Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I agree with that, but I'm simply saying that it's not an "easy" problem. First there's the costs involved, and the fact that escalation is a possible outcome.

How can a ship prevent a pirate boarding without escalating? If they try to outrun them, then the pirates get faster boats. If they use acoustic devices, the pirates use ear plugs, if they use fire hoses, then the pirates can use larger groups, if they use firearms, the pirates use more or more powerful firearms. Where does it end?

You seem to want the crew to avoid any effort to prevent seizure of the ship. How do you expect to prevent this crime without any escalation? If as you claim the sailors are only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates, then what do you expect them to do?

Ranb
 
That's interesting, the data I pulled from the map has only 6 attempts and no hijackings for Q1, 2008 in the Somalia region. But I have nearly the same totals for all of 2008.

Also, my data shows 13 hijackings for April 2009 compared to only 4 in April 2008.


According to the IMB the Somali attacks are coming increasingly further out to sea, which might explain why you didn't count them. The data comes from the IMB's 2009 Q1 report.
 
Given that ship crews have been vigorously resisting pirates for years, and given that pirates have not in any way changed their tactics in those years, the escalation argument would appear to be false.

The pirates appear to be operating at the very limit of their tactical capabilities.
 
There are well over 100 hostages somewhere in Somalia who have been there for months. Nobody knows how many are alive at this point.
 
Or fifteen pirates with RPGs. Whatever. If they start being shot at, they will start shooting back. Violence begets violence. Once shooting becomes a solution to the problem, then more shooting will start being a counter to the solution. Just look at the nuclear escalation following the end of WW2: "The Americans have a really big bomb, comrade. We need to build a bigger bomb."

Okay, that's not quite a Godwin, but it's close.

What really annoys me about this line of argumentation is the assumption that problems can be solved with guns. They can't. Guns only prolong and exacerbate the problem by escalating the violence. Guns have a purpose. Problem-solving isn't it.

This may be one of the most ridiculous posts in this thread yet (Aside from the tea post of course). Perhaps we should take away guns from police and the military. Guns don't solve anything correct? Hell if a criminal or the enemy starts shooting at you, you shouldn't shoot back because guns never solve problems. Is this what you are getting at? You understand how silly that sounds right?

Let me know if a gun solves this hypothetical. Pirates go to board ship. Crew shoots at pirates. Pirates either flee or are killed. Immediate problem solved, self defense achieved. Correct?

Oh and correct me if I am wrong, but didn't we use guns to stop Hitler from taking over all of Europe? I am not too great at history, you may have to bring me up to speed on that.
 
I merely dispute that shooting people is a practical means of defence. But that may just be me. I'm a pacifist, in case you hadn't noticed.

What would you define as a practical means of defense if someone were shooting at you? Lets say you were a police officer or a soldier. What would you use instead of guns to stop a criminal from using a gun to kill you or an enemy soldier from killing you? I never understood the pacifist thing. There have always and WILL always be evil people in this world. If all good men became pacifists, all the good men would either be killed or become slaves.
 
I am just wondering how far you will go to defend yourself and your crew.
Hello? Pacifist! I wouldn't be on the ship in the first place!

Lazarus Long (R.A. Heinlein)
Heinlein was a dick.

What would you define as a practical means of defense if someone were shooting at you?
I've never been shot at and I never plan to.

Lets say you were a police officer or a soldier.
I'm neither.

What would you use instead of guns to stop a criminal from using a gun to kill you or an enemy soldier from killing you?
I'm neither.

I never understood the pacifist thing.
That is very clear, thank you.

There have always and WILL always be evil people in this world.
And there'll always be people like you who are perfectly willing to use violence as a solution to that problem. To me, that makes you just as evil as them. Perhaps that's the part you're not understanding.

If all good men became pacifists, all the good men would either be killed or become slaves.
Because that's totally what happened to Ghandi.
 
According to the IMB the Somali attacks are coming increasingly further out to sea, which might explain why you didn't count them. The data comes from the IMB's 2009 Q1 report.

Since I have the world wide data, I should be able to see it how far out they are. What I see is the highest density of attacks and hijackings is still in the shipping lanes of the Gulf of Aden and some spread out along the South-East coast. There are very few outliers which have been progressively further from the coast each year but I don't think the average has moved much.

I can't say that I'm seeing an accurate picture because I know a big chunk of the data is missing for 2008.
 
Hello? Pacifist! I wouldn't be on the ship in the first place!
So that means you wouldn't go to any place where there might be a chance of being assaulted?

I'm neither.
And what if there are criminals in your neighborhood? You wouldn't want the police to stop them?

And there'll always be people like you who are perfectly willing to use violence as a solution to that problem. To me, that makes you just as evil as them. Perhaps that's the part you're not understanding.
Which means every police officer is an evil person because they use force, deadly force if necessary, to protect *you* who isn't willing to face any danger himself? I guess I just misunderstood you, because that attitude seems both hypocritical and cowardly and I wouldn't want to think that bad of you. :boggled:

Because that's totally what happened to Ghandi.
Well, actually... Yes.
 
So that means you wouldn't go to any place where there might be a chance of being assaulted?
Not if I can avoid it. It's worked for me for the last 40 years.

And what if there are criminals in your neighborhood? You wouldn't want the police to stop them?
Of course I would. What, do you think I'm some kind of libertarian?

Which means every police officer is an evil person because they use force, deadly force if necessary, to protect *you* who isn't willing to face any danger himself?
No, police officers are not evil, most of the time (sometimes they are). Nor are the military. Or at least, if they're evil then they're a necessary evil.

I guess I just misunderstood you, because that attitude seems both hypocritical and cowardly and I wouldn't want to think that bad of you. :boggled:
You say that as though there's something bad about being a coward. "He who fights and runs away lives to fight another day." No, that's not right. "He who fights and runs away lives." That's better, but I prefer "He who runs away lives".

Well, actually... Yes.
You've probably got me on that. I don't know the history as well as I like to think I do. :rolleyes:

American gun culture is the thing I understand least and despise most about America. I do not own a gun, have never owned a gun, have never even fired a gun - even at a range - and I find it completely baffling that some Americans think that it is a necessary part of life. (Note: I'm not going to make the Michael Moore link between gun ownership and violent crime, because I think that particular argument is deeply flawed.)

I've never wanted a gun, and I've never needed a gun. But this isn't a gun control thread so I'll just stop talking now.

Suffice to repeat one last time: Guns are not an easy solution to the piracy problem, any more than they have been an easy solution to the Iraq problem. I commend and admire Quad4_72 and anyone else who has chosen to serve in uniform for doing a nasty, nasty job that I would never, ever do myself. But then again, I commend and admire garbage collectors for the same reason. That's my last word. If anyone wants to start a pacifism thread, I'll be there.
 
How can a ship prevent a pirate boarding without escalating? If they try to outrun them, then the pirates get faster boats. If they use acoustic devices, the pirates use ear plugs, if they use fire hoses, then the pirates can use larger groups, if they use firearms, the pirates use more or more powerful firearms. Where does it end?

A good question, actually. Another reason why it's not an "easy" solution.

You seem to want the crew to avoid any effort to prevent seizure of the ship.

Your perception is a little off, then. That's not what I want.
 
And there'll always be people like you who are perfectly willing to use violence as a solution to that problem. To me, that makes you just as evil as them. Perhaps that's the part you're not understanding.

To be fair, there are situations where violence is unavoidable in order to protect freedom and such and such.

There are situations where violence is not desirable.

And there are situations such as this one for which it's not an easy answer.
 
Given that ship crews have been vigorously resisting pirates for years, and given that pirates have not in any way changed their tactics in those years, the escalation argument would appear to be false.

The pirates appear to be operating at the very limit of their tactical capabilities.

I agree

How many of those millions of dollars of profit would it take for the pirates to increase their tactical capabilities ?

For instance, how much would a torpedo cost ? I don't mean a new, high tech one, but a crappy WW2 era one that's capable of sinking an defenseless freighter ?

They'd only need one, and to use it to sink some random ship, maybe one that's part of a convoy so there's witnesses, or film the act and upload it to YouTube.

Then all they'd need to do is approach a ship and hail it with " surrender and let us on board or we'll sink you with all hands, it's not worth dieing for someone else's goods" to force compliance.
 
I agree

How many of those millions of dollars of profit would it take for the pirates to increase their tactical capabilities ?

For instance, how much would a torpedo cost ? I don't mean a new, high tech one, but a crappy WW2 era one that's capable of sinking an defenseless freighter ?

They'd only need one, and to use it to sink some random ship, maybe one that's part of a convoy so there's witnesses, or film the act and upload it to YouTube.

Then all they'd need to do is approach a ship and hail it with " surrender and let us on board or we'll sink you with all hands, it's not worth dieing for someone else's goods" to force compliance.

Unless there's some incredibly capable sub-group of pirates that I don't know about, this is not feasible at all.

If they bought some cheapo Chines anti-shipping weapon and used it to damage one of those huge cargo ships, I still think it would get them nowhere.

Is there even an affordable weapon that could take on a ship that size and be operated by a malnutritioned illiterate teenager?
 
To be fair, there are situations where violence is unavoidable in order to protect freedom and such and such.

There are situations where violence is not desirable.

And there are situations such as this one for which it's not an easy answer.
I can't find it in me to disagree with you.
 
I agree

How many of those millions of dollars of profit would it take for the pirates to increase their tactical capabilities ?

For instance, how much would a torpedo cost ? I don't mean a new, high tech one, but a crappy WW2 era one that's capable of sinking an defenseless freighter ?

They'd only need one, and to use it to sink some random ship, maybe one that's part of a convoy so there's witnesses, or film the act and upload it to YouTube.

Then all they'd need to do is approach a ship and hail it with " surrender and let us on board or we'll sink you with all hands, it's not worth dieing for someone else's goods" to force compliance.

I am willing to bet you don't know the first thing about firing a torpedo do you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom