Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

Howdy. I'm BBqutioner, and new to this forum - yeh, hello :D

Now I havn't read all of what you've writte on this topic, but I would love to contribute, if just by sharing my own view on this matter.

I've seen many defenitions of the word Intelligent and I can't stress enough what a relative word this is. What I think of as intelligence is individual thinking and originality, where some think of intelligence as a measureable extent of how logic you think, how creative you are, so on.

I don't think Atheism is a very intelligent view, because when someone call themself an atheist they basicly say they don't accept god.
You should watch out for the implication of this statement. Believing there is no god at all is not the same as "not accepting god" as if there were a god to accept.
Not that there is anything wrong with that statement, but when you are trying to find a word that best describes your veiws on how we came to be, what is beyond the cosmic, etc. You dont want to label yourself "godless" because that alone is just a rebelious, arbitrar view on theism. You might feel liberation out of calling yourself a non-believer, makes you feel kinda enlightned and superior, don't it? well, labeling yourself as a "godless" is no less dogmatic that any world view we have.
Plenty of people are willing to consider themselves godless without negative connotation. That includes on occasion agnostics, logical positivists and deists who believe that the existence or nonexistence of god or gods is essentially unknowable and irrelevant.
Atheists finally realize that there is no way an immortal, allpowerful and allknowing creature is flying in the skies, well kudos. But what you are forgetting is your very own opinion on the very matter. You don't have the gals to think of any? there are no reasonable explanation as to how we came, but mocking religious without really having it figured out yourself is not in any way intelligent.
Whether the explanations are adequate or not, many atheists would challenge the assertion that atheism is an alternative form of ignorance. Non theistic theories of how the universe came about exist.
I prefer views such as agnostisism, ignostisism, nihilism, and so on.
Nihilism is entirely and utterly separate from atheism. Making allowance for linguistic issues, I would simply suggest that you look into the implications of those words, and drop "nihilism" for now.
Sorry about all the "english fuzz" but I don't have that good language yet, and I find it very hard to express myself, but I tried my best.

Welcome to the fray.
 
Nihilism is entirely and utterly separate from atheism.

That is not my point, my point is that you should think of an alternative reason and by that label yourself, instead of calling yourself an atheist, wich is basicly directed to theism. I think everyone should make up their minds as for what THEY believe, and how we came to be. Most atheists replace any alternative beliefs with "atheism" and that is unforgivable!

I don't think the dichotomic view Yrrg has, is in any way critic worthy. Atheism is not more intelligent than religious if you look at the big picture, but if you think of the rationallity and logic we've come to find, atheism sure makes alot more sense.

I think most atheist should call themself "eupraxophists" (yeah, I know) instead. Aren't I bold? Hope I was more ontopic this time.
 
deleted: forum database error triggered a double post
 
Last edited:
Hi bbqutioner and welcome to the forum

That is not my point, my point is that you should think of an alternative reason and by that label yourself
I think you'll find that most atheists have many self-applied labels, such as profession/trade, field of study/research, hobbies/sports/etc, political affiliation/inclination in addition to philosophical 'labels' like sceptic

instead of calling yourself an atheist, wich is basicly directed to theism.
So? Although this might be cause for concern/anxiety/worry for you, I have no need to share in your angst, thanks all the same :)

I think everyone should make up their minds as for what THEY believe, and how we came to be.
Some of us prefer to leave our minds open and focus on the possibilities with the highest probability of being consistent with reality

Most atheists replace any alternative beliefs with "atheism" and that is unforgivable!
Why and in whose eyes is that "unforgivable"?
 
One reason to self-identify as atheist is that it serves the purpose of distinguishing us from theists without fragmenting us into hundreds of subcategories of not being theist. If there were not significant numbers of theists who sometimes have an impact on our lives, we would have no need to identify as atheists, just as we have no need to identify ourselves as a-tooth fairy-ists. Should large numbers of people seriously take up belief in the tooth fairy, then we might have to reconsider thinking of ourselves as a-tooth fairy-ists.
 
Why and in whose eyes is that "unforgivable"?

It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.

--

Mister Agenda: that makes alot of sense to me, still I think you should find a subcategory as close to your belief as possible. Most categories are incredibly opposed to eachother.
 
Last edited:
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.

[snip]

I can't see how lack of belief diminishes anyone in any way. What's wrong with the idea that there is no 'truth'?
 
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.

--

Mister Agenda: that makes alot of sense to me, still I think you should find a subcategory as close to your belief as possible. Most categories are incredibly opposed to eachother.

First, I think you'll find that most of the mockery comes from those who have held silly beliefs and have come to realize how silly they were. And, the mockery is the result not of the silly beliefs themselves, but rather the way those beliefs are thrust upon us (in this case by yyreg).

Second: Do you believe in Ra? Thor? Zeus? If not, then you are an atheist with respect to the aforementioned deities. Those of us who self-identify as atheists simply believe in one fewer god than you do.

Third: Most skeptics here consider facts and evidence to be useful tools in determining truth. What tools do you employ?
 
Third: Most skeptics here consider facts and evidence to be useful tools in determining truth. What tools do you employ?

I am not saying; believe this, believe that. I am merely saying that to represent yourself as atheist is closeminded as to what you believe. And I think finding your own belief should be a higher priority as to what you think of others. Why you want to bring up facts and evidences as to why I dont think atheism is a good idea, I have no idea. Because I am not telling you to believe in a given disproven religion, or faith.
 
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.

--

Mister Agenda: that makes alot of sense to me, still I think you should find a subcategory as close to your belief as possible. Most categories are incredibly opposed to eachother.

I think you may be unclear as to the meaning of the word "atheist." It is a simple term applying to the assertion that gods do not exist. Even if there are different degrees of atheism and different sorts of atheists, it is a legitimate blanket term under which all persons who do not believe that gods exist would fall, and a useful one to distinguish such persons from others who do believe in gods, or who consider the matter unanswerable or awaiting an answer. If you consider the term a mockery you either misunderstand the term, or have invested it with your own personal and emotional bias, for which nobody is responsible but yourself.

e.t.a. I would add that to say that it is "hypocritical" to oppose (or even mock) a belief without substituting another belief, is also a mistake. I also don't believe in leprechauns, unicorns or Thetans. I need not come up with alternative beliefs for beliefs I consider to be unfounded. Atheism might be wrong, but if it is true that no god exists, then no god exists. It's really that simple. One need not say "because there is no god I will believe in [fill in blank] instead." Either there is or there isn't. No alternatives are necessary.
 
Last edited:
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth.
How and why you equate atheism with not finding truth baffles me. If you know why you hold such views and can explain your position in a concise and coherent manner, then please do

Otherwise, please resist any urge to expound on this topic :)

Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.
Do omnivores have a justifiable cause for complaint/umbrage whenever someone self-identifies as a vegetarian? :confused:

If you and/or (other?) theists are so insecure in your beliefs that you infer mockery from those, like me, who simply identify as atheists, then I'm afraid that's your/their problem and I sincerely suggest that posting vague slurs against atheism on this forum is unlikely to prove an efficient source of solace
 
I am not saying; believe this, believe that. I am merely saying that to represent yourself as atheist is closeminded as to what you believe. And I think finding your own belief should be a higher priority as to what you think of others. Why you want to bring up facts and evidences as to why I dont think atheism is a good idea, I have no idea. Because I am not telling you to believe in a given disproven religion, or faith.

Close minded: I think you will find that the majority of the atheists on this forum are in fact very open minded. They simply require evidence before believing in something. It is the theists that are close minded: no evidence (or lack thereof), no pointing out inconsistencies, no logic or reason will ever sway them from their beliefs.
 
I am merely saying that to represent yourself as atheist is closeminded as to what you believe.


Representing one's self as atheist merely states something in which you don't believe. It doesn't indicate closemindedness. That would require additional statements, such as a declaration that no evidence would make you change your mind.
 
I am no theist? I am as much atheist as you are, altho I dont represent myself as one when I present my veiws.

I find this very frustrating, because every time I read what I write, it comes out wrong. And I hate to blame language or anything, but I would like to withdraw from this discussion. You can say I dont have anything to back what I mean up etc, dont mind :)

you guys seems like a bright bunch, love to see you discuss, rock on.
 
I am not saying; believe this, believe that. I am merely saying that to represent yourself as atheist is closeminded as to what you believe.

You should define what you believe the word "atheist" to mean. I don't think it means what you think it means.

Do you think that to be theist is to be openminded?

And I think finding your own belief should be a higher priority as to what you think of others.

Are you a theist? It is typical for a theist to attribute the word "belief" to atheists' lack of belief.

Why you want to bring up facts and evidences as to why I dont think atheism is a good idea, I have no idea. Because I am not telling you to believe in a given disproven religion, or faith.

Good. And welcome to the forum, bbqutioner! It will be refreshing to have a theist who can actually discuss.


ETA: Shoot. I thought we had a conversational theist to talk to. Oh well, keep posting bbqutioner.
 
Last edited:
That is not my point, my point is that you should think of an alternative reason and by that label yourself, instead of calling yourself an atheist, wich is basicly directed to theism.
I only use "atheist" in the context of religious beliefs anyway. I have many other labels by which I identify myself: Father, husband, guitarist, motor-sport enthusiast, and many more. I do not call myself an atheist in the same way that many people would call themselves "Muslims", "Buddhists", "Catholics" etcetera. My atheism is simply a lack of belief in gods.

I think everyone should make up their minds as for what THEY believe, and how we came to be. Most atheists replace any alternative beliefs with "atheism" and that is unforgivable!
I don't understand what you mean.

I think most atheist should call themself "eupraxophists" (yeah, I know) instead. Aren't I bold? Hope I was more ontopic this time.
I played the eupraxophone in high school band.;)
 
It's unforgiveable in my eyes, as I think it's every humanbeings obligation to find their own truth. Mocking someones belief without ever having one yourself is, in this context, very hipocrisy.

A Yrreg thread is probably not the best place to form an opinion about the attitudes of atheists toward theists. The mockery directed to Yrreg is the result of his own refusal to engage in actual discussion. Many of us have tried to engage him but have found his willful ignorance and condescension frustrating. There are theists on this forum for whom I have great respect, so it is not Yrreg's theism that I am mocking.

And I would like to state that I, as an atheist, have a great many beliefs. An absence of belief in gods is not the same as an absence of beliefs.
 
In what way is that true?
In a throwaway, humorous, exaggeration for effect sort of way.
Have you seen my "I went to church today" thread?
Yes.
As of three days ago, theism, the bible and pretty strict theology was still well and truly part of the Anglican system.

I suspect there is a difference between between the CoE in England, and the Anglican church in other countries, at least in terms of degree. I'm not seriously suggesting that belief in god is not part of the CoE, but it sometimes feels as though at least some vicars are embarrassed by the idea.
 
Last edited:
I am no theist? I am as much atheist as you are, altho I dont represent myself as one when I present my veiws.

I find this very frustrating, because every time I read what I write, it comes out wrong. And I hate to blame language or anything, but I would like to withdraw from this discussion. You can say I dont have anything to back what I mean up etc, dont mind :)

you guys seems like a bright bunch, love to see you discuss, rock on.
Please don't leave. It can be difficult to make your ideas clear, especially if you are dealing with a language that is not your native one, but discussion can help both sides to a greater understanding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom