. Instead, it was cared for by humans.

This is/was your argument, and I have rebutted it, multiple times, and it encapsulates a crucial difference between you and me: You have to shift, move, change, restate, restate again, whereas I can refer to my mostly untouched arguments.

First, there's nothing contradictory about those statements. You have this amusing habit of focusing on non-existent conceptual conflict.

Take the example of dogs. The genetic decendents of the wolves that stayed wild while their docile bretheren moved closer to humans still exist. So if I am curious what would happen to dogs had they not been domesticated, all I have to do is look at a wolf pack.

Domestication is a long process that happened while animals continued to live in the wild. I am not making any projections that would create an uninterrupted trend fallacy. It's amazing you cannot see this.

This comes from you taking this statement, "I have no idea what would happen to the undomesticated genetics," and interpreting it to mean something drastically larger. I have no idea whether life in the wild for the hypothetically undomesticated animals would have lead to life or death. But I do know very well what would happen to them within the tight parameters nature has given us.

Those statements are not contradictory.

What "goofy nonsense" is that? I answered your questions, but I don't think you have the slightest understanding of what's being said. Again, you need to focus your argument.

Haha, so you really have no idea what you're doing. Fine, that means I should treat you more charitably. I imposed bad faith where simple incompetence sufficed.

Your goofy nonsense is the endless reiteration of your dumb idea without dealing with any of the counter examples I've provided. You may not think they work, fine, but deal with them directly.

Well, I'm not placing much emphasis on these mistakes. You can be the worst speller in the world and still have the right argument. You're not the worst speller in the world, and you're probably wrong... I do rarely correct spelling errors, and I have thousands of posts to my credit. I do see a correction in the second of my first three responses, the passing remark "You can't even spell 'prairies' let alone..." I guess I was provoked by the now-standard "thoughtless," "nonsense," "ejaculate" boilerplate , which I find really energizing, by the way. I did make a more conscious effort after the "literalist" hype. Now I'm a "petulant brat" and "frustrated punk." Your flaming is just so... bad. Thankfully it's mildly amusing, and hopefully cathartic for your sake.

Hey, by all means, respond in kind. I could care less what you say about me, but you can't expect me to ignore your attacks. I don't expect you to ignore mine. But let's be real, here, the tone of this discussion was set when you tried to mock me for thinking Paris Hilton went into the wild and rescued her chihuahua. Don't whine now.

You don't need to defend the practice of analogies. I use analogies quite often, and they're peppered throughout this thread. What you need to defend are your own particular analogies. Geez, get a clue.

You may try to use it, I haven't seen you in any other context, but all I've seen in this discussion is you conflating analogies, taking them literally, and generally not understanding their use. Perhaps there's some thread out there that shows your deft understanding of the technique, but you have given me no evidence to conclude that you have any skill in the area.


This is verbiage without supporting quotes, reminiscent of how my first three responses were allegedly "based around" on mis-spelled words.

You began:
"You're also reducing your claim, mischaracterizing my original objection in the process. If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence."

I responded:
"So here is an analogy I don't understand. What was Paris Hilton's initial violence against her chihuahua? Or do you mean to say the first instance of domestication was a violent act?"

I then went on to discuss both the historic process of domestication (wolves-dogs) and current domestication practices (breaking horses)

Your response:
"I did not say Paris Hilton visited violence upon her dog (geez, talk about an "impoverished" or "frivolous" literal mind ). I'm making a distinction between phases."

And, of course, I did not take it literally. I was using it in the same figurative sense you were.

Your final explanation:
"If you want to make a half-way decent argument, you can claim that perhaps there were some road bumps on the way to domestication, especially, as noted, with modern factory farms. However, all of that is a sunk cost because animals on free range farms enjoy a wonderful life, and their happiness matters."

You then brought up slavery as an example to highlight your point. Bad act in the PAST not justified by modern quality of life.

That's a discussion of the historical process of domestication. YOU analogized it to slavery. Thus, when I discussed the process of dog domestication, I was rebutting the idea that domestication was like slavery. Exactly on point despite your convulsive denials.

And please, show me evidence that the free-range cattle in the Western United States came to be there via factory farms. The animals out there have existed as such since the first settlers brought them. There was no factory farming involved.

As for the tail end of this, I think the writer deserves the credit as well as the blame for analogies and whole posts in general, so thank you very much. You're also mistaking the time-frames. In the case of domestication, the period of brutalization is approximately now (the age of the modern factory farm).

I'm mistaking time frames? Haha, YOU used the example of slavery. YOU argued that contemporary benevolence doesn't justify past bad acts. Where on earth would I get the idea that historical time frame was relevent? Please find me the phrase, sentence, or paragraph in the exchange (beginning with your "counterargument" concerning past violence) that in any way indicates you were talking about modern factory farms.

Once again, you blame me for the idiotic crap you keep coming up with. But here you are again: lost and out of thought you go back to factory farms. Factory farms should be ended. Nothing justifies their existence. You can talk about them all day, but they have no bearing on my stance.

I might also add that if you meant factory farms in your original statement, what is the benevolence? Factory farms are wrong because they are a continuing cause of pain and suffering. Your original analogy now makes LESS sense.

Simple: I never intended it as such an argument. Look again at your original post, my response, and your follow-up tantrums.

YOU brought up the example of slavery. I was dealing with your analogy. Now that you've abandoned that stance, I no longer advance the counter argument.

I'm not impressed with your dancing. You keep pre-emptively insist that it does not contradict what you said earlier, probably because it does contradict what you said earlier. When we were talking about killing a cow, you said that all it does is eats and craps; it's not going to miss its own life. You claimed the crucial difference between it and a similarly functioning human being is that a human being will be able to theorize about its own death. Now when talking about humans with this potentiality the crucial difference becomes these primitive feelings and thoughts.

Really? Is this that hard for you to understand?

1) Difference between a cow and an infant=infant will eventually gain the mental capabilities that make deprivation of years of life harmful

2) Difference between infant and fetus/frozen embryo=potential is the same, therefore some other factor must be advanced. Thus, active life suffices for the frozen embryo, rights of the mother until the end of the second trimester for the fetus (and only because the mother's rights defeat).

I do not need to use the rationale in 1 to justify the distinction in 2.

Not really. I think it's reasonably clear we owe an obligation to child that we do not owe to a freezer full of embryos. I think when it comes to choosing between a two, four, and handicapped twenty year old, those distinctions become much less clear. Notice here your own language, obligation to the child.

Uh...sure. That's pretty much exactly what I said. The point is your burning building does little to inform us. What do you think that obligation is based on?

I almost mentioned this, but wrongly gave you the benefit of the doubt: we already established that grazing need not involve slaughtering. Weak memory, indeed.

I don't know who "we" represents, but I have consistently argued that maintaining the health of the ecosystem requires culling the herd. Animal overpopulation is as destructive to the environment as extinction (see rabbits in Australia, cattle in India, deer in the United States). Therefore, we can either reintroduce predators, which is terrible for livestock suffering, or we can humanely slaughter.

If you disagree, find me a single scientific source showing that overpopulation is not harmful to the environment. I gave you a big list of sources that say the opposite.

This requires clarification.

Just what I said above. The rationale to separate a cow from a child (potential) need not be used to distinguish a child from a fozen embryo.

It's possible for you to go to Darfur, steal whatever food they have, eat it yourself, and you're benefitting. It's a trivial, unenlightening example.

Haha, what? I can also benefit from not being in Darfur. We aren't talking about possible ways I can benefit, we're talking about the sense in which we use the word as applied to domestication.

Pay close attention to my response because I think you're finally back on issue. Another alternative for domesticated animals is to never have existed at all.

Another alternative is for human control of fire to never have existed at all. You have acknowledged that humans benefited from fire, please distinguish these points. If you cannot, than you accept that animals benefit from domestication.

*sigh* I, unlike you, make a distinction between domesticated grazing (that is grazing animals to be slaughtered and consumed) and grazing. I thought we had already established that it's possible to have all of the necessary grazing without the unnecessary slaughtering for purposes of consumption.

How, under your reasoning, will you control animal numbers?

Ending with a laugh line. Good job.

Oh man, you're right, what a joke. I asked you to provide evidentiary support for your ideas. HILARIOUS. What was I thinking?
 
Last edited:
*yawn* Now you ooze more desperation than usual, and this most recent post of yours is a complete mess, and if the "three spelling errors" fabrication from previously was bad enough, you now attempt to reconstruct a discussion on Paris Hilton's dog. I'll delete the first two bloc quotes as they are completely worthless.

Again, a non-response. I understand exactly what you're saying. Without domestication the currently domesticated animals would never have existed, thus they cannot be said to have benefited from human stewardship.

Well, that's good enough. This is related to statements at the very end of this post.

I have given you a number of counterarguments that you have slithered away from, avoided, conflated, and generally bungled so dramatically that you're forced to dribble out single sentence evasions. Either provide actual content or drop the point.

I'm not sure how I can respond to this since it does not argue anything as much assert, and what it does assert has the misfortune of being wrong. This thread was started because you made specific claims about domestication that were false. I called you on them, you protested, I stuck to it, and for the last several posts you have been attempting to revise your assertions while claiming they're the same. You could have simply admitted your mistake. My refusal to follow your moving of the goalposts is now interpreted as slithering away when you can't even tell what's coming and going. This is you running away from your statements while pretending otherwise:

First, there's nothing contradictory about those statements. You have this amusing habit of focusing on non-existent conceptual conflict.

Take the example of dogs. The genetic decendents of the wolves that stayed wild while their docile bretheren moved closer to humans still exist. So if I am curious what would happen to dogs had they not been domesticated, all I have to do is look at a wolf pack.

Domestication is a long process that happened while animals continued to live in the wild. I am not making any projections that would create an uninterrupted trend fallacy. It's amazing you cannot see this.

OK, and there would not be nearly as many as we have today. Let's just settle this matter once and for all, right where it all began, the moment you said:

I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs. In nature the animals would starve, die alone and terrified from a slight injury, suffer from disease, and generally live short lives frought [sic] with danger.

The key verb is "remove." You're not removing them from anything. They would not otherwise exist.

I'm snipping the statements devoid of content, but I'll include the one immediately below, chosen at random, as an example:

You may try to use it, I haven't seen you in any other context, but all I've seen in this discussion is you conflating analogies, taking them literally, and generally not understanding their use. Perhaps there's some thread out there that shows your deft understanding of the technique, but you have given me no evidence to conclude that you have any skill in the area.

Here you fail to quote me, and earlier you attributed your words to me. Now you attempt to reconstruct the exchange with incompetence verging on dishonesty. You should take more than ten minutes editing your posts. You should spend still more time reading for understanding, and organizing your replies, because you're fighting like you're surrounded:

[Cain:]This is verbiage without supporting quotes, reminiscent of how my first three responses were allegedly "based around" on mis-spelled words.

You began:
"You're also reducing your claim, mischaracterizing my original objection in the process. If you want to say that Paris Hilton's dog benefits from her care, or any pet benefits from the benevolent intervention of human beings, then fine. I could do violence against someone, and then nurse them back to health. It's obvious that my second sustained intervention is beneficial (compare with the invasion of Iraq, if you wish). This fact does not retroactively justify the initial violence."

I responded:
"So here is an analogy I don't understand. What was Paris Hilton's initial violence against her chihuahua? Or do you mean to say the first instance of domestication was a violent act?"

I then went on to discuss both the historic process of domestication (wolves-dogs) and current domestication practices (breaking horses)

Your response:
"I did not say Paris Hilton visited violence upon her dog (geez, talk about an "impoverished" or "frivolous" literal mind ). I'm making a distinction between phases."

And, of course, I did not take it literally. I was using it in the same figurative sense you were.

Your final explanation:
"If you want to make a half-way decent argument, you can claim that perhaps there were some road bumps on the way to domestication, especially, as noted, with modern factory farms. However, all of that is a sunk cost because animals on free range farms enjoy a wonderful life, and their happiness matters."

You then brought up slavery as an example to highlight your point. Bad act in the PAST not justified by modern quality of life.

This is not even chronologically correct, as the last two arguments appeared in reverse order, but no matter:

That's a discussion of the historical process of domestication. YOU analogized it to slavery. Thus, when I discussed the process of dog domestication, I was rebutting the idea that domestication was like slavery. Exactly on point despite your convulsive denials.

It seems you did not understand most of what I said, and you're leaping between at least three different examples: we have the domestication of dogs, which I suppose serves as some general catch all, the bad domestication of animals for human consumption, and the good or utopian free-range domestication of animals for human consumption.

All of which apparently leads up to this remark:
I'm mistaking time frames? Haha, YOU used the example of slavery. YOU argued that contemporary benevolence doesn't justify past bad acts. Where on earth would I get the idea that historical time frame was relevent? Please find me the phrase, sentence, or paragraph in the exchange (beginning with your "counterargument" concerning past violence) that in any way indicates you were talking about modern factory farms.

I should clarify. The modern factory farm represents a high water mark in atrocities, but animals have certainly been mistreated throughout their history. Human attitudes have not changed much until very recently, but the differences in treatment -- the extent of the atrocities -- stem from technological empowerment to do harm.

Now this:
And please, show me evidence that the free-range cattle in the Western United States came to be there via factory farms. The animals out there have existed as such since the first settlers brought them. There was no factory farming involved.

So you're ready and willing to defend the treatment of those animals since the beginning? Not just their introduction, the practice of branding, but slaughtering practices, and, now/recent past, their transportation to slaughterhouses and the manner in which they are slaughtered?

Really? Is this that hard for you to understand?

1) Difference between a cow and an infant=infant will eventually gain the mental capabilities that make deprivation of years of life harmful

2) Difference between infant and fetus/frozen embryo=potential is the same, therefore some other factor must be advanced. Thus, active life suffices for the frozen embryo, rights of the mother until the end of the second trimester for the fetus (and only because the mother's rights defeat).

I do not need to use the rationale in 1 to justify the distinction in 2.

The penultimate sentence is incoherent, though maybe that's supposed to testify to some larger symbolism. If the harm is "deprivation of years of life," then why does that apply to the infant and not the embryo? We're talking about relative value -- trying to tease out what matters -- yet you keep evading this point by introducing a conflict between mother and future child that does not exist. Moreover, "active life suffices for the frozen embryo" requires explanation because it seems like you're confusing your own terms. Take a minute to gather your thoughts.

Much later, in an attempt to clarify the distinction, you write: "The rationale to separate a cow from a child (potential) need not be used to distinguish a child from a fozen embryo."

Am I to assume "(potential)" should have been placed after "rationale" instead of "child" because as it stands it's ambiguous since we are also talking about a potential child? Let me just go point blank: What distinguishes the embryo from the child? Let me also focus a misguided argument you made earlier, where you asked the difference between a four year old and a twenty year old. Let's say a mother loses a pregnancy in the first trimester. Let's stipulate that she wanted to bring it to term, raise it, see it flourish as a fully realized human being. Now let's say a mother loses a two year old (he dies painlessly). From a morally neutral point of view, what's the difference (i.e., the relative value of the spontaneously abortion versus the death of the two year old), if any?

Uh...sure. That's pretty much exactly what I said. The point is your burning building does little to inform us. What do you think that obligation is based on?

I don't know what you base on it, but for me it's because a child is a morally significant being worthy of our consideration, regardless of whether or not it can "theorize about it's own mortality," a rather arbitrary and clueless standard.

I don't know who "we" represents, but I have consistently argued that maintaining the health of the ecosystem requires culling the herd. Animal overpopulation is as destructive to the environment as extinction (see rabbits in Australia, cattle in India, deer in the United States). Therefore, we can either reintroduce predators, which is terrible for livestock suffering, or we can humanely slaughter....

How, under your reasoning, will you control animal numbers?

Reading is fundamental. If we simply need animals to graze ecosystems then, sure, we can slaughter them to prevent overgrazing. To prevent overgrazing, not to consume them. Are you unable to summon any other reasons?

This is connected to the next dispute, another issue whizzing right over your head:

If you disagree, find me a single scientific source showing that overpopulation is not harmful to the environment. I gave you a big list of sources that say the opposite....

Oh man, you're right, what a joke. I asked you to provide evidentiary support for your ideas. HILARIOUS. What was I thinking?

You seem incapable of following relevant moral arguments. As noted earlier by another poster, if someone says consuming large herbivores creates less suffering for morally relevant beings, then I think that's an approach we should consider. This is a matter of carrying one's moral principles to their logical conclusion. What's interesting, to me at least, is the moral dispute. By way of contrast, someone could agree that veganism causes the least harm to animals, but that's immaterial, according to thier view, because harms to animals are outweighed by tasty meals. The dispute is one of a moral nature.

Haha, what? I can also benefit from not being in Darfur. We aren't talking about possible ways I can benefit, we're talking about the sense in which we use the word as applied to domestication.

*facepalm*What do you want me to say that I have not already said earlier? You do not seem to understand what the words "trivial" and "unenlightening" mean.

Another alternative is for human control of fire to never have existed at all. You have acknowledged that humans benefited from fire, please distinguish these points. If you cannot, than you accept that animals benefit from domestication.

Do you pay any attention to things I have previously written? There are two separate arguments against domestication:

Earlier, for instance, you said:
I am arguing that domestication is beneficial or preferable to life in the wild.

And by this domestication, of course, you mean idyllic free range scenarios, and I have written: "I will readily concede animals in a 'well tended herd' do not suffer as much as animals in the wild." My argument against this is and has been that if it's so great, then leave the animals alone.* Hence the discussion about future life, children, and embryos, the one you cannot see as "relevent [sic]" because you're flailing in the dark. You cannot keep all of the arguments swirling around straight, much less your own sprawling post, a monument to confusion and ignorance.

*Yes, you may humanely euthanize an animal, or slaughter as an alternative to the introduction of predators, assuming it's possible to manage these animals.
 
No, but somehow I've inferred from this entire thread that I need to stop eating meat on Fridays and stop using any birth control.
 
Extra good Catholics still don't eat meat on Fridays.
Friday is fish day; not a big sacrifice, if you like seafood.

Too much to ask, though, in retrospect. Wise pope.

Using no birth control is a lot easier than eating fish on friday.
 
On the other hand, in the West of Scotland, there seem to be people who consider it the duty of all good Protestants not to eat fish on a Friday. Even if that happens to be the most convenient day to purchase fresh fish!

Yawn.

Rolfe.
 
*yawn* Now you ooze more desperation than usual, and this most recent post of yours is a complete mess, and if the "three spelling errors" fabrication from previously was bad enough, you now attempt to reconstruct a discussion on Paris Hilton's dog. I'll delete the first two bloc quotes as they are completely worthless.

You are a drama queen.


I'm not sure how I can respond to this since it does not argue anything as much assert, and what it does assert has the misfortune of being wrong. This thread was started because you made specific claims about domestication that were false. I called you on them, you protested, I stuck to it, and for the last several posts you have been attempting to revise your assertions while claiming they're the same. You could have simply admitted your mistake. My refusal to follow your moving of the goalposts is now interpreted as slithering away when you can't even tell what's coming and going. This is you running away from your statements while pretending otherwise:

You're right, I should have specifically copied the 20 or so goofy errors you made that appear a few posts directly above. And fortunately you made the same error that began all this a little further on. Hilarious. Your entire point is based around a childish, literal interpretation of a simple point. Awesome stuff.

And interesting that you take pride in being incapable of defending your arguments. It is not sufficient to repeat the same nonsense over and over.

Your argument stye: There are WMD in Iraq. Sorry, you're wrong, there's no evidence. But there are WMD in Iraq. No, these weapons inspectors have documents proving they were destroyed. There are WMD in Iraq. The intelligence you use to draw that conclusion is flawed. Nope, there are WMD in Iraq.

This is not admirable.

And please, show me where my arguments have changed. I provided you a defense showing consistency and you simply ignored it.


OK, and there would not be nearly as many as we have today. Let's just settle this matter once and for all, right where it all began, the moment you said:

Wait, what? Now you're the one performing the fallacy of uniterrupted trends (or using the rationale you falsely described as such). What do you mean there would be more? How do you know this? They could have died from disease, who knows? Amazing how you can mistakenly accuse me of a logical error, then use THE EXACT SAME REASONING. Your lack of self-awareness is staggering.

The key verb is "remove." You're not removing them from anything. They would not otherwise exist.

I'm snipping the statements devoid of content, but I'll include the one immediately below, chosen at random, as an example:

The key word is "retarded." You are retarded for bringing this back up. Once again I MEANT THAT FIGURATIVELY. I recognize that save for the first instance of domestication you are not directly TAKING the animal from nature. It is a figurative statement meant to describe the benefits animals experience from proper human stewardship.

This is honestly amazing. Either you haven't read any of this discussion or your simply too dumb to understand figurative statements.

Here you fail to quote me, and earlier you attributed your words to me. Now you attempt to reconstruct the exchange with incompetence verging on dishonesty. You should take more than ten minutes editing your posts. You should spend still more time reading for understanding, and organizing your replies, because you're fighting like you're surrounded:

This is not even chronologically correct, as the last two arguments appeared in reverse order, but no matter:


Haha, ok. You mentioned slavery first. Please explain how that changes anything. You claimed domestication was like slavery, then used the "sunk cost" phrase. Both points meant to describe your analogy concerning "initial violence." It's hilarious to watch you point out minor errors without attaching any significance to them. Yes, good, I put those two points out of order. How does that change any argument I made? It doesn't.

It seems you did not understand most of what I said, and you're leaping between at least three different examples: we have the domestication of dogs, which I suppose serves as some general catch all, the bad domestication of animals for human consumption, and the good or utopian free-range domestication of animals for human consumption.

All of which apparently leads up to this remark:


I should clarify. The modern factory farm represents a high water mark in atrocities, but animals have certainly been mistreated throughout their history. Human attitudes have not changed much until very recently, but the differences in treatment -- the extent of the atrocities -- stem from technological empowerment to do harm.

Look, once again we're back to the lying/stupidity distinction when it comes to your arguments. Of course humans have mistreated animals. Of course not ALL domesticated animals were treated with care and respect.

When we find instances of animal mistreatment they should be stopped. I don't really know what you're arguing against. You advanced the slavery analogy as though all domestication progressed as such. This isn't true. I am rebutting your claim. In order to do so, I need merely show that the domestication process isn't necessarily like slavery. Which, of course, it isn't.

This is your argument. You need to substantiate the point.


Now this:

So you're ready and willing to defend the treatment of those animals since the beginning? Not just their introduction, the practice of branding, but slaughtering practices, and, now/recent past, their transportation to slaughterhouses and the manner in which they are slaughtered?

Why do you think this is relevent? What point are you making? When have I ever defended mistreatment of animals?

There are plenty or ranchers in the West that have raised animals on free ranges and slaughtered them more or less humanely since the first European settlement. Some didn't.

This is a discussion about the proper way to treat animals. You are the one with the bizarre theory about justification of initial violence. That was YOUR argument. I am pointing out its shortcomings, not advancing a positive point claiming all, most, or even some animals have been treated well from the beginning.

This falls in line with your history of saying really dumb things, having them presented to you in all their glorious idiocy, and then somehow trying to smear the foolishness on me. That was YOUR dumb argument.

The penultimate sentence is incoherent, though maybe that's supposed to testify to some larger symbolism. If the harm is "deprivation of years of life," then why does that apply to the infant and not the embryo? We're talking about relative value -- trying to tease out what matters -- yet you keep evading this point by introducing a conflict between mother and future child that does not exist. Moreover, "active life suffices for the frozen embryo" requires explanation because it seems like you're confusing your own terms. Take a minute to gather your thoughts.

Goddamn. There is literally no way I can make the point simpler than I already have. If you think that last sentence is incoherent you have issues that are beyond my ability to correct.

The "depravation of life" applies to BOTH THE EMBRYO AND THE CHILD. Thus the distinction between those two entities must lie elsewhere. The distinction that allows abortion to be legal and the killing of a live child illegal lies in the rights of the mother.

You really don't get this? Are you playing dumb or are you using a random argument generator to make your points for you?

Much later, in an attempt to clarify the distinction, you write: "The rationale to separate a cow from a child (potential) need not be used to distinguish a child from a fozen embryo."

Am I to assume "(potential)" should have been placed after "rationale" instead of "child" because as it stands it's ambiguous since we are also talking about a potential child? Let me just go point blank: What distinguishes the embryo from the child? Let me also focus a misguided argument you made earlier, where you asked the difference between a four year old and a twenty year old. Let's say a mother loses a pregnancy in the first trimester. Let's stipulate that she wanted to bring it to term, raise it, see it flourish as a fully realized human being. Now let's say a mother loses a two year old (he dies painlessly). From a morally neutral point of view, what's the difference (i.e., the relative value of the spontaneously abortion versus the death of the two year old), if any?

Haha. Awesome. POTENTIAL DISTINGUISHES A CHILD FROM A COW. Embyos and children have the same potential. What are you having trouble with?

Something else distinguishes a child from an embryo because they have the same potential. I have now said this roughly 20 times over the course of this discussion.

Your example is as dumb as everything else you've produced. The death of a fetus meant to be brought to term is sad. The death of a child is sad. Which one is sadder or more unfortunate? I don't know.

I'm not sure what you mean to reflect with that example. From the perspective of the mother I'm sure the death of the child would generally be more difficult because of the years of attachment. A miscairrage in the first trimester will involve the loss of something that seems less real, perhaps. The difference that you ask for is simply one of emotional pain. I don't see how that has anything to do with anything.

And awesome job of, once again, missing the point with the 20 year old, et all. That was brought up to show you how dumb your example of the burning building was. There was no "misguided argument," save the one you offered. Under YOUR reasoning the decision to save one of two people in a burning building magically reveals some truth about their moral value. Don't impose your idiotic arguments on me.

I don't know what you base on it, but for me it's because a child is a morally significant being worthy of our consideration, regardless of whether or not it can "theorize about it's own mortality," a rather arbitrary and clueless standard.

When did I say it wasn't worthy of moral consideration. I think cows are worty of moral consideration, which is why I'm spending time discussing proper care.

This is a pathetic misinterpretation of the point. We are deciding exactly what type of treatment these morallly significant beings should receive. I am arguing that a child and a cow deserve different treatment.

Again, are you lying, intentionally making offensive interpretations, or are you too dumb to understand the argument?

Reading is fundamental. If we simply need animals to graze ecosystems then, sure, we can slaughter them to prevent overgrazing. To prevent overgrazing, not to consume them. Are you unable to summon any other reasons?

Summon any other reasons for what?

One more time: Grazing ecosystems need grazing animals. Grazing animals are better off under human stewardship. Proper stewardship requires control of numbers. Thus there are a number of animals that must be slaughtered. It is ok to eat them.

Explain exactly where your problem lies.

This is connected to the next dispute, another issue whizzing right over your head:

You seem incapable of following relevant moral arguments. As noted earlier by another poster, if someone says consuming large herbivores creates less suffering for morally relevant beings, then I think that's an approach we should consider. This is a matter of carrying one's moral principles to their logical conclusion. What's interesting, to me at least, is the moral dispute. By way of contrast, someone could agree that veganism causes the least harm to animals, but that's immaterial, according to thier view, because harms to animals are outweighed by tasty meals. The dispute is one of a moral nature.

What's your point here? I have said before, and will reiterate now, that if the only reason for slaughtering herd animals was to consume them (and that consumption was not of immediate necessity), the act would not be justified.

You have this goofy habit of arguing against points I haven't advanced.

The failure of the empty nonsense in your last quote lies in assuming we must perform an act for a specific reason in order for it to be justified. Secondary reasons are sufficient.

Look, I'm sure the businesses participating in carbon-credit trading aren't doing it to save the environment. They're doing it to make money. I could care less so long as the end result is environmentally positive.

Likewise, I'm sure many or most ranchers aren't raising cows and slaughtering them out of the kindness in their hearts. Nevertheless, if the practice can justified and harmful acts eliminated, I don't need altruists ranching in order to morally justify meat consumption.

Recognizing that benefit can be gained from incentives based on people's motivation is the only practical way to generate positive change. I recognize people like to eat meat, therefore the sale from properly cared for animals can fund that proper care. Your idealism is cute in an eigth grader but ultimately pointless.


*facepalm*What do you want me to say that I have not already said earlier? You do not seem to understand what the words "trivial" and "unenlightening" mean.

If I didn't before, your writing has given me more than enough examples.

Earlier you asked for examples of your foolish conflation of analogies. Here is one. We are dealing with the question of what it means to benefit. Simply giving another example of a benefit does not contradict my earlier analogy.

Look, I argued that I benefit from my freedom even though I've never been incarcerated. An analagous response to the absurd one you offered in the situation above would be to say, sure but you could also benefit from being in a gang in prison. Ok, but that doesn't mean I don't benefit from my freedom. In the same way, me benefiting from stealing food from Darfur does not mean I DO NOT benefit from living in the United States.

You don't even really understand how to argue. Amazing.


Do you pay any attention to things I have previously written? There are two separate arguments against domestication:

And by this domestication, of course, you mean idyllic free range scenarios, and I have written: "I will readily concede animals in a 'well tended herd' do not suffer as much as animals in the wild." My argument against this is and has been that if it's so great, then leave the animals alone.* Hence the discussion about future life, children, and embryos, the one you cannot see as "relevent [sic]" because you're flailing in the dark. You cannot keep all of the arguments swirling around straight, much less your own sprawling post, a monument to confusion and ignorance.

*Yes, you may humanely euthanize an animal, or slaughter as an alternative to the introduction of predators, assuming it's possible to manage these animals.

I don't even know what to say here. The asterix contradicts completely the sentence it followed. If we are to just "leave them alone" we will not be humanely slaughtering them. Either that or your definition of "leave them alone" means that we care for them, provide them medicine, ensure their nutrition, and slaughter a certain number for the health of the herd and ecosystem. Please explain where your point above differs from anything I've argued.

The only coherent, non-contradictory reading of that last post essentially agrrees with everything I've been arguing. You have a strange, silly mind.

And the issue about embryos has to do with the justification for slaughter in general. Note that you have been arguing against slaughter because it causes harm to the animal, I have argued the opposite. And now in that asterix you tell me it's allowable to "euthanize" the animals. Welcome to my side, I guess you found it makes more sense after all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom