Relativity Quiz

I hope Singularitarian's grading scheme resembles a geodesic on a sphere!

:pedant
 
1) According to the Einsteins Field Equations the gravitational redshift, consider two boxes. They are at a distance [latex]z[/latex] apart moving far away from any matter, thus it is in the absence of any gravitational field with some constant acceleration. At time [latex]t_0[/latex] it lags behind the box which emits a photon of wavelength λ0. Show how the boxes remain contant when distance is considered, so that the photon in consideration reaching the leading box after the time has passed [latex]\Delta t = z/c[/latex] in the reference frame of the boxes. The boxes should reatain an additional velocity of [latex]\Delta v = a \Delta t = az/c[/latex]. Show how th Doppler Effect is redshifted by an amount.

Incomprehensible. Why not link to wherever you got that question from, so we can answer the actual question.

I can't do physics. I can do Google. You might find some similarities here: http://nedwww.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/March01/Carroll3/Carroll4.html

Just before the fourth diagram. Similar words and phrases. ;)
 
Nope. Your second and fourth questions were nonsensical, and Sol got the third question right. He did it with units, you did it without units, he did it using one sign convention, you did it using the other. But, irony of ironies, the sign convention Sol used matches your question #1, whereas you used a different sign convention.

.. and likewise with the units convention.

this is *so* much fun!
 
What I find most interesting about this question, is how the correct answer, as given by Singularitarian, is in fact answering some other question. :)

That struck me as funny, until I recalled he's at HND level. One thing I've discovered[*] about exams at that level is that the questions have a hidden meaning. That question had two answers. (a) the obvious answer 'yes', and (b) the answer that Singularitarian gave to an inferred question.

This is of course dumb examination style. If you wanted answer #b one would ask 'what is the significance of the sign of s^2?'

[*] I discovered this by sitting an AS[**] exam last year at the behest of Mrs Me (a teacher). She had to train me in giving answers of style #b rather than #a to questions of this sort.

[**] A-levels are now split into two parts, this is the first part, which is a qualification in its own right.
 
Gonna be a three day pause here. Don't wait up.
Three day paws? I didn't know we had already got to the kittens.

I'm in:

287747798_d7a89af3f4.jpg


Or are we doing recipes? If so, I'm full ready with the toothpicks to eat of three paws:

Every day more salt to the market silverware and tools to eat with very showy designs and many of practical and comfortable them of using.

Without going very far not long ago my partner Calamar was speaking to us about the chuchillos Spicy Steak Knives de Legnoart and today I am encotrado with these toothpicks to eat of three paws that have seemed brilliant to me.

The Tribacchetta 3-Legged Chopsticks done in secure bamboo will take a big problem from more of one that is inexpert at the time of eating with toothpicks.

Also there can turn out to be a few very elegant pieces to serve some aperitvos.

The name of the designer of the Tribaccheta is Gian Maria Sforza and they can be obtained in the shop of the MOMA.

:D
 
I did my best to identify the source of Singularitarian's GR questions, in order to undo the mutilation and attempt to turn them into actual answerable questions.

All four "questions" come from Lecture Notes on General Relativity by Sean M. Carroll. It's important to note that in the original text, these were not questions - Singularitarian simply mutilated short excerpts from the text in an attempt to turn them into questions.

Okay, here we go:

Original text #1:

Sean M. Carroll said:
Let's consider one of the celebrated predictions of the EEP, the gravitational redshift.
Consider two boxes, a distance z apart, moving (far away from any matter, so we assume in the absence of any gravitational field) with some constant acceleration a. At time t0 the trailing box emits a photon of wavelength λ0.

(Diagram not quoted.)

The boxes remain a constant distance apart, so the photon reaches the leading box after a time Δt = z/c in the reference frame of the boxes. In this time the boxes will have picked up an additional velocity Δv = aΔt = az/c. Therefore, the photon reaching the lead box will be redshifted by the conventional Doppler effect by an amount

(Equation 4.5 not quoted.)

"Question" #1:

1) According to the Einsteins Field Equations the gravitational redshift, consider two boxes. They are at a distance
latex.php
apart moving far away from any matter, thus it is in the absence of any gravitational field with some constant acceleration. At time
latex.php
it lags behind the box which emits a photon of wavelength λ0. Show how the boxes remain contant when distance is considered, so that the photon in consideration reaching the leading box after the time has passed
latex.php
in the reference frame of the boxes. The boxes should reatain an additional velocity of
latex.php
. Show how th Doppler Effect is redshifted by an amount.

Reconstructed question #1:

Given the information above, by what amount will the Doppler effect redshift the photon reaching the leading box?

Original text #2:

Sean M. Carroll said:
To make sense of the (δS)3 term we need to use the following fact, true for any matrix M:

Tr(ln M) = ln(det M) . (4.62)

Here, ln M is defined by exp(ln M) = M. (For numbers this is obvious, for matrices it's a little less straightforward.)

"Question" #2:

2) Show how the term
latex.php
is true for any matrix
latex.php
where
latex.php
is explicitely defined by
latex.php
.

Note:

Singularitarian mutilated this very, very badly. Note that:

- In the original text, "true" refers to relationship 4.62. In the mutilated version, "true" refers to the (δS)3 term (which makes no sense).
- In the original version, there is a relationship 4.62 and the definition of ln M. In the mutilated version, they have been bastardized together into a single horrible monstrosity "exp(ln M) = ln(det M)", which is beyond any meaning - note that the left side is a matrix and the right side is not.

Reconstructed question #2:

Show that Tr(ln M) = ln(det M) for any matrix M.

Original text #3:

Sean M. Carroll said:
One way of understanding a geometry is to explore its causal structure, as defined by the light cones. We therefore consider radial null curves, those for which θ and ϕ are constant and ds2 = 0:

(Equation 7.63 not quoted.)

from which we see that

(Equation 7.64 not quoted.)

This of course measures the slope of the light cones on a spacetime diagram of the t-r plane. For large r the slope is ±1, as it would be in flat space, while as we approach r = 2GM we get dt/dr → ±∞, and the light cones "close up":

(Diagram not quoted.)

Thus a light ray which approaches r = 2GM never seems to get there, at least in this coordinate system; instead it seems to asymptote to this radius.
As we will see, this is an illusion, and the light ray (or a massive particle) actually has no trouble reaching r = 2GM.

"Question" #3:

3) Show how a massive particle has no trouble reaching
latex.php
when a geometry of causual structure is defined under the famous light cone analagies when knowing that we are talking about null curves where
latex.php
and
latex.php
are assumed to remain constant. Also assume that such a configuration would close a light cone. Also show how they can be represented by a positive and negative solution under
latex.php
.

Reconstructed question #3:

In the Schwarzschild metric, show that a massive particle reaches the horizon in finite proper time.
Also, derive the slope of the light cones and show that it goes to infinity as we approach the horizon.

Original text #4:

Sean M. Carroll said:
One piece of conventional calculus that we will need later is the chain rule. Let us imagine that we have maps f : Rm → Rn and g : Rn → Rl, and therefore the composition (composition not quoted).

(Diagram not quoted.)

We can represent each space in terms of coordinates: xa on Rm, yb on Rn, and zc on
Rl, where the indices range over the appropriate values.

"Question" #4:

4) Considering geometrical maps,
latex.php
and
latex.php
, show what it's composition is in terms of spaces. It may well be noted that the indices of range over the appropriate values of such a solution can only be achieved using the Chain Rule.

Note:

Note how badly Singularitarian mutilated the text.

Reconstructed question #4:

Because Singularitarian didn't comprehend the original text, his question is silly:

What is the composition of g and f?

But because that's such a silly question, and because of some hints in the clump of nonsense he wrote, I suspect that perhaps the answer he wants to hear is actually the answer to this question:

How does the chain rule relate the partial derivatives of the composition to the partial derivatives of the individual maps?
 
Last edited:
That struck me as funny, until I recalled he's at HND level. One thing I've discovered[*] about exams at that level is that the questions have a hidden meaning. That question had two answers. (a) the obvious answer 'yes', and (b) the answer that Singularitarian gave to an inferred question.

I didn't know that. Would be fair to say that the real form of A-level questions is, "Here is a matter about which you are expected to know something interesting; if so, tell us." ?

(I've wondered whether all of academia basically boils down to that. "Say something interesting about something; say things interesting enough that others can say interesting things about what you said.")
 
I didn't know that. Would be fair to say that the real form of A-level questions is, "Here is a matter about which you are expected to know something interesting; if so, tell us." ?

(I've wondered whether all of academia basically boils down to that. "Say something interesting about something; say things interesting enough that others can say interesting things about what you said.")

That isn't really what the A Level exams teach, unfortunately, they are much more straightforward than that.

However, they often are set by an experienced mathematician who perhaps has something else in mind for further work, but that is normally only clear to someone who appreciates WHY that question is being asked in the first place. The student isn't expected to be able to extrapolate and delve much deeper, it will earn them no real extra marks.

Shame... but that is how it is.
 
Ban period is over. Time to bring out the popcorn. And to get this thread declared the definition of Own Goal.
 
Ban period is over. Time to bring out the popcorn. And to get this thread declared the definition of Own Goal.


Lol... you are having a giraff surely.

As much as there is nothing wrong in recosntructing questions, i see hardly how anything here can be remotely interesting enough to waste precious popcorn on. Nevertheless, i realized the other day after actually beginning to read for the first time the general standards of work produced here, that many of the members simply like to raise their voices and shout woo-woo because of the sake of it, not because they can actually provide any counter-claims or scientific evidence to refute them.

In this awaking, i am not going to take this place as seriously as i had when i first arrived. Quite unfortunate actually.
 
Nevertheless, i realized the other day after actually beginning to read for the first time the general standards of work produced here, that many of the members simply like to raise their voices and shout woo-woo because of the sake of it, not because they can actually provide any counter-claims or scientific evidence to refute them.


Well, some of us try, but of course there are some members who inevitably drag the average down.

By the way, everyone who posts here is a member.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Lol... you are having a giraff surely.

As much as there is nothing wrong in recosntructing questions, i see hardly how anything here can be remotely interesting enough to waste precious popcorn on. Nevertheless, i realized the other day after actually beginning to read for the first time the general standards of work produced here, that many of the members simply like to raise their voices and shout woo-woo because of the sake of it, not because they can actually provide any counter-claims or scientific evidence to refute them.

In this awaking, i am not going to take this place as seriously as i had when i first arrived. Quite unfortunate actually.

And what you are guilty of doing, is completely ignoring every single proper refutation, and correction, offered. You instead focus on the side commentary, while essentialy pretending the valid objections do not exist.

Thabiguy did an excellent job of refuting your work in this thread and once again you have absolutely nothing specific top say about the very specific comments he made.

We are not the least bit fooled by your attempts to look down on the quality of responses you have received.
 
It's kind of impressive to watch Singularitarian. I am honestly becoming concerned about the risk of mental illness, perhaps something related to narcissism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom