Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Posted by yrreg
I am trying to get you to come up with what you know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.
​

There's a lot of different, condradictory ones. That one, in my mind, is the most likely to be true.


Quote:
Or you believe that your statement is what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God?
​

At least one.


Your mind is not acquainted with the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.

I suspect you are either being flippant or are indeed a naive mind.

I will no longer read any messages from you in this thread.

No, I am not putting you on ignore, just that when I come across your messages here I will not read them, because as I said you are either being flippant or a mind that is indeed naive not constructively fruitful to engage with.


Shall we have a smile together just the same, before I start not giving you any further attention in this thread, okay?

But I do encourage you to engage your mental resources in looking up the theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists and read them, to come up with what your more constructive mind can distill to be their quintessential concept of God.





Yrreg
 
Please read the OP carefully.

I did. You are wrong to assume I did not.


I am asking atheists here to come up with what they know to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.

Why? Can't you look it up, if you want to know?

If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.

You can't tell me what to do.

Go and find out what theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists have for a quintessential concept of God.

Why? If you're under the impression I don't have a god concept, you're wrong. I have the one I was brought up with, the ones I've heard about, and the ones I can imagine. Most of those theistic people you order me to research have similar ideas as mine. The difference, mainly, is that each believes his concept exists, and I don't believe any of them do.

When you have come to the quintessential concept of God from these theistic people, then bring the concept up in this thread.

You first. It was your idea.
 
Yrreg, why do you require anyone to post the theist's "quintessential concept of god"?
 
<snip>
If you want to say something about your own thoughts, please do not take the trouble to write about them here in this thread.
<snip>


Yrreg

I think this is your main problem. You are serious about not wanting atheists to bring their own thoughts here. You simply want confirmation of your own delusions.
 
If you have no idea of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists, please take the time to read on them, just enough to have an adequate acquaintance with what you can sum up to be the quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, namely, theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


Please don't bring up at this point of the thread your own thoughts about God and no God; later we might go into your thoughts.


First, as I say in the OP, I am inviting you to share with me your knowledge of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you ask me what I know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists, here is my statement:


God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


That is what I take to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.





Yrreg
 
If you ask me

Point: we did not.

what I know to be the quintessential

In your tergiversatorial musings, have you, perchance, happened upon the definition of "quintessential?"

Quintessence: A thing that is a perfect example of its type; A pure substance; The fifth alchemical element, or essence, after earth, air, fire, and water.
Quintessential: A thing possessing the quality of quintessence (which see).

Your use of the words suggests strongly that you are aware there are other concept of god, and that the one you are about to impart has been selected from among them


concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists

How did you discover this? Did you query them all? Take a random sampling of same? Read a sufficient number of statements about said, by same? How did you determine suffciency, if the latter? How did you contact them for query, if the former?

In short: can you prove what you're about to say is not

Yrreg said:
your own thoughts about God and no God

Because, if you can't, you have violated the terms you set forth in your own thread.

here is my statement:

(absolute tenterhooks, here; pins and needles, I must say.)




God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​






...that's it?




Really?




God....made....stuff. All the stuff. That's God. The Stuffmaker.



Rather makes him sound like a roll of Mentos, doesn't it? God: the Stuffmaker!



Ooooh! If you put God in Diet Coke, does he make huge jets of carbonated foam shoot up into the air?

That would at least be interesting.
 
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.


So God is my dog? Or maybe a sycamore? Or a penguin? I like penguins.
They are all existent entities and are all independent of man's mind. Along with any other animal and/or plant you care to name.

Your "definition" encompasses every living thing that is not human.
Which makes it very hard to know what you are talking about.



God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.


THAT IS NOT A DEFINITION!
If I say I cooked a pizza, is that a definition of what I am? Does it give you any useful information at all about myself?
If I say I drove a car, is that a definition of what I am? Does it give you any useful information at all about myself?
If I say I work in an office, is that a definition of what I am? Does it give you any useful information at all about myself?



I'm going to quote (again) the definition of "definition":

[url=http://www.answers.com/topic/definition]Answers.com[/url] said:
definition

n.

1.
a. A statement conveying fundamental character.
b. A statement of the meaning of a word, phrase, or term, as in a dictionary entry.
2. The act or process of stating a precise meaning or significance; formulation of a meaning.
3.
a. The act of making clear and distinct: a definition of one's intentions.
b. The state of being closely outlined or determined: “With the drizzle, the trees in the little clearing had lost definition” (Anthony Hyde).
c. A determination of outline, extent, or limits: the definition of a President's authority.



If you really want me to define god, then I choose the Invisible Pink Unicorn.
She is invisible, pink, a unicorn, and all-powerful. And frequently bad-tempered.


That is a definition. It explains the concept, and gives information concerning its characteristics.
You will note that I did not mention that the IPU is the creator of uncertainty and the rapturer of socks. Because these are not things that define her. They are things she does.


And since you are the one demanding that the atheists define god for you, you do not get to stamp your feet in a tantrum and say we are engaging in "non-thinking".

You asked us for a definition. If you don't like the answer, tough beans.




If you really are interested in a meaningful conversation, it would help the rest of us to know what god you are talking about. Specifically. With definitions.



Oh, and please stop making new threads every time you get distracted. It makes it look as though you have attention-deficit-disorder.
 
Last edited:
So I started another new thread, and then another, hoping to come up with one where I can really arrive at the nerve center of atheists' non-thinking, and size them up for what they are without themselves knowing it, because they don't have the habit and skill of self-introspection.

You could have at least pretended that your investigation was going to be objective. Asking now for the second time, why even bother with the threads when you've got your conclusion right there in this post even before you've started:

Atheists are non-thinking and don't have the habit and skill of self-instrospection (as opposed to the other kind of introspection of course).
 
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.
If you are asking atheists if that is the essence of God that they don't believe in, I would say that covers part of it.

But, I also think atheists will deny God exists, no matter how you define God.

We can discover certain things that exist independent of man's mind. Whenever there is independent verification of empirical findings, in science, that is usually what is happening.

If you think God exists, independently of man's mind, what sort of tests can you come up with, to test for His existence?
 
There is no quintessential concept of god, just as there is no quintessential concept of the boogy man. (Or is that boogieman, or bogey man, or boogie woogie, or oogie boogie...)
Or the Boogey Woogie Bugle Boy from Company B ... eagle man.

*OK, a bad groaner, I'll get my coat*

@yrreg:

Quoting yourself is only worthwhile when you said something worth quoting in the first place.

You didn't, so you shouldn't have.

Please read the OP carefully.
I did.

CS Lewis wept. :(

ETA, and against my better judgment (talk about something there is little evidence for :P )

God is.

That is a pithier way of putting forth this thought: God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.

The baseline model of God you (and for that matter I) work with is: (Obviously a C & P from the Nicene Creed, for expediency's sake, there are variations on that theme of course)

Maker of Heaven and Earth, of all that is seen and unseen​

Which obviously includes dark matter. ;) Off to SM & T you go, to learn about dark matter and dark energy. I think it's cool.

DR
 
Last edited:
I'll play.

I'm sure that most people who believe in a god believe that it is something that exists independent of their mind-- an invisible immeasurable form of consciousness that "knows" stuff and "thinks" and "loves" and "plans" and "cares"--He does the kinds of things that material human brains are known to do--only better and more extreme without any brain at all. This entity is outside time and space and is the "explanation" for the deep or mysterious things that humans don't understand. He answers prayers and has "wants" that he reveals through signs or inspired writings or revelations or other private non-verifiable ways... He judges people who don't follow his nebulous rubric and determines how everyone will spend eternity. Although "genderless" due to his invisibility (No sex parts) he is seen as "male" (and capable of impregnating virgins with his magic invisible semen filled with magical DNA.)

I think most believers in a god or gods would agree to most of that stuff. Gods are the opposite of demons... (or Satan if you are into monodiablism)

I don't believe in any invisible forms of consciousness-- not gods, ghosts, goblins, angels, or fairies. I don't believe consciousness can exist absent a material brain and given the eons of belief, I suspect we'd have some actual evidence if this were so. I think it's all wishful thinking and confirmation bias.

I suspect most believers of gods would agree to most of the god paragraph and I suspect most atheists feel as I do. This should answer your question in it's entirety... but I'm sure it will not make much of a dent.

The evidence shows you to be rather impervious to dialogue that doesn't confirm the biases you came here to preach at us.
 
If you have no idea of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists, please take the time to read on them, just enough to have an adequate acquaintance with what you can sum up to be the quintessential concept of God from these theistic folks, namely, theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


Please don't bring up at this point of the thread your own thoughts about God and no God; later we might go into your thoughts.


First, as I say in the OP, I am inviting you to share with me your knowledge of the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.


If you ask me what I know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists, here is my statement:

God is the creator of heaven and earth and everything.
​
That is what I take to be the quintessential concept of God from theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists.





Yrreg
Just to check that you did not pull this out of your rear end, who were the theistic scientists, philosophers and artists? Quotes and links please. And then you might explain the relevance of this asinine "definition"
 
I am denying the existence of invisible immaterial forms of consciousness or entities. There is no evidence than ANY such things exist and tons of evidence to show that humans readily make up such entities to explain that which they don't understand.

Until there is evidence that consciousness of any sort can exist absent a material brain, then, a rationalists finds all such claims suspect for the same reasons you find "invisible pink unicorns" or body thetans or wormhole bigfoot visitation unworthy of your consideration. I can see why people are prone to believing in such things, but I cannot see how consciousness of any sort can exist without a material brain.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom