Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh I know. But I'm getting really really really tired of the 'The Universe was created for life!' argument. Wanted to turn it around with the exact same reasoning.
Don't be silly. The universe is fine tuned for Black Holes...and hydrogen...and expanding space...
 
If God is a being that is unlimited in time, and if He has access to every piece of time as if it were now, the question of who created God is an invalid question. .

You start with "if" and end in certainty.
 
Oh I know. But I'm getting really really really tired of the 'The Universe was created for life!' argument. Wanted to turn it around with the exact same reasoning.

I know. I was just trying to point out another reason that it didn't work.
 
Why must every thread in the JREF Forum turn into a science discussion?

.

Because the believers do not have the courage of their convictions and want the authority of science to cover their nakedness.
 
You don't seem to understand. It's hundreds of dice all being rolled at once, one time. Then you're pointing at the resultant combination of numbers and saying "What are the odds of that?"
In essence, it had to happen to someone. Why not us?


Okay, I am now compelled to inform Joe the Juggler about this thread so that he can show up and tell us all about the Texas Sharpshooter once again. ;) I hope y'all realize this.
 
To put it negatively, atheism provides no basis for morality, no hope, and no meaning for life. While this does not disprove atheism by itself, if the logical outworking of a belief system fails to account for what we instinctively know to be true, it ought to be discarded. Without God there would be no objective basis for morality, no life, and no reason to live it. Yet all these things do exist, and so does God. Thus, the moral argument for the existence of God.

So the only reason for god to exist is to give morality and meaning to human life?
 
Okay, I am now compelled to inform Joe the Juggler about this thread so that he can show up and tell us all about the Texas Sharpshooter once again. ;) I hope y'all realize this.

I propose a new thing: the Texas Anthropic Principle-shooter.
 
Without God:
  • The universe began through unknown processes.
With God:
  • A being of unknown origin existed before the universe.
  • This being acts through unknown forces.
  • It created the universe and us for unknown reasons.
  • It created the universe through unknown processes.
Clearly, the origin of the universe makes less sense with God than it does without God.



To expand on this (apologies if it's been asked before, I haven't read the thread thoroughly):


GIBHOR:

If, for the sake of argument, we accept your answer for the origin of the universe (to wit: God), what, if anything, does that tell us regarding the universe?

What knowledge does it add to our understanding of how things work?
What processes does it shed light on?
What new areas of research does it lead us into?
What new knowledge do we gain?

Why should we just stop and answer "God" just because the origin of the universe prior to 10-43 seconds in currently unknown?
Let's look at some past unknowns...

Gravity, disease, the sun's energy, stars, lightning, weather, mountains, and no doubt many other things were at various times attributed to being the work of God (or gods), before science could explain them. And sometimes still are, sadly.

Did the answer "God" actually explain anything?

Would you be happy if people had accepted the "God" answer and never investigated these phenomena?

Where would we be then?

Wallowing in ignorance.

Given the long history of failure for the "God" explanation, why on Earth should we sit back and put the "god" bandaid over the unknown of the origin of the universe (assuming the term even makes sense)?

So why slap "God" over the unknown? All it does is stifle inquiry.

I say again:

If, for the sake of argument, we accept your answer for the origin of the universe (to wit: God), what, if anything, does that tell us regarding the universe?

What knowledge does it add to our understanding of how things work?
What processes does it shed light on?
What new areas of research does it lead us into?
What new knowledge do we gain?
 
Okay, I am now compelled to inform Joe the Juggler about this thread so that he can show up and tell us all about the Texas Sharpshooter once again. ;) I hope y'all realize this.

If you tossed 50 D10's, and they landed in this order:
314159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510

Would you think it an accident?
 
Okay, I am now compelled to inform Joe the Juggler about this thread so that he can show up and tell us all about the Texas Sharpshooter once again. ;) I hope y'all realize this.

I already brought up a variant of that, but he can explain it more convincingly than I can, so let's have the Juggler!

If you tossed 50 D10's, and they landed in this order:
314159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510

Would you think it an accident?

Yes.
 
If you tossed 50 D10's, and they landed in this order:
314159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510

Would you think it an accident?
What an amazing coincidence! That's like pie or custard or something.
 
If you tossed 50 D10's, and they landed in this order:
314159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510

Would you think it an accident?

It would be extraordinary if it never happened.
 
You're moving on, so that implies that you've conceded that your cosmological argument is not valid. I'm willing to move on, but I'd like to hear you admit that you concede the point.

based on what explanation should i admit the cosmological argument is not valid ?
 
No,you have not provided the evidence promised in the title of this thread.

well, fact that you do not admit the presented facts are no evidence does not mean in fact they are no evidence. It just means you do ignore them. As they permit my presented explanation, they permit any other explanation as well. The quest remains however, which explanation is the best and most reasonable one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom