Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

I read in a swedish newspaper today that Swedens worst scenario is that this virus will infect 3-4million of the swedish population and about 4000 could die. Sounds very unbelievable.

Buy shares in undertakers and coffin manufacturers.

I find it hard to believe that's a worst case scenario, with a death rate of only 0.1%. They could've done much better than that.
 
Buy shares in undertakers and coffin manufacturers.

I find it hard to believe that's a worst case scenario, with a death rate of only 0.1%. They could've done much better than that.

Well ok my mistake, it stood "Horror-scenario" not worst. But is it possible?
 
Well ok my mistake, it stood "Horror-scenario" not worst. But is it possible?

I'd say that the numbers would be about right. It isn't a horribly nasty strain of influenza at the moment, so if it stays true to type and everyone does get it, then a death rate of 1/1000 is reasonable.

Still too early to be sure - the case numbers aren't exploding as you'd expect at the moment, and given the timeline of the epidemic so far.
 
I'd say that the numbers would be about right. It isn't a horribly nasty strain of influenza at the moment, so if it stays true to type and everyone does get it, then a death rate of 1/1000 is reasonable.

Still too early to be sure - the case numbers aren't exploding as you'd expect at the moment, and given the timeline of the epidemic so far.

Oh I hoped the writer was exaggerating...
 
How is it possible you can't see the difference?

If normal 'flu years put hospitals under strain - as they do, year in, year out - how will having 5 - 10 times more people needing hospital treatment not be a disaster, because that is exactly what will happen if the disease is left to run unchecked.

No immunity = vastly more people get it than usual.

If ifs and buts were candy and nuts we'd all have a merry secular-mass
Chillax guys, the world isn't about to end.
 
Group buy-in!
Special for JREF members.
Pork bellies up to 50% discount!!

Buy in now 1-800-NON-H1N1
 

Got a chance to read it.
They address the attack rate:


>> Two questions. First, could you talk about your investigation into the attack rate? Could you tell us what the attack rate is, and how you've been looking at that in Mexico and the United States? And I also have a question about in the genetic analysis, have you ascertained what this virus has in common with or doesn't have in common with the 1918 virus?

>> Do you want to take those questions?

>> Yes. Okay. Let me give you attack rate. I think Nancy can characterize the virus a lot better than I can. There are many ways that we can look at attack rates. And it's one of those tools that epidemiologists use to try to understand the situation. One way is looking in households and families, trying to understand if you have -- when you have a virus in a family, you sort of expect it to go through the family. The proportion of family members that are infected is a good way to come up with an attack rate. So we're looking at lots of families, and aggregating the information to estimate an attack rate. At this point I would say that we're estimating an attack rate that's fairly high. You know, in the 25% to 30% range. But that's not a final attack rate. And it's consistent with what we see with seasonal influenza. There's a lot of what we're seeing that isn't surprising. Because of what we know about seasonal influenza that is easily spread, person-to-person, that family members are at higher risk and further out there. In Mexico, there are some other ways that it's being looked at. But our best data would be from sort of the information we have here. You know, there are also ways, when you have a cohort, a school or a tour group or something that you can estimate an attack rate. So we do think that this virus is easily transmitted, similar to seasonal influenza. This isn't one that -- it is easily transmitted. I'll let Nancy talk about what we know about 12918 -- 1918

Why isn't it higher than seasonal influenza?

Seasonal flu would have a higher attack rate if some people weren't immune, wouldn't it?
 
Why isn't it higher than seasonal influenza?
It is. Attack rate for seasonal influenza is 5% - 15%. I read that statement too, and I'm a little confused by it. Maybe it comes off different in the audio.

Seasonal flu would have a higher attack rate if some people weren't immune, wouldn't it?
Yes. Maybe that explains it.
 
What is a "confirmed" case, in contrast to a confirmed case?

Who are we?
Confirmed, probable and suspected cases are the defined case categories.

CDC definitions
A confirmed case of S-OIV infection is defined as a person with an acute febrile respiratory illness with laboratory confirmed S-OIV infection at CDC by one or more of the following tests:

1. real-time RT-PCR
2. viral culture

A probable case of S-OIV infection is defined as a person with an acute febrile respiratory illness who is positive for influenza A, but negative for H1 and H3 by influenza RT-PCR

A suspected case of S-OIV infection is defined as a person with acute febrile respiratory illness with onset

* within 7 days of close contact with a person who is a confirmed case of S-OIV infection, or
* within 7 days of travel to community either within the United States or internationally where there are one or more confirmed cases of S-OIV infection, or
* resides in a community where there are one or more confirmed cases of S-OIV infection.
"We" are those of us in the infectious disease field that understand the terminology and how to interpret the data relative to specific infectious disease patterns.
 
It is. Attack rate for seasonal influenza is 5% - 15%. I read that statement too, and I'm a little confused by it. Maybe it comes off different in the audio.

Yes. Maybe that explains it.

Is the seasonal 5-15% specifically for close contacts? Like, in household studies?
 
Is the seasonal 5-15% specifically for close contacts? Like, in household studies?
No. As I understand it, that represents the percentage of the population that is infected over the course of the season.
 
If you're not going to make any attempt to extrapolate from confirmed cases to arrive at some estimate of how widespread the virus is, then what's the point of confirming any of them?

When we have more data, I hope some of you go back and put the pieces together you are misreading here.

Extrapolate from confirmed cases, yes, of course, along with ALL the other data. I'm pointing out to the armchair epidemiologists here that one does not, in this case, consider the WHO confirmed cases to have any bearing on total number of cases and deaths. The WHO confirmed cases do, however, provide confirmation of the distance the virus has spread and when it reaches new territory so that clinicians and epidemiologists can begin looking for cases and so that local governments can activate pandemic plans.

With infections such as human H5N1, the WHO confirmed cases represent a pretty close actual case count. But even with that data, a number of studies have been done over time to verify the absence of uncounted infections. Select populations were sampled for H5N1 antibodies to detect uncounted cases. Only a very small number have been found among poultry and open market workers and none in the general populations in the area of the bird epidemics.

That's just one example of how one uses data like the WHO laboratory confirmed case count.

In the case of this pandemic I have already spelled out in detail what the evidence is that the WHO confirmed case count is by no means close to an actual case count. And I already posted the reason the confirmed cases cannot include early cases for which there were no specimens available, even if the WHO wanted to. There is currently no antibody test than can tell us past infection either. Some company will have to develop that specific antibody test in the future if we are to ever have one.

Surely most people with a minimal amount of brain function recognize the absurdity of thinking there have only been 8 deaths and less than 200 total cases from this pandemic so far because that is all the WHO cites as confirmed case fatalities.
 
Last edited:
say the number of people with serious illness is important, and if those numbers are growing exponentially, it seems like we'd have seen it by now (even if you include "suspected" cases). If this thing circles the globe without producing a significant number of people who develop illness serious enough to motivate them to seek care, then it will be an event which will be of very great interest -- to epidemiologists. Everyone else will refer to it as "The other swine flu pandemic that never was".
The number of cases in Mexico are likely in the tens of thousands. With that many cases their hospitals filled to capacity and the country recognized the seriousness of the situation and shut the country down. That's a drastic measure Mexico would not have taken were they not seeing a lot of very sick people.

What the folks who assumed this is an infection which will not fill hospitals in other countries are failing to recognize is that there has indeed been thousands of cases in Mexico. There's no other way so many unrelated cases could have shown up all over North America at virtually the same time. And now the cases are showing up at points further in rapid succession.

What differs is we have not yet seen tens of thousands of cases outside of Mexico yet. We are only so far seeing the first few hundred. Most of the cases began to show up in the US in only the last 2 weeks!!! Two weeks, folks, count 'em. While the first cases tested had symptoms at the end of March, the NY school outbreak started 04/20/09.

And people here think because we've yet to see many serious cases we should conclude there won't be very many? I wouldn't bet the farm. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I'd say that the numbers would be about right. It isn't a horribly nasty strain of influenza at the moment, so if it stays true to type and everyone does get it, then a death rate of 1/1000 is reasonable.

Still too early to be sure - the case numbers aren't exploding as you'd expect at the moment, and given the timeline of the epidemic so far.
A watched pot comes to mind. :)
 
Is the seasonal 5-15% specifically for close contacts? Like, in household studies?
222 kids in the Queens NY school reported to the nurse's office with illness within 4 days of the first 10 that reported to the nurse. The school has ~3,000 counting students and staff. And, the 222 count would not include kids who were ill but didn't report to the nurse, less a few reports that would have been the baseline for seeing the school nurses.

That is a very high attack rate considering a couple things. If the virus were circulating in the community there would be several contact points. This occurred from a relatively small initial group of contagious kids.

And because the incubation period is relatively short, we see that the 222 kids were infected in a fairly short window. And, there were many more than the 222 who reported to the nurses office including many staff and family members.

Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus Infections in a School --- New York City, April 2009
Complete data from this ongoing survey are not yet available, but preliminary results indicate widespread influenza-like symptoms, with hundreds of students and many staff members reporting symptoms that met the case definition for ILI.

DOHMH also initiated active surveillance for severe, hospitalized febrile respiratory ILI among NYC residents, and this surveillance is currently ongoing. On April 26, DOHMH staff members began contacting all 61 NYC hospitals with medical and/or pediatric intensive care units by telephone on a daily basis to identify possible severe cases of S-OIV, defined by the presence of fever ≥100.4°F (≥38°C) and at least one of the following: acute respiratory distress syndrome, pneumonia, or respiratory distress. DOHMH physicians review all possible cases; nasopharyngeal swabs are recommended for cases with no identified etiology. Specimens are tested for influenza A at the NYC Public Health Laboratory, and isolates that cannot be subtyped are sent to CDC for further characterization. Active surveillance identified one to two cases of severe hospitalized ILI per day for which further testing was recommended. Results of the testing are not yet available.

Enhanced passive surveillance also is ongoing.

This example demonstrates an attack rate significantly higher than seasonal flu averages among close and casual contacts.
 
Last edited:
There is currently no antibody test than can tell us past infection either. Some company will have to develop that specific antibody test in the future if we are to ever have one.

The outlook is so bleak we may not have a future? Damn!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom