Let's wrap up this exchange as well.
Your response to PETAs call to violence was "You have to understand, animals are getting hurt!" when it should have been "I am disgusted by the call to violence and want only peaceful debate".
Which demonstrates you are ignoring the context of my remarks. We're talking about terrorist groups who blow up buildings and take care not to harm anyone, which runs contrary to Osama Bin Laden, who, as far as I know, wants to kill as many infidels as people. You see how those two philosophies are opposed? One which does not like the killing and the other that does?
Techno claimed eco-terrorists
could still harm people because the flames might get out of control, or the bomb might not go off when it should. Indeed, and the terrorists would be responsible for those deaths. Now that we have incorporated this moral understanding into our outlook, and if we all accept it, then let's apply it to factory farms and slaughterhouses, where "unintended" abuses invariably take place.
And what sort of response do we see against a call for coherency? Nothing except faux outrage and mistaken allegations of a fallacy people do not understand, improperly capitalize, and, I'm guessing, probably cannot pronounce. In other words, angry cluelessness across the board.
You were at the very least excusing it, if not outright endorsing it.
And here are my controversial remarks:
These are important considerations. Now import the same type of reasoning to the slaughterhouse and the factory farm, where you have documented mistreatment (not at all surprising given the billions of animals processed each year). An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.
The first sentence, as I clarified in numerous follow up posts in case the meaning somehow escaped anyone, agrees the considerations are valid. In other words, eco-terrorists
would be responsible for the deaths of firefighters, people unaccounted for in the building, and so on
even if far greater crimes are committed inside the building they're blowing up, or 10,000 miles away, or 20,000 years ago. I assume we all agree with
that, yes? Cool. Now if you think this is an appropriate moral standard, then apply it consistently. Importantly, in the case of factory farms and slaughterhouses we do not use the words "if" and "could" because we're not speculating about some future death that may or may not happen; we'd instead be talking about deaths that have happened, are happening, and will continue to happen. But you people are incapable of confronting
that argument, hence the tantrums, mistaken "fallacies," and misguided self-righteousness.
As for the rest of your post, you are talking out of your butthole. Perhaps RandFan can translate. I'm not fluent in butthole, but I've picked up a few things from this thread, and most of what you're saying is just irrelevant to the idea of foreseeable consequences and I'm not going to get baited into a discussion outside the purview of my original comments.