World Hunger

Unless they can't pay ...

In which case you're stuck relying on love and compassion for your fellow man. As you can see, it doesn't work particularly well.

Removing the profit motive would not bring food to the needy, it would bring hunger and food shortages to the industrialized world.
 
The "point" is nothing but a declaration with no evidence or even argumentation to back it up (except for the usual strawman, which soylent's side of the debate in this thread has been generous with).
 
Last edited:
So how exactly do you get the idea that criticizing the ideology that the profit motive will provide starving people with the food that they cannot afford implies that I will provide you with food?
How is it that foreign aid is offered, frequently, at no charge to areas where food is scarce, and when the food arrives quite often does two things:

1. skews the local economy
2. aids and abets a population increase, when it is effective, on a land already not sustaining its population.

People have been trading excess ag (and other) production for a few thousand years, dann. It's called civilization. It's why we don't hunter and gather so much, as a species. That a capitalist market model is one of many ways food moves from producers to consumers upsets you. Not sure why, beyond demagoguery.

Even with food given away by a number of capitalist societies, to include Japan, US, Europe, the starving continues. One definition of madness is to keep trying the same thing and expecting a change. The more likely effective approach is attempting to establish viable structures that permit self sustaining agriculture/food production.

That still won't address the thorny problem of population versus sustainable agricultural base, and the ability to establish reserves for bad weather/crop cycles. That takes being organized. You will note that nations who are badly organized tend to have food problems.

DR
 
Last edited:
Oh boy, this is getting tedious. You aren't even trying to back up your completely unsubstantiated claims, are you?

How is it that foreign aid is offered, frequently, at no charge to areas where food is scarce, and when the food arrives quite often does two things:

1. skews the local economy
2. aids and abets a population increase, when it is effective, on a land already not sustaining its population.

Your questions aren't very hard to answer, so it's a pity that you never meant them to be answered seriously:
1. Food offered free of charge in your community would also put your local butchers, bakers and greengrocers out of business. That is the way the market economy works. People would be happy, businesses wouldn't.
2. Which land are you talking about? You cannot possbly be talking about Copenhagen or New York, for instance, even though they are lands that definitely don't 'sustain their populations' with agricultural products since not much grows on the pavement. You also wouldn't worry about the "population increase" in these areas completely bereft of farms.

People have been trading excess ag (and other) production for a few thousand years, dann. It's called civilization. It's why we don't hunter and gather so much, as a species. That a capitalist market model is one of many ways food moves from producers to consumers upsets you. Not sure why, beyond demagoguery.

It upsets me mainly because your demagogic euphemism about capitalism that allegedly is a way of moving food ”from producers to consumers” leaves out the essential thing of what you choose to call ”civilization”: it ”moves” only to those ”consumers” who have the ability to pay, which is why people needing food are not necessarily consumers. On the contrary, they are starving.

Even with food given away by a number of capitalist societies, to include Japan, US, Europe, the starving continues. One definition of madness is to keep trying the same thing and expecting a change. The more likely effective approach is attempting to establish viable structures that permit self sustaining agriculture/food production.

Interesting! So let us hear more about your ”viable structures that permit self sustaining agriculture/food production”:
That still won't address the thorny problem of population versus sustainable agricultural base, and the ability to establish reserves for bad weather/crop cycles. That takes being organized. You will note that nations who are badly organized tend to have food problems.

Like I thought: It was just a build-up to claim that the so-called surplus population is the problem even though this particular piece of cynical stupidity was disproved by Marxists a couple of hundred years ago.
This is the reality of world hunger today:
The number of people suffering from malnutrition, before the worst effects of global price rises, "rose just in 2007 by 75 million," Jacques Diouf, director-general of the Rome-based agency, told an Italian parliament committee, according to ANSA news agency.

An FAO prices index showed global food price rises of 12 percent in 2006, 24 percent in 2007 and 50 percent over the first eight months of 2008, Diouf added -- suggesting the number affected is likely to top one billion by the end of the year.

http://www.independent-bangladesh.c...another-75-million-towards-starvation-un.html

The Director of FAO's Agricultural Development Economics Division, Kostas Stamoulis, said it is the first time in human history that there are so many hungry people in the world.

He said this should not be happening because a lot of the world is very rich despite the economic crisis. So what is happening, he said, contradicts what historically has happened.

"We want to reduce this number, we can eliminate hunger in the world, we have the resources: the food is there. It's not lack of food. This year we have almost the record crop globally so it is not lack of food, it is lack of access to food by those that are hungry," he said.
http://www.voanews.com/english/2009-06-19-voa22.cfm

What the World Economic Crisis Teaches about Capitalism
Why Hunger?
 
Yes, indeed!
You may not know anything about world hunger, but your self-insight is admirable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom