Seismosaurus
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2003
- Messages
- 6,092
Hi.
I'm a science teacher in a UK secondary school. We've recently decided to put a two to three week topic into our Year 9 (kids about 14 years old), and as I've recently acquired a bit of actual power in the department I've decided to make the topic "Investigating Pseudoscientific claims".
The topic will span 8 to 12 lessons. It's not focused on paranormal claims as such, but I am free to work in any reasonable content and I do plan to cover a couple of paranormal elements as well as more mundane claims. Ideally I want each lesson to involve some sort of practical investigation, a "mini-mythbusters" type of thing where the kids are shown a claim which somebody has made and then get to do a reasonably simple investigation which proves or disproves the claim.
Some attention needs to be shown to things like "how do we make this a fair test", "how do we make our results more reliable", etc without going hugely over the top on statistics, etc.
Some ideas I have had are :
I seem to remember a shampoo claiming it makes your hair stronger. So wash some hair strands in the shampoo and then test their breaking strength as compared to non washed hair.
Dowsing. Standard dowsing for water in film cannisters. I love the idea of doing an unblind test where dowsing will seem to work, and then blinding it and finding that it stops working.
Comparing the effect of "name brand" products to budget ones. EG do brand name diapers really absorb more liquid than budget ones?
I want to do an astrology one... I read about one where you do some BS about birth dates and give everybody a printout of a personality profile and have them rate it, but it turns out everybody has the same thing.
I'd like to do some sort of test on homeopathy but I'm not sure what I could do within the context of a school lab to show how pointless these things are. I'd quite like to do the 'take a bunch of sleeping pills' demo that Randi did, but I need some experiment the kids could do on a homeopathic medicine to show it accomplishing nothing.
That's about all I have come up with thus far. I could do maybe one other paranormal one, but I need a bunch more claims that are more in the way of advertising claims, scams, etc. I need to have maybe ten lessons worth overall.
Any suggestions for things to be tested or ways to test would be good. Ideally any test should be simple to do, use standard school lab equipment, and give a nice clear result that's easy to interpret.
I'm a science teacher in a UK secondary school. We've recently decided to put a two to three week topic into our Year 9 (kids about 14 years old), and as I've recently acquired a bit of actual power in the department I've decided to make the topic "Investigating Pseudoscientific claims".
The topic will span 8 to 12 lessons. It's not focused on paranormal claims as such, but I am free to work in any reasonable content and I do plan to cover a couple of paranormal elements as well as more mundane claims. Ideally I want each lesson to involve some sort of practical investigation, a "mini-mythbusters" type of thing where the kids are shown a claim which somebody has made and then get to do a reasonably simple investigation which proves or disproves the claim.
Some attention needs to be shown to things like "how do we make this a fair test", "how do we make our results more reliable", etc without going hugely over the top on statistics, etc.
Some ideas I have had are :
I seem to remember a shampoo claiming it makes your hair stronger. So wash some hair strands in the shampoo and then test their breaking strength as compared to non washed hair.
Dowsing. Standard dowsing for water in film cannisters. I love the idea of doing an unblind test where dowsing will seem to work, and then blinding it and finding that it stops working.
Comparing the effect of "name brand" products to budget ones. EG do brand name diapers really absorb more liquid than budget ones?
I want to do an astrology one... I read about one where you do some BS about birth dates and give everybody a printout of a personality profile and have them rate it, but it turns out everybody has the same thing.
I'd like to do some sort of test on homeopathy but I'm not sure what I could do within the context of a school lab to show how pointless these things are. I'd quite like to do the 'take a bunch of sleeping pills' demo that Randi did, but I need some experiment the kids could do on a homeopathic medicine to show it accomplishing nothing.
That's about all I have come up with thus far. I could do maybe one other paranormal one, but I need a bunch more claims that are more in the way of advertising claims, scams, etc. I need to have maybe ten lessons worth overall.
Any suggestions for things to be tested or ways to test would be good. Ideally any test should be simple to do, use standard school lab equipment, and give a nice clear result that's easy to interpret.