Bentham Open - The tree no one heard fall in the academic forest
"Impact factor provides nowadays the main quantitative tool for ranking, evaluating, categorizing, and comparing journals" A journal's IF "is defined as the ratio between citations and recent (previous two years) citable items published or, in other words, as the average number of citations in a given year of articles published in that journal in the preceding two years" [1] Thus if a journal published 100 citable articles in 2007-8 and they were cited 500 times it would have an IF of 5.0 if they were cited 20 times its IF would be 0.2. In 2004 the two top journals
Nature and
Science had IFs 14 - 16 the average journal's score is 0.88 [2]. IFs are calculated by ISI a division of Reuters
http://us.geocities.com/iipopescu/Jo_rankingb.htm
http://us.geocities.com/iipopescu/Jo_rankingb.htm#references
What then is the IF of the
Open Chemical Physics Journal (
OCPJ)? Since its 1st issue came out in 2008 it won't be ranked by ISI till 2010. A Google Scholar (GS) search returned 11 results with a single citation which gives it an abysmally low Google IF of 0.09, even if we don't count the single indexed 2009 paper, because it is so recent, the GS-IF would be 0.1 but even that is a bit of an over count. The paper was written by "
L Yu,
JL Ding,
B Ho,
SS Feng,
T Wohland" it was cited in a paper by "
Lanlan
Yu, Lin Guo,
Jeak
Ling
Ding,
Bow
Ho,
Si-
shen
Feng, Jonathan Popplewell, Marcus Swann and
Thorsten
Wohland" i.e. the authors cited themselves. Although self citation is rather common even in legitimate academic publications GS has not found any cases of anyone (other than the authors themselves) citing the
OCPJ (or the other Bentham journal Jones published in- see below)
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?n...s+journal&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2009&btnG=Search
But Google only counts papers that are online and it's quite possible they miss some online publications on the other hand they might count publications ISA doesn't and ISI's methodology is complex, thus ISI - IF and GS -IF aren't comparable, so how does the
OCPJ compare to the leading journals in the field?
A GS search for
Chemical Physics (Elsevier) just for the year 2008 returned 878 results. To get a rough average I counted the citations of the 1st, middle (5th) and last (9th) pages of results.
1st: 100 papers 35 of which were cited 84 times
5th (middle): 100 papers 5 of which were cited 23 times
9th (last): 78 papers 25 of which were cited 45 times
Total: 278 papers 65 of which were cited 152 times. 23% of papers cited, approximate IF 0.55, the self citation rate was very close to 50%.
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Elsevier+-"chemical+physics+letters"&num=100&hl=en&lr=&as_publication=chemical+physics&as_ylo=2008&as_yhi=2008&start=0&sa=N
A similar search for the
Journal of Chemical Physics (Am. Inst. of Physics) returned 713 results but many of them were for "Citations" or cited articles not online, though by definition they have at least 1 online citation each, the citations are not counted, I counted them as 1 citation even though most presumably had more.
1st: 100 papers 95 of which were cited at least 97 times
4th (middle): 100 papers 73 of which were cited at least 80 times
8th (last): 11 papers 4 of which were cited 5 times
Total: 211 papers 172 of which were cited at least 182 times. 82% of papers cited, IF > 0.86 (probably over 1.0) the self citation rate was about 65%.
It should be noted that since the 2008 edition of the
OCPJ came out February 14 of that year thus its papers have all been available for 15 months or more,
CP and the
JoCP were published through out the year and their papers have been available on average for 10 months and have had less time to be cited.
http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.bentham.org/open/tocpj/openaccess2.htm
In 2008 Kevin Ryan Dr. Jones and some of the other co-authors "published" a "peer-reviewed" paper in another Bentham publication, the
Open Civil Engineering Journal. GS located 20 papers published there 2007 - 8. The only one cited was the Jones paper but neither of the two were peer reviewed of from scholarly publications. The 1st was our own Ryan Mackay's refutal of David Ray Griffin that appeared on several debunking sites and the other was a self published article (i.e. in the JO9/11S) by the Kevin Ryan the lead author of the original paper.
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?n...gineering&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2008&btnG=Search
And what of the rest of Bentham Open's engineering, chemistry and physics journals? GS located 193 papers published in them in 2008 only 13 were cited 17 times the self citation rate was 65%. But even counting the them the collective G-IF comes out to 0.08, looking only at the chemistry and physics journals the G-IF comes out to 0.06 with a 83% self-citation rate.
Other than complaining about being spamed the scientific community has ignored Bentham Open. Truthers seem to think it is a prominent publisher but it is the scholarly equivalent of the proverbial unheard tree that fell in the forest.