Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
Awesome reading comprehension.

Again, the fact that it is a tradition does not make it harmless, the fact that it's a harmless tradition makes it not worth worrying about.

But I guess you'd rather advance tired stereotypes from the post-war era in an attempt at humorous pith.
One, I'm not worried about it. Two, I agree that most French traditions, as jerky as they may be, are in fact harmless. Three, I never alleged harm, only that the French are jerks.
 
One, I'm not worried about it. Two, I agree that most French traditions, as jerky as they may be, are in fact harmless. Three, I never alleged harm, only that the French are jerks.

Well, I lived in Paris for a while so...I have to admit you're right, my apologies.
 
Awesome reading comprehension.

Again, the fact that it is a tradition does not make it harmless, the fact that it's a harmless tradition makes it not worth worrying about.

But I guess you'd rather advance tired stereotypes from the post-war era in an attempt at humorous pith.
Speaking of circles...
BTW- Some countries have a cultural tradition of being mean (by US standards) to people who think and believe differently. But it's a harmless tradition, right?
 
Speaking of circles...
BTW- Some countries have a cultural tradition of being mean (by US standards) to people who think and believe differently. But it's a harmless tradition, right?

It's pretty easy to figure out. Does it cause harm?
 
If you seriously think forcible detainment, regardless of whether or not the detainee ends up complaining about it afterward, or the police get off their crapfactories and do something about it, is "harmless" then your arguments are barely distinguishable from that of a lunatic, and barely worth wasting keystrokes on.

But hey, let's try.

It is an act of violence. There's no way around that. Declaring that someone is not free to leave implies something will happen to them if they attempt to do so. Your actions are not excused if you tell someone they're not free to leave, and then you don't harm them because they didn't try to leave.

They are all quite lucky they are not in the US and pulling this crap. I guarantee there would be a body count associated with this practice. And I'd have no problem with that if it happened here, or ends up happening in France.
 
Lowering production costs is more important to the profit margin than providing charity for drone-workers.

And that's what running a business is all about - maximizing profits.

Couldn't agree more with this description of capitalism! :)
 
Maybe you can find the actual French law in question, but until then, the evidence is on the side of calling it kidnapping.

My French is a little rusty, but maybe I've been subjected to 'kidnapping', too. It didn't feel nearly as bad as I imagine losing your livelihood does.
 
If my employees kidnapped me, I'd gladly see them hauled off to jail for their criminal trials. Then I'd file civil suits against each one for "pain and duress" and settle for nothing less than everything they own.

Of course, you cannot file civil suits merely for losing your income. In this society the law allows you to harm people in ways that completely ruin their lives, which only goes to show that equality before the law of very unequal citizens is a class law.
“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets or steal bread.” Anatole France (!)
Labor Laws

But of course, this is in America, the country that has twice bailed France out after their leadership has surrendered to foreign powers. It's no surprise that the French teach their business leaders to capitulate to to workers' demands, just as it's no surprise that American business leaders rarely allow their businesses to be held hostage by workers - even unionism is losing it's hold here!

And a lot of good it does everybody! Oh, the blessings of what American business leaders are doing to the rest of the population ...
Unions in the USA
 
Last edited:
And bereaving people of their livelihood isn't? It takes an awful lot of violence to make people accept that they are excluded from the wealth produced in our societies.

Downsizing is not an act of violence. Forcibly detaining (kidnapping) someone is a violent act.

How do you not see the distinction between the two?
 
Downsizing is not an act of violence. Forcibly detaining (kidnapping) someone is a violent act.

How do you not see the distinction between the two?

I find it much more amazing that an employer should be obligated to keep an employee, well, employed.

Why?

My employer is under no obligation to make a job available for me. I am glad that I have a job there, but should our customers ever decide that they no longer need what I am responsible for chances are, my employer would stop providing it.

Why should he be obligated to provide an expensive service that nobody wants, and why should he be obligated to pay me to keep the service available?

Should we be allowed to force our customers to stay our customers and make use of the services we are currently providing, too?

It's an interesting subject, but I can't dwell on it much longer. I have an appointment with my hairdresser. Not that my hair needs cutting or anything, but I had a haircut there before and I'll bereave him of his likelyhood if I don't go there often enough ....
 
Downsizing is not an act of violence. Forcibly detaining (kidnapping) someone is a violent act.

How do you not see the distinction between the two?

The distinction in this case is obvious: The workers lose their jobs and thus their livelihood.
The boss is locked up in his office.
Downsizing is an act of violence, but not according to jurisprudence:

Es gibt viele Arten zu töten. Man kann einem ein Messer in den Bauch stechen, einem das Brot entziehen, einen von einer Krankheit nicht heilen, einen in eine schlechte Wohnung stecken, einen durch Arbeit zu Tode schinden, einen zum Suizid treiben, einen in den Krieg führen usw. Nur weniges davon ist in unserem Staat verboten.
Bertolt Brecht
http://www.zitate-online.de/spruech...ibt-viele-arten-zu-toeten-man-kann-einem.html

There are many ways to kill a man. You can stick a knife in his guts, deprive him of bread, refrain from curing him of a disease, place him in a bad apartment, make him work himself to death, drive him to commit suicide, send him to war etc. Few of these things are forbidden in our state. My translation
 
I find it much more amazing that an employer should be obligated to keep an employee, well, employed.

He isn't, is he? Nor is anybody else. You are 'compelled' to eat, though, which is why unemployment is such a devastating judgment on a society.

And the hairdresser, of course, is compelled to eat, too, which does not make your strawman any better ...
 
Last edited:
He isn't, is he?

As soon as he is being kidnapped to keep people empolyoed that he would otherwise no longer employ: Yes, he is! Especially if the act of kidnapping him is no longer viewed as unethical.

Yes, I agree that it is bad for a society not to have unemployment but to allow unemployment to have such devastating consequences. But it is not the duty of the employers to change that.
 
As soon as he is being kidnapped to keep people empolyoed that he would otherwise no longer employ: Yes, he is! Especially if the act of kidnapping him is no longer viewed as unethical.

That is the reason why he's detained, yes. I don't find the reaction of the workers in this case is "unethical".

Yes, I agree that it is bad for a society not to have unemployment but to allow unemployment to have such devastating consequences. But it is not the duty of the employers to change that.

Well, it's bad for employers not to have unemployment, which is why they tend to moan when the rate of employment goes down. And as long as your livelihood depends on the opportunity to sell your working capacity to people with money, unemployment does indeed have devastating consequences.
It is neither the duty of the employers to change that, nor does anybody expect them to, I think. The change will obviously have to be contrary to the interests of employers as employers. The French workers, too, seem to understand this much. That the nature of the interests of workers and employers is: class struggle - whether in a boom or in a crisis.
Their attempt at solving the problem by locking up the boss, however, is a demonstration of impotence.
 
Should we be allowed to force our customers to stay our customers and make use of the services we are currently providing, too?
....

Good point! We should give employees the right to force employers to keep employing them as soon as we give employers the right to force customers to keep buying their goods.
 
But 'we' should still be able to force unemployment = loss of livelihood on people, right? You cannot possibly want to take that most basic freedom away from 'us', can you?
 
If you seriously think forcible detainment, regardless of whether or not the detainee ends up complaining about it afterward, or the police get off their crapfactories and do something about it, is "harmless" then your arguments are barely distinguishable from that of a lunatic, and barely worth wasting keystrokes on.

But hey, let's try.

It is an act of violence. There's no way around that. Declaring that someone is not free to leave implies something will happen to them if they attempt to do so. Your actions are not excused if you tell someone they're not free to leave, and then you don't harm them because they didn't try to leave.

More hysteria, more unhinged melodrama, and yet again, the weenies voicing this view DO NOT BRING A SINGLE FACT TO THE TABLE.

And this:

They are all quite lucky they are not in the US and pulling this crap. I guarantee there would be a body count associated with this practice. And I'd have no problem with that if it happened here, or ends up happening in France.

Means there's something deeply wrong with you.
 
I don't know. Are you actually talking about a machine to lighten the burden of having to perform a simple mindless job day in and day out, or are you talking of a machine to lighten the expenses of factury owner for the wages of workers performing simple mindless jobs?
For some weird reason the act of depriving people of their livelihood is usually referred to with very different words.

The two are the same. A company might be able to do something with one worker instead of 10. This is very good for the company as it reduces the cost, it is also good for the economy because it increases productivity. If you want to get on the workers side, you need to take back a lot of modern technology that makes people more productive.

I want to eliminate jobs. By making it so that people can individually do much more work you need fewer people to do the same amount of work.
Yes, maybe it is. Where did they take him?

It has been pointed out that you do not need to take someone to be guilty of kidnapping them. Simply holding them in one place against their will does this.
No, it isn't.

Of course it is. Their actions fit the laws in many jurisdictions. Just because you do not like the term, does not mean it is not the correct legal term for their actions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom