The certainty of God's existence.

Why? What would you say creates or causes something (say a universe for example) to begin to exist out of nothing? Why does something exist (our universe) rather than nothing?

What causes something to begin to exist out of nothing? And how? Why does something exist rather than nothing?
 
Last edited:
And here is a Wiki example that is easy to understand.
Which corroborates my comments. The author of the blog you cited - Eric Burns? - was right (though incomplete) up to the point that he attempted to do arithmetic with infinity. And that error shows that mr. Burns knows very little about math.

I did not go into set theory for a reason.
That statement confuses me. You had no reason to go into set theory? Yet, you cite a set theory example to support your arguments? This will get interesting when you start with Godel's ontological argument. :)

Anyway, not that I love wiki but its unbiased in most cases....
It's quite accurate when it is about science, IMHO.
I would add that the original author did follow up but I did not see his summary and closing remarks. I will look at it and determine if its applicable.
You mean the author of the blog? You mean, you haven't read his post you quoted until the end?
 
Stttttteeeeee Riiiikkkke !!!!!!! ONE !Godel does not have anything to do with the KCA genius. It would be helpful if you knew the rank basics of the basics of the KCA, so not to be embarrassing yourself like that
I, however, have directly addressed the Kalām cosmological argument, its relationship to other "first cause" arguments and its primary flaws.
 
Last edited:
What in the hell is going on in this thread? :confused:

I have no idea. This thread is like an episode of Family Guy. Attention Deficit Disorder, anyone? ...but for some reason, I can't turn away.

By the way Mike, did yrreg quote his own posts and answer himself?
 
I <i>really</i> just wish that yrreg wouldn't use the word "enlightenment." Still, I doubt the Zen Buddhist masters would care. BTW, I Ratant, it's taken me a week to figure out that the bug in your icon isn't real. I keep trying to get it off my screen.
 
Hello Rev,
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
The problem I see with this (and I'm sure you've addressed it on other forums) is that this C3 cause must itself have a cause. Which also must have a cause. And so forth. So you're back to the problem of an actual infinity.

Moreover, if this C3 cause is personal, it must by definition be subject to change, because how can personality exist without at least the appearance of decision-making, which involves change? For example, when this causative entity decides to form a universe, there is a pregnant, changing moment of decision.

With change, time is implicit, and therefore, the existence of personality itself implies that this C3 cause cannot be atemporal. At best this cause moves in its own separate temporality. Which again makes it subject to the same P1 and P2 objection.

More likely is that the KCA falls down due to misunderstanding of such basic ideas as what constitutes a "thing" in the sense that a universe might be regarded as a "thing," what any "thing's" nature is, stuff like that.

I'm guessing you've already jumped through these hoops, but I wasn't there for that show. Indulge me.

:)
 
Last edited:
I'm tired.

Could someone please write and post my response to yrreg?

Just start with "Yes, but..."; then go on and on a while about nebulous stuff, and try to wrap it up with a bit of light-hearted mirth.

I'm going to take a nap.
 
I have just experienced an enlightenment, I will look up ex-atheists who have come to the certainty of God's existence, and report here what they say about their psychological as also more importantly for socalled intellectuals their logical or rational grounds for coming to the certitude of God's existence as the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and author of the intelligent scheme of order prevailing in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe.

You have tried this before, remember? Sour grapes with Anthony Flew and claims of Atheists tergiversating with you...or have you forgotten how much you failed and took the penis approach?

It is like if you want to know why ex-prostitutes have come to the certainty of the better option is to abandon prostitution and to take up married life or plain but decent single-hood, you go to ex-prostitutes to ask them why.

Same also with alcoholics and with drug addicts and addicts to cigarettes.

This will not enhance your case nor offer any proof, but I anticipate more of your worthless drivel that wastes readers time and takes up the forums bandwidth.



Ah, you will tell me that the best way to know the merits of atheist certainty that there is no God, is to examine atheists.

When are you going to acknowledge the arguments already given to you Gerry? You could do that instead of ignoring posts just because you don't like them.

Yes, of course, you can always examine yourselves to know your true worth.

Of course. Have you done that?

But I will examine ex-atheists because they had been there done that, and rejected their previous lifestyle and thought system of being and living as atheists.

Did you forget about Anthony Flew?

When you have left atheist lifestyle and thought system or unsystem, tell me and I will interview you.


Have you given up on asking Atheists any further questions?
 
MIKILLINI said:
Have you given up on asking Atheists any further questions?

Well why wouldn't he? They just never get the right answer. Not even by chance. It is spooky!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom