The certainty of God's existence.

How about instead of asking us to follow you on your Google hunt with color commentary, you simply link back to some of your own logical forum writings outlining your certainty of god. Something better than the lame "Satellites, Moons, therefore God" argument you tried to make awhile ago, please.

Well, you could always try this argument he did some years ago:

http://www.freeratio.org//showthread.php?t=103865

Pachomius2000 is Yrreg.
 
But we have already a very useful distinction in the psychological motivations and the logical motivations for a person's certainty of God's existence, from the first hit made with Google.




Yrreg

Perhaps you have found a new and useful distinction from your google search, Yrreg. The rest of us have been fully aware of this throughout. That is why people have variously pointed you to the difference between belief and knowledge: to the meaning of the word "reason"; to the difference between certainty and truth.

It would be nice to think that you have finally got it and that we can look forward to your progress: I still think this thread should be a solo performance: in fact I think it would really be better if you did your research and then came back with a logical argument which seems good to you.
 
yrreg,

God (as you defined it last time I checked) has been definitively and completely disproven, at least twice, in at least two different threads you've started. Have you addressed this proof for the non-existence of God as you defined it then? Have you changed your definition of God?

To save you the work of going back over your old threads, here it is for at least the third time:

Last time I checked you defined God as "the maker of everything." Now, follow me closely. I made my lunch today. My wife made my dinner today. So: Nobody who is not me can be God, because nobody who is not me made my lunch, therefore nobody who is not me can have made everything. And I can't be God, because I didn't make my dinner, therefore I can't have made everything. Since nobody who is not me can be God, and I can't be God, there is no God. QED.

Time to refine your definition!
 
Well, you could always try this argument he did some years ago:

http://www.freeratio.org//showthread.php?t=103865

Pachomius2000 is Yrreg.

Was that an argument? :) I guess in the schoolyard of his intellectual peers, "My daddy can beat up your daddy" is considered an argument.

Thanks for the link as it did provide some quality entertainment while I await dinner (which god did not make, btw). No arbitrary word limits, but here's the instruction for the responses:
Please express your views in laboratory language and mood.
And this is a gem from the first page, when someone claimed that Jews had the edge on Christians when it came to their contributions to the arts and sciences:
Jews can be on broad association taken to belong to the Christian bloc. They are most productive within the Christian bloc, and they are the religious ideological forebears of Christianity. I am almost certain that in a crucial choice they will associate themselves with Christians than with Muslims or say Buddhists, Hindus, other religious identities.
That actually makes less sense than Christians who exclude Catholics from their numbers, unless they need some extra muscle. Oh yrreg.....I wonder what your housemaid must think.

eta: Oops, I guess there's no god. See Hindmost's post above.
 
Last edited:
I can't believe it. Yrreg followed that checklist to a 't'. Forgive me for sounding like a woo but I believe someone pays Yrreg to be this relentless. You just can't get this kind of entertainment for free!
 
I think it's evidence of a new theory: Yrreg is just a script gone wild.

And if you say his name out loud phonetically, it just sounds like you're incredibly frustrated. (Apart from being Gerry backwards) Fits in with his persona quite nicely lol.
 
That sounds... absurd :p

Now I just need someone to explain to me how an infinite number of events is absurd, yet the above quoted part is not.

I'm only going to respond to one member at a time. I have found that a theist in a predominantly atheist or secular forum quickly becomes overwhelmed by the number of rebuttals. I find myself typing out long explanations to four or five members while the members only have me to respond to. I will get to everyone eventually (as long as the discussion remains civil, if it digresses into even mild insults I have to stop posting altogether because by that point its not the subject being discussed its each others personal credibly etc.

Fair enough? Ok, onward ~

We are discussing the KCA yes? Therefore we are discussing the validity of the premises to construct a valid syllogism/argument via deductive reasoning. I described how the 'cause' that caused the universe to begin to exist did not begin to exist because it was atemporal and eternal. The reason it is eternal atemporal is as per Big Bang Cosmology which indicates space time was created in the Big Bang along with gravity etc. And the cause must exist due to the deductive logic of the KCA.

Now here is a cut and paste via the web that describes one reason an infinite series of events is absurd. It one of two. The other reason uses set (Attempting to form a set of actually infinite things).

Here is the first ;


"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.

Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.

Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.

Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."


; }>
 
Google results:

"Certainty of God's existence" - 2,300 hits
"Certainty of God's non-existence" - 24,400 hits

"Drop Kick Me Jesus Through the Goalposts of Life"-- 6,010 hits.
:) Nothing like musical appreciation, I always say!
 
Yrreg, who cares what OTHERS have written about this issue when YOU don't seem to have the intelligence or capability of doing it? Can't you think for yourself?

Do you know any religious fanatics who can think for themselves,Pax?
 

"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.

Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.

Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.

Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."


; }>
The example is incorrect because it mixes arithmetic using finite quantities with arithmetic using infinite quantities. Trying to do so is simply invalid, much like division by zero -- this does not mean that the concept of infinity is invalid, nor does it demonstrate that there cannot be a quantity that is "actually infinite" (whatever that means).

Ironically enough, the very example you quoted was originally meant to demonstrate that our mathematical intuitions (which are formed using small, finite quantities) are simply wrong when it comes to dealing with infinite quantities.
 
I'm only going to respond to one member at a time. I have found that a theist in a predominantly atheist or secular forum quickly becomes overwhelmed by the number of rebuttals. I find myself typing out long explanations to four or five members while the members only have me to respond to. I will get to everyone eventually (as long as the discussion remains civil, if it digresses into even mild insults I have to stop posting altogether because by that point its not the subject being discussed its each others personal credibly etc.

Fair enough? Ok, onward ~

We are discussing the KCA yes? Therefore we are discussing the validity of the premises to construct a valid syllogism/argument via deductive reasoning. I described how the 'cause' that caused the universe to begin to exist did not begin to exist because it was atemporal and eternal. The reason it is eternal atemporal is as per Big Bang Cosmology which indicates space time was created in the Big Bang along with gravity etc. And the cause must exist due to the deductive logic of the KCA.

Now here is a cut and paste via the web that describes one reason an infinite series of events is absurd. It one of two. The other reason uses set (Attempting to form a set of actually infinite things).

Here is the first ;


"Actualizing Infinity
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine a hotel with infinitely many rooms. A guest arrives, however, there are no vacancies. Each room is occupied. But, the man at the front desk tells the guest not to worry. He’ll make room for him. He has each guest move to the room that is one greater than his own. Essentially, N+1. Room 1 becomes vacant and the hotel is able to accommodate the new guest.

Now, imagine that an infinite number of guests arrives. The man at the front desk tells them not to worry; he has the guest in Room 1 move to Room 2, the guest in Room 2 to Room 4. Essentially, the guests in Room N to 2N. In doing so, all of the odd numbered rooms become vacant and the infinite number of guests are able to be accommodated. Yet, remember. The hotel was full when the guests arrived.

Strangely enough, imagine that an infinite number of guests decide to check out the next morning. For example, all of the guests in the odd numbered rooms. So, the hotel had no vacancies, infinitely many guests check out, infinitely many guests remain and infinitely many vacant rooms remain from the guests that checked out. So, infinity – infinity = infinity.

Furthermore, imagine that all of the guests in rooms greater than three check out. So, infinitely many guests check out and three remain. Infinity – infinity = 3.

It’s easy to see that an actually infinite number of things is self-contradictory."


; }>

Not necessarily. "However, the paradox of Hilbert's hotel involves not just an actual infinite, but also supertasks; it is unclear whether this claimed intuition is really the physical impossibility of an actual infinite, or merely the physical impossibility of a supertask. A causal chain receeding infinitely into the past need not involve any supertasks.

It should also be noted that the addition of guests to a full Hilbert's would require infinitely fast communication, in order for every guest to tell the next guest to move one up in a finite amount of time. Thus, a universe could contain an actual infinite hotel, but with a finite speed of light, and hence it would not be able to contain any more guests even if it was full.

This is debatable - if the infinite hotel was a single row of rooms, connected by a long hall, each new guest could be placed in the room nearest the front desk, and told to instruct the inhabitant of room 0 to move to room 1, and pass along a similar message, in a way similar to the working of an infinite systolic array. Then, more guests could always be added - but at a rate limited by the walking speed of the guests, their ability to gather their possessions, etc. However, in that case, the hotel would always be overfull (in an overfull, the number of rooms has exhausted, but guests have been forced to share rooms, or some are deprived of rooms). And of course, you can add more guests to a full finite hotel as well, making it overfull."
From some link, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ea0CDieb4yM
 
Last edited:
Hey Yrreg if you like rational, logical ontological arguments what do you think about Kurt Godels ontological argument for the existence of God? I am happy that one of the greatest mathematical minds of history beleived in God and expressed it in a logical expression. ; {>

Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
I grant none of your premises.

P1 is untrue.
P2 is unsupported.
P3 is untrue.
P5 is mere speculation.
P6 is nonsensical.
 
Last edited:
I'm only going to respond to one member at a time. I have found that a theist in a predominantly atheist or secular forum quickly becomes overwhelmed by the number of rebuttals.
Yes, being wrong often has that effect.

We are discussing the KCA yes? Therefore we are discussing the validity of the premises to construct a valid syllogism/argument via deductive reasoning. I described how the 'cause' that caused the universe to begin to exist did not begin to exist because it was atemporal and eternal. The reason it is eternal atemporal is as per Big Bang Cosmology which indicates space time was created in the Big Bang along with gravity etc. And the cause must exist due to the deductive logic of the KCA.
No.
 
The PAC (Pixy's Antecosmological Counterargment)

P1. The Universe, by observation, began at some point.
P2. Time is a property of the Universe.
C1. Therefore time itself began at some point.
P3. Cause precedes effect.
P4. Precedence is a reference to time.
C2. Therefore there can be no cause and effect without time.
C3. Since time is a property of the Universe itself, and cause and effect is meaningless without reference to time, the Universe cannot have a cause.
P5. God is defined as the primal cause.
C4. God does not exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom