[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

Thank you, Lenbrazil! Excellent information to have! It's good to know what librarians - the very people responsible for maintaining awareness of such journals - and researchers themselves think about Bentham.
 
Lenbrazil, so basically you're saying that journal is like a wiki journal. Is that a fair description?
 
Last edited:
here ill pay 800 dollars if you send in your debunking paper to bentham and get in peer reviewed.

but bet you wont because for a start you cannot debunk nanothermite.You have no argument against it whatsoever, your stupid paint theory is the stupidest thing ive ever heard of in my life.The stuff is more energetic than rdx, and its nanoscaled!
lollolololololololollololol
Secondly some of you are definately working for the government on the payroll because noone with a concious could continue lieing about the events of 911.
 
Secondly some of you are definately working for the government on the payroll because noone with a concious could continue lieing about the events of 911.

The pay is extremely good, what can I say. We also get to be guards at the FEMA camps where we are going to keep all the twoofers (that means you GiE) when they are put into operation (about a year from now). It will be fun!

I might be joking. I could also be bluffing. Or double bluffing. You never know!
 
Last edited:
what peer reviewed paper do you not have to pay for lol

you are not really this stupid right? That is an honest question? They are referring to "pay to publish" of which most are Open Access. Most reputable Journals are not "Pay to Publish" The author does not PAY to have his article published, but rather it is accepted based on its merits alone.

If your comment was meant as some form of humor...it failed.

TAM:)
 
Secondly some of you are definately working for the government on the payroll because noone with a concious could continue lieing about the events of 911.

Ah between you and Kreel (you guys should do lunch at the local "wellness" center) the paranoia is rich.

I love how much ir rots the socks of truthers that ordinary people would have issues and argue against their nonsense. So much so it makes truthers either (A) so paranoid as to think that, or (B) so annoyed as to falsely accuse, others here of working for the govt, and being on the "Payroll".

TAM:)
 
Oh for crying out loud, anybody who dares disagree is a paid disinfo agent. I always LOVE that. They can't call us stupid, because most if not all of the arguments against the truthers make sense and are rational. Their only recourse is to claim that we are professional debunkers, to claim that we have some kind of coaching and training--that's why we are able to make it 'appear' that we are debunking the conspiracy theory.

The best thing is that many truthers would consider spittle-spewing irrationals like Godisenergy and others are themselves paid disinfo agents sent to discredit the truth movement and make them look like fools.

It's funny. it's pathetic. It's sad. It ROCKS!
 
They are referring to "pay to publish" of which most are Open Access. Most reputable Journals are not "Pay to Publish" The author does not PAY to have his article published, but rather it is accepted based on its merits alone.

Let's make a difference between 'pay to publish' journals and journals that assess (usually voluntary) 'page charges' to partly cover the costs of printing. The former are vanity presses. As for the latter, I'll just do some sciencey-looking stuff and quote:

Kligfield 2005 said:
Page charges? Many current medical journals do not
assess page charges, but some do, including the Journal of
Electrocardiology. The uninitiated might be excused for
confusing "page charges" with "vanity publishing", but
these charges have played an important role in supporting
the scientific and medical literature. Publication charges to
authors are rooted in the 1960s, in a government-sponsored
initiative to increase the ability of not-for-profit scientific
publishing to keep up with the explosion of funded
research productivity.

Reference:
Kligfield, P., 2005. Rethinking page charges. J. of Electrocardiology 38, 296-8.

The entire editorial is available through ScienceDirect; it is followed by a response from the publisher, from which the following is an excerpt:

We also understand that
page charges are a deterrent to authors in developing countries who utilize electrocardiologic
techniques in the absence of other, more expensive technologies. Please be assured that
inability to pay page charges in no way affects the editorial decision to accept or reject a
paper for publication. As publishers we find page charges to be the least desirable source of
funding; however, given the economics of this subspecialty journal, page charges are
essential in order to get this important content to readers.

In other words, they're not trying to make money with page charges; they're just trying to keep a small-circulation journal running. I wonder if Bentham can say the same.

Disclaimer: I know nothing about the Journal of Electrocardiology; it's not even remotely connected to anything in which I could claim some level of expertise. Kligfield's editorial is just something that came up in a quick google search on 'page charges'. I do not know whether it is a high-quality journal or not; it is published by Elsevier, so there is a pretty darn big name behind it.
 
Some journals levy page charges, some don't, and this applies to journals of all shapes and sizes. OA journals in general have to, because they can't pay for publishing through subscriptions. The thing that decides their credibility in academic circles is the editorial standards, which is Benthem's problem.
 
Some journals levy page charges, some don't, and this applies to journals of all shapes and sizes. OA journals in general have to, because they can't pay for publishing through subscriptions. The thing that decides their credibility in academic circles is the editorial standards, which is Benthem's problem.

I noticed a few other differences between ACP which you linked to earlier and Bentham. The former:

- makes referee comments public

- some of the referees are named

It makes sense that serious open journals which charge for publication would adopt open peer review to (among other reasons) remove any hint of vanity publishing, that would go especially for for profit ventures like Bentham.

It is interesting to note that charges are roughly compatible but ACP

- actually prints copies, which isn't cheap especially if done in Europe

- pays the referees which I imagine isn't cheap. Their charges are about 3x what I would charge to review the English of such a paper (if the author had decent English) and the papers have 3 - 4 referees who are PhD's living in Europe (I only have a BA and live in the 3rd world

Bentham is actually based in the United Arab Emirates but most the work is done in Pakistan to cut expenses. So what justifies their fee other than the vanity (or agenda) of the authors?

The UAE is of course a country with just about zero academic tradition. The first post secondary school there (a university) didn't open till 1977.

education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1610/United-Arab-Emirates-HIGHER-EDUCATION.html
 
I noticed a few other differences between ACP which you linked to earlier and Bentham. The former:

- makes referee comments public

- some of the referees are named

It makes sense that serious open journals which charge for publication would adopt open peer review to (among other reasons) remove any hint of vanity publishing, that would go especially for for profit ventures like Bentham.

It is interesting to note that charges are roughly compatible but ACP

- actually prints copies, which isn't cheap especially if done in Europe

- pays the referees which I imagine isn't cheap. Their charges are about 3x what I would charge to review the English of such a paper (if the author had decent English) and the papers have 3 - 4 referees who are PhD's living in Europe (I only have a BA and live in the 3rd world

Bentham is actually based in the United Arab Emirates but most the work is done in Pakistan to cut expenses. So what justifies their fee other than the vanity (or agenda) of the authors?

The UAE is of course a country with just about zero academic tradition. The first post secondary school there (a university) didn't open till 1977.

education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1610/United-Arab-Emirates-HIGHER-EDUCATION.html

The open peer review system is something fairly unique, even among OA journals, but it does work very well, helping to make it all a lot more transparent and accountable. They don't actually pay the referees (at least, they've never paid me anything to review stuff there...) but even so, producing a quality journal costs money and it has to come from somewhere.

I guess the point I'm trying to stress is that paying to have something published doesn't in itself make it a vanity publication. But that doesn't stop the Benthem journals being utterly rubbish. If someone does publish a debunking paper, putting it in a more credible journal would very effectively trump Jones and co. That and I'd be loathed to give any money to that cowboy outfit, if this is the standard of work they're willing to disseminate.
 
The open peer review system is something fairly unique, even among OA journals, but it does work very well, helping to make it all a lot more transparent and accountable..


Bentham has starnge cross between open and annonymous peer review. The editors and readership don't know who the referees were but the authors do.

They don't actually pay the referees (at least, they've never paid me anything to review stuff there...) but even so, producing a quality journal costs money and it has to come from somewhere.

They made reference to the 'cost of peer-review' (not an exact quote) what costs are there if they don't pay the referees?

I guess the point I'm trying to stress is that paying to have something published doesn't in itself make it a vanity publication. But that doesn't stop the Benthem journals being utterly rubbish.

I guess several 'debunkers', myself included, were too quick to judge open access publishing but Bentham raises a few black flags including that it is a for profit venture and a rather obscure one at that, add in the information in my post below and their spamming and the doubts raised by academics about it and Ryan Mackay's discovery Jones previous paper there was published without the forknowledge of the editor and the resignation of Dr. Pileni etc etc etcand the whole mess stinks incrediblly of a company far more preoccupied with profit than any kinds of standards.
 
As if further evidence were needed that the "peer review" process at Bentham Open is completely irregular I took a look at the Open Chemical Physics Journal's (OCPJ) submissions page. Pay attention to the e-mail addresses in this excerpt:

A successful electronic submission of a manuscript will be followed by a system-generated acknowledgement to the principal/corresponding author within 72 hours of the dispatch of the manuscript. Any questions with regards to the preparation of and submission of your manuscript to the journal should be addressed to [email protected] and copied to [email protected]

NOTE: Any queries therein should be addressed to [email protected] and copied to [email protected]

http://www.bentham.org/open/tocpj/MSandI.htm

[email protected]

"oa" as in "Open Access" thus authors' inquires about the peer review of their manuscripts are processed by a central office

[email protected] / [email protected]

The same three e-mails are listed on the submission pages for 9 other Bentham Open "journals" such as ones covering: Addiction, Numerical Methods and Urban Studies.

http://www.google.com.br/search?q="...ence.org"[email protected]&hl=pt-BR&filter=0

Bentham's HQ is in the UAE but much (most?) of the work is done in Pakistan*. Except for one from Bangladesh (formerly part of Pakistan) all the people named "Shehzad" I found on Google were Pakistanis. The name Jalil is common through out the Islamic world. None of the editorial board members are from southwestern or south central Asia or Muslim countries.

http://www.aardvarknet.info/access/number50/monthnews.cfm?monthnews=11

The only one with 's' as their first initial is "S Zhou" from China, "shehzad zhou" generated zero hits on Google. The few who have 's' as their 2nd or 3rd initial or the initial 'j' live in Spain, Australia, the US, Germany, Singapore or Sweden and don't have last names indicating their are of south-central Asian/Muslim descent.

And just in case you were wondering none of the OCPJ editorial board members discussed above are also members of the editorial boards of the Bentham Open 'Journals' of Addiction, Numerical Methods or Urban Studies.

Although there is no mention of Mr. Shehzad the most recent submissions page of the OCPJ on the Internet Archive, from January 2008 also instructed authors "Any queries therein should be addressed to [email protected] and copied to [email protected]", the same instructions also appear on the current and most recent archived copies of the Bentham Open Civil Engineering Journal submission pages. Authors are currently instructed "your manuscript to the journal should be addressed to [email protected] and copied to [email protected]" Like Mr. Shehzad, Ms. Irshad also handles 11 Bentham Open "journals" on a diverse range of subjects in addition to civil engineering: Sports Sciences, Fuel Cells and Parasitology among others.

http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/MSandI.htm
http://web.archive.org/web/20070918133903/http://www.bentham.org/open/tociej/MSandI.htm
http://www.google.com/search?q="[email protected]"&hl=en&rlz=1C1GGLS_enBR325&start=0&sa=N&filter=0

To make a long story short not only is the peer review process of Bentham Open's "journals" run by the commercial publisher rather than the respective editorial boards but

1) This should be apparent to anyone who submits to them especially someone like Dr. Jones who submitted to two different publications.

2) The staff who do this do NOT specialize to particular branches of science and thus have no way of being able to select competent reviewers. What makes this especially suspicous is that authors are encouraged to recomend referees. Though this is common even among serious publication normally with expertise in the subject makes the selection. Though Jones claimed "editors choose the referees and usually pick at least one or two reviewers that the authors did NOT mention -- and that is almost certainly the case with this paper" Harritt indicated to the Danish magazine he "know(s) the names of the two researchers –so-called referees—who have reviewed he article".Assuming there was a slight translation* or paraphrasig error and he meant he 'knows the names of two of the researchers' Harrit et.al. knew two of the 3 - 4 referees, then again Jones might have lied
Jones however claimed that "In the end, all the reviewers -- who were selected by the editor(s) -- approved publication. Thus, the paper was subjected to peer review by the editor or editors, and it passed the peer-review process."* But the reviewers were almost certainly chosen by the publisher not any editors and Jones almost certainly knows this especially after his exchange correspondence with Ryan Mackay and Mahmood Alam from Bentham over the peer review process for the "14 Points" 'paper' published by the Open Civil Engineering Journal. In other words Jones seems lied.

http://911blogger.com/node/19780

* Can any of the Danes out there double check the translation of this phrase?
 
Last edited:
Bentham Open - The tree no one heard fall in the academic forest

"Impact factor provides nowadays the main quantitative tool for ranking, evaluating, categorizing, and comparing journals" A journal's IF "is defined as the ratio between citations and recent (previous two years) citable items published or, in other words, as the average number of citations in a given year of articles published in that journal in the preceding two years" [1] Thus if a journal published 100 citable articles in 2007-8 and they were cited 500 times it would have an IF of 5.0 if they were cited 20 times its IF would be 0.2. In 2004 the two top journals Nature and Science had IFs 14 - 16 the average journal's score is 0.88 [2]. IFs are calculated by ISI a division of Reuters

http://us.geocities.com/iipopescu/Jo_rankingb.htm
http://us.geocities.com/iipopescu/Jo_rankingb.htm#references

What then is the IF of the Open Chemical Physics Journal (OCPJ)? Since its 1st issue came out in 2008 it won't be ranked by ISI till 2010. A Google Scholar (GS) search returned 11 results with a single citation which gives it an abysmally low Google IF of 0.09, even if we don't count the single indexed 2009 paper, because it is so recent, the GS-IF would be 0.1 but even that is a bit of an over count. The paper was written by "L Yu, JL Ding, B Ho, SS Feng, T Wohland" it was cited in a paper by "Lanlan Yu, Lin Guo, Jeak Ling Ding, Bow Ho, Si-shen Feng, Jonathan Popplewell, Marcus Swann and Thorsten Wohland" i.e. the authors cited themselves. Although self citation is rather common even in legitimate academic publications GS has not found any cases of anyone (other than the authors themselves) citing the OCPJ (or the other Bentham journal Jones published in- see below)

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?n...s+journal&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2009&btnG=Search

But Google only counts papers that are online and it's quite possible they miss some online publications on the other hand they might count publications ISA doesn't and ISI's methodology is complex, thus ISI - IF and GS -IF aren't comparable, so how does the OCPJ compare to the leading journals in the field?

A GS search for Chemical Physics (Elsevier) just for the year 2008 returned 878 results. To get a rough average I counted the citations of the 1st, middle (5th) and last (9th) pages of results.

1st: 100 papers 35 of which were cited 84 times
5th (middle): 100 papers 5 of which were cited 23 times
9th (last): 78 papers 25 of which were cited 45 times
Total: 278 papers 65 of which were cited 152 times. 23% of papers cited, approximate IF 0.55, the self citation rate was very close to 50%.

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Elsevier+-"chemical+physics+letters"&num=100&hl=en&lr=&as_publication=chemical+physics&as_ylo=2008&as_yhi=2008&start=0&sa=N

A similar search for the Journal of Chemical Physics (Am. Inst. of Physics) returned 713 results but many of them were for "Citations" or cited articles not online, though by definition they have at least 1 online citation each, the citations are not counted, I counted them as 1 citation even though most presumably had more.

1st: 100 papers 95 of which were cited at least 97 times
4th (middle): 100 papers 73 of which were cited at least 80 times
8th (last): 11 papers 4 of which were cited 5 times
Total: 211 papers 172 of which were cited at least 182 times. 82% of papers cited, IF > 0.86 (probably over 1.0) the self citation rate was about 65%.

It should be noted that since the 2008 edition of the OCPJ came out February 14 of that year thus its papers have all been available for 15 months or more, CP and the JoCP were published through out the year and their papers have been available on average for 10 months and have had less time to be cited.

http://web.archive.org/web/*/http://www.bentham.org/open/tocpj/openaccess2.htm

In 2008 Kevin Ryan Dr. Jones and some of the other co-authors "published" a "peer-reviewed" paper in another Bentham publication, the Open Civil Engineering Journal. GS located 20 papers published there 2007 - 8. The only one cited was the Jones paper but neither of the two were peer reviewed of from scholarly publications. The 1st was our own Ryan Mackay's refutal of David Ray Griffin that appeared on several debunking sites and the other was a self published article (i.e. in the JO9/11S) by the Kevin Ryan the lead author of the original paper.

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?n...gineering&as_ylo=2007&as_yhi=2008&btnG=Search


And what of the rest of Bentham Open's engineering, chemistry and physics journals? GS located 193 papers published in them in 2008 only 13 were cited 17 times the self citation rate was 65%. But even counting the them the collective G-IF comes out to 0.08, looking only at the chemistry and physics journals the G-IF comes out to 0.06 with a 83% self-citation rate.

Other than complaining about being spamed the scientific community has ignored Bentham Open. Truthers seem to think it is a prominent publisher but it is the scholarly equivalent of the proverbial unheard tree that fell in the forest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom