Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

The spokeman is not refering to exploding the buildings with the people in them. Think of it like the movie Fight Club. They do various acts of destruction as a way to fight consumerism and when they blow the major credit card company headquarters they make sure there are no people inside.
Why in god's name do people resort to this insane logic? You do realzie that these nutcases have failed in that regard and can provide cases where the bombs were an actual danger to people. ITS A BOMB. Bombs don't necessairly blow up when people want them to and when they don't they are a risk to everyone arround. You are ignoring the firefighters who put themselves in danger to estinguish any flames caused by the bombs.
 
Last edited:
Why in god's name do people resort to this insane logic? You do realzie that these nutcases have failed in that regard and can provide cases where the bombs were an actual danger to people. ITS A BOMB. Bombs don't necessairly blow up when people want them to and when they don't they are a risk to everyone arround. You are ignoring the firefighters who put themselves in danger to estinguish any flames caused by the bombs.
It's terrorism and it exists for a reason. FWIW: It's effective. There are people and organiztions that alter their behavior due to this activity whether it is provide resources and a facility for reproductive health (abortion clinic bombings) or research.

Those who are the subject of it claim that it is very violent and life altering whether it causes physical injury or not. My home was broken into at night once and though no one was physically injured it left long term emotional scars.

It's not as begnin as some would think.
 
Why in god's name do people resort to this insane logic? You do realzie that these nutcases have failed in that regard and can provide cases where the bombs were an actual danger to people. ITS A BOMB. Bombs don't necessairly blow up when people want them to and when they don't they are a risk to everyone arround. You are ignoring the firefighters who put themselves in danger to estinguish any flames caused by the bombs.

These are important considerations. Now import the same type of reasoning to the slaughterhouse and the factory farm, where you have documented mistreatment (not at all surprising given the billions of animals processed each year). An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.
 
These are important considerations. Now import the same type of reasoning to the slaughterhouse and the factory farm, where you have documented mistreatment (not at all surprising given the billions of animals processed each year). An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.


So you are not making excuses for terrorism?
Nice.
 
My thanks to you Cain for including me in your signature. My ego can take a break for awhile. And to answer Simon's question, I do think it is about me. :)

Of course it lacks context and as it is would likely cause someone to think A.) that I don't think rape is wrong or B.) I'm incapable of formulating a coherent argument against rape.

IOW: Out of context your quote is a lie.

"Every edit is a lie." --Jean-Luc Godard
 
An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.
So you are not making excuses for terrorism?
Nice.

This is Cain's version of coherency. To minimize one moral wrong find one worse. It's a form of Tu Quoque.

You do it to and you are worse.
 
This is Cain's version of coherency. To minimize one moral wrong find one worse. It's a form of Tu Quoque.

You do it to and you are worse.

Indeed, on both counts-- Cain's technique for 'consistency' being a form of Tu Quoque as well as equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something. It's just not that black or white. I oppose what the PETA and other eco-terror supporters do, but not because I think they're out to kill people. Instead, it's because they support criminal methods to achieve a purpose that is remarkably opposite to what their 'official' goals are-- they do more harm in their activities than good. Causes that are obviously worse for the individuals that might be recipient or even sympathetic to the cause itself, due to a nihilistic twisting of priorities and an advocacy of criminal (and sometimes violent) behavior. Sometimes it even bears the characteristics of cult-like behavior, but not in all cases.

ETA: oddly, a book that I think people of both sides of this "to (eat) meat or not to (eat) meat" debate would enjoy reading The Science of Good and Evil by Michael Shermer. It would appeal to both Cain's and Kevin's appeal to a utilitarian approach and to the evolutionary psychological approach RandFan (and, to a lesser degree, myself) have put forth. There's no real solid argument for or against veg[etari]an-ism, but the book is interesting and has some good arguments on morality. I'm not saying it's a good description of my own moral bases, but a lot of them are similar. The_Animus (and some others, including RandFan), you might be interested in checking it out.
 
Last edited:
ETA: oddly, a book that I think people of both sides of this "to (eat) meat or not to (eat) meat" debate would enjoy reading The Science of Good and Evil by Michael Shermer. It would appeal to both Cain's and Kevin's appeal to a utilitarian approach and to the evolutionary psychological approach RandFan (and, to a lesser degree, myself) have put forth. There's no real solid argument for or against veg[etari]an-ism, but the book is interesting and has some good arguments on morality. I'm not saying it's a good description of my own moral bases, but a lot of them are similar. The_Animus (and some others, including RandFan), you might be interested in checking it out.
:) I have it and I've mentioned it in this thread to Keven on multiple occasions. It's a great book.
 
:) I have it and I've mentioned it in this thread to Keven on multiple occasions. It's a great book.

Maybe you mentioning it prompted me picking it up, and I just didn't consciously remember it. I agree it's a great book, though.
 
Maybe you mentioning it prompted me picking it up, and I just didn't consciously remember it. I agree it's a great book, though.
Shermer, Dawkins et al raise an important point.

Do humans act morally because of moral philosophy? The answer is yes, to a degree. Formally, moral philosophy informs our legal system and ethics and helps mold the zeitgeist.

However, by and large, people don't reason their morality and we are as likely to act because of adaptive traits as we are because of laws and ethics.

For those interested I recomend:

The Darwin Debate

Melvyn Bragg and a panel of scientists debate what Charles Darwin's theory of evolution tells us about ourselves and human society. Filmed in at the Linnean Society - the world's oldest biological society - in Piccadilly, London.

Panel:
Steven Pinker, professor of psychology at MIT
Meredith Small, Cornell professor of anthropology
Steve Jones, biologist and a professor of genetics and head of the biology department at University College London
Sir Jonathan Miller, theatre and opera director, neurologist, author, television presenter, humorist and sculptor.
 
This is Cain's version of coherency. To minimize one moral wrong find one worse. It's a form of Tu Quoque.

You do it to and you are worse.

Here's some advice. Think twice before you commit yourself to using a term you do not understand -- even if you have used it before and, for whatever reason, nobody chose to call you on it. Take special care when using Latin, and extra special care with anything that has a whiff of "fallacy" to it.

"Technoextreme" suggests a moral principle: we are responsible for the consequences of our actions, even if the outcome is not intended. Moreover, even if nothing bad does happen, an action can still be condemned for its recklessness. There is no "tu quoque" because I am not arguing his (possible) failure to recognize actual atrocities invalidates his claim against eco-terrorists. Quite the opposite, I said "these are important considerations," so let's apply them across the board, which, yes, has to do with coherency and consistency.

It's funny you'd spout this sort of nonsense right after taking issue with my signature, which has been up for a few days. And on that I do not think anyone will entertain A), and the only people will take B) seriously are those who have had the misfortune to read your posts in threads such as this one.

--------------------
GreNME not surprisingly echos the same error but adds fabrication and innuendo.

"equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something."

Where do I do that?

And then:
"Sometimes it even bears the characteristics of cult-like behavior, but not in all cases."

Earlier you attempted a similarly slimy comparison, but against Kevin and myself:

"Considering you and Cain are making similar absolute arguments (if X then Y, no exception), one could infer based on your arguments alone that you were religious about this matter."

Even though you're the one mistakenly inferring an "absolutist" position, and then inferring other nonsense from this false position.

And as I've said before, I've read Shermer's book, wrote an e-mail to him and received a reply back. Now that Hotmail has a search function, I can reproduce it here. I've also read Pinker, Wright, Ridley, Dawkins, and others. More importantly, I also read moral philosophy, bio-ethics...

------------
technoextreme writes:
I had no idea that I had been included in his signature.

Maybe you guys are less perceptive than I thought...

thaiboxerken:
I think he places the most damaging points to his positions in his signature.

So, as I was saying about perceptiveness...
 
GreNME not surprisingly echos the same error but adds fabrication and innuendo.

"equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something."

Where do I do that?

strawman.jpg


Cain, not everything I post is always about you. You're just fishing for stuff to get outraged about at this point.
 
Hotmail sucks, so I do not have my original letter, which apparently criticized him for failing to cite Singer's work. The other stuff deals with ethical egoism and is-ought gaps in Ayn Rand's so-called "Objectivism" (Shermer is an ex-Objectivist).

I don't think I betray any confidences since I'm just some jackass writing a letter. This is from 3/27/04

Dear [Cain]

Thank you kindly for such a long and thoughtful analysis of my book. Anyone who takes the time to both read and write about this deserves a response.

Ethical egoism: you are correct, and for the most part throughout the book I used other people's ideas not to summarize them textbook fashion, but as reference points for the development of my own ideas. I did include one very shorrt section summarizing a bunch of other ethical systems, only out of some obligation to show that I was not operating out of a vacuum. I like Peter Singer's work; it just never came up for me and I did not think to toss him into the bibliography just for completeness sake. His expanding circle of sentiments is an important concept.

In the first half of the book I'm using science to explain the origins of morality, much as one might use science to explain the origins of the emotions, the origins of intelligence, etc. In the second half of the book I'm using science to INFORM moral decisions, not necessarily make them in some final fashion. With science and reason I think we can come to some moral positions that are better informed and more rational than those made without science and reason, such as abortion, animal rights, etc.

It is wrong to torture animals because of the ask first principle ("Is it okay if I torture you?" as a thought experiment only, of course), and the principles of happiness and liberty. It is a higher moral principle to seek your own happiness and liberty while also trying to increase the happiness and liberty of even animals, especially primates and marine mammals.

I went to David Friedman's web page. I will read the paper you flagged on Rand. I had not seen this, and I like the work of both Friedmans.

Thank you again for the very useful feedback.


The important part is the middle-segment. I have no problem with the first half of his book, as he frames it. The second half, I have no problem as he describes it here, but I remember thinking he wanted to do more than merely "INFORM" morality, hence my query (this would also go part of the way in explaining RandFan's crazy views, though I am not blaming Shermer for that mess). Science can inform moral decisions: the other night on The Daily Show, Mike Huckabee claimed a fetus's heart begins to beat after 21 days. Science can tell us the heart is beating, but it cannot tell us if heart beats are morally significant.

Just now I had to ask "what the **** is the 'ask first principle'?" and Google's first hit takes me straight to Shermer's book:

http://books.google.com/books?id=ig...o5SCCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1

Incidentally, in this section Shermer writes:
"If we cannot reliably turn to the Bible and other sacred texts to determine moral right and wrong, to whom shall we turn?"

Now apply this same standard to evolution-as-morality: incest, genocide, adultery, war, homosexuality, xenophobia. Which is why (I presume) Shermer wants to restrict himself to claiming science only informs.
 
Cain, not everything I post is always about you. You're just fishing for stuff to get outraged about at this point.

I'm sorry for interpreting the following as having something to do with me:

Cain's technique for 'consistency' being a form of Tu Quoque as well as equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something.
 
Here's some advice.
Here's some for you. Don't commit Tu Quoque fallacy.

There is no "tu quoque" because I am not arguing his (possible) failure to recognize actual atrocities invalidates his claim against eco-terrorists. Quite the opposite, I said "these are important considerations," so let's apply them across the board, which, yes, has to do with coherency and consistency.
Doesn't fly. At best your "important considerations" can only serve to minimize by comparison which is exactly what you do.

It's funny you'd spout this sort of nonsense right after taking issue with my signature...
Your signature is a lie without context and in your heart of hearts you know that.
 
Last edited:
...this would also go part of the way in explaining RandFan's crazy views...
My "views"? My views are that evolutionary biology can explain why we have moral sentiment and why we behave the way we do. That our ability to feel empathy is an important aspect of our morality. That we evolved to have adaptive traits like reciprocal altruism.

So please, Cain, if you've any sense of integrity, quote the specific "crazy views"?

Science can inform moral decisions:
Yep, that's what I've been saying all along. Nothing more nothing less. Kevin on the other hand has said over and over that what is natural (science) has nothing to do with morality. He was very specific in his claim.

If you deny it I will happily prove it.

Now apply this same standard to evolution-as-morality: incest, genocide, adultery, war, homosexuality, xenophobia.
No one in this thread, AFAIK, has ever said that anything can or should be justified simply because it is an evolutionary trait or adaptation. That's just a strawman of your making. On the contrary, I've said, over and over that we should not confuse "is" with "oughts".

Cain, my position is the same as Shermer's, Pinker's, Dawkins and the rest. And for the record, I've accepted the idea of Singer's expanding circle and stated so on this forum a number of times. I like Peter Singer very much. I don't agree with everything he says but I gladly acknowledge that he is a respected expert and I'm happy to give him the deference that he is due.

If you honestly believe that my views deviate from theirs then please to identify which view or views that you think does so. It's rather poor form to assert that someones views are crazy without stating which views or why you think they are crazy.
 
Last edited:
The other stuff deals with ethical egoism and is-ought gaps in Ayn Rand's so-called "Objectivism" (Shermer is an ex-Objectivist).
I could be wrong but I don't think Shermer was ever an objectivist. I've never been either for the record. From the beginning it struck me as woo. I was pleasantly surprised to find that Shermer's view was the same as mine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom