Easy solution to the pirate problem...

In 2008 2 ships were boarded and 42 hijacked by Somali pirates. 815 crew members were taken hostage, 2 were reported injured, 4 were killed, and 14 are missing.

In Q1, 2009 a total of 9 ships were hijacked by Somali pirates, and 1 boarded. 157 crew members were taken hostage, and 4 injured.

For what it's work, after the IMB stressed that Masters should do everything they could to resist hijacking, the rate of successful pirate attacks in the first quarter of 2009 dropped dramatically compared with the previous year.


That's interesting, the data I pulled from the map has only 6 attempts and no hijackings for Q1, 2008 in the Somalia region. But I have nearly the same totals for all of 2008.

Also, my data shows 13 hijackings for April 2009 compared to only 4 in April 2008.
 
You've just claimed that cutting out opperations should be pretty much imposible. Centuries of militry history suggest otherwise.

I have absolutely no idea what you are talking about here.
 
No, but close. If it's closer to 60% then it's not really "easy", is it ?

Assuming the pirates are seen at a good distance (which they should be with guards as I have suggested) putting a rifle over the side of the ship and shooting them is about as easy as it gets. This is the easy solution I am proposing. In this thread I have outlined everything necessary to accomplish this. We have seen accounts of pirates being deterred by mere pistols and fire hoses. With a rifle, the pirates would not even have a chance to get near the ship. I think the gun haters and tea proposers are purposely ignoring exactly what I am outlining.
 
They already have these things.
Or fifteen pirates with RPGs. Whatever. If they start being shot at, they will start shooting back. Violence begets violence. Once shooting becomes a solution to the problem, then more shooting will start being a counter to the solution. Just look at the nuclear escalation following the end of WW2: "The Americans have a really big bomb, comrade. We need to build a bigger bomb."

Okay, that's not quite a Godwin, but it's close.

What really annoys me about this line of argumentation is the assumption that problems can be solved with guns. They can't. Guns only prolong and exacerbate the problem by escalating the violence. Guns have a purpose. Problem-solving isn't it.
 
Assuming the pirates are seen at a good distance (which they should be with guards as I have suggested) putting a rifle over the side of the ship and shooting them is about as easy as it gets. This is the easy solution I am proposing. In this thread I have outlined everything necessary to accomplish this.

I'm not saying that actually shooting at the pirates is hard to do. What's I'm saying is that implementing this solution is not as "easy" as you claimed, and other consequences of that solution might make it not the best solution.

In any case, this thread has made it VERY clear that it isn't simple.
 
Escalating the response may diminish the entire situation, if the certainty of death attacking any boat rises beyond an "acceptable" amount to the pirates.
No response or capitulation on the first show of intent to attack encourages the activity.
Their bravery is quite dependent on the lack of deadly response.
Up the ante a bit.
 
.....What really annoys me about this line of argumentation is the assumption that problems can be solved with guns. They can't. Guns only prolong and exacerbate the problem by escalating the violence. Guns have a purpose. Problem-solving isn't it.

While it will take more than firearms to eliminate pirate attacks, I do not think that any sailors being attacked by pirates would agree with you. If pirates are shooting at their ship, then I'm sure most sailors are going to want firearms as part of the solution to the immediate problem.

You need to remember that when pirates are shooting at a ship, that problem is not the economic situations lead to the piracy, but the bullets and rockets used against the crew. When all other measures to curb piracy fail, the ships crew needs adequate means to defend themselves. A ship alone at ship is solely responsible for their own safety. Discouraging any practical means of defense is immoral.

Ranb
 
I merely dispute that shooting people is a practical means of defence. But that may just be me. I'm a pacifist, in case you hadn't noticed.
 
What really annoys me about this line of argumentation is the assumption that problems can be solved with guns. They can't. Guns only prolong and exacerbate the problem by escalating the violence. Guns have a purpose. Problem-solving isn't it.

Sure they can, once you kill everyone who disagrees with you, you win.
 
I merely dispute that shooting people is a practical means of defence. But that may just be me. I'm a pacifist, in case you hadn't noticed.

What means would you be willing to use if you were on a freighter in the Gulf of Aden that was being attacked by pirates in speedboats? Assume that help is not immediately available and that your shipmates are counting on each other to prevent a pirate boarding.

If non-lethal (such as speed, fire hoses, acoustics) do not work, are you willing to use deadly force to defend yourself and your shipmates? There is no wrong answer here; I am just wondering how far you will go to defend yourself and your crew.

I am former Navy, I was trained (however poorly) to use deadly force to defend the ship. I might even be capable of it if I ever found myself in that position.

Ranb
 
I merely dispute that shooting people is a practical means of defence. But that may just be me. I'm a pacifist, in case you hadn't noticed.
.
Just the thought of being shot at keeps me from going to some areas around here! :)
 
...
I am former Navy, I was trained (however poorly) to use deadly force to defend the ship. I might even be capable of it if I ever found myself in that position.

Ranb
,
One of the guys I fly toy airplanes says that he was given an M1 carbine, but with no bullets, to defend the cruiser he was on off the coast of Korea in the '50s, when he had the watch.
 
I merely dispute that shooting people is a practical means of defence. But that may just be me. I'm a pacifist, in case you hadn't noticed.
A "pacifist male" is a contradiction in terms. Most self-described "pacifists" are not pacific; they simply assume false colors. When the wind changes, they hoist the Jolly Roger.
Lazarus Long (R.A. Heinlein)
 
Escalating the response may diminish the entire situation, if the certainty of death attacking any boat rises beyond an "acceptable" amount to the pirates.
No response or capitulation on the first show of intent to attack encourages the activity.
Their bravery is quite dependent on the lack of deadly response.
Up the ante a bit.

I agree with that, but I'm simply saying that it's not an "easy" problem. First there's the costs involved, and the fact that escalation is a possible outcome.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom