NY Times Declares WOD a failure. But misses the obvious ...

There's a good reason they don't see that.

It's not true.



Well, that's true, but only because the population has increased substantially. As a percentage, the number of people in poverty has dropped dramatically, as can be seen from this graph (Wikipedia).

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/c/c9/Poverty_by_Age.png[/qimg]

It's the little details that make the story even more compelling. Notice how well poverty had been reduced by about 1980, when Reagan decided that he wanted to fight on the other side.

Half of the rise you see there around 1980 is during the Carter Administration, which is inconvenient as heck for your partisan rant. Ronald Reagan did not take office until January 1981.

In fact, it appears pretty obvious that every rise in the poverty rate has been centered around business recessions--'73-'75, '79-'82 (really double-dip), '91-'92, '00-'01. I confidently predict another rise in the poverty rate in 2009, which I just as confidently predict will not be accompanied by posts from you attributing it to that notorious fifth columnist, Barack Obama.
 
But it was sold as ushering in utopia. And perhaps it has only helped bankrupt the US. Ten trillion dollars gone, and what do we have to show for it that wouldn't have happened anyway if we'd just left those 10 trillion in taxpayer hands where they could have grown the economy? Actually in that case, the poverty rate would probably be half what it is today.

You seem, to forget that there was a war going on, and that that just ate up a lot of resources without creating any jobs at home. It just helped resdistribute wealth upward, as wars always do.

Upward redistribution of wealth is what causes pverty in an industrialized nation.
 
By all means, DA, link us to the thread where you did that? Is the reason you didn't link it because when I pointed out the above facts concerning the drop in the poverty rate prior to the WOP beginning, all of you of RAN? :D
No, that would be another of the dumb crazy fantasies in your head.
 
Originally Posted by Dr Adequate
You remember how we proved this nonsense was idiotic the first time you puked it out?

Originally Posted by BeAChooser
By all means, DA, link us to the thread where you did that? Is the reason you didn't link it because when I pointed out the above facts concerning the drop in the poverty rate prior to the WOP beginning, all of you of RAN?

No, that would be another of the dumb crazy fantasies in your head.

Folks, let's take a look and see whether Dr Adequate is telling the truth.

Here's the thread where the facts about WOP spending and the poverty rate was first presented by me back on April 8th:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=138408&page=11

Take a look and you won't find anyone challenging the ten trillion dollar figure I cited. Nor will you find anyone challenging the statement that there are as many poor people now as there were back when the WOP started. Nor will you find anyone challenging my poverty rate figures or addressing my questions about the poverty rate dropping before the WOP began. That data and question was first mentioned in a post (#405) to gdnp. Notice that gdnp (and everyone else) completely ignored that observation and the questions I asked about it, just like on this thread. I made note of the fact it was being ignored in post #417.

Dr Adequate was present on the thread. He posted in #423 but not to challenge any of my claims with data of his own, or answer my questions.

In post #428, I again challenged liberals to answer my question about why the poverty rate was dropping before the WOP began as fast or even faster than it did after the WOP began. And here was DA response in post #433:

Originally Posted by BeAChooser
I can't help but notice that not one of you Obama supporters has stepped up to the plate and tried to explain why the poverty rate was dropping before the WOP began ... dropping just as fast or even faster than it did after the WOP got underway ... underway spending (wasting?) $10 trillion dollars. I can't help but notice that not one of you Obama supporters wants to debate the issue of the National Debt. Not one of you is willing to defend the wisdom of Obama doubling it and putting into place programs that will lead to trillion dollar deficits being the norm in 10 years. All I hear is <crickets> but your silence says volumes.

Are your delusions germane to this thread?

If not, I would advise you that you can find them debunked elsewhere.

Notice that DA did nothing but point his finger back in time and claim I could find my assertions debunked elsewhere ... like he's again trying to do on this thread. But certainly gdnp didn't debunk anything previously, since gdnp specifically stated in post #434 that "I do not recall participating in a thread on poverty rates, pre-1964 or otherwise." So where was this "elsewhere"?

In post #436, I replied to DA. Here is what I posted:

I bet you can't point me to a link. I bet you are just doing what democrats always do when confronted with facts they can't dispute. Ignore ignore ignore. Deny deny deny. Spin spin spin. Go ahead, Dr Adequate. Point me to a thread where the drop in the poverty rate before the WOP even began was explained away by you folks. Bet you don't.

And guess what. DA didn't make another post. In fact, everyone on the other side simply stopped posting. In short, they ran, just like I said they did. And the same is true on every thread since then where I've mentioned these inconvenient facts. So it would appear that DA either has a very poor memory or is a liar. Are you willing to admit your memory is poor, DA? :D
 
I will freely admit that you've crapped this stuff out so many times that I do not know when was the first time you did so. Was it only April? You seem to have been telling the same stupid lies forever.
 
You seem to have been telling the same stupid lies forever.

You haven't proven anything I posted is a lie.

And you seem to have been caught being ... well ... dishonest.

Does that make YOU a liar since you don't seem to want to admit that your memory is really poor? Afterall, it was only April. :D
 
Did you mean for this thread to be about the war on drugs or the war on poverty? Or is it about unequal coverage for something completely unrelated and where I am failing to see even a hair of a double standard?
 
You haven't proven anything I posted is a lie.

And you seem to have been caught being ... well ... dishonest.

Does that make YOU a liar since you don't seem to want to admit that your memory is really poor? Afterall, it was only April. :D
Having checked your claims, the first of your stupid droolings I can find about the "War On Poverty" were in August 2008.

This would perhaps explain my impression that you have been lying about this subject for longer than since this April --- without hypothesizing dishonesty on my part.

Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Did you mean for this thread to be about the war on drugs or the war on poverty? Or is it about unequal coverage for something completely unrelated and where I am failing to see even a hair of a double standard?
He wanted a further opportunity to dribble out his drool about the "War On Poverty". Since everyone is bored senseless by his stupid lies on this topic, he pretended that the thread was about the "War On Drugs".
 
Having checked your claims, the first of your stupid droolings I can find about the "War On Poverty" were in August 2008.

And did you find any thread in which the data I noted about the decline in the poverty rate before the WOP began and it's leveling off after the WOP began was refuted (as you claimed was the case)? Because that August 2008 thread doesn't have any such refutation. In fact, reading it one finds liberals ignoring those facts even back then. :D
 
Since everyone is bored senseless by his stupid lies on this topic

Again, DA, I challenge you to prove the facts I cited about poverty and spending in the WOT are false.

If you can't do that, should we just conclude that you are the real liar on this thread?
 
The war WOP would have worked had Nixon not skewed it to the advantage of corporations locating in communities, rather than small businesses growing in communities. And then there was the little problem of a large war debt that we had to deal with.

Same thing today. We are pouring billions into the WOD and WOT and getting pretty near nothing back into the less affluent neighborshoods.

If you pass some money through the hands of the poor, it eventually winds up in the hands of the corporations anyway, but, at least, it helps the mom-and-pop on the corner in the process. You at least have some example for the kids in the neighborhood to suggest that there is a reward for effort.
 
Again, DA, I challenge you to prove the facts I cited about poverty and spending in the WOT are false.

If you can't do that, should we just conclude that you are the real liar on this thread?
Poverty rates fell to a historic low following the introduction of the legislation that you refer to as the "War On Poverty". This suggests that it was a success. If you have any reason to think otherwise other than ideological presuppositions, now would be a great time to say what it is.
 
Poverty rates fell to a historic low following the introduction of the legislation that you refer to as the "War On Poverty". This suggests that it was a success. If you have any reason to think otherwise other than ideological presuppositions, now would be a great time to say what it is.

:rolleyes: Obviously you haven't devoted more than a few neurons to this thread.
 
Poverty rates fell to a historic low following the introduction of the legislation that you refer to as the "War On Poverty". This suggests that it was a success. If you have any reason to think otherwise other than ideological presuppositions, now would be a great time to say what it is.
:rolleyes: Obviously you haven't devoted more than a few neurons to this thread.
So, you've got nothing?

I thought so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom