Homeopathy: Rustum Roy drops the bomb

Uggh...I don't believe I can torture myself like that. {snip}
I appreciate your support :).

Maybe someone can correct me.

It seems they used solvents (not pure water) including electrolytes (solutes). They used them to make homeopathic dilutions of some other solutes. The resulting solutions were different from pure water (Duh). Moreover, their data points did not have any particular trend; rather, they showed ordinary noise, and some extraordinary deviances from trends. That is in their tabular data.

They also show graphical data. In some cases they find small deviations from what they expect. It looks like random variation. In addition, they have a graph showing the variation of pH for a few dilutions of sodium bicarbonate: duh, the pH increases as the bicarbonate increases. Knock me down with a feather!! Who would have expected that!? Well, I would.

Then, they claim they have inexplicable results. I can explain it ... but, this post is running too long and I think readers know the explanation. It's the "I" word (incompetence).

Meow, how does this support homeopathy?
 
no one gives a damn. it was done, people looked at it and shrugged.

Of course they did. Other people who work with water, gases and spectroscopy on a daily basis for their entire working lives have never seen such results. They probably giggled and laughed too.

sort of like when that Dr Bridgman from Harvard found out that water has a memory of sorts. the whole thing where he freezes water at one pressure and notes that at a different pressure it remembers the structure it was previously frozen at.
And don't you see that, if it was actually true, research meteorologists would have noted it in a century of research? :boggled:
 
sort of like when that Dr Bridgman from Harvard found out that water has a memory of sorts. the whole thing where he freezes water at one pressure and notes that at a different pressure it remembers the structure it was previously frozen at.
And don't you see that, if it was actually true, research meteorologists would have noted it in a century of research? :boggled:


I would still like to see a proper reference for this. All the instances of this claim I have so far found are either from Dana Ullman, without giving a specific citation, or meow quoting or paraphrasing Ullman.
 
And we all know how careful and conscientious DullMan is when quoting and assessing material from other sources....

Rolfe.
 
I would still like to see a proper reference for this. All the instances of this claim I have so far found are either from Dana Ullman, without giving a specific citation, or meow quoting or paraphrasing Ullman.

I'll assume that there was a quote attribution error in your post. :D

My formal meteorological training is now something like 45 years old and I can't call upon anything specific that disprove the claim but there has been a huge amount of research into cloud and rain formation and I think that any of the anomalous effects reported by the homeopaths would have been noted in such research. :jaw-dropp
 
Bridgman's work involved studying the behaviour of water at extremely high pressures (70,000+ atmospheres), so it is perhaps of little interest to most meteorologists. Not sure why anyone thinks it would apply to homeopathy either....
 
Meow

Bridgman's work involved studying the behaviour of water at extremely high pressures (70,000+ atmospheres)... Not sure why anyone thinks it would apply to homeopathy....

...and so we come full circle.

Okay, meow, "wikipedia: p value" can wait for a while.
(I don't think you're going to figure it out anyway)

Drag yourself back here and provide us with your answer to this question repeated from way back at the beginning of your appearances here:

What has the behaviour of water at 70,000 atm to do with homoeopathy?

BJ
 
Last edited:
And we all know how careful and conscientious DullMan is when quoting and assessing material from other sources....

Rolfe.


and when i do something like that i get swarmed with warning PM's (i've gotten 22 so far --most of them from Cuddles)and threats of being banned.



meow
 
Bridgman's work involved studying the behaviour of water at extremely high pressures (70,000+ atmospheres), so it is perhaps of little interest to most meteorologists. Not sure why anyone thinks it would apply to homeopathy either....

I must send a telepathic tweet to my Jovian meteorological friends then to see if they have noticed anything unusual. :yikes:
 
Bridgman's work involved studying the behaviour of water at extremely high pressures (70,000+ atmospheres), so it is perhaps of little interest to most meteorologists. Not sure why anyone thinks it would apply to homeopathy either....


because the water is able to retain some type of information; this is the basis for what the homeopaths are claiming.

therefore it is of extreme importance in putting a big dent in all of your skepticism.
 
because the water is able to retain some type of information; this is the basis for what the homeopaths are claiming.

therefore it is of extreme importance in putting a big dent in all of your skepticism.

If I go outside, drop my pants, and write my name in the snow, then water (snow) has 'retained some type of information'. It's irrelevant to Homeopathy because urinating in public is (presumably) not a part of their methodology.
 
If I go outside, drop my pants, and write my name in the snow, then water (snow) has 'retained some type of information'. It's irrelevant to Homeopathy because urinating in public is (presumably) not a part of their methodology.
huh?
 
and when i do something like that i get swarmed with warning PM's (i've gotten 22 so far --most of them from Cuddles)and threats of being banned.


It's funny, you are perfectly prepared to spam the board with multiple copies of, for example, the abstract of Elia, but now you think you're not allowed to post a simple reference. You don't need to quote the whole of the work, just tell us where it is either with a link or with a reference for where it is published. That is well within the forum rules.

ETA: In fact, within the last hour, and over four hours after you posted the above excuse, you were perfectly happy to copy and paste, without any attribution, what is evidently part of a list of references from somewhere or other. If you could do that, why can't you provide a reference for Bridgman's work on water frozen at altitude?
 
Last edited:
because the water is able to retain some type of information; this is the basis for what the homeopaths are claiming.
What information?
How long does it last?
How much information?
How does this "information" interact with the biochemical and cellular processes?
What is the saturation of information?
 


What? You didn't understand that post and you think you can get a handle on p value in wikipedia?? Good luck, meow. You're going to need it.

Look, I'll extend the deadline by another three days, but then I definitely want an answer.

BJ
 
Bridgman's work involved studying the behaviour of water at extremely high pressures (70,000+ atmospheres), so it is perhaps of little interest to most meteorologists. Not sure why anyone thinks it would apply to homeopathy either....


But we actually have no clue what Bridgman reported. The book is pretty old, and nobody posting here has ever seen a copy. The text is not available online. We only know the field in which he was working, as far as I can see.

We have nothing but DullMan's recollections of something he thinks was contained in the book. His recollection was so wide of the mark that when he first posted about it he got the title of the book spectacularly wrong. And it wasn't just a typo - he actually posted that water frozen at one "altitude" remembered the freezing pattern at another. It seems he was actually thinking "altitude" when he posted.

He found that whenever one takes water to certain altitudes and freeze it, it freezes in a different pattern based on the high pressure of altitude. However, he found that once water is frozen at one altitude, it "remembers" the structure of the water and refreezes in a similar pattern at a different altitude.


But the book is nothing at all to do with altitude, it is about extremely high-pressure systems.

Now we know how astoundingly deviant DullMan's reports of what is written elsewhere can be from what is actually written there. Remember his repeated insistence that Holmes "idolised" some doctor or other, and when Mojo finally found the reference we discovered that Holmes was actually deeply critical of the guy? And a number of other similar instances.

So really, we have no clue what Bridgman reported that was relevant to this discussion, if anything. Mojo followed up another reference to the same work, in the Rao et al. paper, and found that there the authors were reporting that Bridgman was working on SiO2 glass, not on water. There was no mention of Bridgman having presented any results from water.

We won't have any idea what Bridgman really said until someone gets their mitts on an actual dead-tree copy of that book and finds out. Repeating something Dana Ullman has said on the assumption that he's correct (as Meow is doing) is unwise, to put it politely.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
But we actually have no clue what Bridgman reported. The book is pretty old, and nobody posting here has ever seen a copy. The text is not available online. We only know the field in which he was working, as far as I can see.

We have nothing but DullMan's recollections of something he thinks was contained in the book.


Look carefully at what Dana posted on this forum:
P.W. Bridgman, PhD, former professor of physics at Harvard for a couple of decades, and he is a Nobel Laureate. He wrote a book called THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDE. He found that whenever one takes water to certain altitudes and freeze it, it freezes in a different pattern based on the high pressure of altitude. However, he found that once water is frozen at one altitude, it "remembers" the structure of the water and refreezes in a similar pattern at a different altitude. Water does seem to have a memory, and you can seem to "write" on it.


...and what he said in the quotation from the ENHR/ECCH symposium I quoted in the "More fun with..." thread:
The authors also refer to the work of PW Bridgman, a Nobel Prize-winning physicist (1946) and professor at Harvard. He wrote several books, including the THE PHYSICS OF HIGH ALTITUDES. He researched the effects of freezing water at various altitudes and found that freezing water at higher altitudes created different ice crystallization patterns than at lower altitudes. And yet, when he melted the ice that was frozen at a high altitude and then refroze it at a low altitude, the ice maintained the crystallization pattern of the higher altitude.
These experiments provide additional evidence for how pressure can influence the STRUCTURE of water without influencing the material content of the water.


He says in both cases that Bridgman wrote a book called The Physics of High Altitude(s), and that Bridgman made certain observations about water frozen at higher and lower altitude, but he doesn't actually quite state that the observations are reported in the book (which was in any case called The Physics of High Pressure). They are two separate statements. It almost looks as if the book title was brought in to make Bridgman appear to be an authority on high altitudes.

There are copies in a few libraries I might be able to get access to, but without a clear statement that the observations in question are actually in the book, and preferably a page number as well, I'm not really prepared to waste time on a wild goose chase.
 
Last edited:
I had a quick look online and I could only find copies for £30 upwards. Not an amount I'm really willing to spend to check this out and end up with a tediously boring book on my hands.

I'm going to London in a few weeks and may try and find a copy in a library if nobody else succeeds.
 
I put in a request at my local library. I will let you know if anything comes of it. It's kinda fun to track down these references - it must be useful to those who are on the fence to see that the supposed support is a gross misrepresentation. I'm still somewhat surprised when I discover the extent to which people like DUllman are willing to perpetuate what they know to be a lie, but I imagine that feeling will eventually go away.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom