An investigative topic for kids

Seismosaurus

Philosopher
Joined
Mar 15, 2003
Messages
6,092
Hi.

I'm a science teacher in a UK secondary school. We've recently decided to put a two to three week topic into our Year 9 (kids about 14 years old), and as I've recently acquired a bit of actual power in the department I've decided to make the topic "Investigating Pseudoscientific claims".

The topic will span 8 to 12 lessons. It's not focused on paranormal claims as such, but I am free to work in any reasonable content and I do plan to cover a couple of paranormal elements as well as more mundane claims. Ideally I want each lesson to involve some sort of practical investigation, a "mini-mythbusters" type of thing where the kids are shown a claim which somebody has made and then get to do a reasonably simple investigation which proves or disproves the claim.

Some attention needs to be shown to things like "how do we make this a fair test", "how do we make our results more reliable", etc without going hugely over the top on statistics, etc.

Some ideas I have had are :

I seem to remember a shampoo claiming it makes your hair stronger. So wash some hair strands in the shampoo and then test their breaking strength as compared to non washed hair.

Dowsing. Standard dowsing for water in film cannisters. I love the idea of doing an unblind test where dowsing will seem to work, and then blinding it and finding that it stops working.

Comparing the effect of "name brand" products to budget ones. EG do brand name diapers really absorb more liquid than budget ones?

I want to do an astrology one... I read about one where you do some BS about birth dates and give everybody a printout of a personality profile and have them rate it, but it turns out everybody has the same thing.

I'd like to do some sort of test on homeopathy but I'm not sure what I could do within the context of a school lab to show how pointless these things are. I'd quite like to do the 'take a bunch of sleeping pills' demo that Randi did, but I need some experiment the kids could do on a homeopathic medicine to show it accomplishing nothing.

That's about all I have come up with thus far. I could do maybe one other paranormal one, but I need a bunch more claims that are more in the way of advertising claims, scams, etc. I need to have maybe ten lessons worth overall.

Any suggestions for things to be tested or ways to test would be good. Ideally any test should be simple to do, use standard school lab equipment, and give a nice clear result that's easy to interpret.
 
Sounds great.

Some random ideas.

For your homeopathic test you could get the kids to make a c30 dose of food colouring. When they see how fast the colour goes you can follow up with the maths to see when there are no molecules left.

In Ben Goldacre’s bad science book he has a chapter on how drug companies mess with the results of trials to make their product appear better than they are. You may be able to do something like that towards the end of the course.

Ben also talks about ear candling and another pseudoscience treatement where you put your feet in a solution which has a current passed through and you are ‘detoxed’ demonstrated by the gunk left in the water at the end. Obviously in both cases you get the same effect irrespective of the candle being in your ear or your feet in the water.

The astrology test could be difficult as it really needs people separated. In a classroom it will not take the kids long to realise they have the same one. You could present 12 horoscopes and see if the kids can pick their own out. You would need to be careful as there are themes with some signs and astrologers often refer to them. Someone reading them regularly could pick theirs out.
 
Great idea. However, let's get the nasty stuff out of the way first.

Clear this with your administration team first, and get somebody with more grunt than you to give you their firm support. Give them all the details on what you plan on doing and outline the expectations of potential backlash. Especially in a country like the UK, which seems to count homeopathy as a religion, you're going to have a good chance of upsetting a cart or two and will need to have done the groundwork to prepare for it. You'll need prepared responses for parents which has the backing of your school.

It might then pay to start with the historical stuff. Maybe spontaneous generation, for instance? Go through the experiments that led to us dismissing the notion. They're not hard to replicate, and have the advantage of having few people who still believe that spontaneous generation continues to have merit. Have as a research piece something about miasmas or balancing the humours. Maybe then lead them into undergoing their own research piece on astrology or dowsing.

Good luck. Please heed my advice on the first part, though. Even if you're a department head, you'll need to suss out the support from the rest of the school community. It might seem paranoid, but all it takes is one person to get their panties in a bunch, and you'll find yourself grateful for having already done the hard work in responding to it.

Athon
 
Last edited:
As to the astrology readings, try the Forer effect.
http://skepdic.com/forer.html
A student did this with fake Rorschach inkbots administered and then handed out a week later. We had to tweak the readings to make them warmer for our population.
http://www.identifont.com/samples/kenn-munk/Rorschach.gif

If it works, you can point out that that is the way asstrology works. If it doesn't, you can point out that that is the way that the Rorschach works.
 
Last edited:
Hi.

I'm a science teacher in a UK secondary school. We've recently decided to put a two to three week topic into our Year 9 (kids about 14 years old), and as I've recently acquired a bit of actual power in the department I've decided to make the topic "Investigating Pseudoscientific claims".

The topic will span 8 to 12 lessons. It's not focused on paranormal claims as such, but I am free to work in any reasonable content and I do plan to cover a couple of paranormal elements as well as more mundane claims. Ideally I want each lesson to involve some sort of practical investigation, a "mini-mythbusters" type of thing where the kids are shown a claim which somebody has made and then get to do a reasonably simple investigation which proves or disproves the claim.

Some attention needs to be shown to things like "how do we make this a fair test", "how do we make our results more reliable", etc without going hugely over the top on statistics, etc.

Some ideas I have had are :

I seem to remember a shampoo claiming it makes your hair stronger. So wash some hair strands in the shampoo and then test their breaking strength as compared to non washed hair.

Dowsing. Standard dowsing for water in film cannisters. I love the idea of doing an unblind test where dowsing will seem to work, and then blinding it and finding that it stops working.

Comparing the effect of "name brand" products to budget ones. EG do brand name diapers really absorb more liquid than budget ones?

I want to do an astrology one... I read about one where you do some BS about birth dates and give everybody a printout of a personality profile and have them rate it, but it turns out everybody has the same thing.

I'd like to do some sort of test on homeopathy but I'm not sure what I could do within the context of a school lab to show how pointless these things are. I'd quite like to do the 'take a bunch of sleeping pills' demo that Randi did, but I need some experiment the kids could do on a homeopathic medicine to show it accomplishing nothing.

That's about all I have come up with thus far. I could do maybe one other paranormal one, but I need a bunch more claims that are more in the way of advertising claims, scams, etc. I need to have maybe ten lessons worth overall.

Any suggestions for things to be tested or ways to test would be good. Ideally any test should be simple to do, use standard school lab equipment, and give a nice clear result that's easy to interpret.

Sounds like a great idea.

Here are some questions you could perhaps ask the class to consider about astrology: Horoscopes Versus Telescopes: A Focus on Astrology.

The page has a few suggested activities on it as well; but I'm not sure how practical they'd be, though you could perhaps change them a bit to suit the class.
 
Great idea. However, let's get the nasty stuff out of the way first.

Clear this with your administration team first, and get somebody with more grunt than you to give you their firm support. Give them all the details on what you plan on doing and outline the expectations of potential backlash. Especially in a country like the UK, which seems to count homeopathy as a religion, you're going to have a good chance of upsetting a cart or two and will need to have done the groundwork to prepare for it. You'll need prepared responses for parents which has the backing of your school.

Never fear, this is not being done by myself in isolation. The topic is being developed as part of a whole school overhaul of everything we teach that will go on years, and the relevant high ups are involved in and informed all the way through. I've already had approval of the topic from my department head, who is also a deputy head in the school, and we've discussed potential controversy. (We humerously suggested lesson titles like "Why Your Parents are Wrong to Believe in God" :) )

It might then pay to start with the historical stuff. Maybe spontaneous generation, for instance? Go through the experiments that led to us dismissing the notion. They're not hard to replicate, and have the advantage of having few people who still believe that spontaneous generation continues to have merit. Have as a research piece something about miasmas or balancing the humours. Maybe then lead them into undergoing their own research piece on astrology or dowsing.

A spontaneous generation one might be interesting, though we do want to make the focus very much on present day things. The over-riding directive of the whole process is to make the lessons more engaging and interesting for the kids than they currently are, and we want to do that by testing the kinds of claims they see in everyday life, in movies, in adverts, on TV shows, etc.

Thanks for the input. :)
 
I'd suggest both contemporary and classic themes. What woo issues are currently making the rounds?

The one that sticks out at the moment is the 2012 apocalypse theory. Over the next few years you'll find that the kids are being inundated with information from many different sources about this. It might help them to investigate it now.

The other one I'd suggest is the moon-landing hoax conspiracy theory, which is a favourite with many teenagers.

If you have time, throw in some of the alternative therapies, like reiki, and also audiophile woo.
 
He wants things that can be falsified with practical experiments in the classroom.

Seismosaurus, I'm not sure how practical this would be to do, but I wonder if it would be possible to teach a few of them some tricks that have been used by psychics, and then get them to use them on the rest of the class and see if the others can guess how they were done?

For instance, if you can access a phone, there's one trick where a volunteer picks a card, which the "psychic" sees, and then the "psychic phones up another "psychic" who tells the volunteer which card it is. The trick is done by the person on the other end of the phone picking up the receiver and saying "Ace, 2, 3, 4" etc., and when they get to the right number, the "psychic" with the volunteer says hello. Then the one on the other end of the phone says, "hearts, clubs" etc, and when they get to the right suit, the person with the volunteer says something else. It's a kind of code for them to tell which card it is. Then they hand the phone to the volunteer, and the "psychic" on the other end tells them what card they picked.

There are probably quite a few things like that, where the other kids could try to guess how it was being done.
 
Hey, did you find something good to do in the end? If so, it would be interesting to know what you've decided on, and how the lessons go when you do them.
 
a "mini-mythbusters" type of thing where the kids are shown a claim which somebody has made and then get to do a reasonably simple investigation which proves or disproves the claim.

Some attention needs to be shown to things like "how do we make this a fair test", "how do we make our results more reliable", etc without going hugely over the top on statistics, etc.
One idea: reverse the roles - get the kids to (even hypothetically) create a brand/product and then assert claims along the lines of 'clinical tests show that our brand is 42% more effective than brand X'


Comparing the effect of "name brand" products to budget ones. EG do brand name diapers really absorb more liquid than budget ones?
Although I only vaguely recall a class or three like this when I was a skule kid, using bleach as a subject, the lessons I learned remain with me today; it's not the cost/100g of the whole product, it's the cost/the (molar?) mass of the active ingredient (e.g. NaClO %)
 
After some discussion within the faculty, here's what we have come up with.

1) Mini claims : Does the Lynx effect exist? Can you hear anything in the EVP message? If I dilute food dye to 30C, what am I left with?

We put a bunch of stuff into lesson one because some of them seemed like pretty short and simple things to test, so we wanted a busy, very practical lesson to kick off.

2) Subjectivity of measuring – students taste testing different candy bars and describing them via a radar diagram, comparing results.

This one is again a simple thing to test. We're going to have a radar diagram with axes for crunchiness, sweetness, stickyness, etc. The idea is to get them realising that it's not easy to measure subjective experience, but you can at least make it somewhat systematic.

3) Does shampoo really make your hair stronger?

Lots of shampoos claim to make hair stronger, so we're going to hang weights on strands of hair and see if washed strands are any.

4) Is telepathy real?

Zenner card reading session. We've done one of these before, and already have all the stuff for it.

5) Gender battle - are girls better at multitasking?

Might turn this into a general "girls vs boys" thing competing in various metal and dexterity exercises.

6) The placebo effect.

Measure resting pule rate then repeat once a minute for five minutes after drinking a coloured liquid from a bottle marked "High caffeine drink". See if it affects the heart rate, and reveal at the end that it is just water.

7) Dowsing.

Does dowsing work? Why does it seem to work?

8) Comparing name brands to budget brands

We decided to go with kitchen roll testing; absorbancy, tissue strength.

9) Exploring coke myths

Coke as a cleaner, teeth in coke, coke and mentos.

It's surprisingly hard to get hold of Human teeth. Dentists have to treat them as biological waste. I have got hold of a practice whose manager is related to the school however, and may be willing to sneak some to us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom