Jay;
in the end, you seem to be claiming that while we have validly pointed out MANY flaws within the paper, from a scientific pov, from a methods pov, that the essence of the paper is the collection of Spectroscopy outputs and calorimeter outputs.
The problem is those outputs are completely useless with such poor science and scientific method surrounding them. Without a proper chain of custody, detailing where the samples were, how they were handled/stored, and by who for every step of the way, the samples are useless, as they could have been tampered with and/or spoiled.
Without a thorough attempt to rule out other sources of the chips, many of which are MORE LIKELY sources of said chips, they have clearly shown (A) their lack of respect for, and (B) their lack of desire for, the scientific method, and forensic investigation in general.
Without providing their samples, with a valid and thorough account of chain of custody, to an independent (truly independent, not their associates, not someone they discussed the topic with online, and not with someone who KNOWS WHAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR IN THE DUST) lab for analysis, their results are NOT REPEATABLE, which throws out the window yet another fundamental of scientific research.
SO you see, those spectroscopy outputs you find so fascinating, are useless without the rest. I could provide you with similar spectroscopy outputs and you would never know where I got them, or how, or anything else about them, yet they would be JUST AS INTERESTING standing on their own, if I simply said, I GOT THEM FROM A SAMPLE OF WTC dust.
Sorry, but I am gonna have to go with the dozens of other WTC dust Analysis that found fiber, gypsum, organics, and paint, but NO THERMITE, done by professional labs unaffiliated with each other, and without agenda.
oh and by the way, IIRC, one of the reasons why Jones eventually had to admit that the only way his "thermite chips" theory was plausible was if the thermite was used as FUSES for conventional explosives, is because Dr. Greening, Mackey, and others, proved to him that it would require over 100 layers of his alleged spray on thermite (based on the thickness of the "exothermic layer" of his chips) to bring the steel to a temperature anywhere close to softening it.
TAM
