Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

I just don't see a basic reproductive number of one creating hundreds of infections within a few days like that.
The R0 takes a broad view. It's an average. Obviously, there is always the potential for a single patient to pass the virus on to a large number of others -- just as it is possible for a single patient (or a large number of patients) to not pass it on to even one other person. We have no way of knowing how many subclinical cases there may be, but we're really not seeing an exponential overall spike in clinical cases. Yet.
 
Does the Swine Flu need special testing equipment / methods to identify it? How does it show up with their current in-use testing methods? I know that for the normal flu they often do a nasal swab and then test it somehow in the lab.
 
Does the Swine Flu need special testing equipment / methods to identify it?

Yes and no. If testing using primers for seasonal flu determines that it is type A influenza but is unable to identify the specific subtype, the reasonable assumption is that it is the novel strain. The sample is then sent off to a special lab to be verified by another, more sophisticated test. In other words, if the standard test fails to identify it, that very failure constitues a tentative confirmation that it is the novel strain.
 
Why not prepare now? Then come Fall you don't have to be scared and you don't have to panic.
Good advice. Personally, I've been fully prepped for several years now. If necessary, I could throw the deadbolt on my front door and not open it again for weeks. I even have a stash of Tamiflu (as well as Amantadine, effective against one of this year's seasonal strains, but not the other).
 
The R0 takes a broad view. It's an average. Obviously, there is always the potential for a single patient to pass the virus on to a large number of others -- just as it is possible for a single patient (or a large number of patients) to not pass it on to even one other person. We have no way of knowing how many subclinical cases there may be, but we're really not seeing an exponential overall spike in clinical cases. Yet.

Well, maybe the NY school outbreak is the result of a few hyper-contagious people, but even that would be included in the average, and I'm really not seeing how an average one-for-one transmission rate could cause hundreds of cases in a few days.

we're really not seeing an exponential overall spike in clinical cases.

I don't think there's evidence available either way yet. The MMWR said the CDC is currently trying to figure out if there's a spike in the hospitals or not.

There is a lack of hysterical news reports from local NY TV stations. But...umm...I'd be surprised if the CDC communications dept hasn't asked those local networks to please not spark a national panic if they do hear about an increase in ILI cases running to the ER.
 
Good advice. Personally, I've been fully prepped for several years now. If necessary, I could throw the deadbolt on my front door and not open it again for weeks. I even have a stash of Tamiflu (as well as Amantadine, effective against one of this year's seasonal strains, but not the other).

Party at Dymanic's house!

:D
 
....We have no way of knowing how many subclinical cases there may be, but we're really not seeing an exponential overall spike in clinical cases. Yet.
Your assessment reveals the shortcomings of making the false assumption the "confirmed" cases are intended to represent actual cases, or that "confirmed" cases is really the only data we have to draw accurate estimates from.

What makes anyone think WHO is even trying to confirm every case? It would be a total waste of laboratory resources in this situation and in addition, many of the deaths were before intense surveillance was set up. There may be either no viable specimens available for testing or there may be specimens on a back log that will be useful looking back but that are of lower priority than testing specimens of cases to document spread to new locations.

From the CDC link kelly already posted comes: Told ya so (not necessarily directed at you) ;)
The clinical spectrum of S-OIV illness is not yet well characterized in Mexico. However, evidence suggests that S-OIV transmission is widespread and that less severe (uncomplicated) illness is common. Patients with confirmed disease have been identified in several states, and suspected cases have been identified in all states, which suggests that S-OIV transmission is widespread. In addition, several countries are reporting S-OIV infection among persons who have travel histories involving different parts of Mexico in the 7 days before illness onset. To date, case-finding in Mexico has focused on patients seeking care in hospitals, and the selection of cases for laboratory testing has focused on patients with more severe disease. Therefore, a large number of undetected cases of illness might exist in persons seeking care in primary-care settings or not seeking care at all. Additional investigations are needed urgently to evaluate the full clinical spectrum of disease in Mexico, the proportion of patients who have severe illness, and the extent of disease transmission.
(emphasis mine)

The point is there are many pieces of evidence that can be used in epidemiology to assess the extent of spread of disease. Confirmed case counts are only one piece of evidence. In some cases confirmed cases closely represents actual cases. But in many situations such as the one we are seeing, confirmed cases are not intended to represent actual cases.
 
Google newsing "New York hospital swine" gets you this:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/01/health/01fear.html?ref=health

“They’re coming without any symptoms; they just want to be checked,” said Ana Marengo, a spokeswoman for the Health and Hospitals Corporation, which operates the public hospitals of New York City. “It’s definitely crowding all our emergency rooms.”

In New York, where 49 cases have been confirmed and 16 more were suspected, some hospitals have reported healthy people — the “worried well,” in the words of some health officials — returning from vacation in Mexico and going straight from the airport to the emergency room. The city’s public hospitals reported 100 to 135 more patients each day in each emergency room since the outbreak.

I don't see anybody actually saying "We have no increase in actual ILI here at all, for sure."
It's probably almost impossible to tell when a lot of people who normaly don't run to the ER for ILI suddenly start doing so. (and that's neverminding the people who just sneezed and go).
 
Last edited:
Party at Dymanic's house!
Heh. Probably at just about the time you were typing that, I was unceremoneously tossing one of my family members out on her ass because five minutes after she showed up, she announced that she has a sore throat. I knew I should have used that deadbolt.
 
Your assessment reveals the shortcomings of making the false assumption the "confirmed" cases are intended to represent actual cases, or that "confirmed" cases is really the only data we have to draw accurate estimates from.
What is a "confirmed" case, in contrast to a confirmed case?

Who are we?
 
What makes anyone think WHO is even trying to confirm every case?
If you're not going to make any attempt to extrapolate from confirmed cases to arrive at some estimate of how widespread the virus is, then what's the point of confirming any of them? I say the number of people with serious illness is important, and if those numbers are growing exponentially, it seems like we'd have seen it by now (even if you include "suspected" cases). If this thing circles the globe without producing a significant number of people who develop illness serious enough to motivate them to seek care, then it will be an event which will be of very great interest -- to epidemiologists. Everyone else will refer to it as "The other swine flu pandemic that never was".
 
News interview with some of the confirmed NY students:

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jvOtr9vaygAoki_8xOba_uqT3z0AD97TKF9G0

It might be too soon to know because it's still incubating, but I wonder what % of their parents are going to catch it, too?
I was disappointed that the MMWR on mexico didn't address attack rates among close contacts of confirned cases. But it was interesting to see that in table 2, there were zero confirmed cases among people over 60.
Makes me think of this:
http://biomicro.sdstate.edu/WangX/Micr425/Pathogenesis/Influenza_A.pdf
Clearly, there may be multifactorial “extra ingredients” factors
such as a role for cell-mediated immunity which, at
present, must have an importance which has not been disclosed
to date.
The occurrence in nature of new reassortant viruses might
be far more frequent than we commonly think. These may
not find a foothold since a permissive host population, based
on more than we know at present, might be required in
order for them to reappear in epidemic or pandemic events.
Such speculation, irrespective of lack of definitive evidence,
does give a different way to view the pandemic virus cycle
and provides a new approach to predictive epidemiology of
influenza.
 
Last edited:
I say the number of people with serious illness is important, and if those numbers are growing exponentially, it seems like we'd have seen it by now (even if you include "suspected" cases).

How do you know NY isn't?
People's hysteria and running to the ER over every sneeze there is going to make it difficult to tell if there's really an increase in ILI or not. They're probably going to have to compare April and May pneumonia deaths to an estimate for last year or something. It's not that easy to tell if there are really more sick people around.
The first NY symptom onset was just over a week ago. Those kid's parents might just now be experiencing their first cough themselves, too.

It's way too early to say it would already be happening, AND it might be happening right now but they can't say for sure, because evaluating an increase is difficult under these circumstances.
 
I suppose you're right. It's a bit early.

I'll take it!
:p

But really, the spike might not happen for another week, and then it'll be another week or more before they can honestly confirm that.
 
I read in a swedish newspaper today that Swedens worst scenario is that this virus will infect 3-4million of the swedish population and about 4000 could die. Sounds very unbelievable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom