Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

This is such a bizarre view I don't know where to begin.

A nation is not an individual. They can't be "alcohalic" in the sense that the entire population will unanimously behave one way or the other.

In Somalia a small group of very violent warlords have been terrorizing the population. The people being murdered and having their aid shipments stolen would love to see an end to their assailants.
Not enough, apparently, to do anything about it. One is only terrorised by one's own consent. A warlord only has the power that those around him grant him.

They very much do not want to be beaten, raped, and murdered, but they are so poor and destitute that they can't really mount a rebellion.
How does that follow? Nearly every rebellion in history is out-equipped by the powers that be- in large part that's why they are the powers that be.

So I don't know how your alcoholism analogy even applies. Yes, the warlords are gleefull drunks, but that says nothing about their victims.
You've got it backwards. The "victims" are the addicts- and they are content enough with the situation as it is to not do anything about it, no matter what harm it does them or how much better it could be.

Of course all situations are not the same, we have to seriously analyze the amount of good we can do vs. the cost of intervention. For example, I think that our little adventure in Iraq caused far more harm to the populace, even with a brutal dictor as the other option, than it saved. And yet the actions in Kosovo were necessary and successfull. A similar intervention could have done a great deal in Rwanda.
That's just speculation. It could as easily have been a clusterhump of epic proportions, just like our interventons in Somalia have been.
 
You asked for stats showing that violent resistance increased the chance of the victim being injured. I provided them. I should also point out that violent resistance tends to decrease the chance of the crime being successful (although so does running-the-hell-away). Most pacifists are happy to trade a loss of the money in their wallet against the decreased risk of being hurt; that's part of what makes them pacifists.

I asked for no such thing, I never doubted the statistics. You're confusing me with someone else. I merely criticized what you think those statistics show.

Now, show me a statistic that proves that "running-the-hell-away" decreases crime. So your argument is that if the police, coming on, say, an armed robber, turned and ran, there would be less incidents of armed robbery in the United States? That I would like to see substantiated.

All you've done is provide evidence that a victim who fights back will incur more injury than one that runs. I don't doubt that for a second. But again, you've conflated the two issues I brought up earlier.

Yeah. Among other things, we can look to Britain for an example.

Terrible example, the British population isn't remotely as armed as Americans, and about 7% of British police do carry guns. England, for a number of reasons, has significantly less violent crime than the US, ergo there is less need for the police to carry firearms.

You've also forgotten a little bit of recent history. I wonder, just wonder, if British law enforcement officials carried firearms in Northern Ireland.

Still waiting for justification on that one.

Still waiting for you to explain how you would have dealt with Kosovo peacefully.

So might I suggest staying-the-hell-out-of-the-Southside-of-Chicago?

People live in the Southside of Chicago. I went their to offer them free legal services because they couldn't afford normal representation.

You're pacifism sounds the most selfish, cowardly approach to life I can imagine. It is the duty of the strong to protect the weak. You cannot solve the issues facing a place like the Southside of Chicago by avoiding conflict and disarming the police force. Enough officers are killed as is, you really think the drug dealers will lay down their weapons when a cop approaches with a billy club?

I have said, and will say again, that the vast majority of armed conflicts do more harm than good, but that doesn't mean that the application of force isn't sometimes necessary. You've escaped that issue by simply saying that you're perfectly content to let people be murdered as long as your life isn't threatened.

This is just a cowardly bit of sophistry: you say force is never necessary because it doesn't bother you that warlords are slaughtering people in Somalia.
 
Not enough, apparently, to do anything about it. One is only terrorised by one's own consent. A warlord only has the power that those around him grant him.


How does that follow? Nearly every rebellion in history is out-equipped by the powers that be- in large part that's why they are the powers that be.


You've got it backwards. The "victims" are the addicts- and they are content enough with the situation as it is to not do anything about it, no matter what harm it does them or how much better it could be.

Wow! Talk about blaming the victim...
 
Not enough, apparently, to do anything about it. One is only terrorised by one's own consent. A warlord only has the power that those around him grant him.

Is this a serious position? Abused people are abused because they consent to domination?

My god, that's shocking and horrific.

So women in the Middle East are subjugated and humiliated because they want to be. If they simply stood against their oppressors they would be free?

There is such a massive disparity of power in Somalia that the subjugated groups cannot fight back. What would you suggest they do? The warlords will just slaughter them without conscious. And notcie that the only way to "break their addiction" will be through violence. Sit-ins don't work against Somali warlords.

And how about the Kosovars? They were in the process of being exterminated. They fought back desperately, but their enemy was happy to wipe them from the face of the Earth. What were they supposed to do? I guess the genocide was their fault because they didn't want to live badly enough.

How does that follow? Nearly every rebellion in history is out-equipped by the powers that be- in large part that's why they are the powers that be.

That's true, and a great many rebeillions have failed miserably and their response led to complete devistation. In recent history the Kurds tried to rebell against Saddam Hussein and were nearly gassed into extinction. How many thousand of slave revolts in the history of the planet resulted in more death and destruction to the rebels?

A rebellion, in the least, requires some organization. The Somalis are so devastated by the violence that they cannot muster the necessary groups. I find it unbelievable that you blame the Somalis for their suffering at the hand of warlords.

You've got it backwards. The "victims" are the addicts- and they are content enough with the situation as it is to not do anything about it, no matter what harm it does them or how much better it could be.

Yes, I'm sure Polish Jews were "content" to be rounded up and tossed into ovens. Sometimes, often, the power differential is so great that rebellion cannot occur.

That's just speculation. It could as easily have been a clusterhump of epic proportions, just like our interventons in Somalia have been.


This completely misses the point. I would love for you to explain how you would have kept the Kosovars from extinction with Pacifism. Please, lay it out.
 
I'm glad you admit that. So tell me again what's wrong with pacifism?

That you let innocent people suffer immensely to keep you conscious clean.

We did nothing to intervene in Rwanda when a small military force could easily have saved hundreds of thousands of lives. According to you, this is a good thing because we avoided a dangerous situation and didn't have to kill.

I find your stance to be morally repugnant and self-serving. You are only allowed to avoid violent situation because other people in your society do not share your cowardice. I do not simply mean soldiers, though their sacrifice allows you to adopt your selfish position, I also include police officers who confront violence on a daily basis. They provide a haven for you to avoid parts of the country and world you deem beneath you.
 
I find that subjects like this involve an awful lot of what if... scenarios. I generally don't find considerations of hypotheticals very productive, because they tend to address idealistic, fantasy worlds rather than the real world.


Arth---generally I agree with you, but I feel I have to point out that "what ifs" are highly valuable.

I trained in CPR and 1st aid. I've had to perform the Heimleich once, but other than that I haven't used any of the information from the course, and hope I never have to. However, that whole course was one series of "what ifs", and if I hadn't considered them at the time and learned how to deal with them, right now there'd be one more dead kid with a piece of hot dog lodged in his throat.
 
Is this a serious position? Abused people are abused because they consent to domination?
In part, yes. An abuser is unlikely to stop dominating on his own as he (and I'm using "he" generally, not as a gender-specific term, mind) reaps the benefits, and the victim wishing or praying for someone else to stop it is abdicating responsibility for one's own self determination.

My god, that's shocking and horrific.
yes it is. Doesn't make it any less true.

So women in the Middle East are subjugated and humiliated because they want to be.
Not entirely, no. Most of them were born into it and taught that lifestyle before they knew any better. But that does not absolve them from personal responsibility for what happens to them.

If they simply stood against their oppressors they would be free?
Not "simply", but they won't ever be free if they do not, will they?

There is such a massive disparity of power in Somalia that the subjugated groups cannot fight back.
Such is your assertion. Why can't the same be said for the American colonists? The French peasants of 1789? Hell, any of these?


What would you suggest they do?
Stand up for themselves. Or leave.

The warlords will just slaughter them without conscious.
So you claim. Funny thing about warlords, the more people they kill, the fewer people there are to rob and steal from. Killing one person to scare the others works great- when it works. Killing everybody bacause they aren't afraid anymore is self-destructive to the warlord.

And notcie that the only way to "break their addiction" will be through violence. Sit-ins don't work against Somali warlords.
How do you know? Worked for Ghandi.

And how about the Kosovars? They were in the process of being exterminated. They fought back desperately, but their enemy was happy to wipe them from the face of the Earth. What were they supposed to do? I guess the genocide was their fault because they didn't want to live badly enough.
Being the target of a campaign of extermination is a different subject than willingly living under oppression.

That's true, and a great many rebeillions have failed miserably and their response led to complete devistation. In recent history the Kurds tried to rebell against Saddam Hussein and were nearly gassed into extinction. How many thousand of slave revolts in the history of the planet resulted in more death and destruction to the rebels?
And your point is...? Are you saying that they would have been better off living in misery and squalor until someone came to deliver them? Violence is only wisely used when one has a superior force?

There is no guarantee anywhere that standing up for one's self is going to be successful at gaining one's freedom- but it is guaranteed that not standing up for one's self will fail to bring freedom. Deliverance by a foreign hand is just changing masters.

A rebellion, in the least, requires some organization. The Somalis are so devastated by the violence that they cannot muster the necessary groups.
That's an assertion. Care to back that up? I just know that they aren't mustering, and if it is not their responsibility to do so, why is it ours to "save" them?

Honestly, you're one of the ones advocating violence as a political solution in this thread- or is that only an option for rich white folk?

I find it unbelievable that you blame the Somalis for their suffering at the hand of warlords.
Where should the blame lie?

Yes, I'm sure Polish Jews were "content" to be rounded up and tossed into ovens.
Not all of them.

Sometimes, often, the power differential is so great that rebellion cannot occur.
So you assert. Where in history has that been the case?

This completely misses the point.
It is the point. If violence is a valid political solution then it is a solution available to everyone, not just the people with the biggest guns.

I would love for you to explain how you would have kept the Kosovars from extinction with Pacifism. Please, lay it out.
Where in the world did I say that it was possible?
 
It isn't to me, can you explain it?


What is this "evil" of which you speak?

I have started another thread for the military topic. Military vs. other jobs. And the evil that I speak of are people that commit such atrocities as genocide or criminals who murder.
 
I don't. I propose to run the hell away. If you want to charge in guns-ablazing,.... well, you've never claimed to be a pacifist, have you?

But don't tell me that you are required to do that. I'm still waiting for an example where violence is actually "required."

Nazi Germany. Do you think violence was required to stop them?
 
And the evil that I speak of are people that commit such atrocities as genocide or criminals who murder.
A few clarifying questions:
Is violence an answer only to violence, then?

By "murder" do you mean to indicate only killings that are unsanctioned by the prevailing law of the land, or any killing of one person by another?

Is preventing genocide the only legitimate use of political violence, in your opinion? There have been relatively few incidences of violence being used politically to quell genocide compared to the many uses of violence for other, often less "heroic" political reasons.

And yes, I do intend to separate uses of violence by political entities, which I have less tolerance for than personal uses of violence.
 
A few clarifying questions:
Is violence an answer only to violence, then?

By "murder" do you mean to indicate only killings that are unsanctioned by the prevailing law of the land, or any killing of one person by another?

Is preventing genocide the only legitimate use of political violence, in your opinion? There have been relatively few incidences of violence being used politically to quell genocide compared to the many uses of violence for other, often less "heroic" political reasons.

And yes, I do intend to separate uses of violence by political entities, which I have less tolerance for than personal uses of violence.

I believe violence may be used in self defense and the defense of others. Would you disagree with that statement? So as it applies to politics, if my country is attacked (9/11) we are more than justified to retaliate in defense so it does not happen again (Seeking out the people who harbor terrorists and the terrorists themselves). That is another scenario besides genocide where political violence is necessary.
 
Arth---generally I agree with you, but I feel I have to point out that "what ifs" are highly valuable.

I trained in CPR and 1st aid. I've had to perform the Heimleich once, but other than that I haven't used any of the information from the course, and hope I never have to. However, that whole course was one series of "what ifs", and if I hadn't considered them at the time and learned how to deal with them, right now there'd be one more dead kid with a piece of hot dog lodged in his throat.

I would correct you in that "what if" scenario's can be highly useful, but that doesn't mean that they always are. It depends on the application. When used in the reference you gave with CPR training, or perhaps some technical training for a type of job, then the "what if" scenarios can have value. When it comes to understanding the application of tactics, both in large and small scales, a "what if" set of questions can be valuable. However, in the context of discussing a reasoning and logic for pacifism, "what if" usually takes the form of some Hollywood-esque scenario that normally doesn't reflect real life in a useful fashion.

The reason for this is because the majority of the types of violence most of us will come across in our lives will consist of almost entirely situations where violence is a choice. Some guy trying to pick a fight with me in a bar or a home invader demanding I give them whatever they can carry out the door are different levels of likely, but the chances of walking in on someone attempting to rape your daughter or you being the only person who can step in to stop Crime A from taking place are typically the stuff of fantasy and fiction. Much in the same way typical martial arts techniques are not supposed to be applied in a "someone does this, you do this" fashion, violence in real life does not tend to happen in ways where there is a "right move" to counteract the violence done to you or those you care for. Holy hell, if only that were the way life worked, then I could think of several cases in my own life where things would have been way easier and far less messy. Unfortunately, life tends to be more complicated and fluid than that, and even if someone is totally prepared for violence they can be taken advantage of or something can happen that is completely out of the realm of their capabilities for violence to affect.

Now, I don't say any of this as a pacifist. I'm certainly not a pacifist by any stretch. If anything, I tend to have the outlook on violence similar to one that many Muslims I've known tend to have based on their faith: violence is justified when you or those you care for are threatened, to the proportion appropriate to end the threat (to you or those you care for), but it isn't healthy or wise to seek it (violence) out. I'm definitely not above violence, but I also don't try to provoke it or look to it as an answer for most stuff either. I'm quite capable of it, and that's less a brag (there's always someone better/stronger/etc.) than it is an acknowledgment that I can make a bad situation worse if I don't mind myself properly. To me, that's baggage, not a boon, and because of that I can respect a pacifist's choice even if I don't agree with it fully.

It should be pointed out, though that there is pacifism as a social strategy on the large scale, and a more personal pacifism that doesn't encompass every action of everyone. The type arthwollipot seemed to be describing is the latter, not the former.
 
I believe violence may be used in self defense and the defense of others. Would you disagree with that statement?
On the personal level, I agree 100%. On the political level, somewhat less so. I agree that self defense of a nation is important, but often times what gets called "self-defense" is somewhat... vague.

When it comes to "defense of others", politically, it is even moreso. I don't see why it is our responsibility to "defend" the Somalis or the Iraqis from themselves, just because we have the biggest guns.

So as it applies to politics, if my country is attacked (9/11) we are more than justified to retaliate in defense so it does not happen again (Seeking out the people who harbor terrorists and the terrorists themselves).
Do you feel that along with and in addition to that there needs to be an examination of our own political behaviour that may have provoked the attack in the first place?

That is another scenario besides genocide where political violence is necessary.
Are there any more?
 
I would correct you in that "what if" scenario's can be highly useful, but that doesn't mean that they always are. It depends on the application. When used in the reference you gave with CPR training, or perhaps some technical training for a type of job, then the "what if" scenarios can have value. When it comes to understanding the application of tactics, both in large and small scales, a "what if" set of questions can be valuable. However, in the context of discussing a reasoning and logic for pacifism, "what if" usually takes the form of some Hollywood-esque scenario that normally doesn't reflect real life in a useful fashion.

The reason for this is because the majority of the types of violence most of us will come across in our lives will consist of almost entirely situations where violence is a choice. Some guy trying to pick a fight with me in a bar or a home invader demanding I give them whatever they can carry out the door are different levels of likely, but the chances of walking in on someone attempting to rape your daughter or you being the only person who can step in to stop Crime A from taking place are typically the stuff of fantasy and fiction. Much in the same way typical martial arts techniques are not supposed to be applied in a "someone does this, you do this" fashion, violence in real life does not tend to happen in ways where there is a "right move" to counteract the violence done to you or those you care for. Holy hell, if only that were the way life worked, then I could think of several cases in my own life where things would have been way easier and far less messy. Unfortunately, life tends to be more complicated and fluid than that, and even if someone is totally prepared for violence they can be taken advantage of or something can happen that is completely out of the realm of their capabilities for violence to affect.

Now, I don't say any of this as a pacifist. I'm certainly not a pacifist by any stretch. If anything, I tend to have the outlook on violence similar to one that many Muslims I've known tend to have based on their faith: violence is justified when you or those you care for are threatened, to the proportion appropriate to end the threat (to you or those you care for), but it isn't healthy or wise to seek it (violence) out. I'm definitely not above violence, but I also don't try to provoke it or look to it as an answer for most stuff either. I'm quite capable of it, and that's less a brag (there's always someone better/stronger/etc.) than it is an acknowledgment that I can make a bad situation worse if I don't mind myself properly. To me, that's baggage, not a boon, and because of that I can respect a pacifist's choice even if I don't agree with it fully.

It should be pointed out, though that there is pacifism as a social strategy on the large scale, and a more personal pacifism that doesn't encompass every action of everyone. The type arthwollipot seemed to be describing is the latter, not the former.

I understand where you are coming from, but I think you are missing what I am trying to get out of it. I am trying to understand a pacifists mind. In other words, what WOULD get someone who is so against violence to use violence. Is there a point when an extreme pacifist would use violence in the defense of themselves or another person? That is where the what if scenario comes into play. If you came into your home and saw a man attempting to rape your daughter, would you use violence to stop this? I honestly don't think this scenario is TOO far out there either. I realize the unlikeliness of the situation, but it serves a purpose. The purpose is to see if there is a point where an extreme pacifist would resort to violence.
 
I find your stance to be morally repugnant and self-serving. You are only allowed to avoid violent situation because other people in your society do not share your cowardice.

I find the use of "cowardice" to be a little strong, here. Not everybody has either the guts or the inclination to grab a gun and shoot at other people, even if it could be justified. That doesn't make these people "bad", as the term "coward" implies.
 
I understand where you are coming from, but I think you are missing what I am trying to get out of it. I am trying to understand a pacifists mind. In other words, what WOULD get someone who is so against violence to use violence. Is there a point when an extreme pacifist would use violence in the defense of themselves or another person? That is where the what if scenario comes into play. If you came into your home and saw a man attempting to rape your daughter, would you use violence to stop this? I honestly don't think this scenario is TOO far out there either. I realize the unlikeliness of the situation, but it serves a purpose. The purpose is to see if there is a point where an extreme pacifist would resort to violence.

I think that is going to be a highly individualised decision.
 
I understand where you are coming from, but I think you are missing what I am trying to get out of it. I am trying to understand a pacifists mind. In other words, what WOULD get someone who is so against violence to use violence. Is there a point when an extreme pacifist would use violence in the defense of themselves or another person? That is where the what if scenario comes into play. If you came into your home and saw a man attempting to rape your daughter, would you use violence to stop this? I honestly don't think this scenario is TOO far out there either. I realize the unlikeliness of the situation, but it serves a purpose. The purpose is to see if there is a point where an extreme pacifist would resort to violence.

What you're describing here isn't trying to understand the mind of a pacifist. What you're attempting to do is catch the pacifist mindset in a "gotcha!" moment. It more resembles the evangelical Christian constantly trying to ask pointed questions of an atheist to finally say, "Ha! See? You don't know that there isn't a God, do you? You just believe you do! You rely on faith!"

Try to examine it without looking for a "gotcha!" moment for a bit. You might be able to approach the concept with a little less trouble for doing so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom