Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?


[ Have I already done a thread on this topic here? ]



In this thread I hope to discuss first what are the criteria of intelligence.


Then compare atheists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their atheistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence.




Addressing atheists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​





Yrreg
 
I will only reply to this post if you put in 12 or fewer words. No pleonasm. That's the only way to intelligently debate, don'tcha know?
 
Last edited:
Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?
Are aphilatelists acting intelligently in embracing aphilatelism?

In other words, Is aphilatelism an intelligent worldview?

[ Have I already done a thread on this topic here? ]
[ Yes, you have already done a thread on this topic here and it too was merely a blatant attempt to troll ]

In this thread I hope to discuss first what are the criteria of intelligence.
Bollocks

Or, rather, why should ANYONE believe that this thread will be any different from the other 78 troll-fests you have started?


Then compare atheists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their atheistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence.
Then compare aphilatelists' ways of thinking or non-thinking in embracing their aphilatelistic worldview, with the criteria of intelligence.
Addressing atheists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​
Addressing aphilatelists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​
 
What are your criteria of intelligence?
  • The ability to coherently engage in dialog and debate.
  • The ability to answer questions with something other than non sequiturs, personal attacks and fallacy.
 
  • The ability to coherently engage in dialog and debate.
  • The ability to answer questions with something other than non sequiturs, personal attacks and fallacy.

The question is, Do atheists act intelligently when attempting to discuss with someone who refuses to abide by your listed criteria?
 
The question is, Do atheists act intelligently when attempting to discuss with someone who refuses to abide by your listed criteria?
:) Damn good question. Perhaps these "atheists" are just masochistic?
 
I don't have any criteria of intelligence, because it is not a property that can be discreetly measured. So, my distinction between intelligent and non-intelligent beings is based on habit rather than reason.

Yes, atheism is an intelligent worldview because it encourages people to solve their own problems.
 
I still hold hope that Yrreg may read something in our posts to spark his thoughts.

(There must be SOME way in.)
 
Atheism needn't be embraced. Its more of a default zone. Religion is what needs the embracing. Its very needy.
 
Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

In other words, Is atheism an intelligent worldview?






Addressing atheists:


What are your criteria of intelligence?​



Whatever else, it would not involve:

  • Believing in things without proof, especially when it is claimed belief without proof is a core value of worth intellectually.
  • Knuckling under, voluntarily, because someone or something is threatening me with harm or offering treasures, especially when that involves praising him, her, or it only because it demands I should.
 
Last edited:
Are non-Scientologists acting intelligently in embracing non-Scientology?

In other words, Is non-Scientology an intelligent worldview?
 
Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?


Bolding mine. I have a problem with the wording.

I, for one, do not "embrace" atheism.
It's not a position I cling to and suckle on.

I simply don't believe in god.

Why is is so hard for some people to grasp that it is possible to simply not have a belief?


Allow me to illustrate the point I am trying (and have been trying for some time now) to make:
Yrreg: Do you believe in Thetans?

As I've said before, I'm not trying to mock, belittle or insult you with that question.

I assume, given your comments about the "non-thinkingness" of bringing up the supernatural beings you don't ascribe to, that you do not believe in them.

Let me restate that: You do not believe in Thetans.

You lack that belief.
​


So plainly, it is possible to not believe in something, even if many other people (tens of thousands, at least) do.



Why then do you continue to make threads about the same topic, in which you do nothing but insult anyone who happens not to believe the same things you do?










Not that you're likely to read this post, given past performance.



ETA: Dang. I should have read Articulett's post.
 
Last edited:
Are non-Scientologists acting intelligently in embracing non-Scientology?

In other words, Is non-Scientology an intelligent worldview?
:)

It doesn't get any better than that. I note that you've been presenting this argument for some time arti and most simply ignore it.

I wonder why?

BTW: I embrace non-stamp collecting as a hobby.
 
Yrreg -- Your question is loaded with your worldview. One more time:

Atheism is not a "worldview" that someone "embraces". It is a position on a single issue--Do you believe in god(s)?--that one answers with "No." All other aspects of a person's worldview may be, and often are, different.

The converse is not true because the acceptance of a deity requires at least two other ideas: That there are things outside the Universe; and that evidence is not required for belief.

Framing your statement in the terms of your preferred conclusion makes it pointless to have any further discussion.

Good luck to you, Miss Kitt
 
I don't know what to say. It seems whatever deviates from the trolls point of view is non-thinking.

Why do some religionists, assume that all atheists, were, at sometime, religionists?
I have never "embraced" religion or atheism. God(s) are one of many things I don't believe. No labels needed for all the others
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom